Eliane Morissens (10 August 1927 – 9 December 2006) was a Belgian teacher and activist. Raised as a feminist, she was active as a trade unionist and socialist. Morissens studied to become a chemical engineer, but was employed as a teacher, as there were few other options for women in her era. She worked her way up to assistant headmistress of a provincial technical college but in 1977 was denied a promotion to become the head of the school. When asked in 1980 to appear on a television broadcast about lesbians, she decided to participate. During the broadcast, she stated that she had been denied the promotion because of her lesbianism. She commented on the irony of the school board being unwilling to put a lesbian in charge of girl students, but having no concern about appointing a man for the post.
Eliane Morissens | |
|---|---|
 Morissens in the Netherlands in 1982 | |
| Born | Eliane Willie Fernande Morissens 10 August 1927 Etterbeek, Belgium |
| Died | 9 December 2006 (aged 79) La Garde, France |
| Occupation(s) | Teacher, activist |
| Years active | 1957–1988 |
| Known for | Challenging discriminatory employment policies against LGBT workers |
Morissens was terminated from her job without pay two days after the broadcast. The school board denied that the decision was based on her sexuality. The board claimed their decision was rooted in professional misconduct, since she had questioned their authority on the television program. She asked for a review of the case by the provincial appeals committee, which upheld the decision in 1982, but allowed her limited compensation under early retirement. She then appealed to the Council of State, the highest court in the country. In 1984, the court upheld her termination and denied that her freedom of expression had been violated. Her plight became a cause célèbre in the LGBT community throughout Europe and the Americas, garnering international press coverage and demonstrations. The international LGBT community raised funds for her personal use and legal fees, campaigned for her reinstatement, lobbied legislators and teachers' unions, and continued with protests on her behalf.
Embarrassed by the international attention, the Flemish Socialist Party introduced a measure in 1982, which passed in 1985, to repeal article 372bis of the Belgian Penal Code, which set a higher age of consent for homosexual relations. That year, Morissens filed an appeal with the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, France. In 1988, the court dismissed her appeal, but acknowledged her freedom of expression was abridged; however, they found the curtailment justifiable because as a teacher she was required to maintain a professional demeanor. The European Union adopted legislation in 2000, to prohibit employment discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation following recommendations by the Legal Affairs Committee of the European Parliament, which had reviewed legal challenges of discrimination including Morissens's case. She died in southern France in 2006 and is remembered for bringing the issue of employment discrimination against homosexuals to worldwide attention.
Early life and education
editEliane Willie Fernande Morissens was born on 10 August 1927 in Etterbeek, Belgium.[1] From a young age, Morissens knew she was a lesbian and it was not an issue with her parents. They counseled her to be independent and did not pressure her to marry. Her mother was a feminist and Morissens later said that for herself if you were a lesbian, you were a feminist.[2] She studied to be a chemical engineer,[3] but chose to be a teacher as it was one of the few career paths open to women. She was involved in trade union organizing and in the early 1950s joined the Socialist Party of Wallonia. Because neither the trade unions nor the socialists involved women in positions of power, she pressed both organizations to allow women's inclusion in administrative and leadership positions. Morissens was active in the struggle against police and security service repression. There were no support groups for homosexuals in Wallonia and only a few in Flanders,[2] but she did meet LGBT activists with whom she was open about her sexuality.[4]
Career
editTeaching
