Lecture 14 08022024

Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 8

Urban Sociology

Lec 14: 08/02/2024


Gentrification and urban informality

Dr. Amrita Sen


Department of Humanities and Social Sciences
Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur
email: [email protected]
The City: 2 Views

• Chaos, unplanned,
• Planned, orderly, organised –
with modern infrastructure disorder – with slums,
vendors, etc.
Introduction
The study of cities is marked by a paradox:
1. Much of the urban growth is taking place in the Third World
2. But, urban theory is driven by the First World.

The First World – ‘models’ and the Third World is considered the
‘problem’?
• The problem : Planning practices are borrowed – do not fit our Ananya Roy

context.
• How “planning” produces the “unplannable” - placing informality
outside the formal order of urbanization.
Informality – as a mode of Urbanization

• Informality is not a separate sector.

• It is a series of transactions that connect different


economies and spaces to one another.

• How?

• In Dharavi, slum dwellers manufacture products for global


markets.
Dharavi, Mumbai.
• Here, informality is a mode of urbanization.

• Mode = manner/ form / method.


Does gentrification lead to urban development??
1. Lack of Comprehensive development
2. Lack of inclusive employment
3. Lack of equally distributed development
4. Land valued more than people
GENTRIFICATION OF CITIES: A CASE OF MUMBAI

• The outbreak of fire at two


upscale restaurants in the
Kamala Mills compound
in Mumbai's erstwhile
textile mill area claimed 14 lives
on 28 December 2017.

• As the investigation progressed, various issues related to the arbitrary


structural alterations, and illegal use of space in the Kamala Mills building
came to the fore.
• Arbitrary structural transformations to buildings, with little concerns
for safety and structural abilities.

• Gentrification creates new spaces of capital accumulation that are


directly linked to bourgeois modes of consumption.

• Disguised by ideologies of heritage, conservation, and elite


placemaking.

• Service sector firms, information technology industries, media and


advertising, finance, and the creative sector occupied the mill
compounds and factory buildings.
• There is a transformation from heavy industry to creative stores and
creative industries.

• The original structure might not have been erased.

• But the identity has been changed due to reconfiguration of space.

• Produced a secluded space because of its high pricing thereby increasing


inequality.

You might also like