Eteeap Io03
Eteeap Io03
HARVARD COLLEGE
LIBRARY “What” “How”
Organizational
Priorities Values
DEPARTMENT
UNIT OR
Your
Departmental
Priorities
Individual Priorities
Broader Than
Performance Appraisal
Begins with a look at goals &
strategies of the organization
Organizational Alignment
…a key to Performance
Management
Defining Performance
Facilitating Performance
Encouraging Performance
Performance Appraisal
• Validity
360 Degree Appraisal
• Problem Solving
Performance management
Definition:
Employee performance management is the process of
involving employees in accomplishing your agency’s
mission and goals.
Accountability
Performance target
setting and
outcome/results
review
AND / OR
Managing performance for …
Employee
Development
Competence assessment
and development
Stages of performance management
Monitor
Develop
Plan
Reward Review
SMART
Management by Objectives introduced the
SMART method for checking the validity of
Objectives,
'SMART':
• Specific
• Measurable
• Achievable
• Realistic, and
• Time-related.
What performance will be
measured?
• Behaviors – how the work is done
– Performance factors / competencies
– Required behaviors
– Behaviors supporting desired organizational
culture
• Results – what is achieved
– Performance outcomes
– Performance compared to job standards
– Performance goals and/or objectives
Approaches to designing an
appraisal form
• Trait based
• Behavior based
– Competencies (or performance factors)
– Behaviors
• Results based
– Performance outcomes
– Objectives
Rewards, recognition, and
compensation
• Recognizing employees for
performance
– Non-monetary rewards
– Informal and ongoing
acknowledgements of good work
• Compensation
– Merit increases?
– Pay to market?
– Increases added to base pay or lump
sum?
Separate conversation about pay from conversation about performance!!!!!
Performance Standards
• Managers assume
standards are clear
• Communicate -
What is to be done?
• How well should it
be done?
Progressive Disciplinary Systems
• Steps
1) Counsel Employee about Performance
Problem
2) Verbal Reprimand & Warning
3) Written Reprimand & Warning
4) Disciplinary Layoff (Short-term)
5) Discharge
Progressive Disciplinary Systems
• Reasons to Avoid Discharge
• Unfair Labor Practice (Legal & Contractual
Restrictions)
• Company Payments Toward Unemployment
& Severance Pay
• Strikes
• Court Action - Back Pay Awards
• Investment in Human Resources
Problems with Appraisals
• Survey by Ernst & Young showed that 38% of
employees say they are rated unfairly or not at all
• Deming argues that Performance Appraisal is
“A Deadly Disease in Organizations”
• Disregards existence of system
• Erroneously attributes variation in performance to
individuals (85-15 rule)
• Undermine teamwork, improvement
• Focuses on short-term, end product
Appraisal Interviews
• Give Feedback daily
• Encourage
participation
• Judge performance
not personality
• Be specific - provide
critical incidents
• Set mutual goals