editIn 1957, Morissens began teaching chemistry at the provincial technical college in Saint-Ghislain, a village in the province of Hainaut in the Wallonia region of Belgium.[5][6] She did not disclose her lesbianism to her employer,[4][5] and because of the conservative environment and predominance of Catholicism in the country, she typically hid her sexuality from her colleagues and her students. Morissens had a vacation home in the south of France. She said that she could only truly be herself for four months of the year when she was there.[2] She actively picketed in the 1960 general strike in Wallonia, although most women provided only support services, bringing refreshments for the participants. The student protests in 1968 gave rise to a new generation of feminists with whom she began interacting.[2] During the course of her career, she received several promotions, eventually becoming the assistant headmistress at the school.[4][6] In 1977, she applied to become the college's headmistress and was denied the promotion. Though the reason was not explicitly stated, non-public information led Morissens to conclude that it was because a lesbian could not be in charge of a girls' school which had over 1,000 girls and 200 boys.[7][8]
Conflict with the school board
editIn 1980, Morissens was approached by a women's group from Brussels and asked to appear on a television program discussing homosexuality. Morissens said she agreed because she was tired of hiding, wanted to help her students, and sought to be open about her involvement in LGBT activism.[2] In weighing her decision, she thought that her long and exemplary tenure, her age (53), and speaking anonymously would shield her from any serious repercussions.[2][5][9] On 28 October 1980, she participated in a lesbian panel discussion, "Fragments de bonheur" (Fragments of Happiness), aired on RTB-Liège without giving her name, or identifying her school.[3][5][9] In the discussion, Morissens stated that she had been denied a promotion because she was a lesbian.[4] She also questioned why her sexuality would pose any more of a risk to the female students than a male teacher's sexuality.[10][Notes 1] She was placed on leave two days after the broadcast and on 8 November suspended without pay from her job by the Députation Permanente du Hainaut, the school board of the province.[4][5][7]
The school board claimed that Morissens's sexuality had nothing to do with her firing, rather it was because she had challenged her employer's authority over a promotion decision.[3][4] They specified that as a civil servant, her dismissal was acceptable because her criticisms of her superiors were unjustified and transferred her case to the local government council to appoint a review committee.[10][11] Lesbians in Belgium began campaigning for her reinstatement.[7] When she asked the Socialist Party, which had the majority on the local council, for their support, she was told by the party leadership that personally she had a right to express herself, but as a teacher she was legally required to be discreet. Both the party and the trade unions refused to support her, although later the trade union changed its position.[2][9]
._D,_Bestanddeelnr_931-9285.jpg)
After fifteen months with no decision, Morissens began a hunger strike in January 1982.[4][9][11] She ended it thirty-eight days later when her health began to fail.[12] Her hunger strike resulted in more than two thousand letters of support being sent from as far away as Japan. Members of the British and European Parliaments wrote to the Belgian premier to pressure a settlement of her case.[2][4] The provincial appeals committee accepted the statement by the school board that her homosexuality was not a reason for her termination and upheld their decision.[3][12] They allowed Morissens to collect her salary, BEF 57,000 per month (approximately US$1,800) for two years, but thereafter drastically reduced her pension allowance to BEF 20,000 per month (approximately US$400) based upon the scale for early retirement.[3][8][13][Notes 2]
Council of State appeal
editIn protest of her firing and the compensation plan, Morissens asked for the case to be reviewed by the Council of State, the highest court in the country.[4][12][15] Her appeal asked that they review the harshness of the penalty and charges of professional misconduct, as well as whether the decision was a violation of the European Convention on Human Rights, which guaranteed her freedom of expression.[16] She challenged the notion that she did not have the right to criticize her employer, as her right to do so under the convention was only restricted if her statement posed a risk to state security or violated someone else's rights.[17] She also noted that her statement about the equal risk she and male teachers might pose to female students was said to point out the discrimination in the hiring practice to people on the panel who would understand her situation.[1][8] The school countered her challenge noting that her statement called into question the reputation of the male teachers at the school and violated the provincial law that teachers maintain professional conduct in all circumstances. They further noted that she was free to express herself provided she did not violate the principles required for civil servants in maintaining societal order and discipline.[17]
