Swaim's Panacea (also called Swaim's Celebrated Panacea) was an American patent medicine sold by William Swaim (1781–1846)[2] of Philadelphia, starting in approximately 1820, with formulations still being sold into at least the 1920s. It was advertised to cure various diseases including scrofula, mercurial disease, deep-seated syphilis, rheumatism, sores, swellings, etc.[3][4]
History
editSwaim was originally a bookbinder, and the popular story went that he discovered the recipe on the page of a book he was binding at his New York shop. More likely he obtained the recipe from Dr. N.J. Quackinboss who had administered it to Swaim himself. Quackinboss was using a formulation previously published by a Dr. McNeven which originated from France, where a remedy called the "Rob de Laffecteur" invented by the French apothecary Pierre Boyveau was very popular.[5][6][7]
Swaim moved to Philadelphia and began to market his own version of the cure, at least by 1820, and perhaps as early as 1811.[8] After getting permission to administer his concoction to some local asylum residents to alleged beneficial effect (and gathering numerous endorsements,[9] including from local physicians), he was able to sell his product at high prices ($3 a bottle, a significant sum at the time), and became very wealthy with a net worth of approximately $500,000.[10][11]
Swaim used a symbol of Hercules killing the Hydra in early advertisements of his product, which was being bottled in rectangular bottles by 1825, and in green cylindrical bottles by 1829.[13] Swaim advertised heavily, and took advantage of developments in commercial lithography in the 1830s to advertise his concoction with a portrait of a woman named Nancy Linton, advertising her "actual appearance" after being cured, although this appearance still looks rather gruesome to modern eyes. The panacea contained mercury, and Linton's appearance appears to reflect signs of mercury poisoning.[14] Mercuric chloride (called corrosive sublimate at the time) did have a prior history of being used to treat syphilis. Oil of wintergreen and sarsaparilla were prominent ingredients of Swaim's product.[15]
By 1828, the Philadelphia Medical Society published a report strongly refuting Swaim's laudatory claims and previous endorsements of the popular panacea, as had the New York Medical Society. Respected physicians who had endorsed the product as promising in the beginning, such as Nathaniel Chapman who later founded the American Medical Association, disavowed their early approvals.[5] Despite Swaim's claim that the product contained no mercury, the medical reports showed otherwise.[16][17][18]
After William Swaim died in 1846, his son James continued the business until his death in 1870, along with Franklin Stewart, a Philadelphia physician and Swaim's "Medical Director".[19][20] (Stewart's son Samuel Swaim Stewart invented the Banjeaurine.[19]) "Swaim's Laboratory" was located in Philadelphia at 113 S. Seventh St, just below Chestnut for many years. Sometime after 1890, production was moved to Clifton, Staten Island in New York.[21]
In 1900, James F. Ballard of St. Louis, who produced a number of patent medicines, acquired the rights to Swaim's Panacea and all other Swaim products from the Swaim family.[21] In the 1910s, the United States government fined Ballard $30 for misbranding of products under the Pure Food and Drug Act of 1906, including Swaim's Panacea, as he was continuing to advertise the product with the amazing claims that had then been made for over 90 years.[22][23][24] It appears the product continued to be sold at least into the 1920s.[citation needed]
Copycats
editThe success of Swaim's Panacea generated a number of copycat products, including "Swayne's Panacea", "Swinn's Panacea", and "Parker's Renovating Vegetable Panacea," the last of which claimed a lineage older than Swaim and used an image of Hercules having already killed the Hydra in its advertising. The Swaims cautioned purchasers to avoid knock-offs, and to look for the distinguishing features of their bottles and labeling.[1]
Swaim's Panacea in popular culture
editThe popularity of the Panacea is reflected in publications of its time. For example, the product was mentioned in the song The Connecticut Pedlar (c. 1851), where the pedlar's list of offerings includes "Swaim's panacea and Jonses's drops too."[25] And in an 1849 letter to the Southern Literary Messenger, Edgar Allan Poe defended the poetry of Bayard Taylor against critics "who possess little other ability than that which assures temporary success to them in common with Swaim's Panacea or Morrison's Pills." Abolitionist William Lloyd Garrison mentions "taking my third bottle of Swaim's Panacea" for scrofula in an 1836 letter.[26]
One of the most comprehensive accounts of the story of Swaim's Panacea is in the 1961 book The Toadstool Millionaires: A Social History of Patent Medicines in America before Federal Regulation by James Harvey Young.[18]
See also
editReferences
edit- ^ a b (30 April 1847). Advertisement, Burlington Free Press, p. 4, col. 6 (advertisement notes that James Swaim has taken over after death of William Swaim on July 21, 1846, and contains detailed description of how product is sold so that consumers will not purchase knock-offs, and notes of label, "in centre is a portrait of the late Wm. Swaim...")
