Mastodon Live Feed is gone

This is more of a rant (not sure if this comm is appropriate for it).

I’ve been watching Lemmy’s ongoing discussion regarding PieFed. It turns out Mastodon got similar problems, too.

The largest Fediverse instance already shadowbanned people, e.g:

This profile has been hidden by the moderators of mastodon.social.

If you didn’t find (and save) a profile before it poof’d, it’d be pretty much unreachable.

It’s been a while since I’ve been using the Web solely for consumption of public content (esp. long texts). I ceased posting altogether (with this post breaking 2mo of silence) for reasons beyond the current scope. My source of content are firehoses (e.g. Lemmy /all sorted by “New comments”, Mastodon Live Feed), partly due to the chaotic nature (it pleases me as ND) alongside my beliefs (Chaos Magick, noise as gnosis), partly due to how it’s the closest to a true discovery algorithm…

Today, I opened Mastodon only to be faced with a missing Live feed:

This feed has been disabled by your server administrators.

Yes, public feeds are noisy, spammy, pornographic. But it should be up to the user to decide what they wanna see: I muted +3k spam accounts by myself as I doomscrolled the “Live feed” daily.

Then out of naiveté/maliciousness/both, some ppl love to parrot the classic ancap line:

Just do your server!

I mean, it’s that trivial, amirite? As if the source of the problem wouldn’t be replaced by CloudFlare (2nd Biggest Internet Cancer, only losing the topmost rank to the Ruler of the Tumors, the Online Advertisement), AWS/GCP/DigitalOcean/etc, Mastohost, or regional ISPs if you use a PC (doing your ISP, too? Also do your own ICANN and IANA, do your own ASNs and BGPs, everyone knows how it’s so easy-peasy /s).

(As a sidenote, radio communication is truly lovely: no one’s able to stop transceivers… well, except for ITU and their bureaus requiring operators “a loicense” for people to vibrate a quantum fabric of spacetime continuum that predates us hominids: after all, how’d the “Wise Ones” get to knock at ham operator’s doors to seize “dangerous” Baofengs after suddenly becoming unlawful due to “Security”?)

Yes, mastodon.social (nevermind the “social” TLD) could be simply ditched, problem is how it’s home for most Fediverse accounts me and others would like to discover and read/watch; problem is how it’s “model” for other instances, pretty much the Fediverse as a whole. I wouldn’t be surprised if this “trend” went viral: imagine no Lemmy feed other than your following list (didn’t know the random, SEO-lacking, lone profile out there, shouting at the void things you’d deem interesting to your tastes? Don’t worry, you won’t!)

For me and unknown others who also lurk the global chatter, mastodon.social became indistinguishable from mainstream, lacking live global feeds. Meanwhile, people used to shout at the void will be pushed even further…

…But hey, we’re safer now 😌 /s

@[email protected]

    • Dethronatus Sapiens sp.@calckey.worldOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      5 hours ago

      @[email protected] @[email protected]

      To a certain extent, I kind of already switched a long time ago, when I also began trying other platforms such as Sharkey (the instance I’m posting from).

      But the way federation works, it requires that a profile must be discovered in order to be followed. Even though Alice at Sharkey can follow Bob at Mastodon without needing to create a Mastodon, discovering Bob relies on Mastodon tools, so if the Mastodon admins turned off/limited the search, live feed, profile directory and/or other potential discovery mechanisms, the only way Alice could find and follow Bob would be by knowing Bob from somewhere else, be it from a common friend/fan (recommendation) or if Bob links to his profile from other instance/platform.

      And Mastodon.social is, by far, the largest Fediverse instance. It’s where accounts are, pulled by the “Network Effect” (newcomers are likely to sign up for Mastodon.social than, say, calckey.world). I may use Sharkey now, or whatever other instance-platform combination, but I must subscribe to a Mastodon profile shall I want to follow their content from here, and this requires me to know said profile’s existence before I can follow them. If I don’t know their existence beforehand, I won’t be able to follow them.

      Live feed is an almost “unfiltered” (insofar it can be any topic/human field of knowledge in any language, akin to the Wikipedia’s “Random Article” feature but unrestricted to a specific language) stream of content that pops up as soon as it’s published, a broadcast of existences. One of the things I really love is randomness, and Live Feed used to have it: I can see Turkish news articles (nothing I could understand because I don’t speak Turkish, but it’s cool trying to read it nevertheless) popping up next to Japanese-written (idem) microblogging about food, and automated profiles monitoring some random mischievous cat who leaves and enters some living room, and some public CCTV bot profile posting weather information for a random bridge.

      Notice how it’s highly diverse. And chaotic. Sometimes unpleasant things pop up too, as part of the very nature of randomness: then erotica pop up too, sometimes Vietnamese advertisement for machinery, crypto bots, scams, etc. All I need to do is to simply mute them, then they stop appearing and the randomness gets shaped to my interests, akin to a Weasel program (“methinks it’s a weasel”).

      I discovered artists and arts this way. Many artistic pictures and aesthetic photos I saved were found through live feed. I discovered an profile who posts things about religious archaeology. I even experienced spiritual gnosis through synchronicity.

      All those profiles and content are hosted at Mastodon.social, so finding them depends on its discovery features. And that’s the point: they just disabled this feature this week. Silently. I saw nobody talking about this other than me/this thread, maybe I’m one of the few who used to use said feature.

      Stats for Fediverse Servers, showing mastodon.social at the first rank.

  • notsosure@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    2 days ago

    Neither Lemmy nor mastodon should be used for illegal, anti-democratic, false-fact or hateful purposes. Let’s keep the fediverse safe and pleasure for all.