Chapter 1
Chapter 1
Chapter One
Introduction to
indeterminate
structure
10/27/20Stability & Determinacy of 1
24 structures
Outlines
Introduction
Determinacy of structures for different types of
beams, portal frames and truss
Stability of structures
Structural loads
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 2
Learning outcomes of this chapter
Describe the stability and determinacy.
For analysis of indeterminate structures, adopt an
appropriate structural analysis method.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 4
Introduction
Before going into the analysis of any structure, it
is necessary to identify its statically type
(classification) i.e. whether it is determinate or
indeterminate, stable or unstable.
An unstable arrangement of supports and structural
members should be avoided.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 5
Determinacy of structures
What does mean determinacy of structures?
The determinacy of structures refers to the degree to which
the structural system is fixed.
Why it is needed to fix structures?
To determine the loads it must withstand, materials used to
construct it.
Indeterminacy is introduced in structures on account of
functional requirements, limitations on types of framing and
need for stiffness.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 6
Determinacy of structures
Based on response of the structures to the external
applied loads in the form of reactions or
displacements, indeterminacy of the structures
maybe classified into two general categories.
a) Static indeterminacy due to support reactions
b) Kinematic indeterminacy due to joints
displacement
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 7
Determinacy of structures
a) Static indeterminacy
Depending upon determinacy, structures maybe
classified into two general categories.
i. Statically determinate
ii. Statically indeterminate
When all support reactions in a structure can be
determined from equilibrium equations solely, the
structure is referred to as statically determinate.
10/27/2024 Stability & Determinacy of 8
Determinacy of structures
When all support reactions in a structure cannot be
determined from equilibrium equations solely (i.e. more
unknown support reactions than available equilibrium
equations), the structure is referred to as statically
indeterminate.
In addition to more unknown support reactions, a
structure is statically indeterminate when it possesses
more members than necessary for stability (and
equilibrium).
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 9
Determinacy of structures
These excess members or support reactions are
called redundant or degree of static indeterminacy.
The degree of static indeterminacy is the number of
unknown support reactions in excess of the
available equilibrium equations.
To analysis indeterminate structures, we need ways
of establishing additional equations.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 10
Determinacy of structures
These additional equations may be derived from
compatibility of deformation or from conditions of
symmetry and known as compatibility equations.
Compatibility equations must be equal to the
number of static degree indeterminacy.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 11
Determinacy of structures
External and Internal Static Indeterminacy
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 14
Determinacy of structures
Where:
is the number of internal forces for each member
is the number of members
is the number of unknown reactions
is the number of equations of equilibrium at each joint
is the number of joints of the structures
is the number of internal releases (internal hinges and/or
internal rollers)
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 15
Determinacy of structures
If a structure is supported by more than three reactions,
then all the reactions cannot be determined from the three
equations of equilibrium.
Such structures are termed statically indeterminate
externally ().
The reactions in excess of those necessary for equilibrium
are called external redundants, and the number of external
redundants is referred to as the degree of external
indeterminacy.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 16
Determinacy of structures
If a structure is supported by fewer than three
support reactions, the reactions are not sufficient to
prevent all possible movements of the structure in
its plane.
Such a structure cannot remain in equilibrium
under a general system of loads and is therefore,
referred to as statically unstable externally ().
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 17
Determinacy of Structures-Beams
A beam is a structural element that is capable of
withstanding load primarily by resisting bending.
Beams generally carry vertical loadings (in plane
moments and forces normal to the axis of the
beam).
Thus, for beams , , and the total degree of static
indeterminacy for a beam can be calculated as:
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 18
Determinacy of Structures-Beams
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 19
Determinacy of Structures-Beams
Note: In the determination of , components of the
support reactions in the direction parallel to the
beam axis must be ignored since there is no internal
axial force in any bean members.
Stability of a beam is depends on external supports
only and its determinacy relates on the number of
available and conditional equations.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 20
Determinacy of Structures-Beams
Let is the available number of reaction
components, is the minimum number of reaction
components required for stability usually , and n is
the number of special/ conditional equation.
