Lecture Slides
Lecture Slides
h
Methods Click to add text
DR PRAGYA SONAWANE
24TH DECEMBER 2021
EXPECTATION
S
CONSTRUCTIV
E
PARTICIPATIO
N
EXPECTATIONS
EXPECTATIONS
WHY THIS
COURSE?
Plan for the day
Process of Enquiry: How we know what we know.
Errors in Enquiry
Overview of Research Process; Inductive and Deductive reasoning
Formulating Research Objectives
Criteria for good research
Qualitative Methods
o Essence of qualitative data
o Sampling in qualitative research
o Data collection and Analysis
Quantitative Methods
o Developing a hypothesis, a research problem
o Reliability and Validity
o Developing a questionnaire
o Data Collection and Analysis
o Descriptive Statistics and Inferential Statistics
Writing Conclusion
Bibliography
How We Know
What We Know
Direct Experience and Observation
Personal Inquiry
Tradition
Authority
Looking for
Reality
Two Criteria
Both provide a starting point for inquiry, but can lead us to start at the wrong point and push us in the
wrong direction.
Inaccurate observations
Errors in Inquiry
Solutions
Inaccurate observations
◦ Measurement devices guard against inaccurate observations and add a degree of precision.
ERRORS IN INQUIRY
AND SOLUTIONS
Overgeneralization
Solutions
Overgeneralization
◦ Commit to a representative sample of observations and repeat a study to make sure the same results are
produced each time.
ERRORS
IN
INQUIRY
Selective observation
OH
NO!!!
O
YES!!
Solutions
Selective observation
◦ Make an effort to find “deviant cases” that do not fit into the general pattern.
ERRORS
IN
INQUIRY
Illogical Reasoning
Solutions
Illogical Reasoning
◦ Use systems of logic consciously and
explicitly.
Foundations of
Social Science
Theory - logic
Data Analysis - comparison of what is logically expected with what is actually observed
What is research?
What is
research?
Research is defined as the creation of new knowledge and/or the use of existing knowledge in a
new and creative way so as to generate new concepts, methodologies and understandings. This could
include synthesis and analysis of previous research to the extent that it leads to new and creative
outcomes
Basic Vs Applied
Basic
Research
The purpose of both basic and applied research is to contribute or develop a body of knowledge. Basic research
is generally not related to a specific problem and its findings cannot be immediately applied.
It is also known as fundamental or pure research and it is a systematic investigation set to achieve a better and
more detailed understanding of a research subject or phenomenon, not to solve a specific problem.
Applied Research
Applied research directly addresses the problem at hand. In general, applied research is launched by the firm, agency,
or individual facing a specific problem.
Applied research is designed to focus on providing practical solutions to a specific problem. It is a form of
investigation that entails solution-oriented inquiries into a phenomenon, a field of study or research subject
generally employing empirical methodologies.
Basic research is a development or contribution to the theory where the findings are used directly or immediately.
Whereas, applied research is organized to address a specific problem and its findings are immediately applied by the
decision maker based on their feasibility and sustainability.
Examples of basic research in education include:
How does the human memory work?
How do children acquire new languages?
Examples of applied research in education include:
A study to build students' interests in religious studies.
A study to improve classroom interaction between teachers and
students.
Examples of basic research in psychology include:
How do panic attacks happen?
What are the symptoms of anxiety disorders?
Examples of applied research in psychology include:
What are the treatment options for anxiety disorders?
What are the ways to improve employees' productivity in the
workplace?
Consider the hypothetical example of a multinational
company engaged in the manufacturing and selling of
toothpaste. The company has got a big client base and has
almost 100 million customers in rural and urban India.
The company is enjoying a sound market position and
willing to enhance the client base by 10 million
customers in the next 2 years. After 1 year of fixing this
target, the company assessed its performance. An
estimation revealed that, instead of enhancing, the client
base of the company is surprisingly reduced to
approximately 95 million customers. The company
management is worried and wants to ascertain where the
actual problem lies. Superficially, the problem seems to
be the loss of customers and it has to be elaborated and
Case Example 1 properly addressed.