Morissens began speaking about homosexual rights at both local community meetings and abroad.[2] The case prompted protests, articles, and fundraising events throughout Europe and the Americas.[18] The case was brought to the attention of the International Women's Day conference held in Amsterdam in 1982, and Morissens was invited to speak.[7][19] It was covered in the French magazine Gai pied, which set up a support network to organize demonstrations and launched a petition drive. The magazine covered the case as it made its way through the court system and urged subscribers and members of the International Gay Association (IGA) to pressure the Council of Europe to renounce discrimination against homosexuals.[20] Eva Isaksson, a Finnish activist who produced the Lesbian Information Secretariat Newsletter for the International Lesbian Information Service (ILIS)[21][22] published information on ILIS's letter-writing campaigns, fund-raisers for Morissens's legal and personal expenses, and solidarity demonstrations. ILIS organized public protests in Belgium, Britain, Finland, France, Norway, and Spain.[19] Both ILIS and IGA lobbied European teachers' unions in support of Morissens.[19][23]
Morissens's fight had raised international awareness about employment discrimination and job security for homosexuals, and caused a public outcry in Belgium.[24][25] Embarrassed by the treatment she had received from Wallonia's socialist party, in June 1982 the Flemish Socialist Party introduced a measure to repeal article 372bis of the Belgian Penal Code.[26] This article had been inserted into a child protection bill passed in the 1960s to prevent minors from being seduced by homosexuals.[27] It set the age of consent for homosexuals at eighteen, two years higher than that imposed for heterosexual relations.[27][28] In October 1984, the Council of State upheld Morissens's termination, noting that their authority could not replace that of the local authorities unless the penalty imposed was excessive in relation to the facts of the case.[29][30][Notes 3] Their ruling, according to a report published in The Body Politic in March 1985, found that during the 1980 broadcast when panelists were discussing whether gay teachers posed a danger to students, Morissens had noted that no one discusses danger when male teachers lead all female classes. The magazine reported "it was this statement, seen as insulting to the school board, in addition to Morissens's coming out as a lesbian, that led to her dismissal".[29] The Council of State ruled that Morissens had not proved her allegation that her sexuality cost her the promotion. They also found that while civil servants could make reasonable criticism of their superiors, they were forbidden from making attacks upon their reputations or undermining public confidence.[31] In the wake of the ruling, in June 1985 article 372bis of the penal code was repealed.[26]
Court of Human Rights appeal
editAfter the ruling, Morissens filed an appeal with the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, France.[29] They examined the case on 3 May 1988.[1] Although they found that the actions of the school board had violated her freedom of expression under Article 10 of the Convention on Human Rights, the court held that it was a justifiable interference because the right is conditional based upon other laws and provisions for protecting the public. Their analysis noted that staff regulations of the province provided rules under which staff could be disciplined and that she had access to those regulations;[32] that the right to free expression was curtailed if it breached the rights of others; and that the duties and responsibilities of expressing herself required her as a teacher to accept restrictions to her right to free expression to avoid undermining public confidence.[33] The court dismissed her appeal basing their decision on the fact that her dismissal to protect her employer and colleagues was a reasonable restriction on her freedom of expression.[33][34] The LGBT community was disappointed in the outcome because the court had refused to recognize or examine the discrimination their community faced in employment and had narrowly focused on free expression and its limits.[35][36] However, the rise of the AIDS epidemic in the late 1980s, shifted many activists away from political issues because they feared stigmatization by what was perceived as a "gay disease".[37]
Death and legacy
editMorissens died on 9 December 2006 in La Garde, Var, France.[citation needed] She is remembered for her activism and raising international awareness about employment discrimination against homosexuals.[3] Her case also served as a catalyst for changing the laws regarding discrimination on the basis of sexuality in Belgium, though comprehensive anti-discrimination legislation in the country would not be achieved until 2003.[38][39] The case was also part of the evidence in a report on employment discrimination faced by the LGBT community which was deliberated by the Legal Affairs Committee of the European Parliament in 1984.[40] The conclusion of the Legal Affairs Committee was that avenues available to eliminate discrimination were drafting of new legislation or extensions of existing laws to redefine prohibitions of discrimination on the grounds of sex to include homosexuals.[41] The committee recommended that the European Community had a social obligation to ensure that homosexuals did not face discrimination in their workplaces and that there was a valid legal basis to protect the rights and freedoms of the LGBT community under the Convention on Human Rights.[42] Directive 2000/78/EC was finally adopted by the European Union prohibiting employment discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation (or age, beliefs, or disability) in 2000.[43][44]
Notes
edit- ^ The Council of Europe Staff reported the quote as, "I was expecting to take up the post of head teacher in a very large school of 1,000 girls and 200 boys. Then people said, though unfortunately this was never stated in writing, that it was unthinkable that a homosexual woman should be put in charge of a school with 1,000 girls. I find that rather amusing! There are at present two men in charge of the school; I dont know whether that doesn't make the risk all the greater…"[1] while the 1982 ILGA-bulletin reported the quote as "I was preparing to become responsible for a very large school that was attended by 1,000 girls and 200 boys. It was said – but unfortunately not put into writing – that it was unthinkable that a homosexual woman should be the Head of a school attended by girls – that's funny! At present, the school is run by two men; I don't know if the danger is not even greater…".[6]
- ^ Conversion based upon historical monetary rates for 1980 and 1982 as reported by Laurent Pelé at FXTOP of Sartrouville, France.[14]
- ^ "Considérant qu'il n'appartient pas au Conseil d'Etat de substituer son pouvoir d'appréciation, quant à la gravité de la peine infligée, à celui de l'autorité compétente pour prononcer cette sanction, sinon dans le cas où raisonnablement il devrait être admis que la peine prononcée serait hors de toute proportion avec les faits reprochés". ["Considering that it is not for the Council of State to substitute its discretion, as to the seriousness of the sentence imposed, for that of the competent authority to impose this sanction, except in the case where reasonably it should be admitted that the sentence imposed would be out of all proportion to the facts charged".[30]
References
editCitations
edit- ^ a b c d Council of Europe Staff 1992, p. 40.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i de Lange 1982, p. 5.
- ^ a b c d e f Pastre 1982, p. 104.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i Lester 1982, p. 1.
- ^ a b c d e Le Monde diplomatique 1982, p. 13.
- ^ a b c Waaldijk 1993, p. 111.
- ^ a b c d Santing 1980, p. 3.
- ^ a b c Dumont & Deroover 1984, p. 1187.
- ^ a b c d Gay Community News 1982, p. 1.
- ^ a b Waaldijk 1993, p. 112.
- ^ a b Het Parool 1982, p. 7.
- ^ a b c The Body Politic 1982, p. 20.
- ^ Etty 1982, p. 3.
- ^ Pelé 2022.
- ^ Dumont & Deroover 1984, pp. 1186–1187.
- ^ Dumont & Deroover 1984, pp. 1187–1188.
- ^ a b Dumont & Deroover 1984, p. 1189.
- ^ Lester 1982, p. 1; Het Parool 1982, p. 7; Etty 1982, p. 3; Pastre 1982, p. 105.
- ^ a b c Wilson 2022, p. 136.
- ^ Pinhas 2011, pp. 15–16.
- ^ European Lesbian Conference 2017.
- ^ Wilson 2022, p. 135.
- ^ United Press International 1982.
- ^ Pastre 1982, p. 105.
- ^ Dupont 2019, p. 332.
- ^ a b Dupont 2019, p. 333.
- ^ a b Dupont 2019, p. 328.
- ^ Bleys 2016, p. 125.
- ^ a b c The Body Politic 1985, p. 18.
- ^ a b Dumont & Deroover 1984, p. 1190.
- ^ Council of Europe Staff 1992, p. 41.
- ^ Council of Europe Staff 1992, p. 42.
- ^ a b Council of Europe Staff 1992, p. 43.
- ^ van der Veen, Hendriks & Mattijssen 1998, p. 496.
- ^ Borghs 2016, pp. 44–47.
- ^ Elsen 1988, p. 16.
- ^ Borghs 2016, pp. 46–47.
- ^ Dupont 2019, p. 335.
- ^ Borghs 2016, p. 55.
- ^ Squarcialupi 1984, p. 12.
- ^ Squarcialupi 1984, pp. 27–28.
- ^ Squarcialupi 1984, p. 30.
- ^ Official Journal of the European Communities 2000, p. 303/16.
- ^ Howard 2018, p. 60.
Bibliography
edit- Bleys, Rudy (2016). "Belgium". In Dynes, Wayne R. (ed.). Encyclopedia of Homosexuality. Vol. 1. Abingdon, Oxon: Routledge. pp. 123–125. ISBN 978-1-138-94641-5.
