Week 2 - Lecture 4 - Control Loop Hardware
Week 2 - Lecture 4 - Control Loop Hardware
Australia Malaysia
Lecture Note 4
Control Loop Hardware
2
Learning outcomes
3
Typical feedback control loop
4
Typical feedback control loop
Actuator
System
F1 F2
T1 T2
Sensor
System
Controller TC
T
TT
Electrical/
Pneumatic
Transmitter
7
Components and Signals of a Typical
Control Loop
Note: The transmitted signal ranges indicated are standard
everywhere around the world.
F1 F2
T1 T2
Thermowell
3-15 psig
T
Air 4-20 ma
I/P D/A Thermocouple
millivolt signal
8
Responsibilities of control engineers
9
Controllers/Control
Computers
• Pneumatic controllers
• Electronic analog controllers
• Supervisory control computers
• Distributed Control Systems (DCS)
• Fieldbus technology
10
Pneumatic Controllers -
Phase I
• Introduced in the 1920’s
• Installed in the field next to the valve
• Use bellows, baffles, and nozzles with an air supply
to implement PID action
• Provided automatic control and replaced manual
control for many loops
11
Pneumatic Controllers -
Phase II
• Transmitter type pneumatic controllers began to
replace field mounted controllers in the late 1930’s
• Controller located in control room with pneumatic
transmission from sensors to control room and
back to the valve
• Allowed operators to address a number of
controllers from a centralised control room
12
Pneumatic Controller Installation
Pneumatic => air pressure to deliver signal from one
component to another.
Pneumatic controller => uses analog or continuous
signal.
F1 F2
T1 T2
Thermowell
3-15 psig
T
Air Thermocouple
millivolt signal
T sp Air
Pneumatic 3-15 psig
Transmitter
Controller
13
Electronic Analog
Controllers
• Became available in the late 1950’s
• Replaced the pneumatic tubing with wires
• Used resistors, capacitors, and transistors-based
amplifiers to implement PID action
• Out-sold pneumatic controllers by 1970
• Allowed for advanced PID control enhancement:
ratio, feedforward, etc.
14
Electronic Controller Installation
The electronic signal is continuous or analog.
The signal ranges are standard worldwide.
F1 F2
T1 T2
Thermowell
3-15 psig
T
Air 4-20 ma
I/P Thermocouple
millivolt signal
T sp Electronic 4-20 ma
Analog Transmitter
Controller
15
Computer Control System
• Based upon a mainframe digital computer
• Offered the ability to use data storage and
retrieval, alarm functions, and process
optimization
• First installed in a refinery in 1959
• Had reliability limitations
16
Supervisory Control Computer
Update
Video Display Alarming setpoints,
Printer controller
Unit Functions
tunings
...
17
Distributed Control System-
DCS
• Introduced in the late 1970’s
• Based upon redundant microprocessors for
performing control functions for a part of the plant,
giving it SUPERIOR RELIABILITY
• Less expensive per loop for large plants
• Less expensive to expand
• Facilitates the use of advanced control
18
DCS Architecture
Data
System Host
Storage PLC
Consoles Computer
Unit
Data Highway
(Shared Communication Facilities)
Local
Console
Local
Control .............. Local
Control
Local
Console
Unit Unit
19
Distributed Control System (DCS) Architecture
A distributed control system (DCS) is a computerised control system for a process or
plant usually with a large number of control loops, in which autonomous controllers
are distributed throughout the system, but there is a central operator supervisory
control.
20
Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distributed_control_system
DCS and Troubleshooting
21
Control Relevant Aspects of a
DCS
• The most important control aspect of a DCS is the
cycle time for controller calls.
• The shortest cycle times are typically around 0.2
seconds while most loops can be executed every
0.5 to 1.0 seconds.
• These cycle times affect flow control loops and
other fast control loops.
22
Fieldbus Technology
• Based upon smart valves, smart sensors and
controllers installed in the field
• Uses data highway to replace wires from sensor to
DCS and to the control valves
• Less expensive installations and better reliability
• Can mix different sources (vendors) of sensors,
transmitters, and control valves
• Now commercially available and beginning to
replace DCSs
23
Fieldbus Architecture
Plant-Wide Network
.................
Local Local
Area Area
Network Network
25
26
Sensor Systems
You cannot control what you cannot measure (Tom DeMarco)
Sensor
• temperature sensors
• flow sensors
• level sensors
• pressure sensors
• composition analyzers
Transmitter
27
Major issues for selecting
sensors
Accuracy Process measurement
dynamics
Reproducibility
Calibration
Linearity
Maintenance
Reliability
Consistency with process
Sensitivity
environment
Resolution
Dynamic safety
Range/Span and Zero
Cost
28
Accuracy vs Reproducibility
Accuracy - Degree of conformity to a standard (or true) value
when a sensor is operated under specified conditions.