100 million customers; the problem and solution can be explored by contacting these customers in a
pre-specified and systematic manner
He/she has to select an appropriate research design and should also focus on developing or adopting a tool
(questionnaire) to address the problem.
Obviously, the researcher cannot contact all the customers. He has to determine a sample size and suitable sampling
techniques to cater to the diverse population of rural and urban India in an optimum manner.
Administering the questionnaire to the respondents and executing the related fieldwork is another concern of the
researcher.
Data coding and data preparation is the next step before launching statistical analysis. As the next step, an appropriate
statistical test must be used and the obtained statistical result must be properly interpreted.
This obtained information must be conveyed to the decision maker and it is the decision maker who actually takes the
final decision.
Business
Research
Process
Design
Inductive research approach
When there is little to no existing literature on a topic, it is
common to perform inductive research because there is no
theory to test. The inductive approach consists of three
stages:
1.Observation
1. A low-cost airline flight is delayed
2. Dogs A and B have fleas
3. Elephants depend on water to exist
2.Observe a pattern
1. Another 20 flights from low-cost airlines are delayed
2. All observed dogs have fleas
3. All observed animals depend on water to exist
3.Develop a theory
1. Low cost airlines always have delays
2. All dogs have fleas
Testable statements
If and then statements
Null Hypothesis: Ho(negative
statement)
Alternate Hypothesis: Ha
If you water the plant, then it will grow.
Ho- There is no impact of water on the
growth of plant
Ha- There is an impact of water on the
growth of plant
When conducting deductive research, you always start with a theory (the result of
inductive research). Reasoning deductively means testing these theories. If there is
no theory yet, you cannot conduct deductive research.
4.Analyse the results: does the data reject or support the hypothesis?
1. 5 out of 100 flights of low-cost airlines are not delayed = reject hypothesis
2. 10 out of 20 dogs didn’t have fleas = reject hypothesis
RECAP
RECAP
Exploration
Description
Explanation
EXPLORATION
•A study into the role of social networking sites
To identify the nature of impact of work process re-engineering on the levels of employee motivation
What is the difference in the number of landline telephone calls made between Millennial
adults and older people?
The main emphasis of quantitative research is on deductive reasoning that tends to move from the
general to the specific and is also known as top-down approach.
The validity of the hypothesis is proved by combining one or more valid observations or rules.
It fails to take account of people’s unique ability to
interpret their experiences, construct their own meanings
and act on these. It leads to assumption that facts are true
and same for all people any time.
Limitations
Qualitative research is about recording, analyzing and
understanding the deeper meaning and significance of the
revealable variables. The research approach adopted is an
inductive method, wherein the researchers develop a
theory or look for a pattern on the basis of the data
that he/she has collected. It involves a strategic and
conventional move from specific to general and is
sometimes called the bottom-up approach
The problem of adequate validity or reliability is a major criticism. Because of the subjective nature
of qualitative data and its origin in single contexts, it is difficult to apply conventional standards of
reliability and validity.
Contexts, situations, events, conditions and interactions cannot be replicated to any extent nor any
kind of generalizations can be made to a wider context than the one studied with any confidence.
The time required for data collection, analysis and interpretation is lengthy.
different?
Qualitative Research Purpose
72
Process of Enquiry: How we
know what we know.
Errors in Enquiry
Overview of Research Process;
Inductive and Deductive
reasoning
Formulating Research
Objectives
Criteria for good research
Purpose of Research
Qualitative and Quantitative
DEFINING
THE
RESEARC
H
PROBLEM
In simple words, we can say that research problem
defines the destination before starting the journey. It
specifies, what to do, how to do, where to do and what
the outcomes are. Thus, without a properly defined
problem, the research cannot progress.
Test Question
Research Problem
Research question
Will the price hike cause lower consumption of alcohol among school children?