- Borghs, Paul (Fall 2016). "The Gay and Lesbian Movement in Belgium from the 1950s to the Present". QED. 3 (3). East Lansing, Michigan: Michigan State University Press: 29–70. doi:10.14321/qed.3.3.0029. ISSN 2327-1574. JSTOR 10.14321/qed.3.3.0029. OCLC 6951977288. S2CID 151750557. Retrieved 3 June 2022.
- Council of Europe Staff (1992). "Case-law of the Commission: 2. Application No. 11389/85 Eliane Morissens v. Belgium". Yearbook of the European Convention on Human Rights, 1988. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers. pp. 40–45. ISBN 978-0-7923-1787-6.
- de Lange, Wera (13 April 1982). "Beroepsverbod in België 'Als je lesbisch bent, word je automatisch feministe'" [Professional Ban in Belgium 'If you are a lesbian, you automatically become a feminist']. De Waarheid (in Dutch). No. 113. Amsterdam, the Netherlands. p. 5. Retrieved 2 June 2022 – via Delpher.
- Dumont, Michel; Deroover, Willy (1984). "N° 24.516: Arret du 27 juin 1984" (PDF). Recueil des du arrets conseil d'etat [Collection of Rulings of the Council of State] (Report) (in French). Heule, Belgium: Éditions Administratives UGA. pp. 1184–1194. report #D/1989/0857/1. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2 March 2022. Retrieved 3 June 2022.
- Dupont, Wannes (November 2019). "Pas de Deux: Out of Step, Diverging Chronologies of Homosexuality's (De)Criminalisation in the Low Countries". Tijdschrift voor Genderstudies. 22 (4). Amsterdam, the Netherlands: University of Amsterdam: 321–338. doi:10.5117/TVGN2019.4.001.DUPO. ISSN 1388-3186. OCLC 8453584756. S2CID 213698186. Retrieved 3 June 2022.
- Elsen, Casimir (1988). "The Eliane Morissens Affair: A Lost Case". ILGA Bulletin (4). Geneva, Switzerland: International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association: 15–16. ISSN 0281-627X.
This negative ruling by the European Commission on Human Rights means that the case of Mrs. [sic] Eliane Morissens is definitely lost. Despite this negative outcome…let this failure of our protest not be a discouragement to support other cases of discrimination in the future…Just as a final marginal point of information: even when the ruling by the European Commission on Human Rights had been positive, it would have no practical effect for Mrs. Morissens (except maybe financially) [as] this case has lasted for so many years that she has reached in the meantime the age of retirement.
- Etty, Elsbeth (10 March 1982). "Interview met Eliane Morissens" [Interview with Eliane Morissens]. De Waarheid (in Dutch). No. 85. Amsterdam, the Netherlands. p. 3. Retrieved 3 June 2022 – via Delpher.
- Howard, Erica (June 2018). "EU Anti-Discrimination Law: Has the CJEU Stopped Moving Forward?" (PDF). International Journal of Discrimination and the Law. 18 (2–3). London: SAGE Publishing: 60–81. doi:10.1177/1358229118788454. ISSN 1358-2291. OCLC 7867769369. S2CID 149636842. Archived from the original (PDF) on 17 June 2022. Retrieved 17 June 2022.
- Lester, David (18 February 1982). "Pickets Support Fired Belgian Teacher" (PDF). The Sentinel. Vol. 9, no. 7. San Francisco, California. p. 1. Archived (PDF) from the original on 13 February 2019. Retrieved 2 June 2022.
- Pastre, Geneviève (Spring 1982). "L'affaire Éliane Morissens, mise a la retraite d'office pour homosexualité" [The Éliane Morissens Case: Automatically Retired for Homosexuality]. Masques (in French) (13). Paris, France: Association Masques: 104–105. ISSN 0981-9614. Retrieved 3 June 2022 – via Gallica.
- Pelé, Laurent (3 June 2022). "Historical Converter: Belgian Francs to USD". Sartrouville, France: FXTOP. pp. 1980, 1982. Retrieved 3 June 2022.
