Art History 57: Renaissance and Baroque Art Professor Black
Art History 57: Renaissance and Baroque Art Professor Black
Professor Black
Late Renaissance
Three Geniuses
Leonardo, Raphael and Michelangelo Center of Italian art shifted from Florence to Rome Shift in patronage
Emergence of powerful ruling patrons (popes, noble families)
guilds become less important as patrons
Art effects
Refinement of early Renaissance ideals Interested in improving the natural world, while early Renaissance painters focused on truth to details (not improvement) Greater grandeur (unity of composition)
MORE SERENITY more movement interest in human figure and gesture
Maturation of Albertis historia (gestures tell the story) Inherits the obsession with organizing space (from early Renaissance) Inclination to generalize and idealize figures Strong light-dark contrasts (typical of Leonardo)
To create mystery
Light is clear revealing form Lucid, accessible image Landscape is inviting and uncomplicated More intelligible Mary is perfectly centered and framed
Oval shaped face and smooth skin on Mary
Venice
peaceful republic (called The most serene city) Religious leaders chosen by secular leaders, secular leaders chosen by people Connection with Islamic and Asian worlds Unique topographyconsists of 100 islands connected by walkways
Venice and Florence have very different topographies, contributing to their representational manners Florence has strong stone buildings and very straight linesnot surprising that perspective was created there Venice is surrounded by water and focuses on light and color
Most influential of all paintings of this subject Figures below (apostles) In shadows below In motion Alternation of RED and GREEN Stress on red Angles repeat gesture of apostles, tying composition together God, the father and the angles create a lid at the top to close the composition High Renaissance principles Pyramidal composition CompareMichelangelo very similar Venetian Greater drama and expression Sensuous immediacy Richer color More varied light golden light, shadows, etc. light is softer and more atmospheric Brushwork is more spontaneous IMPOSTOapplication of pigment is thicker more painterly!!! More interested in the expressive possibilities of the use of oil paint Colors are built up with many layers of transparent glazes Oil paint dries slower and is easier to make revisions
CREATES NEW COMPOSTIIONAL TYPE! Commissioned to celebrate a victory against the Turks led by Pesaro
Turbaned figure being led to throne by a Christian knight Red flag has the papal coat of arms on it Similarities
monumental, heroic classical architecture use of red contains the movement by repetition of red Lid of cloud closes in composition Pesaro is less symmetrical Rhythm that moves up Diagonal of steps and figures links figures on bottom to figures on top More painterly More energy
CompareRaphael
Differences
Commissioned for patrons private relaxation room filled with erotic bacchanal images Figures arranged in a garland Female nudesymbolizes the effects of wine Lighting
Dark on left, light on right
Composition
Males in dark on left, females in light on right
Zeus came in as a light shower and impregnated her. This is crudely humorous
Legs spread open
Style
Very atmospheric Strong diagonal from bottom left to top right
Mannerism
1520s-1600 (Between High Renaissance and Baroque
periods)
(such as balance) After quest for perfect realism (i.e., mastery of the human form) during the High Renaissance, Mannerists attempted to diverge entirely Began distorting human figures Irrational space and perspective to reveal emotional turmoil
Mannerist Artists
Bronzino Parmigianino
Baroque
Style
Simple figures Aimed at the senses Use of spotlight (Caravaggio) Iconography is direct and simple to read
Requires minimal thought to appreciate Broader, less ambiguous than Mannerist poses; less classical, more opera/drama-like
Gestures ContrappostoBaroque movement of figures in time Baroque depends on the counter-directional movement of hips and shoulders to create the illusion of movement
Baroque Artists
Caravaggio Volatile person Murdered a man in Rome in a disagreement over a tennis match Had to flee to Naples Became a knight, attacked another Fled to Sicily Three groups looking for him
Roman govt
Knights The prison he had escaped from Expected a pardon and sailed over to get it Died on the ship, pardon was given three days later! Accomplishments Direct and real communication between artwork and viewer Validates true religious emotions Observer feels sensually and emotionally involved in the scene Made art seem believable, realistic figures and emotions Use reality effects to a previously unseen degree Merged Central Italian and North manners Sculpture forms of Central Use of light and pigment of Northern Artemisia Gentileschi
Caravaggio,Bacchus, 159596
Plays to the spectator offering the viewer the wine with other hand he is loosening his toga possibly homoerotic, was Caravaggio gay? 1603accused of having male and female lovers Representational strategies traces of Mannerism face is stylized, idealized Rejection of mannerism also present: extremely REALISTIC fruit basket Not idealized at all Reaction against mannerism, New Baroque traits Very physical Importance of interplay with viewer Very direct, not complicated Convincing reality effects (the still life)
References to Michelangelo
Butcher is Noah Animal about to be slaughtered represents figures in foreground of Noah painting
Peter wanted to be crucified upside down because he was not worthy of being crucified right side up like Christ Much tension Dirty, unidealized figure lifting the cross
Feet dirty, rear end up and out
realistic human imperfection
Peter
Rugged old man Michelangelos natural musculature Presented as symbol of humanity
all of the torturers are faceless and inhumane
Humble
Persian general is trapped by composition Have their bodies on top of him Very physically involved in scene Feminist interpretation Violence of these scenes were related to the rapes of the artist by her teacher painted means of revenge? decapitation is symbolic of castration?