Hypothesis
Theory formulation
The question has never been asked before, but it now merits
exploration due to changes in accepted theory, data collection
technology or culture.
The secondary data are not only used for problem understanding and exploration but are also used to
develop an understanding about the research findings.
Expert Survey
To get the authentic information about the problem, the researchers sometimes consult the experts of
the concerned field. These experts provide authentic and relevant information useful for the research,
which otherwise is difficult to obtain.
For example, an automobile company would like to penetrate in the rural market segment and would
like to understand the requirements of the potential rural customers. How to collect exploratory data?
Focus groups are widely used in the investigation of applied-research problems and are
recognized as distinct research methods.
In a focus group, a small number of individuals are brought together in a room to sit and talk
about some topic of interest to the focus group sponsor.
In fact, the focus group interview is a qualitative research technique in which a trained
moderator leads a small group of participants to an unstructured discussion about the topic of
interest. It generally involves 8 to 12 individuals who discuss a particular topic under the direction
of a moderator, who promotes the interaction and guides the discussion on the topic of interest.
which is rare in a survey. In addition, a careful examination of their facial expressions and
voice modulation gives an opportunity to read the respondents’ feelings apart from words.
In an individual interview, some of the thoughts or ideas can be dropped out, whereas in a
focus group, there is a possibility to explore most of the ideas. If one participant will not be
able to present an idea, it will be presented by another participant. In this manner, all the
important dimensions of the problem are properly addressed.
An unstructured discussion provides flexibility to the focus group interview technique. The
moderator can lead the discussion to the desired direction.
The presence of many participants really triggers the discussion. A careful selection of
participants can lead to some fruitful information.
The focus group has the biggest advantage in terms of spontaneous responses by the
participants. The participants respond to a topic in a natural manner and flow of
communication also follows a natural sequence.
An experienced and effective moderator can control the discussion and generate the relevant
information. The effective and required intervention by the moderator results in a
channelized discussion in the focus group research.
Advantages of
FGD Interaction among the group members is an added advantage of the focus groups. Mutual
exchange of thoughts stimulates every participant to express their views freely.
The focus group can generate information fast. Its execution is also fast.
Limitations
The first drawback of the focus group interview technique is the scientific validity of the findings. The findings are
exploratory and qualitative in nature and need to be strengthened by conducting further structured research. Moreover,
the statistical validity of the procedure is also under serious doubt as the participant group is small and may not be a true
representative of the population.
The second limitation of the focus group research is the bias because of the moderator and the participants. As the
direction and mode of the discussion are based on the moderator, providing a biased approach cannot be easily ruled out
by the moderator. The participants who can talk and express well can also divert the real findings of the focus group. One
or two individuals dominating in conversation can really distract the discussion. In addition, the analysis is subjective in
nature; hence, the findings cannot be cross validated.
The third drawback of the focus group research lies in its important outcome as findings. No doubt, the focus group
presents important information but these are not conclusive. As a matter of drawback of the focus group research, some
managers treat the information as conclusive without taking the pain of launching a conclusive research.
Depth Interviews
A depth interview is a probing between a highly
skilled interviewer and a respondent from the target
population to unfold the underlying opinions,
motivations, emotions, or feelings of an individual
respondent, on a topic generally coined by the
researcher.
Advantages
The depth interviews are especially advantageous when the research topic is sensitive or
personal for a respondent. In this type of situation, the respondent always feels comfortable
answering the questions from one interviewer rather than from a group.
One-on-one interviews give greater flexibility to both the respondent and the interviewer.
Much revealing and authentic information can be obtained from the depth interview.
Personal interviews are easily scheduled when compared with the group interviews. Hence, the
depth interviews can be arranged much conveniently compared with the focus group
interviews.
The depth interviews can handle some complex topics well, as it is personal in nature.
Limitations
Success of the depth interview is completely based on the skill of an interviewer. Searching a skilful and an experienced
interviewer is not an easy task.
