Unit 5 - Part 1 1 0
Unit 5 - Part 1 1 0
Practice 1-7
Quick Quiz – Reference, Sense, and Referring Expressions
• love is the predicator in The white man loved the Indian maiden
• wait for is the predicator in Jimmy was waiting for the downtown bus
Note that some of the elements that we have stripped away in isolating
the predicator of a sentence do carry a certain amount of meaning.
Thus the indicators of past and present tense are clearly meaningful.
The semantics of tense is interesting, but its contribution to the mean-
ing of a sentence is of a different type from the contribution made by
the predicator, and will not be pursued here.
Notice also that the verb be in its various forms (is, was, are, were, am) is not
Strip away referring expressions and the verb be (and possibly other
elements) to identify the predicators in the following sentences:
hungry, ill, crook, asleep, hit, show, bottle, - and , or, but , not , are
are all predicates not predicates
Are the following predicates?
(1) dusty Yes / No (4) you Yes / No
(2) drink Yes / No (5) Fred Yes / No
(3) woman Yes / No (6) about Yes / No
The definition of 'predicate' above contained two parenthesized conditions. The
first,'(or sequence of words)' , is intended to take care of
examples like wait for, in front of, which are longer than one word, but
which it seems sensible to analyze as single predicates.
The second parenthesized condition, '(in a given single sense)', is more
important, and illustrates a degree of abstractness in the notion of a
predicate. A 'word', as we use the term, can be ambiguous, i.e. can have
more than one sense, but we use 'predicate' in a way which does not
allow a predicate to be ambiguous.
A predicate can have only one
sense. Normally, the context in which we use a word will make clear
what sense (what predicate) we have in mind, but occasionally, we shall
resort to the use of subscripts on words to distinguish between different
predicates.
• The word bank has (at least) two senses. Accordingly, we might speak
of the predicates bank1, and bank2
• Similarly, we might distinguish between the predicates man1. (noun)
= human being, man2(noun) = male adult human being, and man3
(transitive verb) as in The crew manned the lifeboats.
• Notice that 'predicate' and 'predicator' are terms of quite different sorts.
The term 'predicate’ identifies, elements in the language system independently of particular
example sentences. Thus, it would make sense
• to envisage a list of the predicates of English, as included, say, in a
dictionary. The term 'predicator' identifies the semantic role played by
a particular word (or group of words) in a particular sentence.
• In this way, it is similar to the grammatical term 'subject'; one can talk of the
subject of a particular sentence, but it makes no sense to talk of a list
of 'the subjects of English ': similarly, one can talk of the 'predicator' in
a particular sentence, but not list 'the predicators of English'.
• A simple sentence only has one predicator although it may well contain more
Predicate - Continued
(1) In which of the following sentences does the predicate male function as
a predicator? Circle your choice.
(a ) The male gorilla at the zoo had a nasty accident yesterday.
(b) The gorilla at the zoo is a male
(c) The gorilla at the zoo is male
(2) In which of the following sentences does the predicate human function
as predicator?
(a) All humans are mortal.
(b) Socrates was human .
Assignment for next class
Unit 5 – Predicates
Practice: 8-15