- Pinhas, Luc (Fall 2011). "es ambivalences d'une entreprise de presse gaie: le périodique Gai Pied, de l'engagement au consumérisme" [The Ambivalences of a Gay Media Company: The Periodical Gai Pied, from Commitment to Consumerism] (PDF). Mémoires du livre / Studies in Book Culture (in French). 3 (1). Sherbrooke, Quebec: Groupe de recherches et d'études sur le livre au Québec. doi:10.7202/1007576ar. ISSN 1920-602X. OCLC 4894564457. S2CID 194089355. Retrieved 3 June 2022.
- Santing, Froukje (31 December 1980). "Lesbianisme vaak niet erkend en vijandig bejegend" [Lesbianism Often Unrecognized and Hostile]. NRC Handelsblad (in Dutch). Amsterdam, Netherlands. p. 3. Retrieved 2 June 2022 – via Delpher.
- Squarcialupi, Vera (13 February 1984). Report Drawn Up on Behalf of the Committee on Social Affairs and Employment on Sexual Discrimination at the Workplace (PDF) (Report). Strasbourg, France: European Parliament. Working Documents 1983-1984: Report 1-1358/83. Archived (PDF) from the original on 1 June 2020. Retrieved 17 June 2022.
- van der Veen, Evert; Hendriks, Aart; Mattijssen, Astrid (1998). "Lesbian and Gay Rights in Europe: Homosexuality and the Law". In Nardi, Peter M.; Schneider, Beth E. (eds.). Social Perspectives in Lesbian and Gay Studies: A Reader. London: Routledge. pp. 491–505. ISBN 978-0-415-16708-6.
- Waaldijk, Kees (1993). "3. The Legal Situation in the Member States". In Waaldijk, Kees; Clapham, Andrew (eds.). Homosexuality Essays on Lesbian and Gay Rights in European Law and Policy. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers. pp. 71–130. ISBN 978-90-04-48187-9.
- Wilson, Ann Marie (January 2022). "Dutch Women and the Lesbian International". Women's History Review. 31 (1). Abingdon, Oxfordshire: Routledge: 126–153. doi:10.1080/09612025.2021.1954338. ISSN 0961-2025. OCLC 9405931614. S2CID 240520862.
- "Belgian High Court Backs Teacher's Firing". The Body Politic (112). Toronto, Ontario: Pink Triangle Press: 18. March 1985. ISSN 0315-3606. Retrieved 2 June 2022.
- "Belgian Socialist Statement Tells Stand on Morrissens". Gay Community News. Vol. 9, no. 38. Boston, Massachusetts. 17 April 1982. p. 1. Retrieved 2 June 2022.
- "Belgian Teacher Ends 38-Day Hunger Strike". The Body Politic (82). Toronto, Ontario: Pink Triangle Press: 20. April 1982. ISSN 0315-3606. Retrieved 2 June 2022.
- "Council Directive 2000/78/EC of 27 November 2000: Establishing a General Framework for Equal Treatment in Employment and Occupation". Official Journal of the European Communities. L (43, Part 303). Luxembourg City, Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities: 16–22. 2 December 2000. ISSN 0378-6978. OCLC 201530307. Archived from the original on 21 May 2022. Retrieved 17 June 2022.
- "Eva Isaksson". European Lesbian Conference. Vienna; Austria: EuroCentralAsian Lesbian Community. 2017. Archived from the original on 21 April 2021. Retrieved 31 May 2022.
- "Le combat d'Eliane Morissens" [The Fight of Eliane Morissens]. Le Monde diplomatique (in French). No. 11555. Paris, France. 24 March 1982. p. 13. Retrieved 2 June 2022.
- "Lesbienne krijgt steun" [Lesbian Gets Support]. Het Parool (in Dutch). No. 11348. Amsterdam, the Netherlands. 22 January 1982. p. 7. Retrieved 3 June 2022.
- "The 1982 Congress of the International Gay Association adjourned..." United Press International. Boca Raton, Florida. 12 April 1982. Retrieved 3 June 2022.