Probing by the interviewer can sometimes put the respondent in an uncomfortable situation. The respondent may develop a
feeling of being trapped in the situation and may become non-cooperative.
Continuous interviewing sometimes generates monotony and boredom for the interviewer, which ultimately dilutes the
quality of the gathered information.
Like any other exploratory research technique, the analysis and interpretation of the data are difficult exercises. The
reliability of the obtained data is also under serious doubt because there is lack of consistency in conducting the interview
in terms of the approach adopted by the interviewer. The depth interviews also lack statistical validity.
Case Analysis
A case study research method actually combines the record analysis and observations from
individual and group interviews. The case studies become particularly useful when one needs to
understand some particular problem or situation in great depth and when one can identify the cases
rich in information.
The case studies are mainly used for the exploration, classification, and hypothesis development
stage of the research process. The case study research methodology generally deals with some
contemporary issues and is conducted to explore the “why” and the “how” of a research
phenomenon.
The case studies are mainly used for the exploration, classification, and hypothesis development stage
of the research process. The case study research methodology generally deals with some contemporary
issues and is conducted to explore the “why” and the “how” of a research phenomenon.
The major advantage of the case research is its appropriateness to research, an area where few studies
have been carried out. The case studies are being conducted to address a real problem; hence, it really
provides a sound knowledge base to the existing body of knowledge.
Weakness of the case study research includes difficulties in generalizing research result and the
subjectivity of the data collection and analysis process. In addition, the case analysis is time consuming
and requires expert interviewers.
PROJECTIVE TECHNIQUES
Projective Techniques
Projective technique is achieved by presenting the respondents with ambiguous verbal or visual
stimulus materials, such as bubble cartoons, which they need to make sense of by drawing from their
own experiences, thoughts, feelings, and imagination before they can offer a response.
The projective technique is used to generate the information when the researcher believes that the
respondent will or cannot reveal the desired meaningful information by direct questioning.
METHODS OF CONDUCTING
EXPLORATORY RESEARCH
45 and 90
Weight
Class Rank
Serial Order
Numbers convey different meanings that are always case specific.
The
The scale
scale determines
determines the the amount
amount of
of information
information
contained
contained in
in the
the data.
data.
The
The scale
scale indicates
indicates the
the data
data summarization
summarization and
and
statistical
statistical analyses
analyses that
that are
are most
most appropriate.
appropriate.
Nominal Scale
If data are labels or names used to identify the attribute of an element, then the nominal scale is
used. For example, assume that a marketing research company wants to conduct a survey in three
emirates of UAE: RAK, Dubai, Sharjah. While compiling the data, the company assigns the Numeric
Code “1” to RAK, “2” to Dubai, and “3” to Sharjah. In this case, 1, 2, and 3 are the labels used to
identify the three different emirates.
•Gender
•Political preferences
•Place of residence
Ordinal Scale
For example, a manufacturing company administers a questionnaire to 150 consumers to obtain the consumer perception for one
of its products. Each consumer is asked to judge between three given options: excellent, good, or poor. Clearly, excellent is ranked
the best and poor the worst, with good ranked between the two. If we want to assign numeric values to these three attributes, “1”
can be used for excellent, “2” for good, and “3” for poor. In most cases, when we apply statistical tools and techniques, for the
sake of interpretation convenience, rankings are set in reverse. In this case, “1” will be used for poor, “2” for good, and “3” for
excellent. Therefore, the lowest number has the lowest ranking and the highest number the highest ranking.
Status at workplace
In the interval level measurement, the difference between the two consecutive numbers is
meaningful. The interval data are always numeric. For example, three students of M.Sc. Statistics
have scored 65, 75, and 85 in the subject reliability theory. These three students can be rated in terms
of their performances
In the above example, we can also compute that between the highest and the lowest ranking points,
the difference is 20 marks.