- ^ Colonial and revolutionary families of Pennsylvania; genealogical and personal memoirs, vol. IV, p. 12 (1911)
- ^ Wolfe, Richard J. Tarnished idol: William Thomas Green Morton and the introduction of surgical anesthesia: a chronicle of the ether controversy, p. 574 (2001)
- ^ England, John W. The First Century of the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy, 1821–1921, pp. 73–74 (1922)
- ^ a b Medical Society of the State of New York.Report on Swaim's Panacea (1827)
- ^ Lloyd, John Uri. History of the Vegetable Drugs of the Pharmacopeia of the United States, p. 41 (1911)
- ^ Stein, John Bethune. The Rob, Medical Record, (June 7, 1913), pp. 1021–23
- ^ Advertisement, The Democratic Press (June 21, 1811) (2010 discussion at antique-bottles.net includes scan of 1811 advertisement for Swaim's Panacea, though Swaim's advertisements and other reports later dated his start to 1820)
- ^ (2 August 1823). Medical Quackery - Swaim's Panacea, New York Evening Post, p. 2,col. 4 (editorial questioning an article published in Philadelphia "tending to bring into discredit the Panacea", and defending "the efficacy of Mr. Swaim's discovery.")
- ^ The Manufacturing Interests of the City of Buffalo ..., p. 86 (2d ed. 1866)
- ^ American experiences: readings in American history, Volume 1, p. 218 (1994)
- ^ Advertisement, 1822, in Merchant's and Shipmaster's Assistant (1822)
- ^ History of Drug Containers and Their Labels, p. 78 (1999)
- ^ "Every Man His Own Doctor": Popular Medicine in Early America, pp. 38, 43 (1998)
- ^ David McCormick (Winter 2019). "Pennsylvania's Nostrum Kings". Pennsylvania Heritage.
One of the ingredients of the formula was syrup of sarsaparilla...Swaim substituted oil of wintergreen in place of sassafras, which was in the original formula
- ^ Report on Quack Medicine, The Christian Spectator, pp. 431-38 (August 1828), Vol. 2, No. 8
- ^ Quack Logic, The Journal of Health (March 24, 1830), pp. 222–23 (Vol. 1, No. 14)
- ^ a b Young, James Harvey. The Toadstool Millionaires, ch. 5 (1961)
- ^ a b Gura, Philip F. & James F. Bollman. America's Instrument: The Banjo in the Nineteenth Century, p. 140 (1999)
- ^ "Swaim's Celebrated Panacea". Terre Haute Weekly Gazette. Terre Haute, Vigo County. 13 June 1878. p. 3.
- ^ a b (November 1900). Swaim's Preparations, Landmarks of the Proprietary Trade Came to St. Louis, The National Druggist, Vol. 30, No. 11, p. 440
- ^ 4373. Misbrqanding of ..., Notices of Judgement Under the Food and Drugs Act (1916)
- ^ Cramp, Arthur J., ed. Nostrums and Quackery, Vol. II, p. 584 (1921)
- ^ Swaim's Pancea, National Museum of American History (photographs of post-1900 bottle, which states in part "The business of Swaim's Laboratory was purchased by James F. Ballard from Eliza Battanchon Swaim, on Oct. 22, 1900 and was moved from Staten Island, N.Y., to St. Louis, Mo., in that year.")
- ^ The Connecticut Pedlar (1851)(sheet music)
- ^ A House Dividing Against Itself, 1836–1840, p. 189 (1971)
External links
edit- Swaim's Panacea, at The Quack Doctor (2009)
- Some Remarks Upon a Publication by the Philadelphia Medical Society Concerning Swaim's Panacea ... (1828) (Swaim's response to the Philadelphia Medical Society report), via Google books
- A treatise on the alternative and curative virtues of Swaim's panacea ... (1833), via Google books (Linton appears on page 86)