Baroque Classicism
BAROQUE CLASSICISMRenaissance Classicism combined with Baroque emotion
Renaissance features
Rational Very organized, in grid
Influenced by Carracci
Ceiling fresco Less sensual More intellectual than Carracci Aurora, the dawn, is fleeing from Apollo in his chariot
Female figures represent the hours of the day
Classical referencemythology is characteristic of Baroque Baroque qualitiesdawns emotional retreat from Apollo
Classicism because Renaissance painters focused on antiquity QUADRO REPORTATOnot fixed to aid viewer in looking at the ceiling painting
No foreshortenings to aid viewer
PAPAL HISTORY
Papal History
Paul V
Years of austerity Reintroduced pomp and richness into Catholicism Wanted to restore glory of catholic church in realm of arts
Preferred
Dynamic Baroque
Used this style to celebrate and commemorate Catholic victory over the Protestants entering the CATHOLIC RESTORATION era! Comes after the Reformation
1622canonized five new saints after not canonizing any for decades New appreciations
ScienceGalileo, Copernicus
infinite universe
DYNAMIC BAROQUE
Pope Urban VIII Barberini (1623-44) had preference for this style Qualities
Complex Emphasis on light and color Irregularintended to overwhelm
Dramatic Idealized Very aesthetic Painterly Catholic themes
Reason: The Catholic Restoration had just taken place and the Catholic church was celebrating and commemorating its victory over Protestantism
New pope, Urban VIII, had just come into powerdawning of a new day
Had great preference for dynamic baroque and popularized the style
Return to realism
Allegories
Charity
baby suckling a woman, while an other baby cries at the death of the pope and she smiles at him to give comfort twisted postures dynamic draperies pockets of shadow made by deep cuts in the marble for beautiful draperies folds
Angel appears to St. Teresa and pierces her heart with a flaming arrow
Baroque Emotion
Spanish mysticismdescribes union with divine
Uses physical terms for a spiritual experience Very emotional drapery Cloud vs. smooth skin Deep grooves cut in marble to create texture and extreme drama in draperies Diagonal between faces heads downward toward St. Theresa
Texture
Composition
Francesco Borromini
Bernini
Giuliano da Sangallo
Primary purpose: to persuade viewers of some truth, meant to stimulate emotions Traits of Baroque Architecture: 1 more complex ground plans 2 greater height, greater emphasis on the ` dome 3 curved walls 4 fully projecting columns instead of pilasters 5 rhythmic bay arrangements 6 fusion of sculpture and architecture 7 coextensive space that engages the spectator
Bernini
Displays the
Located in Prato
Spanish. Realism.
Emphasized reality effects Lowly, dignified people evoke higher ideas Secular scenes have religious intent Few mythological scenes because the Inquisition banned female nudity, essential to mythological art Why .Spanish culture has always preferred reality effects Fernando Gallego (1470)early Renaissance reality effects .Influence of Spanish Mysticismunification of the soul with god ..mystical union described in earthy, realistic, plain-spoken language, religion reveals itself through the most mundane parts of life Anxiety about the strength of Christianity in Spain ...Muslims had control until 1400s Spanish Inquisition took control back
Ribera..
No notes on this.
Drunken Silenus.
Ribera..
1626.
Grotesque approach to mythology Dark, grotesque colors Satyrs and father of Silenus, Pan, present Moralrepresents the evils of over indulgence Sluggish turtle Sluggish donkey Ripped paper with artists signature
Bearded Woman.
1631.
Ribera..
Portrait .A woman, who at 37 began to grow a beard, and at 52 she and her husband had a baby Demonstrates Spanish interest in the grotesque, unusual, macabre Emphasis gender flexibility .Emphasis on manly-looking features Yet exposes large breast .Husband is timid in background .Spanish fad in cross-dressing and crossing gender roles is this due to strictness of gender laws in Spain Secular, as well as religious/moral meaning? Feminine Symbols .Cornucopia and spindle are references to the tasks of domestic women and fertility
Clubfooted Boy.
1642.
Ribera..
Appears secular, but is religious .Club-footed, tooth-rotted peasant boy, smiling, holding a paper that says Give me alms for the love of god This gives form to the catholic view of salvationto perform good works assures your place in paradise Boy .Smiling because he is an instrument of salvation and will go to heaven Indifferent to his suffering, Christ-like .Has great dignity, holding crutch proudly as if it is a royal baton or gun Towers over the mountains in the background
St. Serapion.
Zurbaran..
1623.
Meant to be a model for the monks of the monastery it was commissioned by SerapionMurdered in Africa trying to convert people Depicts the monk hanging from a tree by his arms Spanish traits .Spanish austerityNot gory details, just the peacefulness following the martyrdom Composition Block-like composition Hands turned in so as not to disrupt the box shape Extremely balanced Loops of drapery counter-balance the head on the left to keep balance of composition Extremely 3D accomplished through lighting and coloring delicate handling of the degrees of white, very realistic
Zurbaran..