If
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 21
Determinacy of Structures-Beams
Note: is not a sufficient condition for stability.
o , statically determinate
o , statically indeterminate
10/27/2024 Stability & Determinacy of 22
Determinacy of Structures-Beams
Examples (Determine total degree of static
indeterminacy , degree of external and internal
indeterminacy of the following beams)
𝐹𝐵𝐷
𝑎¿
Total degree of static indeterminacy for beam
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 23
Determinacy of Structures-Beams
Where:
is the number of members
is the number of unknown reactions
is the number of joints of the structures
is the number of internal releases (internal hinges
and/or shear releases)
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 24
Determinacy of Structures-Beams
Degree of external indeterminacy of a beam
For beams
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 25
Determinacy of Structures-Beams
is number force and moment reaction components
is total number of parts
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 26
Determinacy of Structures-Beams
𝑏¿ 𝐹𝐵𝐷
is number force and moment reaction components
is total number of parts
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 27
Determinacy of Structures-Beams
Degree of external indeterminacy of a beam
Where:
is the number of unknown reactions
is the number of internal releases (internal hinges and/or
internal rollers)
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 29
Determinacy of Structures-Beams
Degree of external indeterminacy of a beam
Where:
is the number of unknown reactions
is the number of internal releases (internal hinges and/or
internal rollers)
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 30
Determinacy of Structures-Beams
𝑑¿ 𝐹𝐵𝐷
is number force and moment reaction components
is total number of parts
A beam is unstable.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 31
Determinacy of Structures-Beams
𝐹𝐵𝐷
𝑒¿is number force and moment reaction components
is total number of parts
A beam is unstable.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 32
Determinacy of Structures-Trusses
A simple truss can be made by combining three bars
to form a triangle.
Stability depends partly on external supports and
partly on the arrangement of members or bars.
Three reaction components are required for external
stability and determinacy of a plane truss without
condition equations.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 33
Determinacy of Structures-Trusses
For trusses (pin jointed frames, ) and thus total
degree of static indeterminacy .
External degree static of indeterminacy
The external statically classification of the truss
depends on the total number of reaction
components, and their arrangement.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 34
Determinacy of Structures-Trusses
where is the number of equilibrium equations and
is the number of conditional equations. For trusses .
Let is the available number of reaction components,
is the minimum number of reaction components
required for stability usually , and n is the number of
special/ conditional equation.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 35
Determinacy of Structures-Trusses
If
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 36
Determinacy of Structures-Trusses
Internal degree static of indeterminacy .
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 38
Determinacy of Structures-Trusses
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 39
Determinacy of Structures-Frames
A frame is a structure of continuous members being connected by
rigidly joints.
This type of structures ca resist both transverse and longitudinal
loadings.
For frames () and thus total degree of static indeterminacy .
Stability depends partly on external supports and partly on
moment resisting joints.
External degree static of indeterminacy where is the number of
equilibrium equations and is the number of conditional equations.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 40
Determinacy of Structures-Frames
The number of conditional equation introduced by
a hinge joint is equal to the number of members at
the joint minus one.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 41
Determinacy of Structures-Frames
Let is the available number of reaction components,
is the minimum number of reaction components
required for stability usually , and n is the number of
special/ conditional equation.
If
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 42
Determinacy of Structures-Frames
Internal degree static of indeterminacy .
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 44
Determinacy of Structures-Frames
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 45
Stability of structures
The resistance offered by a structure to
undesirable movement like sliding, collapsing,
overturning, etc. is called stability.
A statically stable structure is a structure that can
resist any actions without the development of the
rigid body movement (mechanism) on the entire
structure or within any parts of the structure.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 46
Stability of structures
For the static stability of a structure, proper and
sufficient number of constraints must be provided
to the entire structure in terms of supports so as to
prevent the rigid body movement (translation and
rotation) in the structure.
This means stability depends upon the support
conditions and arrangements of members.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 47
Stability of structures
In structural analysis, a structure is said to be stable
when it can support any possible system of applied
loads.
To ensure the equilibrium of a structure or its
members, it is not only necessary to satisfy the
equations of equilibrium.
But, the members must also be properly held or
constrained by their supports.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 48
Stability of structures
Based on this concept of static stability, a statically
unstable structure is a structure that is not statically
stable.
In the other word, a structure that exhibits the rigid
body movement (mechanism) for the entire
structure or within any parts of the structure when
subjected to a particular action.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 49
Stability of structures
Stability can be divided into two as external and internal.
External stability
A structure in which there are insufficient number of
constraints or improper constraints to prevent motion
from taking place is called an unstable entire structure.
This is external instability.
What matters is not only the number of support reactions
but also their arrangement.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 50
Stability of structures
Structures for which the numbers of reaction
components are greater than or equal to the
number of available equilibrium equations but that
are unstable due to arrangement of these reaction
components are said to be geometrically unstable.
