Chapter 6
Chapter 6
1
INTRODUCTION
• Plane Solids
– All engineering problems are 3-D. It is the engineer who
approximates the problem using 1-D (beam or truss) or 2-
D (plane stress or strain).
– Stress and strain are either zero or constant in the
direction of the thickness.
– System of coupled second-order partial differential
equation
– Plane stress and plane strain: different constraints
imposed in the thickness direction
– Plane stress: zero stresses in the thickness direction (thin
plate with in-plane forces)
– Plane strain: zero strains in the thickness direction (thick
solid with constant thickness, gun barrel)
– Main variables: u (x-displacement) and v (y-displacement) 2
TYPES OF 2D PROBLEMS
• Governing D.E.
by
bx
• Definition of strain
• Stress-Strain Relation
3
TYPES OF 2D PROBLEMS cont.
• Boundary Conditions
– All differential equations must be accompanied by boundary conditions
4
PLANE STRESS PROBLEM
• Plane Stress Problem:
– Thickness is much smaller than the length and width dimensions
– Thin plate or disk with applied in-plane forces
– z-directional stresses are zero at the top and bottom surfaces
– Thus, it is safe to assume that they are also zero along the thickness
5
PLANE STRESS PROBLEM cont.
• Stress-strain relation
6
PLANE STRAIN PROBLEM
• Plane Strain Problem
– Thickness dimension is much larger than other two dimensions.
– Deformation in the thickness direction is constrained.
– Strain in z-dir is zero
7
PLANE STRAIN PROBLEM cont.
• Plan Strain Problem
– Stress-strain relation
8
EQUIVALENCE
• A single program can be used to solve both the plane stress
and plane strain problems by converting material properties.
From → To E ν
9
PRINCIPLE OF MINIMUM POTENTIAL ENERGY
• Strain Energy
– energy that is stored in the structure due to the elastic deformation
– h: thickness, [C] = [Cσ] for plane stress, and [C] = [Cε] for plane strain.
– stress and strain are constant throughout the thickness.
– The linear elastic relation {σ} = [C]{ε} has been used in the last
relation.
10
PRINCIPLE OF MINIMUM POTENTIAL ENERGY cont.
• Potential Energy of Applied Loads
– Force acting on a body reduces potential to do additional work.
– Negative of product of the force and corresponding displacement
– Concentrated forces
A
h
z ST
y
{Tx,Ty}
x
11
PRINCIPLE OF MINIMUM POTENTIAL ENERGY cont.
• Total Potential Energy
– Net energy contained in the structure
– Sum of the strain energy and the potential energy of applied loads
Finite Element
Equation
12
CST ELEMENT
• Constant Strain Triangular Element
– Decompose two-dimensional domain by a set of triangles.
– Each triangular element is composed by three corner nodes.
– Each element shares its edge and two corner nodes with an adjacent
element
– Counter-clockwise or clockwise node numbering
– Each node has two DOFs: u and v
– displacements interpolation using the shape functions and nodal
displacements.
– Displacement is linear because three nodal data are available.
– Stress & strain are constant.
y v3
3 u3
v1
1 u1 v2
u2
2 x 13
CST ELEMENT cont.
• Displacement Interpolation
– Since two-coordinates are perpendicular, u(x,y) and v(x,y) are
separated.
– u(x,y) needs to be interpolated in terms of u1, u2, and u3,
and v(x,y) in terms of v1, v2, and v3.
– interpolation function must be a three term polynomial in x and y.
– Since we must have rigid body displacements and constant strain
terms in the interpolation function, the displacement interpolation must
be of the form
14
CST ELEMENT cont.
• Displacement Interpolation
– x-displacement: Evaluate displacement at each node
v3
3 u3
v1
– In matrix notation u1 v2
1
u2
2
15
CST ELEMENT cont.
• Displacement Interpolation
– where
– Area:
16
CST ELEMENT cont.
N1(x,y)
N2(x,y)
N3(x,y)
17
CST ELEMENT cont.
• Displacement Interpolation
– A similar procedure can be applied for y-displacement v(x, y).
Shape
Function
– N1, N2, and N3 are linear functions of x- and y-coordinates.
– Interpolated displacement changes linearly along the each coordinate
direction.
18
CST ELEMENT cont.
• Displacement Interpolation
– Matrix Notation
19
CST ELEMENT cont.
• Strain Interpolation
– differentiating the displacement in x- and y-directions.
– differentiating shape function [N] because {q} is constant.
20
CST ELEMENT cont.
