Fatality Analysis & Past Lessons 2019-2023
Fatality Analysis & Past Lessons 2019-2023
LESSONS
2019-2023
LTSL
Nishil G. Jos
FY2022-23/ 30 October, 2023
Hit by moving
The garbage collection tractor ran over victim while vehicle
EPC, Buxar 28-Feb-21
taking a turn in the road inside the Labour Colony
(Tractor)
While removing the Office roof panel, victim Fall from height
RRUVNL, Chhabra 4-Mar-20
slipped and fell down from a height
The tractor was deployed for disposal of garbage at Labour colony. While the tractor
was inside the colony and taking right turn near a drain, it came across the victim
who was crossing in front of the vehicle. Driver of the tractor could not control the
movement of the tractor and one wheel ran over the victim.
Position of vehicle
immediately after
the incident
They were handling and lowering it by using 25 mm dia. PP rope and pulley arrangement. While guiding the rope, the rigging
crew lost the grip over the rope.
As a result, the rope got accelerated and the loose end of PP rope, which was lying on the platform in a coil form, got
entangled on the victim’s feet and he fell and was dragged.
While being dragged, he hit the rigging crew members on his way and they also fell. The victim’s leg got stuck in the adjacent
structure. This sudden jerk resulted in the severing of his left leg below the knee and suspected injury on his head.
Due to this impact, the temporary rope restraining rod on which the rope was wound before the pulley, broke from its welding
and the rope also got cut. As a result, the yoke assembly fell from a height of approx. 100 meters and got damaged.
The Victim was rushed to Metro hospital where he was declared brought dead.
In addition, one of the rigging crew members, Mr. Sahid Anwar Ansari, Khalasi of M/s. Dilip Chaudhari, aged 21 years, suffered
a hairline crack on his left foot and cut injury on his forehead as he fell on the floor.
Site Conditions
• The temporary rope restraining rod was fixed by tag welding and was not having adequate strength to
take the impact load.
Management:
• Allowing the work to be carried out by adopting wrong and unsafe practice of lowering heavy assembly by
pulley and rope arrangement.
• Not followed the emergency protocol of ensuring transport of victim after providing first aid and/or with
proper first aid measures.
Job Factors:
• The spoke assembly was too big and heavy and should have been partially dismantled and handled by
Winch & diversion pulley & wire rope arrangement only as is followed for this activity.
TECHNOLOGY | ENGINEERING | MANUFACTURING | CONSTRUCTION | LIFE CYCLE SERVICES
Sensitivity : This Document is Classified as "LNT Internal Use".
What is being done to prevent reoccurrence ?
6/6
• Comprehensive Method Statement of Slip-form dismantling to be developed by technical expert
team in close consultation with execution members and implemented after approval of Client.
• Based on the Method statement, SOPs, JSA, checklists to be developed and implemented for
dismantling activity for slip-form assembly.
• Supervision to be strengthened during the critical to safety activities like slipform dismantling.
• Emergency Plan for safe transport of injured to be followed.
• Rigging crew of the Contractor to be changed.
To insert the tie-beam (held by a crane) between the 2 columns, the foundation bolts and nuts of
one column were loosened and a wedge was inserted and hammered to create the gap between
the columns. The victim had gone to the scaffolding platform at a height of 9 meter, to check the
proper placement of beam inside the columns.
This loosened column was already stitch welded to another tie-beam at 9 meter. During this
process of hammering of the wedge, the other end of this tie beam gave way and the column and
the tie-beam fell down.
As a result, the victim also fell along-with the column and his head was trapped between the
column and beam. He succumbed to his head injury.
TECHNOLOGY | ENGINEERING | MANUFACTURING | CONSTRUCTION | LIFE CYCLE SERVICES
Sensitivity : This Document is Classified as "LNT Internal Use".
Incident Brief
3/9
ID Fan Side
C-1
C-2
C-4 C-3
B-1
B-3 B-2
B-4
Behavioral:
5. The victim, a ‘Sikh’ person was wearing full ‘pagri’ but no helmet, although he was wearing harness
and safety shoes and his harness was latched to column
6. The victim was advised by the fitter to come down from the column, which he refused
Supervision:
7. The concerned package engineer, safety supervisor and erection manager did not comply with the
erection procedures, considering these light structures a low risk activity as compared to the heavy
boiler structures
8. Proper area lighting was not ensured for late evening activity
• At NTPC Tanda project, on 23rd August 2019, a gang of 15 workmen were engaged for ESP duct
alignment and final fit-up activities.
• For carrying out this activity, several temporary scaffold platforms comprising of 2 or 3 nos.
scaffolding planks were built at different locations and elevations over the external surface of the
duct.
• Post lunch session, it was required to lower the gas cutting set along-with gas pipe from one of the
scaffolding working platform. Around 2.40 PM, the victim lowered the gas cutting set by standing on
one of the scaffolding platform.
• After completing lowering of the gas cutting set, he started climbing down the platforms one after
another and during this process, lost his balance and fell on the ground from approx. 20 meter
height to ground level.
• He became unconscious and was rushed to NTPC Hospital immediately where he was declared as
brought dead by the Hospital authorities.
Persons are
entering here
Safety net
not provided
Below the
bottom working
platform Life Line
A. Unsafe Action
• Allowing the work to be carried out at height without access ladder, life line, safety net,
etc.
B. Unsafe Condition
• Rope & pulley arrangement was not adopted to lower / shift the gas cutting set & pipes.
• There was no life line available in the temporary platform from where the victim fell
down. The lifeline was below this platform.
Corrective Actions:
Workman
Duct Panel
Material
Workman
Trailer
vehicle
Duct Panel slided and Fell down along-with Victim. He got trapped
between panel and ground
panels
Corrective Action:
Counter-measures:
made.
• M/s. Synergy Thrislington Instacon Pvt. Ltd. was given the contract to
dismantling and shifting work of site office at Chhabra Project Site.
• A team of 6 nos. workmen were doing the dismantling activity under
one Supervisor.
• On 04.03.2020 around 11.30 AM, the Victim was working without
securing himself on the structure frame for removing the frame.
While doing so, he slipped and fell down from a height of 2.75 meters
and sustained head injury.
• He was taken RRUVNL Medical Centre After getting the necessary
first-aid, he was referred to Chhabra Hospital.
• After getting initial treatment, he was referred to MBS Hospital, Kota.
He was declared brought dead by MBS Hospital, Kota
Workman
Frame
Structure of
Site Office
being
dismantled
Duct Panel slided and Fell down along-with Victim. He got trapped
between panel and ground
B. Unsafe Condition
• Loose frame of the structure.
Corrective Actions:
• Plan the dismantling methodology with the Contractor considering all the site specific
hazards and associated risks, specially the risk of fall and collapse of structure.
• Provide proper access ladder / platform to carry out the dismantling activity and ensure that
the workers are always wearing the required PPEs.
• Ensure the competency of all the workmen being deployed by the Contractor
• Sensitize all the workmen regarding the hazards related to fall of person, material, and
importance of adherence to protocol of working at height and permit system.
Together we succeed!
STRONG FINISH 2023
48