Power and Politics in Organizations Chapter Six
Power and Politics in Organizations Chapter Six
Power and Politics in Organizations Chapter Six
1
Ch. 5 Power and Politics in organizations
A Definition of Power
Individual Power
Position Power
Personal Power
• Referent power
• Legitimate power
• Expert power
• Reward power
• Coercive power
3
PERSONAL POWER
4
Bases of Power: Formal Power
Legitimate Power: you derive from your formal
position or office held in the organization's
hierarchy of authority.
For example, the president of a corporation has certain
powers because of the office they hold in the
corporation. Like most power, legitimate power is based
upon perception and reality.
5
Coercive Power
Coercive power is when someone in a
position of power uses the threat of
punishment to force subordinates
into complying with their demands.
Fear of punishment is the incentive to
comply. There are many types of
coercive power, including expert power,
legitimate power, reward power, and
informational power
6
7
Bases of Power: Personal Power
Expert Power/ use your specialized skills to help your
team members,
Influence based on special skills or knowledge. It is generally
acknowledged that physicians have expertise and hence
expert power: Most of us follow our doctor’s advice.
Computer specialists, tax accountants, economists,
industrial psychologists, and other specialists wield
power as a result of their expertise.
11
Influence Tactics
• What power tactics do people use to translate power bases into
specific action?
• What options do they have for influencing their bosses, coworkers, or
employees
• Research has identified the following influence tactics.
1. Legitimacy. Relying on your authority position or saying a request
accords with organizational policies or rules.
2. Rational persuasion. Presenting logical arguments and factual evidence
to demonstrate a request is reasonable.
3. Consultation. Increasing the target’s support by involving him or her in
deciding how you will accomplish your plan.
4. Exchange. Rewarding the target with benefits or favors in exchange for
following a request.
5. Personal appeals. Asking for compliance based on friendship or loyalty.
6. Pressure. Using warnings, repeated demands, and threats.
7. Coalitions. Enlisting the aid or support of others to persuade the target
to agree. Common examples of coalitions within organizations
are unions that may threaten to strike if their demands are not 12
Definition of politics
• Those activities that are not required as part of one’s formal role in
the organization, but that influence the distribution of advantages
within the organization.
• It is outside one’s specified job requirements.
• It encompasses efforts to influence decision-making goals,
criteria, or processes.
It includes such behaviors as withholding information, whistle
blowing, spreading rumors, Leaking confidential information to
the media, Exchanging favors with others in the organization for
mutual benefit, and Lobbying on behalf of or against a particular
individual or decision alternative.
• Organizational politics are activities people perform to acquire,
enhance, and use power & other resources to obtain their preferred
outcomes in a situation where there is uncertainty or disagreement.
13-13
Identify the causes and consequences of political behavior
13-15
Individual factors
• Factors Contributing to Political Behavior as shown in Exhibit , include individual
factors.
• Researchers have identified certain personality traits, needs, & other factors that
are likely to be related to political behavior.
• Individuals with an internal locus of control are more prone to take a proactive
stance & attempt to manipulate situations in their favor.
• The Machiavellian personality is comfortable using politics as a means to further
his/her self-interest.
• An individual’s investment in the organization, perceived alternatives, and
expectations of success will influence the tendency to pursue illegitimate means
of political action.
• The more a person expects increased future benefits from the organization, and
the more that person has to lose if forced out, the less likely he or she is to use
illegitimate means.
• Conversely, the more alternate job opportunities an individual has—due to a
favourable job market, possession of scarce skills or knowledge, prominent
reputation, or influential contacts outside the organization—the more likely the
person is to employ politics. 16
Organizational factors
• The organizational factors that influence politics are many. Political activity is probably more a
function of the organization’s characteristics than of individual difference variables.
• When an organization’s resources are declining, when the existing pattern of resources is changing,
and when there is opportunity for promotions, politics is more likely to surface.
• Cultures characterized by low trust, role ambiguity, unclear performance evaluation systems, high
pressures for performance, and self-serving senior managers will create breeding grounds for
politicking.
• When organizations downsize to improve efficiency, people may engage in political actions to
safeguard what they have.
• Promotion decisions have consistently been found to be one of the most political in organizations.
• The less trust there is within the organization, the higher the level of political behavior and the more
likely it will be illegitimate.
• Role ambiguity means that the prescribed behaviors of the employee are not clear. The greater the
role ambiguity, the more one can engage in political activity with little chance of it being visible.
• Subjective performance criteria create ambiguity. Single outcome measures encourage doing
whatever is necessary to “look good.” The more time that elapses between an action and its
appraisal, the more unlikely that the employee will be held accountable for his/her political
behaviors.
• The more pressure that employees feel to perform well, the more likely they are to engage in
politicking.. When employees see top management successfully engaging in political behavior,
17
a
climate is created that supports politicking.
Identify the causes and consequences of political behavior
13-18
Consequences of political behavior
• For most people, who have modest political skills or are
unwilling to play the politics game, outcomes tend to be
predominantly negative.
• Exhibit summarizes the extensive research on the relationship
between organizational politics and individual outcomes.
• There is very strong evidence indicating that perceptions of
organizational politics are negatively related to job satisfaction.
• The perception of politics leads to anxiety or stress.
• When it gets to be too much to handle, employees quit.
• When employees of two agencies in a recent study in Nigeria
viewed their work environments as political, they reported
higher levels of job distress & were less likely to help their co-
workers.
19
Chapter SIX
Define conflict
A Definition of Conflict
• A process that begins when one party perceives that another party
has negatively affected, or is about to negatively affect,
something that the first party cares about.
• The parties to it must perceive conflict.
14-21
Differentiate between the traditional, &
interactionist
• The Traditional View of Conflict
• Assumed all was bad & to be avoided.
• Viewed negatively and discussed with such terms violence,
destruction, and irrationality.
• Conflict was a dysfunctional outcome resulting from poor
communication, a lack of openness & trust between people,
and the failure of managers to be responsive to the needs
and aspirations of their employees.
Exhibit 5.1
conflict
29
STATUS INCONSISTENCIES
• Very often, functions whose activities are the most central &
essential to a company’s operations come to view themselves as
more important than other functions & believe they have
higher status or prestige in the organization.
• As a result, they may attempt to achieve their goals at the
expense of other functions & the result is conflict among
functions that lowers organizational performance. Top managers
need to work to prevent this happening.
• To demonstrate their high status, they respond more slowly to
the needs of other functions & this also results in conflict
between them.
• Task relationships generate conflict between people & groups
because organizational tasks are interrelated & affect one
another.
TASK INTERDEPENDENCIES
• If one function does not do its job well, the ability of the
function next in line to perform at a high level is reduced, &
the outcome is likely to be conflict.
• For example, the ability of manufacturing to reduce costs on
the production line depends on how well R&D has designed the
product so it can be made more cheaply & how well sales has
attracted large customer orders so large production runs
(which lower production costs) become possible.
• The potential for conflict increases as the interdependence of
functions or divisions increases.
• Thus, as task interdependence increases from pooled, to
sequential, to reciprocal interdependence, the potential for
conflict among functions or divisions is greater.
Scarcity of Resources
• Competition for scarce resources produces conflict.
• Conflict over the allocation of capital occurs among
divisions & between divisions & corporate headquarters.
• Budget fights can be fierce when resources are scarce.
• Other organizational groups also have an interest in the way
a company allocates scarce resources.
• Shareholders care about the size of their dividends.
• Employees want to maximize their salaries & benefits.
• Managers in competition for scarce resources may fight
over whom should get the biggest pay raise.
Pondy’s Model of Organizational Conflict
Exhibit .5.2
Stage 1:
Latent Conflict
Stage 2:
Perceived Conflict
Stage 3:
Felt Conflict
Stage 4:
Manifest Conflict
Stage 5:
Conflict Aftermath
Pondy’s Model of Organizational Conflict
Compromise
Low
Avoidance Competition
Low High
Interest in achieving individual goals
Direct negotiations
• groups are held either with or without a third-party
negotiator.
• The third party facilitates the bargaining process to help the
parties in dispute find a solution to their problem.
• Sometimes the manager, often the CEO, who is responsible
for the performance of the parties in conflict acts as the
third party.
• A third party who plays the role of mediator takes a neutral
stance & works with the parties to reconcile their
differences.
• Five forms of negotiation can be identified as the parties
in conflict attempt to manage their differences:
compromise, collaboration, accommodation,
avoidance, & competition (see Exhibit 5.3).
REACTIONS TO CONFLICT
Organizational Culture
Every company has its own unique personality, just like
people do.
The unique personality of an organization is referred to as
its culture.
In groups of people who work together, organizational
culture is an invisible but powerful force that
influences the behavior of the members of that group.
55
Dimensions of Organizational Culture
57
Culture as a Liability:
Barrier
Barrier toto change:-
change:- Consistency
Consistency of of behavior,
behavior, an
an asset
asset in in aa
stable
stable environment,
environment, may may then
then burden
burden the
the organization
organization andand
make
makeititdifficult
difficultto
to respond
respond toto changes.
changes.
Barrier
Barrier toto diversity:-
diversity:- Hiring
Hiring new
new employees
employees who
who differ
differ from
from
the
the majority
majority in in race,
race, age,
age, gender,
gender, disability,
disability, or
or other
other
characteristics
characteristicscreates
createsaa paradox
paradox
Barrier
Barrier to to acquisitions
acquisitions and and mergers:-
mergers:- MoreMore than
than thethe
financial
financial advantage
advantage and and product
product synergy,
synergy, decision
decision on on
merger
merger and and acquisition
acquisition havehave recently
recently focused
focused on on the
the
cultural
cultural compatibility
compatibility of of the
the two
two firms.
firms.
60
Strong versus Weak Cultures
• If most employees (responding to management surveys) have
the same opinions about the organization’s mission & values,
the culture is strong; if opinions vary widely, the culture is
weak.
• The more members who accept the core values & the greater
their commitment, the stronger the culture and the greater its
influence on member behavior, because the high degree of
shared-ness and intensity creates a climate of high behavioral
control.
• Factors Influencing the Strength of Culture
1. Size of the organization
2. Clarity of cultural values and beliefs
3. Age of the organization
4. Rate of employee turnover
61
Creating and Sustaining Culture
How Culture Begins?
• Ultimate source of an organization’s culture is its founders.
1. Founders hire and keep only employees who think & feel the same way
they do.
2. Founders indoctrinate and socialize these employees to their way of
thinking and feeling.
3. The founders’ own behavior acts as a role model that encourages
employees to identify with them & thereby internalize their beliefs,
values, and assumptions.
64
Keeping Culture Alive
• Three forces play a particularly important part in sustaining a culture
• Selection
• Concern with how well the candidates will fit into the organization.
• Provides information to candidates about the organization.
• Eg, selecting employees who have entrepreneurial skills for company which values
innovation.
• Top Management
• Senior executives help establish behavioral norms that are adopted by the organization.
Through words and behavior, senior executives establish norms that filter through the
organization about,
• for instance, whether risk taking is desirable, how much freedom managers give
employees, what is appropriate dress, and what actions earn pay raises, promotions, and
other rewards.
• Socialization
• The process that helps new employees adapt to the organization’s culture. 65
Stages in the Socialization Process
Pre-arrival Stage
This refers to the individual’s set of values , attitudes and expectations about both the
work and the organization. One way to capitalize on prehire characteristics in
socialization is to use the selection process to inform prospective
employees about the organization as a whole
Encounter Stage
The stage in the socialization process in which a new employee sees what the
organization is really like and confronts the possibility that expectations and reality may
diverge.
Metamorphosis Stage
The stage in the socialization process in which a new employee changes and adjusts to
the work, work group, and organization.
This time the new comers accept the norms of the organization, their peers and the
work 66
A Socialization Model
A successful metamorphosis should have a positive impact
on new employees’ productivity and their commitment to
the organization and reduce their propensity to leave the
organization.
67
How Culture Affects Managers
• Managerial Decisions Affected by Culture
• Planning
• The degree of risk that plans should contain
• Whether plans should be developed by individuals or
teams
• The degree of environmental scanning in which
management will engage
• Organizing
• How much autonomy should be designed into
employees’ jobs
• Whether tasks should be done by individuals or in
teams
• The degree to which department managers interact with
each other 68
Cont’d…..
• Leading
• The degree to which managers are concerned
with increasing employee job satisfaction
• What leadership styles are appropriate
• Whether all disagreements—even constructive
ones—should be eliminated
• Controlling
• What criteria should be emphasized in employee
performance evaluations
• What repercussions will occur from exceeding
one’s budget
• Whether to impose external controls or to allow
employees to control their own actions
69
Demonstrate how an ethical culture can
be created
• How can management create a more ethical culture?
1. Be a visible role model. Employees look to top
management behavior as a benchmark.
2. Provide ethical training. Training sessions should
reinforce standards of conduct and clarify
permissible practices
3. Reward ethical acts and punish unethical ones.
16-70
Ch. 8. Organizational Structure and Design
Definition
• Organization structure defines how tasks are formally divided,
grouped , and coordinated.
• It refers to the division of labor as well as the patterns of
coordination, communication, work flow , and formal power that
direct organizational activities.
• In general, it is the formal arrangement of jobs within an
Organization
Organizational Design- refers to the creation & modification of
organization structure.
The process of developing or changing an organization’s structure
Key Elements Organization Structure
I.I.Work
Workspecialization
specialization
II.
II.Departmentalization
Departmentalization
III.
III.Chain
Chainofofcommand
command
IV.
IV.Span
Spanofofcontrol
control
V.
V.Centralization
Centralizationand
anddecentralization
decentralization
VI.
VI.Formalization
Formalization
I. Work Specialization
The degree to which tasks in the organization are subdivided into
separate jobs with each step completed by a different person.
Divide a job into a number of steps, each completed by a separate
individual.
In essence, individuals specialize in doing part of an activity rather than
the entirety.
Example: Henry Ford became rich and famous by building automobiles
on an assembly line, demonstrating that work can be performed more
efficiently by using a work specialization strategy. Every Ford worker
was assigned a specific, repetitive task. By breaking jobs up into small
standardized tasks, Ford was able to produce cars at the rate of one
every 10seconds, while using employees who had relatively limited
skills.
Work Specialization (cont’d…)
Division
Divisionof
oflabor:
labor:
1.
1. Makes
Makesefficient
efficientuse
useof
ofemployee
employeeskills
skills
2.
2. Increases
Increasesemployee
employeeskills
skillsthrough
through
repetition
repetition
3.
3. Less
Lesstime
timeisisspent
spentin
inchanging
changingtasks
tasks
and
anditit increases
increasesproductivity
productivity
cont’d
However, Overspecialization can result in human
diseconomies from boredom, exhaustion, stress,
increased absenteeism, and higher turnover which
more than offset the economic advantages.
2. Departmentalization
After deciding what job tasks will be done by whom,
common work activities need to be grouped together so
work gets done in a coordinated & integrated way.
How jobs are grouped together is called
departmentalization.
For instance, a hotel might have departments such as:
Front desk operations
Sales & catering
Housekeeping and laundry, and
Maintenance.
Types of departmentlization
1. Functional- Groups employees based on work performed (e.g.,
engineering, accounting, information systems, human resources)
2. Product Groups employees based on major product areas in the
corporation (e.g., women’s footwear, men’s footwear, and apparel &
accessories)
3. Customer Groups employees based on customers’ problems and
needs (e.g., wholesale, retail, government)
4. Geographic Groups employees based on location served (e.g., North,
South, Midwest, East)
5. Process Groups employees based on the basis of work or customer
flow (e.g. Enrollment, testing, payment). —like that found in many
government offices or in health care clinics.
IV. Span of control
• How many employees can a manager efficiently
and effectively direct?
• This question of span of control is important
because it largely determines the number of
levels & managers an organization has.
Span of Control
• The number of employees who can be effectively & efficiently
supervised by a manager.
• The traditional view was that managers should not—directly
supervise more than 5/6 subordinates.
Most effective and efficient span depends on:
1. Employee experience and training (more they have, larger span)
2. Similarity of employee tasks (more similarity, larger span)
3. Complexity of those tasks (more complex, smaller span)
4. Physical proximity of employees (closer proximity, larger span)
5. Amount and type of standardized procedures (more
standardized, larger span)
6. Sophistication of the organization’s management information
system (more sophisticated, larger span)
cont’d
• Wider spans are more efficient in terms of cost.
• Narrow spans have three major drawbacks.
1. First, as already described, they are expensive because they
add levels of management.
2. Second, they make vertical communication in the organization
more complex.
3. Third, narrow spans of control encourage overly tight
supervision and discourage employee autonomy.
Current Trends on span of control
For the following reasons , most organization today
prefer wider span of control:
1. To reduce overhead cost and other costs
2. To speed up decision making
3. To increase flexibility
4. To get closure to customers
5. To empower employees
VI. Formalization
Formalization-
Refers to the degree to which jobs within the organization are standardized( job
description, rules, procedures , policies).
High formalization:
Minimize job incumbent’s option (what, when , how… to do)
Allow employees to handle the input in exactly the same way
Results consistent and uniform out put
Low standardization:
Job behaviors are relatively non-programmed
High level of freedom for employees discretion
Allow employees to consider alternatives in their works
Although some formalization is necessary for consistency and
control, many organizations today rely less on strict rules and
standardization to guide and regulate employee behavior
Key Design Questions and Answers for Designing the Proper Organizational
Structure
Research
ResearchFindings:
Findings:
•• Work
Workspecialization
specializationcontributes
contributestotohigher
higheremployee
employeeproductivity,
productivity,but
butititreduces
reducesjob
job
satisfaction.
satisfaction.
•• The
Thebenefits
benefitsofofspecialization
specializationhave
havedecreased
decreasedrapidly
rapidlyas
asemployees
employeesseek
seekmore
more
intrinsically
intrinsicallyrewarding
rewardingjobs.
jobs.
•• The
Theeffect
effectof
ofspan
spanof
ofcontrol
controlononemployee
employeeperformance
performanceisiscontingent
contingentupon
upon
•• Individual
Individualdifferences
differencesand
andabilities,
abilities,
•• Task
Taskstructures,
structures,and
and
•• Other
Otherorganizational
organizationalfactors(
factors(like
likeuse
useof(MIS)
of(MIS)technology...)
technology...)
Participative
Participativedecision
decisionmaking
makinginindecentralized
decentralizedorganizations
organizationsisispositively
positivelyrelated
relatedto
to
job
jobsatisfaction.
satisfaction.
Analyze the behavioral implications
of different organizational designs
Organization’s structure can have significant effects.
A review of the evidence leads to a pretty clear conclusion: you
can’t generalize!
Not everyone prefers the freedom & flexibility of organic
structures.
Some people are most productive & satisfied when work tasks
are standardized & ambiguity minimized.
Summary and Implications for
Managers
End of the course