April 12, 2021
October 14, 2019
#MakeoverMonday: Ironman World Championship Medalists
The viz to makeover is a simple table from Wikipedia:
What works well?
- The years are listed in order from most recent to oldest.
- Table can be sorted
- Including separate columns for each medal
- Including links to each athlete
- I'm not convinced that both the flag and country abbreviations are necessary; one is probably enough.
- Some of the athletes have red text and some have blue. I couldn't find anything on the page that explained this.
- Comparing athletes across years is difficult because of the precision of the times/
May 21, 2018
Makeover Monday: How well did The Guardian predict the Premier League table?
What works well?
- Sorting the teams by prediction makes sense since this is an evaluation of their performance against their prediction.
- Including the logos so people can find their favorite team
- Including the numbers for the table position so that the reader doesn't have to count as they go
- Shading every other row helps break up the view
What could be improved?
- If you don't know the team logos, it can be hard to track a team across the table.
- It's hard to see which team did better and worse than expected.
- There's no scale for how "well" The Guardian predicted the table.
My Goals
- Focus on the difference between the predicted and actual results
- Try to create some sort of unit chart (I didn't have time to figure out the calcs, so I cheated with distribution bands)
- Make it easier to see if team finished above or below the predictions
- Finish in under an hour because we did MM live at the Data School and had to present to Eva at the end of the hour
May 6, 2018
Makeover Monday: Toughest Sport by Skill
What works well?
- The sports are ordered by the rank by default, making it easy to see how the compare to other sports.
- You can sort by any of the column headers.
- All of the definitions are provided and thoroughly explained.
- If you need to look up a value, a table works perfectly.
What could be improved?
- It needs to be easier to see the relative difference between sports.
- Comparing more than one metric at a time across two sports takes too much brain power (for me at least).
- Filtering would help make the list more digestible.
My Goals
- Allow the user to compare two sports, rather than all sports at once.
- Make the difference between the sports across all of the skills easier to understand.
- Show which skill is harder/easier when comparing two sports.
July 31, 2017
Makeover Monday: The 28th SEA Games
Let's have a look at the original viz:
What works well?
- The different backgrounds for the sections help split apart the viz and inform you that they are to be read independently.
- It's very informative about the games overall.
What could be improved?
- The parts are all disjointed.
- There's no overall story.
- When I ask "so what?", I can't answer it.
May 24, 2017
Workout Wednesday: NCAA Final Score-by-Score
Here's your challenge:
- Final dashboard is 700x700
- Everything must be a single sheet except for the footer
- Match the title, summary below the title, colors, and tooltips
- Each circle represents a score
- Circles are sized by the type of basket (FT, 2Pt, 3pt)
- Score must be cumulative across the game; note that time counts down in basketball
- Tooltips should shows the score at that moment in time and a description of what happened
- UNC color is #6490C6 while the Gonzaga color is #00143F
- Gridlines should be displayed every 5 minutes and every 10 points
- Last basket for each team should be labeled with the cumulative score
August 1, 2016
Makeover Monday: How Different Media Outlets Get Around Saying "Groin"
Definitely my quickest Makeover Monday ever. Forgive me, I’m busy at the bar at the beach.
This week we looked at a rather funny dataset from FiveThirtyEight about how the media tries to avoid saying “groin” when someone in a sporting event gets hits where it hurts. They presented their work in this table:
There’s nothing particularly terrible about this other than a table of numbers makes comparisons more difficult than necessary. The summary on the right helps it make a bit more sense.
For my viz, I wanted to create a chart that I’ve never built - a treemap bar chart. Basically this is a way to view the distribution of the words by each media outlet but also summarize them in bar chart form so that you can see which media outlet ranks the highest.
January 11, 2016
Makeover Monday: Stephen Curry Hates Mid-Range Jump Shots
This week's Makeover Monday looks at this simple stacked bar chart from Sports Chart of the Day:
What works well:
- Nice labelling on the axes; this makes it clear what we data is displayed
- Nice annotation of the point of the chart
What could be done better:
- Needs a better title
- Needs to incorporate shooting % so that I can better understand the relationship between shots taken and shooting %
- Group together all shots over 30 feet
- Find a better way to compare the number of shots taken on each range. I find the stacked bars hard to compare within in a shot distance.
- Make the different shot ranges more clear, e.g., what defines a long 2?
- Provide a summary
- How are Curry's shot selections changing over time?
With these considerations in mind, here is my my makeover of the chart:
Note: If you'd like to participate in Makeover Monday, check this link for the details.
November 19, 2015
Philadelphia Has the Worst Sports Teams in North America
How bad are Philly sports teams?
- The Eagles are more or less unwatchable. They’re inventing new ways to lose.
- The 76ers have lost 20+ games in a row. That’s really, really hard to do in the NBA.
- The Flyers couldn’t score if there was no goalie in the opposing net.
- The Phillies…well, they did their best to be one of the worst baseball teams of all-time.
I took the ugly table of numbers from the article and built the interactive dashboard you see below, confirming my worst fears.
This merely confirms the misery that is being a Philadelphia sports fan.
September 28, 2015
Makeover Monday: How Much More Valuable are NFL Franchises than Other Leagues?
Business Insider’s chart is lacking context, so in today’s makeover, I walk you through a few simple methods for adding context to a simple bar chart.
January 14, 2015
January 13, 2015
Makeover Monday: Cristiano Ronaldo is the Most Popular Athlete in the World and it isn't Even Close
I've reviewed a lot of Cork's charts and this one makes many of the same mistakes as his past charts:
- It's incredibly annoying to have to turn my head sideways to read the chart.
- The chart is in ascending order, yet the story emphasizes the descending order.
