Iss PPT Iii

The balancing act of the Indian State in the
manufacturing sector (PSUs)

• Profitability vs. social welfare (secured
employment generation)
• The changing industrial and social relations in
the factory as well as in Bhilai due to rising
ethnic tensions
• The simultaneous presence of two models of
economic development in the PSU – The
Nehruvian Socialist Model and the Post-
Liberalization Model
From Manufacturing to Knowledge
Economy in Contemporary India:
Emergence of a ‘new middle’ class?
State Funded Technological Education
Today
• State funded higher education as facilitating
private capital led growth especially in the
knowledge economy sector
• The turn to the IT/Knowledge Economy from
the 1990s in post-liberalization India
• The prominence of private capital led IT
industries absorbing state funded
engineering/management graduates
The Rise of the Knowledge Economy in
India (especially IT)
• Clean Economy
• Less demands on land and other resources
• Private Capital led growth
• A work-force that is relatively more educated
than in manufacturing or services industries
like retail
The Dominance of the ‘new’ urban middle
class
• IT work-force visibly more successful with
higher salaries
• Often based in urban settings
• Consumerist Class with new tastes and life-
styles
• Image of a mobile, consumerist class, with
new aspirations in a rapidly privatizing and
globalizing world
What is ‘New’ about the ‘New Middle Class’
in India
• Post-liberalization generation with high levels
of education
• Socially composed from an earlier middle class
with roots in PSUs and state sector jobs
• However, new aspirations and the biggest
champion of privatized growth in India rather
than state led development
The New Middle Class and its Cultural
Capital
• Cultural Capital – social qualities of an individual
person such as education, tastes, communicational
skills, interactive skills, felicity over languages (such
as English in India) that help in social mobility
• Not just education but the entirety of cultural
capital as crucial to finding a job and succeeding in
the Knowledge Sector such as in IT
• Continuous grooming and enhancing of cultural
capital through soft-skill training
• https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cISYzA36-
ZY
Soft-Skill and Social Dispositions
• Entrepreneurship and faith in privatization for
growth rather than direct intervention by the
developmentalist state (like in Nehruvian India)
• Ability to be flexible and adopt to cross-cultural
demands in various kinds of global work-sites
• Assertiveness and self-confidence in the work-
space
• Time-management and ability to achieve work-
life balance
Narrative of a New Global India
• https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pHfavihw
5pY
The Middle Class and the Founding Myths of Indian IT
• Austere, not driven by monetary gains only, self-

sacrificing, simple life-styles, humble origins – the
narrative of N. R. Narayana Murthy (Infosys
Technologies)
• The upper caste dimensions of this narrative of
success – Brahmins as inherently intellectual and
ability to think
• Not coming from wealthy, traditional trading castes
but succeeding through entrepreneurship,
education, integrity and self-sacrifice
The Moral Qualities of Indian IT
• Supposed to have integrity,
professionalization, efficiency.
• Contrasted with the the corruption, greed and
inefficiency of older forms of corporations
whether state-owned (PSUs) or traditional
family run businesses.
Contradictions in the Cultural Capital of the
New Middle Class
• Simultaneously belonging to two different eras –
state led Nehruvian socialism and post-
liberalization
• Both austere and enterprising, both consumerist
and self-sacrificing, both traditional and modern
• Some degree of inclusion to socio-economically
marginalized castes, gender and class identities
but within an overarching upper caste, urban,
male domination
Image of the ‘global Indian’ foregrounded
by the IT industry
• Is easily able to assimilate often contradictory
cultural characteristics – ‘traditional and modern’/
‘western and Indian’
• Both western and Indian values are reduced to a
few simple attitudes and life-styles – punctual,
disciplined, time-management skills – western/
austere, not driven by monetary gains, self-
sacrificing – Indian values
• Re-imagining ‘new middle class’ values by blending
in qualities of western and Indian values
Meritocracy or Inherited (Cultural) Capital?
• The success of the IT professionals and the

New Middle Class as driven by merit only?
• The role of inherited cultural capital such as
language skills or educational exposure
• The New Middle Class as ‘New’ or is it a case
of older and dominant class and caste groups
now going global?
The end of Globalization?
• Implications for Indian industries attuned to
globalization like IT?
• The rise of nationalism and protectionist
markets?
• The constraints for labor and capital migration
• Challenges before the ‘global Indian’
industries

Iss PPT Iii

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Iss PPT Iii

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Iss PPT Iii

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

The balancing act of the Indian State in the

manufacturing sector (PSUs)

• Austere, not driven by monetary gains only, self-

• The success of the IT professionals and the

You might also like