One of the first still-lives since the ancient world Simplethree objects Lemons, Basket of oranges, a Group of a cup, pewter saucer, and rose Eye moves from left to right (lemons to cup Move up to leaves of oranges and down into oranges, forceful indentation of naval of oranges forces you to stay there Moves down toward cup Handle is turned toward the left, opposite side that most right-handed viewer would grabthis cup is not for the viewer Mood calm dark background Religious theory The objects represent the Virgin Mary Roserepresents Marys divine love Lemonsrepresent her fidelity Orange blossomsrepresent her purity (In Mediterranean brides wore these in their hair on their wedding day)
Velazquez..
Velazquez..
Surrender of Breda.
1634.
Historical painting for the throne room, hung on walls leading toward the throne Depicts fall of Dutch Breda to the Spanish Dutch on left, Spanish on right Spanish depiction: Dark, uniform outfits, Officers in front , Very straight, proudly held-up lances, Energetic horse Dutch depiction: Tattered garments, Foot soldiers are in front, Useless, blunt weapons, Tired horse Main Scene: Justin of Nasa giving Spinoza the key to the city puts hand on shoulder of Dutchman in a chivalrous, friendly, respectful way Reveals influence of Italian trips on Velazquez Paint effects Smokey atmospheresensitivity to optical effects Brushwork is looser and more varied Thick in foreground, thin in background
Rokeby Venus.
Velazquez..
1649.
Rare example of mythology in Spanish art Nudity is accepted because this is a private commission Inquisition cannot take ban its production Body is facing opposite viewer Probably sourced from the Hellenistic Hermaphrodite Technical qualities Interest in texture Curves of the poses emphasized Venetian, painterly, colorful brushwork Unidealizedflesh of real woman/model Venus is older than usualbeauty is fleeting Blurry reflection of face does not display the common Venus youth
Las Meninas.
Velazquez..
1656.
Velazquez painting princess Paradoxesreading of the painting meant to be unstable Is that a mirror or a portrait Representation is an act of blindness , not vision The picture looks out at a scene for which it scene False RealityRepresentation presented as real but Painting reacts to the limitations of representation
itself is a
its not
Open Balcony Chapel Native Christian converts not allowed to enteronly Spaniards monks preached to them from balcony Located in same religious place used before the turn to Christianity Atrium Cross You see just his face, not his body On the lower part of the crucifix there are stories of the crucifixion Thought that these crosses were meant to teach people about religion Base of cross: Mary sad about Christ Style Flat, native style Crucifixion Fresco, 1560-80 Modeling is 3D, Christ is musculaturesimilar to Michelangelo Black and white with touches of red in Mary Magdalene and Johns hair Detailed landscape in background Indigenous elements Ointment jar, attribute of Mary Magdalenetop of lid is a jaguar head, a native symbol of a deity
Baroque Realism:
Doubting Thomas
Looks very Caravaggio Textbook example of baroque realism Light adds drama Picks out important arrears Light creates texture Realistic wound is in the center Christ looks dead because this is after the crucifixion Difference from Italian Baroque Realism Caravaggio is very realistic and modest Artegas work is seductive and idealized (mannerism)
Northern Baroque
Hollandmid-1600s --Dominated by ProtestantsCalvinists and Mennonites --No church commissions for art because these groups did not support religious objects and huge alter pieces --There was no monarchy so there is no royal patronage -Holland ruled by State holder -Thus there was private art PATRONAGE BY MIDDLE CLASS -Effect--shift to portrait, genre paintings and still-lives
---
The Concert
Honthorst, 1620
Moralistic message
Frankness of sexuality
Large-scale painting Figures cut off (Italian influence) Emphasis on figures Use of light and shade, spotlight
The Alchemist
Ostade, 1661
Detailed, disorderly
Trying to convey the confused mind of the foolish alchemist who thinks he can make gold
Neglecting family
Wife is in background wiping the babies bottom
associated with Dutch proverb: This body, this body, What is it but waste and shit? Only the after-life matters
View of Dordrecht
Jan van Goyen, 1640 Harlem school
Windmill by a River
Goyen, 1642
Tonal landscape
Colors are only yellow and grey and green
Windmill and sand dunes signify Holland Human figures very insignificant Sky dominates
Separation of parts of land (land, water, sky) Reading of picture is controlled by strong diagonals Less sky, more land Color contrasts are much more drastic than the Goyen
Jewish Cemetery
J.V. Ruisdael, 1660
Structural landscape
Rich, dark colors Dramatic use of light and shade Tangibility of objects depicted
Allegorical
Church ruins added in
represent fleeting life also an attempt to Christianize the painting
Composition
Eye enters in at left with rainbow because that is how Westerners read Continues right toward tree that points down to the coffins
Malle Babbe
Frans Hals, 1633
Portrays an actual female bar-goer Body turns one way, head the other
creates strong diagonal to organize painting
The Proposition
Judith Leyster, 1630
Foreigner is offering a young woman a coin in the dark and she turns away, fearful of him Does not look happy; usually in these types of portraits the women are happy and excited at the advances of men
Perhaps Leysters opinion is different because she is a woman