Ratio level measurements possess all the properties of interval data with meaningful ratio of two values. The ratio scale must contain a zero value that indicates
that nothing exists for the variable at zero point.
For example, a company markets two toothbrushes priced AED 30 and AED 15, respectively. In the ratio scale, the difference between the two prices, that is, AED
30 − AED 15 = AED 15, can be calculated and is meaningful. With it, we can also say that the price of the first product, AED 30, is two times that of the second
product.
Comparison
A comparison between the
four levels of data
measurement in terms of
usage potential
In terms of measurement
capacity, nominal, ordinal,
interval, and ratio level data
are placed in an ascending
order. This means that the
nominal data are the weakest
and the ratio data are the
strongest in terms of
applicability in different
statistical tests.
The Hierarchy of Levels
Nominal
The Hierarchy of Levels
Ordinal
Interval
Ordinal Attributes can be ordered
Ratio
Interval Distance is meaningful
Data
Qualitative Quantitative
Numerical
Numerical Nonnumerical
Nonnumerical Numerical
Numerical
Nominal
Nominal Ordinal
Ordinal Nominal
Nominal Ordinal
Ordinal Interval
Interval Ratio
Ratio
LET’S
MEET
AT
2.00PM
123
In the previous
section..
Research Problem- answer the five Ws
Literature Review
Scales of Measurement
Random and
Systematic Error
Random Error
1) fluctuations in the person’s current mood.
2) misreading or misunderstanding the questions
3) measurement of the individuals on different days or in different
places.
These error may cancel out as you collect many samples
Systematic Error
Sources of error including the style of measurement, tendency
toward self-promotion, cooperative reporting, and other
conceptual variables are being measured.
THE
CRITERIA
FOR GOOD
MEASUREMEN
T
Validity, Reliability, and
Sensitivity
Reliability
R E L IA B IL ITY
S T A B IL ITY IN T E R N A L C O N S IS T E N C Y
TEST RETEST E Q U IV A L E N T F O R M S S P L IT T IN G H A L V E S
Validity
V alid ity
CONCURRENT P R E D IC TIV E
SENSITIVITY
A measurement instrument’s ability to accurately measure
variability in stimuli or responses.
Sensitivity
Sensitivity is the ability of a measuring instrument to measure the meaningful
difference in the responses obtained from the subjects included in the study. It is
to be noted that the dichotomous categories of response such as yes or no can
generate a great deal or variability in the responses. Hence, a scale with many
items as a sensitive measure is required.
For example, a scale based on five categories of responses, such as “strongly
disagree,” “disagree,” “neither agree nor disagree,” “agree,” and “strongly
agree,” presents a more sensitive measuring instrument. To enhance the
sensitivity of the measuring instrument, a single-question scale must be avoided
and a researcher’s focus should be on including more relevant items or
questions.
How Do You Improve the Reliability and Validity of
Your Measured Variables?
Conduct a pilot test, trying out a questionnaire or other research instruments on a small group
Be certain to consider face and content validity by choosing reasonable terms and that cover a broad range of
issues reflecting the conceptual variables..
Audi--2
BMW--3
Land Rover--4
In another way of measurement, the researcher will simply ask a
question that will you be purchasing a luxury car produced by
Company X, say “Yes” or “No.” Answers yes and no are coded as
1 and 2, respectively.
Tesla—1/2
Audi—1/2
BMW—1/2
Land Rover—1/2
The quality of the research always depends on the
fact that what measurement techniques are adopted
by the researcher and how these fit in the
prevailing research circumstances.
In the forced-choice
ranking scaling technique, the
respondents rank different
objects simultaneously from a
list of objects presented to them
Paired-comparison scaling
Open ended
The open-ended questions provide a free-to-answer opportunity to the respondents instead
of fixed-response choices. In an open-ended question, a respondent remains free to provide
his or her opinion about any topic in his or her own words. While narrating an opinion or
attitude, the respondent provides a deep insight about the phenomenon under study. This
really helps a researcher to design a questionnaire in a more structured manner. Hence, the
open-ended questions are extremely useful for an exploratory research.
