Excel Failure Analysis 25
Excel Failure Analysis 25
EXCEL WORKOUT
(A (B) σ
cracks )
σmin=0MPa
reinforcing rib
time
Cracks have been discovered in several locations along
the edge of a 6Al-4V titanium housing for the
hydraulic power drive unit for the wing flap actuators
of a commercial aircraft. The rib is 6.4 mm thick and
51mm wide as shown in figure above. The cracks go all
the way through the thickness and are about 2.54 mm
issues
A). If the part is subjected to static loading only (no fatigue) and the maximum estimated loading
produces a tensile load along the rib of 223 kN, would you recommend grounding the plane? How
confident are you in making the recommendation?
B). however, what if the part is subjected to fatigue load? What is your recommendation??
C). If fracture mechanics dominates the failure domain, what is your recommendation?
6Al-4V titanium
properties KI = Kic
yield ultimate toughness crack β Ki
MPa MPa MPa√m mm MPa√m stress
1100 1170 100 2.54 1.12 2161.548767 683 Mpa
a=(1/3.1416)*(Kic/βσd )^2
1.169179584
Thick cylinder
Thick cylinder governing equations
Lamé’s equations:
Hoop Stress,
Radial Stress,
Aspect Ratio
Test
(Should appear
circular)
4x3
16x9