30
Span and Zero
Span - Difference between maximum and minimum reading values.
The larger the range, the poorer the accuracy, and reproducibility
=> engineers select the smallest range that satisfies the process
requirements.
Suppose that that sensor has an accuracy of 99%, what would be the sensor
reading when it is dipped in a hot oil at temperature 150oC?
31
Process measurement dynamics,
Calibration and Maintenance
Process measurement dynamics - Time constant and deadtime.
Short time constant is better for good control performance.
Long deadtime may cause control instability.
Some sensors can have direct contact with the process materials,
while others must be protected.
33
Smart Sensors
http://www.cyberphysics.co.uk/
topics/heat/thermometer.htm
Citation: Omega WWW site
35
Actuator System
Control Valve
• Valve body
• Valve actuator
I/P converter or transducer
36
Control Valve
37
Direct Acting Valve
This valve also called fail closed valve, meaning that if the air
system (compressor) fails, then the valve will be fully closed. For
this case, the air is fed from the bottom of the diaphragm while the
spring is located at the top of the diaphragm.
38
Reverse Acting Valve
This valve is also called fail open valve, meaning that if the air system
fails for some reasons, then valve will be fully opened. In this case,
the air is fed above the diaphragm while the spring located at the
bottom of the diaphragm.
39
Valve Actuator Selection - Summary
Choose an air-to-open for applications for which it is
desired to have the valve fail closed.
Also known as fail closed valve.
Fail closed means the valve will close when the
control signal is interrupted or lost.
43
Temperature Sensor Comparison
Sensor Type Limits of Application Accuracy Dynamics: Advantages Disadvantages
(°C) t (s)
Thermocouple
type E: ±1.5 or 0.5% for 0 -good reproducibility
-100 to 1000 -minimum span of 40 °C
chromel-constantan to 900 °C -wide range
type J: Depending -temperature vs. emf not
0 to 750 ±2.2 or 0.75% exactly linear
iron-constantan strongly on the
type K: thermowell
0 to 1250 ±2.2 or 0.75% -drift over time
chromel-nickel (material,
diameter, and -low emf corrupted by
type T: ±1.0 or 1.5% for - wall thickness), noise
-160 to 400
copper-constantan 160 to 0 °C the location of
the element in
the sheath (i.e. -good accuracy -self-heating
RTD -200 to 650 ±0.20 or 0.002 % bonded or air -small span possible -less physically rugged
space, the fluid
type, and the -linearity -self-heating error
fluid velocity.
Typical values
are 2 to 5 -highly nonlinear
seconds for
Thermistor -40 to 150 ± 0.10 °C high fluid -good accuracy -only small span
velocities. -little drift -less physically rugged
-drift
-low cost
Bimetallic - ± 2% - -local display
-physically rugged
-not high temperatures
-simple and low cost
Filled system -200 to 800 ± 1% 1 to 10 -sensitive to external
-no hazards
pressure 44
Cost - Sensors involve costs and when selected properly, provide
benefits. These must be quantified, and a profitability analysis performed.
Process variable Cost Comments
(US$ in 2003)
Flow - orifice 500-3500 Flange connections, 2-12 in pipe
Flow - pitot and similar 1000-2000 Calibration costs extra
Flow - mass 1500-7000 1 in. pipe, cost depends strongly on sensor technology
Flow - positive displacement 3000-5000 1500 SCMH
Flow - turbine 3000 2-3 in. pipe, cost depends strongly on pipe size
Flow - venturi/nozzle 500-1000 6 in. pipe, costs vary depending on sensor type and materials
of construction
Temperature - thermocouple 200 Cost includes thermal well. With transmitter could cost up to
$2000
Temperature - RTD 100-250 Cost includes thermal well. With transmitter could cost up to
$2000
Temperature - thermister See RTD
Temperature - optical pyrometer 500-5500 Thermal imaging much more expensive
Temperature - bimetalic 65 For local display only
Pressure - bourdon 300 Local indication
Pressure - electronic 1000-4000 Many technologies (See Liptak, 2003)
Level - pressure difference 1500 Local indicators few hundred dollars
Level - float 2000-5000 Switch or local indicator lower cost
Level - displacement 2500
Level - Laser 4000-6000
Level - Radar 1500-5000
Level - Ultransonic 650-2500
Analyzer - sampling system 3500-7000 Single sample stream
Analyzer - installation -- Varies depending upon the location, safety requirements,
and analyzer technology
Analyzer -- 45
Must determine the cost for each analyzer type individually
Thermocouples: Specific metal pairs are used in
practice for selected accuracies and ranges of
temperature
T2 T1
T1
Provides higher
accuracy than other
two devices, much less
physically robust, and
can lose accuracy if
operated outside of
recommended range.