Answers to the open-ended questions require a careful interpretation. In any case, it is very
difficult to have a subjective interpretation without human bias. Open-ended questions have
the tendency to provide an extra importance to the respondents who are more expressive.
closed ended
The closed-ended questions provide response alternative to the respondents instead of
giving them a free-to-express response option. The choice offered to the respondents can
be either in the form of a rating system or a set of response alternatives. These response
alternatives are presented to the respondents and they select the most appropriate one. The
closed-ended questionnaires are generally cheaper, more reliable, and faster to code, and
analyse the collected data.
As the question is already structured, the interpretation bias is also reduced, which
ultimately saves time and cost. Coding and tabulation of data also become very easy as the
response alternatives are fixed and the researcher has no burden to create categories from
a wide range of different narratives provided by the different respondents.
Dichotomous questions
Dichotomous questions have only two response alternatives usually presenting the two
extremes “yes” or “no.” To make the alternatives balanced, the researchers often present a
third neutral alternative “don’t know.”
1. Please specify your gender.
Male ___________Female _________
2. Is it an attractive policy with special features for kids?
Yes ________No ________Cannot say ___________
3. Will you be purchasing this policy this year?
Yes ________No ________Cannot say ___________
4. Do you have any other policy related to children?
Yes ________No ________Cannot say ___________
Multiple-Choice Questions
While asking multiple-choice questions, the researcher presents
various answer choices to a respondent and the respondent is
supposed to select any one from the options. The multiple-choice
questions are also referred as multichotomous questions.
1. How do you rate the services offered by the bank?
Excellent ________Very good _______Moderate _______Just right _______Poor ____________
2. How much are you planning to spend in a “fixed deposit scheme” this year?
Less than Rs. 20,000 Rs 20,001 to Rs 40,000 Rs 40,001 to Rs 60,000 Rs 60,001 to Rs 80,000 Rs 80,0001
to Rs 1,00,000
3. For what time period will you be investing in a “fixed deposit scheme”?
Less than 1 year 1 year to 2 years 2 years to 3 years 3 years to 4 years 4 years to 5 years
While preparing a questionnaire, the researcher must always be careful as the respondent may be a common person
who will not be able to understand the technical language.
What is your perception about the new advertisement campaign?
A researcher should frame the same question as:
What is your view about the new advertisement campaign?
In some situations, a researcher’s questions are based on the respondent’s memory. The
respondents tend to forget the incidents that are not important for them. These incidents may
be important for the researcher, and he or she has framed question on these incidents.
In the past two months, how many times you have eaten ice cream of Brand “X” with
your family?
How many times you enjoyed ice cream parties with your family in past 2 months?
Respondent’s Ability to Answer Must be Considered
Funnel technique suggests asking general questions first and then the specific questions. The general
questions allow an interviewer to have knowledge about the respondent’s understanding and opinion about the
subject matter to be investigated.
Work technique suggests that difficult-to-answer, sensitive, or complicated questions should be placed later in
the questionnaire. Researchers generally place the scaled questions in this category as the respondent has to put
much effort to answer these questions compared with simple questions.
The third technique is the section technique in which questions are placed in different sections with respect to
some common base.
DATA
COLLECTIO
N
Stages of Data Analysis
EDITING
CODING
ERROR
CHECKING
AND
DATA ENTRY VERIFICATION
DATA ANALYSIS
DATA ANALYSIS
Coding
Inferential Statistics
Hypothesis:
Letter of
Conclusions
authorization
Final area
Appended parts
Data collection
forms
Detailed
calculations
General tables
Bibliography
Bibliography and References
SBS cites using the American Psychological Association (APA) format. This section is a short
summary of citation and referencing techniques. When in doubt, consult the Publication Manual of
the American Psychological Association, 7th ed.
In principle, citations are embedded in the text and show up to three bits of information: