3-Experimental Designs and Layout
3-Experimental Designs and Layout
• Treatments
• Are the different procedures we want to
compare.
• These could be different kinds or amounts of
fertilizer in agronomy,
• Different insecticides or their doses,
• Different temperatures for insect development,
• Different food for insect growth.
• Experimental units
• Are the things to which we apply the treatments.
• These could be plots of land receiving fertilizer,
• Plots receiving different insecticides,
• Plots receiving different insect populations,
• Insects receiving different doses of chemicals
• Variable-
• Variables are quantities of interest or which serve as
the practical substitutes for the concepts of interest.
• Responses
• Are outcomes that we observe after applying a
treatment to an experimental unit.
• That is, the response is what we measure to judge
what happened in the experiment; we often have
more than one response.
• Responses for the above examples might be nitrogen
content or biomass of corn plants, or insect survival or
mortality with certain chemicals.
• Randomization
• Assignment of treatments to experimental units
by using a chance mechanism.
• Replication-
• Assignment of individual treatments to multiple
experimental units
• Blocking-
• Assignment of treatments within multiple groups
of experimental units
• Experimental Error
• Is the random variation present in all experimental
results.
• Different experimental units will give different
responses to the same treatment,
• and it is often true that applying the same treatment
over and over again to the same unit will result in
different responses in different trials.
• Experimental error does not refer to conducting the
wrong experiment or dropping test tubes.
• Measurement units (or response units)
• Are the actual objects on which the response is
measured.
• These may differ from the experimental units.
• For example, consider the effect of different fertilizers
on the nitrogen content of corn plants.
• Different field plots are the experimental units, but
the measurement units might be a subset of the corn
plants on the field plot,
• or a sample of leaves, stalks, and roots from the field
plot.
• Blinding
• Occurs when the evaluators of a response do not know
which treatment was given to which unit.
• Blinding helps prevent bias in the evaluation, even
unconscious bias from well-intentioned evaluators.
• Double blinding occurs when both the evaluators of the
response and the (human subject) experimental units do not
know the assignment of treatments to units.
• Blinding the subjects can also prevent bias, because subject
responses can change when subjects have expectations for
certain treatments.
• Control
• Has several different uses in design.
• First, an experiment is controlled because we as experimenters assign
treatments to experimental units. Otherwise, we would have an
observational study.
• Second, a control treatment is a “standard” treatment that is used as a
baseline or basis of comparison for the other treatments.
• This control treatment might be the treatment in common use, or it might
be a null treatment (no treatment at all).
• For example, a study of new chemical could use a standard chemical as a
control treatment,
• or a study on the efficacy of fertilizer could give some fields no fertilizer at
all. This would control for average soil fertility or weather conditions.
• Placebo
• Is a null treatment that is used when the act of applying a treatment
— any treatment—has an effect.
• Placebos are often used with human subjects, because people often
respond to any treatment:
• For example, reduction in headache pain when given a sugar pill.
• Blinding is important when placebos are used with human subjects.
• Placebos are also useful for nonhuman subjects.
• The apparatus for spraying a field with a pesticide may compact the
soil.
• Thus we drive the apparatus over the field, without actually spraying,
as a placebo treatment.
• Factors combinations to form treatments.
For example, the population of growth is the
result (or effected) by temperature and light.