• Strain Interpolation
21
CST ELEMENT cont.
• Property of CST Element
– Since displacement is linear in x and y, the triangular element deforms
into another triangle when forces are applied.
– an imaginary straight line drawn within an element before deformation
becomes another straight line after deformation.
– Consider a local coordinate ξ such that ξ = 0 at Node 1 and ξ = a at
Node 2.
– Displacement on the edge 1-2: 3
1 a
– Since the variation of displacement is linear, ξ
the displacements should depend only on 2
u1 and u2, and not on u3.
22
CST ELEMENT cont. 3
1 a
1 x
2
Element 2 3
1 2
x
(0,0) (1,0)
24
EXAMPLE – Interpolation cont.
y
• Element 2: Nodes 2-3-4
(0,1) (1,1)
4 3
1 2
x
(0,0) (1,0)
26
CST ELEMENT cont.
• Potential energy of concentrated forces at nodes
y
3
Ty
1
s Tx
2 x
{T}={Tx,Ty} 27
CST ELEMENT cont.
• Rewrite with all 6 DOFs
29
CST ELEMENT cont.
• Potential energy of body forces
– distributed over the entire element (e.g. gravity or inertia forces).
30
CST ELEMENT cont.
• Total Potential Energy
• Element 1 E1
N2
5
– Area = 0.5×10×10 = 50.
50,000 lbs
N1
10
32
EXAMPLE 8.1 cont.
• Matrix [B]
33
EXAMPLE 8.1 cont.
• Stiffness Matrix for Element 1
34
EXAMPLE 8.1 cont.
• Matrix [B]
• Stiffness Matrix
35
EXAMPLE 8.1 cont.
• Assembly
Symmetric
• Rx1, Ry1, Rx4, and Ry4 are unknown reactions at nodes 1 and 4
• displacement boundary condition u1 = v1 = u4 = v4 = 0
36
EXAMPLE 8.1 cont.
• Reduced Matrix Equation and Solution
37
EXAMPLE 8.1 cont.
• Element Results
– Element 1
38
EXAMPLE 8.1 cont.
• Element Results
– Element 2
39
DISCUSSION
• These stresses are constant
over respective elements.
• large discontinuity in stresses
across element boundaries
40
BEAM BENDING EXAMPLE
-F
2 4 6 8 10
1m
1 3 5 7 9
5m F
41
BEAM BENDING EXAMPLE cont.
• y-normal stress and shear stress are supposed to be zero.
42
CST ELEMENT cont.
• Discussions
– CST element performs well when strain gradient is small.
– In pure bending problem, σxx in the neutral axis should be zero.
Instead, CST elements show oscillating pattern of stress.
– CST elements predict stress and deflection about ¼ of the exact
values.
• Strain along y-axis is supposed to be linear. But, CST elements
can only have constant strain in y-direction.
• CST elements also have spurious shear strain.
v2
1 2
How can we improve
accuracy? u2
What direction?
43
CST ELEMENT cont.
• Two-Layer Model
– σxx = 2.32 × 107
– vmax = 0.0028
44
RECTANGULAR ELEMENT
• Each edge is parallel to the coordinate direction (not practical)
• Lagrange interpolation for shape function calculation
• Interpolation:
4 3
y
?
1 2
x
45
LAGRANGE INTERPOLATION
• Interpolation
x1 x x2
u1 u(x) u2
46
RECTANGULAR ELEMENT cont.
uII
• Lagrange Interpolation 4 3
– Along edge 1-2, y = y1 (constant) y
1 uI x 2
47
RECTANGULAR ELEMENT cont.
uII
• Lagrange Interpolation 4 3
– Y-direction y
1 uI x 2
– Combine together
48
RECTANGULAR ELEMENT cont.
• Lagrange Interpolation
49
RECTANGULAR ELEMENT cont.
• Shape functions for rectangular elements are product of
Lagrange interpolations in the two coordinate directions.
• Note that N1(x, y) is:
– 1 at node 1 and 0 at other nodes.
– Linear function of x along edge 1-2 and linear function of y along edge
1-4.
– Zero along edge 2-3 and 3-4.
• Other shape functions have similar behavior.
N1
4 3
1 2
50
RECTANGULAR ELEMENT cont.
• Displacement interpolation
– Same interpolation for both u and v.
51
EXAMPLE 8.2
• Shape Functions y
4 (0,2) 3 (3,2)
1 (0,0) 2 (3,0)
N1 N2
52
RECTANGULAR ELEMENT cont.