- The colors aren't distinct enough from each other for me. For example, the colors for Track & Field and Cricket and too similar.
- The chart, on it's own, doesn't capture the entire story that's in the article.
You can download the data here and the workbook here.
December 15, 2014
Makeover Monday: ESPN is biggest reason cable TV isn’t going to die anytime soon
Consider this simple bar chart by Cork Gaines of Business Insider:
Seems simple enough, right? Simple, yes. But is it 100% truthful? No.
- I'm not convinced the data is accurate. The rights listed on wikipedia don't align, but you shouldn't assume wikipedia is 100% accurate either.
- The very first bar bugs me. How can you bucket a bunch of sports into NCAA when each sport has a separate contract?
- Using a bar chart assumes that all of these contracts started in 2010, which is not the case.
- This chart shows that the college football playoff contract started in 2010, yet the CFB playoffs don't start until 2015. This is clearly wrong.
August 18, 2014
Makeover Monday: SEC Football Coaches Get Paid!
Saturday Down South is a website dedicated to all things SEC football. This past Thursday, they published this list of the salaries for each coach in the SEC (except for Vanderbilt who does not publish their coach's salary).
This list is simple enough, yet when I saw it, I felt like there was more of a story in there. You can clearly see, just from the table, that Nick Saban is a huge outlier. He's a winner, and he gets paid to win. Keep in mind that these are only their base salaries too. Bonuses, appearance fees, etc. are not included.
I decided to use Tableau's story points for the first time to answer a couple of key questions:
- How much of an outlier is Saban compared to his peers in the SEC, to other coaches in other sports and to other college football coaches?
- How widespread is this level of pay for college football coaches and how does the SEC stack up?
- Is Saban worth the money?
- If you want to tell a story, know the questions you want to answer ahead of time. This will help you plan the beginning, middle and end of the story.
- As I answered questions, I was led to more questions, which led to finding more data, which led to a better story. Be prepared to iterate.
- Story Points are pretty inflexible. You can't do any formatting of you viz once you're inside the Story Point. You have to go back to the original worksheet to change anything. I had expected this to work more like editing a viz on a dashboard.
- I feel like I'm not quite using Story Points as they were intended. I feel like I'm missing their intent in this attempt because I could have done all of this same formatting with multiple dashboards and tabs. I need to learn more about the “idea” behind Story Points.
February 27, 2013
Do you like the NBA? Do you like beer? How much will you have to pay?
Business Insider published this vertical bar chart of beer prices in the NBA. The data is incredibly simple, yet they made the chart unnecessarily hard to read.
Some of the problems I see with this chart include:
- The vertical bars should be horizontal, which would make them easier to read and compare.
- The bars are sorted backwards. The topic is high beer prices, so the highest prices should be first.
- This chart requires you to turn your head sideways to read it. When you mentally turn your head, suddenly the chart goes from right to left, instead of left to right. Bars are easier to compare when left aligned vs. right aligned because that’s how we read.
I previously had some data from Forbes about franchise values (and other financials). I added the beer price to the data set. My goals for this viz were:
- Redesign the chart, factoring in the problems I’ve noted
- Make the chart a bit more fun
- Determine if there’s a relationship between what teams charge and their revenue, franchise value, etc.
October 31, 2012
Has you wife accused you of putting on a few pounds? Find the exercises that are right for you.
Earlier this week, my wife was having a conversation on Facebook about our move to California when she suddenly said “he has gained weight from the cafeteria.”
She’s was being funny. If you ever meet her, you’ll know what an angel she is quite quickly, especially for putting up with me.
Unfortunately she’s not exactly wrong. I pretended to be offended of course.
Many of us are familiar with the “freshman 15” from college. At Facebook, there’s the “Facebook 15”. Same idea. I can use the unbelievably tasty, free food and unlimited snacks as an excuse (moderation is a challenge), but I really haven’t gained much weight, maybe five pounds.
I exercise, not often enough however. I decided that I needed some help, so I build this viz to help me find the right activities for me.
May 16, 2012
Is drug testing working in baseball? An interactive analysis.
Cork Gaines wrote about the HR trend in baseball since testing started for performance enhancing drugs. He presented a chart of the trend (surprising effective given his past charts), but he never answered his own question….is testing working?
One way to determine the answer is through comparisons to other statistics.
I downloaded the season averages across both leagues and MLB in total from baseball-reference and built this interactive analysis. The stats are order by batting stats then pitching stats.
This viz allows you to compare home runs to many other statistics through the selectors at the top right. In addition you can:
- View any two statistics to look for trends by choosing a primary measure and a comparison
- Filter the time frame to all years, the pre-testing era, and the testing era (1993+)
- Filter the leagues to focus your analysis
- Click on a league at the bottom to highlight that league
In this initial view of HR vs. ERA, I see a couple of things:
- HR are on a slow descent in the testing era, especially since 2000
- ERA is in a similar decline, possibly indicating that improved pitches has had as much of an impact as testing
- Batting Average has remained flat. This means that the reduction in HR has not impacted BA.
- Teams are simply scoring fewer runs, likely due to the reduction in long balls
- The trend in complete games is despicable
What do you see? Play around with the different stats and see if you can draw any conclusions.
March 20, 2011
A 17-slice pie chart is a bit excessive
The commentary included with the pie chart below is fantastic, but the pie chart is absolutely horrible.
A simple bar char is much more effective. With the bar chart, it’s so much easier to see just how favored Ohio State is to win the tournament. Also, there’s no color legend, therefore you’re not tempted to assume the colors mean something.
With the bar chart, I can clearly see that Florida and UNC are way overrated and Texas is way underrated (the seeds are in parentheses).