Thermistor
RTD
Thermocouple
Citation: Omega WWW site 50
Flow Sensor Comparison
elbow meter 3:1 5-10% of full span - -low pressure loss -very poor accuracy
FC
liquid
cooling
52
Sensors: How do we measure fluid flow?
The most frequently used flow sensor is the orifice meter. What
is the basic principle for this sensor?
FC
liquid
Velocity increases;
Bernoulli says that
53
pressure decreases
Sensors: Principles of the orifice meter
Bernoulli’s
eqn.
General meter
eqn.
Y=The compressibility factor, accounts for the expansion of compressible gases for
incompressible fluids, Y=1
Cavitation!
The liquid could be near
pressure
P = P1 –
its bubble point, so that a
orifice
What is a key
disadvantage of the
orifice meter?
Ploss = P1 – P2
Pressure loss!
When cost of pressure
pressure
P = P1 – increase (P1) by
orifice
Non-
P3 recoverable pumping or compression
pressure
drop
is high, we want to avoid
the “non-recoverable”
Distance
pressure loss.
57
Pressure Sensor Comparison
Limits of
Sensor Accuracy Dynamics Advantages Disadvantages
Application
bourdon, "C" up to 100 MPa 1-5% of full span -
-low cost with
-hysteresis
reasonable accuracy
spiral up to 100 MPa 0.5% of full span - -affected by shock and
-wide limits of
vibration
application
helical up to 100 MPa 0.5-1% of full span -
capacitance/
up to 30 kPa 0.2% of full span - - -
inductance
-sensitive to temperature
piezoelectric - 0.5% of full span very fast -fast dynamics
changes
58
Pressure affects chemical reactions, separations,
and many other key process performance
indicators. It should not exceed the strength of
the vessel!
Bourdon Tube for local display of
pressure
-limited range
displacement 0.3-3 m - - -good accuracy -cost of external mounting
for high pressures
-good accuracy
-assumes constant density
differential essentially no -large range
- - -sealed lines sensitive to
pressure upper limit -applicable to slurries temperature
with use of sealed lines
62
Typical Differential Pressure-
based Level Measurement
Upper Tap
Diaphragm
Vapor
DPT
Liquid
Lower Tap
63
Float based level sensing
64
Non-contact level measurements
Ultrasound Radar/Microwave
65
Composition Analyser Sensors
X1
X2
Soft sensor Y
X3
X4
67
Inferential/soft sensors
MLR and PLS - most popular in industrial applications due to
their simplicity and practicability.
Table 2: Statistics of soft sensor application (Kano and Ogawa, 2010; Kano
and Koichi, 2013)
Methods
Process
Phys MLR PLS O.L. ANN JIT Gray Total
Distillation 20 256 41 6 0 5 3 331
Reaction 5 32 43 0 0 5 1 86
Polymerization 0 4 8 0 3 0 5 20
Others 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 2
Total 25 293 93 6 3 10 9 439
69
Types of Globe Valves
1. Quick Opening- used for safety by-pass applications
where quick opening is desired
2. Equal Percentage- used for about 90% of control valve
applications since it results in the most linear installed
characteristics
3. Linear- used when a relatively constant pressure drop
is maintained
1 across the valve
Note. f(x) here is a normalised valve
coefficient
QO
0.5 f(x) = actual flowrate at x/max flowrate
f(x)
Linear
= actual valve coefficient at x/
=% valve coefficient at max flowrate
0
0 20 40 60 80 100
x= Stem Position (% Open)
70
The desired valve characteristic is achieved through
the design of the valve seat and plug
71
Control valve calculations
75
Determine flowrate through control
valve given installed ΔP-Fv data
77
Optional Equipment
Valve positioner
• a controller that adjusts the air instrument in
order to maintain the stem position at the
specified position.
• Substantially reduces the deadband of the valve.
Positioners are almost always used on valves
serviced by a DCS.
Booster relay - provides high-capacity air
flow to the actuator of a valve.
• Can significantly increase the speed of large
valves. 78
Valve Positioner
Valve
Positioner
79
Booster Relay
80
Valve Deadband
81
Control Relevant Aspects of
Actuator Systems
82
References
http://www.pc-education.mcmaster.ca/Instrumentation/go_inst.htm
83
Any questions?
84