• Strain-displacement relation
– Similar to CST element
53
RECTANGULAR ELEMENT cont.
• Element stiffness matrix (from strain energy)
54
RECTANGULAR ELEMENT cont.
• Nodal and distributed forces are the same with CST element
• Body force (constant body force b = {bx, by}T)
55
EXAMPLE – SIMPLE SHEAR
y
• E = 10 GPa, v = 0.25, h=0.1m
• F = 100 kN/m2
• {Qs} = {u1, v1, u2, v2, u3, v3, u4, v4}T. 4 f 3
1 2
x
• FEM equation (after applying BC)
• Nodal displacements
56
EXAMPLE – SIMPLE SHEAR cont.
• Strain & Stress
Deformed
Undeformed shape
shape
57
EXAMPLE – PURE BENDING
y
• Couple M = 100 kN.m f
• Analytical solution 4 3
1m
1m
1 2 f
• FEM solution x
58
EXAMPLE – PURE BENDING cont.
• Strain & Stress
Undeformed
shape
Unable to make curvature
Deformed Trapezoidal shape -> non-zero shear stress
shape
(σxx)max /(σxx)exact = 4.364/6.0 (73%)
59
BEAM BENDING PROBLEM cont.
• Sxx Plot Max v =
0.0051
61
BEAM BENDING PROBLEM cont.
• At bottom surface, y = 0 4 3
1 2
• Stress:
62
RECTANGULAR ELEMENT
• y-normal stress and shear stress are supposed to be zero.
63
RECTANGULAR ELEMENT
• Discussions
– Can’t represent constant shear force problem because εxx must be a
linear function of x.
– Even if εxx can represent linear strain in y-direction, the rectangular
element can’t represent pure bending problem accurately.
– Spurious shear strain makes the element too stiff.
Exac
t
Rectangula
r
element
64
RECTANGULAR ELEMENT
• Two-Layer Model
– σxx = 3.48×107
– vmax = 0.0053
65
BEAM BENDING PROBLEM cont.
• Distorted Element
Max v =
0.004
66
BEAM BENDING PROBLEM cont.
• Constant Shear Force Problem
Max v =
0.0035
67
BEAM BENDING PROBLEM cont.
4 7 3
• Higher-Order Element?
– 8-Node Rectangular Element
8 6
1 5 2
– Strain
68
BEAM BENDING PROBLEM cont.
• 8-Node Rectangular Elements
69
BEAM BENDING PROBLEM cont.
• If the stress at the bottom surface is calculated, it will be the
exact stress value.
Sxx Syy
70
ISOPARAMETRIC ELEMENT
• Quadrilateral Shape
– Most commonly used element (irregular shape)
– Generalization of rectangular element
– Use mapping to transform into a square (Reference element).
– The relationship between (x, y) and (s, t) must be obtained.
– All formulations are done in the reference element.
v3
y v4 t
3 u3
4 4 (-1,1) 3 (1,1)
u4
v1
s
1 u1 v2
u2 1 (-1,-1) 2 (1,-1)
2 x
t
4 (-1,1) 3 (1,1)
1 (-1,-1) 2 (1,-1)
72
ISOPARAMETRIC MAPPING cont.
y t
3
4 4 (-1,1) 3 (1,1)
1
1 (-1,-1) 2 (1,-1)
2 x
Proportional mapping
For a given (x,y), find corresponding
(s,t).
For a given (s,t), find corresponding
(x,y).
73
ISOPARAMETRIC MAPPING cont.
– Use the shape functions for interpolating displacement and geometry.
– For a given value of (s,t) in the parent element, the corresponding
point (x,y) in the actual element and displacement at that point can be
obtained using the mapping relationship.
Displacement Geometry
interpolation interpolation
74
EXAMPLE
• Find mapping point of A in the physical element
– At point A, (s, t) = (0.5, 0.5)
– Physical coord
y t
3 (2,4) 4 (−1,1) 3 (1,1)
2 (4,4)
A (.5,.5)
B (1,2) s
x
4 (0,0) 1 (6,0) 1 (−1,−1) 2 (1,−1)
75
EXAMPLE cont.
• Find mapping point of B in the reference element
– At point B, (x, y) = (1, 2)
76
JACOBIAN OF MAPPING
Shape functions are given in (s,t). But, we want to differentiate w.r.t. (x,y) in
order to calculate strain and stress. Use chain rule of differentiation.
In Matrix Form
77
JACOBIAN OF MAPPING cont.
