Akong Report!

Akong Report!
Historical Interpretation
• History is not just a study of the past but also involves
understanding how it impacts the present.
• Geoffrey (presumably a historian) describes history as
an attempt to uncover significant aspects of the past
using limited evidence.
• He suggests that while history is based on facts, it is
also shaped by historians’ judgments, meaning it
involves interpretation.
The Code of Kalantiaw
• The Code of Kalantiaw was once believed to be an
ancient legal code created by Datu Kalantiaw in 1433 in
the Philippines.
• It was considered a source of pride and a symbol of
Filipino legal history until it was debunked in 1968 by
historian William Henry Scott.
• Scott’s research revealed that the code was actually a
part of a fictional work written by Jose E. Marco in 1913.
• Despite this revelation, some people continue to believe
in the authenticity of the Code of Kalantiaw.
Historical Interpretation and Primary
Sources
• Historians collect facts from primary sources and interpret them to
make the past understandable for their audience.
• Primary sources may not always be accessible or easily understood
by the general public, which can lead to misinterpretation if not
properly analyzed by a trained historian.
• Different interpretations of the same event can arise depending on
who reads the primary source, when it is read, and how it is read.
• As students of history, it is crucial to recognize and critically evaluate
different interpretations to understand the past accurately.
• Interpretations of historical events can change over time, and
tracking these changes is an important skill for understanding history.
“Sa Aking Mga Kabata”
• Is a poem traditionally attributed to Jose Rizal, believed to have been
written when he was just eight years old.
• There is significant evidence suggesting that Rizal did not write the poem:
• No manuscript of the poem in Rizal’s handwriting exists.
• The poem was first published in 1906 by Hermenegildo Cruz, who claimed
to have received it from Gabriel Beato Francisco. Francisco, in turn,
claimed to have received it from Saturnino Raselis, a supposed close
friend of Rizal, though Rizal never mentioned this person in his writings.
• The poem’s use of the word “kalayaan” is questionable, as Rizal reportedly
first encountered the word later in life through Marcelo H. del Pilar’s
translation of one of his essays.
• History is not a fixed set of facts but rather a construct open to
interpretation.
History as a Construct
• Many “facts” about the past that we accept as true may
not be accurate or may change over time as new
interpretations emerge.
• History is a construct, meaning it is shaped by how it is
interpreted and understood by people over time.
Multiperspectivity
• Multiperspectivity is the practice of looking at historical
events, figures, developments, cultures, and societies
from various perspectives.
• It acknowledges that there are multiple ways to view
and interpret the world, each with its own validity and
limitations.
Importance of Multiple Perspectives
• Exploring multiple perspectives in history is crucial
because singular narratives often fail to capture the
complexity of historical events.
• Multiperspectivity in history allows for a richer, more
diverse exploration of the past.
Different Sources, Different Truths
• This diversity of perspectives adds complexity but also
depth to historical scholarship, making it richer and
more comprehensive.
Case Study: The First Catholic Mass
in the Philippines
- The site of the first Catholic Mass in the Philippines has
long been debated. Butuan was traditionally believed to
be the location for centuries.
- A monument was erected in Butuan in 1872 to
commemorate this event, based on early interpretations
of historical sources.
• - Later scholarship, beginning in the late 19th century
and continuing into the 20th century, challenged this
interpretation and proposed Limasawa Island as the
actual site of the first Mass.
Primary Sources for the First Mass
- **Francisco Albo’s logbook**: Albo, a pilot on
Magellan’s expedition, provided latitude coordinates and
described the islands they encountered.
- **Antonio Pigafetta’s account**: Pigafetta, the
chronicler of the expedition, offered a detailed narrative,
including descriptions of the first Mass.
• - These sources describe the expedition’s route,
leading to the conclusion that the first Mass likely took
place on the island of “Mazava,” now believed to be
Limasawa.
Analysis of the Case Study
• - The new details from Albo’s account further support the interpretation that
Mazava (or Mazaua) aligns with the island of Limasawa. Albo’s description of the
location and the events matches Limasawa’s geographical features.
• - He also describes the planting of a cross on a mountaintop from which three
islands could be seen to the west and southwest, consistent with Limasawa’s
geography.
• - Although Albo does not directly mention the first Mass, the planting of the
cross could be interpreted as part of the religious activities associated with it.
• This extended analysis of Albo’s account emphasizes the importance of
considering all available evidence when interpreting historical events. The
detailed geographic descriptions in Albo’s logbook, when cross-referenced with
modern maps, suggest that the first Catholic Mass in the Philippines took place
on Limasawa Island, not Butuan, as was traditionally believed.
• The shift in interpretation illustrates how historical understanding evolves as new
readings and more nuanced analyses of primary sources emerge.

Akong Report!

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Akong Report!

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Akong Report!

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Akong Report!

You might also like