When the reaction elements are three or more like
supports that are either parallel or concurrent, they
are not sufficient to maintain static equilibrium.
10/27/2024 Stability & Determinacy of 51
Stability of structures
For a structure to be externally stable, the following
conditions must be met:
a) Non-Parallel reactions
The reactions at the supports should not be parallel to
each other.
If the reactions are parallel, even if there is sufficient
numbers of reaction, it cannot be restrain rigid body
movement which leading to external instability.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 52
Stability of structures
b) Non-Concurrent reactions
The reactions at the supports should not pass through the same
point.
If the reactions are concurrent, it indicates that the forces at the
supports are acting in a single line of action and they cannot
prevent rotation of the structure about their concurrent point
which can result in external instability.
By satisfying these conditions of external stability, a structure can
maintain its overall stability and resist external loads and forces.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 53
Stability of structures
Beam
Truss
Parallel supports
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 54
Stability of structures
For this case of parallel supports, even if we have
sufficient number of supports, due to their improper
arrangement, they will offer no resistance to
horizontal movement, thus making the arrangement
unstable.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 55
Stability of structures
Concurrent supports
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 56
Stability of structures
Internal stability
A structure is considered to be internally stable or
rigid, if it maintains its shape and remains a rigid
body when isolated from the supports.
Conversely, a structure is termed internally unstable
(or non-rigid) if it cannot maintain its shape and may
undergo large displacements under small
disturbances when not supported externally.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 57
Stability of structures
This internal instability is caused by too many
internal releases (i.e. internal hinges) or improper
arrangement of members.
Examples of internally stable structures
Note that each of the structures shown forms a rigid body and each can
maintain its shape under loads.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 58
Stability of structures
Examples of internally unstable structures
Stable truss
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 60
Stability of structures
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 61
Stability of structures
Generally, to investigate the static stability of a
structure, first find degree of static indeterminacy .
If the degree of static indeterminacy of a given
structure is less than zero, i.e. , then the structure is
statically unstable.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 62
Stability of structures
For degree of static indeterminacy , investigate the
structure for the development of rigid body motion
(mechanism) within the structure under a particular
action.
If there is any mechanism, then the structure is
statically unstable.
If no mechanism, then the structure is statically
stable.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 63
Stability of structures
Mechanism of the entire structure is caused due to
insufficient number of constraints or improper
constraints (parallel and concurrent constraints).
While the mechanism in any portion of the structure
is caused by too many internal releases or improper
arrangement of members.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 64
Stability of structures
Investigate the static stability of the following
structure
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 65
Stability of structures
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 66
Stability of structures
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 67
Stability of structures
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 69
Structural loads
The loads that act on common civil engineering
structures can be grouped according to their nature
and source into three classes:
a) Dead loads (Permanent loads),
b) Live loads (Variable loads) and
c) Environmental loads
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 70
Structural loads
a) Dead loads
Dead loads are those that act on the structure as a
result of the weight of the structure itself and of the
components of the system that are permanent
fixtures.
As a result, dead loads are characterized as having
fixed magnitudes and positions.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 71
Structural loads
Examples of dead loads are the weights of the
structural members themselves such as beams and
columns, the weights of roof surfaces, floor slabs,
ceilings or permanent partitions walls and so on.
How we can determine dead loads?
Dead loads associated with the structure can be
determined if the materials and sizes of the various
components are known.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 72
Structural loads
The determination of the characteristic values of self-
weight and of the dimensions and densities shall be
in accordance with ES EN 1990:2015 ‘General
actions’ Part 1-1 section 4.1.2.
Nominal dimensions should be those as shown on the
drawings.
where A is members cross-section and is a unit
weight of composed materials
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 73
Structural loads
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 74
Structural loads
b) Live loads
Live loads also known as imposed loads are those
that may vary over time and often result from the
occupancy of the structure.
Typically live loads may include people, movable
objects like furniture, vehicles and so on.
Live loads are variable as they depend on usage and
capacity.
10/27/2024Stability & Determinacy of 75
Structural loads
How we can determine live loads?
The magnitude of live loads are varying on the structure
and its impossible to obtain accurate values.
Because of this, design codes such as our very nation’s
‘ES EN 1991:2015 Part 1-1 ‘General Actions’ section
6.3 provide equivalent loads for various building
categories and their specific usages.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 76
Structural loads
Imposed Loads on Buildings
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 77
Structural loads
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 78
Structural loads
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 79
Structural loads
Values of imposed actions
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 80
Structural loads
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 81
Structural loads
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 82
Structural loads
Imposed Loads on Bridges
Live loads on bridges consist primarily of vehicles,
which vary in weight, size, and frequency of
occurrence (cars, trucks, buses).
Live loads are often concentrated at specific points
where vehicles are located on the bridge.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 83
Structural loads
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 84
Structural loads
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 87
Structural loads
Live loads on buildings may not account for significant
dynamic effects, as the movement of occupants is
generally slower and less impactful compared to vehicles
on a bridge.
Live loads on bridges are often concentrated at specific
points where vehicles are located on the bridge.
Live loads on bridges are typically transient, as vehicles
are not stationary; they pass over the structure relatively
quickly.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 88
Structural loads
Bridges must account for dynamic impact factors due to the
acceleration and deceleration of vehicles, as well as potential
collisions, which can increase the effective live load.
In summary:
Live loads on buildings are primarily influenced by occupancy
and usage patterns, with a focus on static and sustained loads.
Live loads on bridges are characterized by dynamic vehicle
traffic, requiring considerations for concentrated loads and
dynamic effects.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 89
Structural loads
c) Environmental loads
Environmental loads refer to the forces and stresses
exerted on a structure due to natural environmental
factors.
These loads can significantly impact the design and
performance of civil engineering structures, requiring
careful consideration to ensure safety and
functionality.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 90
Structural loads
Environmental loads include:
i. Wind Loads
ii. Seismic Loads
iii. Soil Loads
iv. Snow Loads
v. Temperature Effects
vi. Rain Loads
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 91
Structural loads
i. Wind Loads
Wind loads are the environmental load cases caused
by a moving (blowing) air mass against an
obstructing structure and hence subsequently
converting the kinetic energy of the wind into a
potential energy of pressure.
This wind pressures can be either positive or
negative.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 92
Structural loads
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 93
Structural loads
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 94
Structural loads
Positive wind pressures: are loads having pushing
effects (towards the structure).
Negative wind pressures (suctions): are those loads
having pulling effects (away from the structure).
These loadings caused by wind are expected to affect
three perspective faces of a given structure.
These are the windward, leeward and sides of a
structure
10/27/2024 Stability & Determinacy of 95
Structural loads
Windward faces
Those in the upwind direction or from which the
wind is coming.
Windward faces are always loaded with positive
wind pressures.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 96
Structural loads
Leeward faces
Those which are away (downward or downwind)
from the upcoming wind.
Leeward faces are always loaded with negative
wind pressures (suctions).
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 97
Structural loads
Side faces
Those faces parallel to the direction of the wind.
Side walls can be loaded with positive or negative
pressures depending on the geometric plan shape of
the structure.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 98
Structural loads
Wind Loads-Analysis
Exposure extent of the structure is dependent on
terrain roughness and topography of its location,
expresses the vulnerability of the structure to wind
actions.
Because of this, design codes such as our very nation’s
‘ES EN 1991:2015 ‘General Actions’ Part 1-4 section
5.2 provide characteristics wind loads value.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 99
Structural loads
ii. Earthquake Loads
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 100
Structural loads
An earthquake is a sudden motion in the earth’s upper crust
(Lithosphere) caused by abrupt releases of accumulated
strains energy in rocks below, volcanic activity, landslides
and collapse of underground caves.
The ground surface moves both in horizontal and vertical
directions during an earthquake.
The magnitude of the vertical ground motion is usually
small and does not have a significant effect on most
structures.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 101
Structural loads
It is the horizontal component of ground motion that
causes structural damage and must be considered in
design of structures located in earthquake prone
areas.
The seismic base shear force for each horizontal
direction in which the building is analyzed shall be
determined by ES EN 1998:2015 section 4.3.3.2.
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 102
Quiz (5%)
1) The preconditions for checking of the determinacy
of a given structure is its stability. (True/False) (1
mark)
2) Investigate the external and internal stability and
determine the total degree of static indeterminacy,
external and internal indeterminacy of the
following framed structures. (3 marks)
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 103
Quiz (5%)
𝑎¿ 𝑏¿
3) What are
𝑐 ¿
the causes of the external and internal
instability of structures? (1 mark)
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 104
E R
P T
H A
E C
T H
O F
N D
E
10/27/2024
Stability & Determinacy of 105