• Derivatives of shape functions w.r.t. (x,y) coordinates:
78
JACOBIAN OF MAPPING cont.
• Jacobian is an important criterion for evaluating the validity of
mapping, as well as the quality of element
• Every point in the reference element should be mapped into
the interior of the physical element
• When an interior point in (s, t) coord. is mapped into an
exterior point in the (x, y) coord., the Jacobian becomes
negative
• If multiple points in (s, t) coordinates are mapped into a single
point in (x, y) coordinates, the Jacobian becomes zero at that
point
• It is important to maintain the element shape so that the
Jacobian is positive everywhere in the element
79
EXAMPLE (JACOBIAN)
Jacobian must not be zero anywhere in the domain (-1 ≤ s, t ≤ 1)
y
• Nodal Coordinates 3(2, 2)
4(0, 1)
• Iso-Parametric Mapping
x
1(0, 0) 2(1, 0)
• Jacobian Matrix
80
EXAMPLE (JACOBIAN) cont.
• Jacobian
Constant s
t
4 (-1,1) 3 (1,1)
Constant t
1 (-1,-1) 2 (1,-1)
81
EXAMPLE (JACOBIAN) cont.
y
• Nodal Coordinates 4(0, 5) 3(5, 5)
2(1, 4)
• Mapping
1(0, 0)
x
• Jacobian
82
EXAMPLE 8.3 (JACOBIAN) cont.
Constant s
• In general the element geometry
is invalid if the Jacobian is either
zero or negative anywhere in the Constant t
element.
• Problems also arise when the
Invalid mapping
Jacobian matrix is nearly singular
either due to round-off errors or
due to badly shaped elements.
• To avoid problems due to badly > 15o
shaped elements, it is suggested
that the inside angles in quadrilateral < 165o
elements be > 15˚ and < 165˚
83
INTERPOLATION
• Displacement Interpolation (8-DOF)
84
INTERPOLATION cont.
• Strain
85
INTERPOLATION cont.
• Strain cont.
Strain-displacement matrix
– The expression of [B] is not readily available because the matrix [A]
involves the inverse of Jacobian matrix
– The strain-displacement matrix [B] is not constant
86
EXAMPLE
• {u1, v1, u2, v2, u3, v3, u4, v4} = {0, 0, 1, 0, 2, 1, 0, 2}
• Displacement and strain at (s,t)=(1/3, 0)?
• Shape Functions
• At (s,t)=(1/3, 0)
y t
4 (0,2) 3 (3,2) 4 (-1,1) 3 (1,1)
s
x
1 (0,0) 2 (3,0) 1 (-1,-1) 2 (1,-1)
87
EXAMPLE cont.
• Location at the Actual Element
88
EXAMPLE cont.
• Derivatives of the shape functions w.r.t. s and t.
89
EXAMPLE cont.
• Jacobian Matrix
• Strain
91
FINITE ELEMENT EQUATION
• Element stiffness matrix from strain energy expression
92
NUMERICAL INTEGRATION
• Stiffness matrix and distributed load calculations involve
integration over the domain
• In many cases, analytical integration is very difficult
• Numerical integration based on Gauss Quadrature is
commonly used in finite element programs
• Gauss Quadrature:
93
NUMERICAL INTEGRATION cont.
• Constant Function: f(s) = 4
– Use one integration point s1 = 0 and weight w1 = 2
94
NUMERICAL INTEGRATION cont.
• Quadratic Function: f(s) = 3s2 + 2s + 1
– Let’s use one-point Gauss Quadrature
96
NUMERICAL INTEGRATION cont.
• 2-Dimensional Integration
– multiplying two one-dimensional Gauss integration formulas
t t t
s s s
97
NUMERICAL INTEGRATION EXAMPLE
• Integrate the following polynomial:
– One-point formula
– Two-point formula
98
NUMERICAL INTEGRATION EXAMPLE cont.
– 3-point formula
– 4-point formula
99
NUMERICAL INTEGRATION
• Application to Stiffness Matrix Integral
100
PROJECT 2
• Analysis and Design of Torque Arm
– Material properties: E = 206.8 GPa, Poisson’s ratio = 0.29, thickness =
1.0 cm, mass density = 7850 kg/m3
– Preliminary analysis: Knowledge from Mechanics of Materials
– Convergence study on vertical displacement at the load application pt
– Modify the shape of the torque arm to reduce weight
All dimensions in cm
2.5 4.2
4
1.0 2789N
Fixed
5
12 15 5066N
42
101