Scribd
Upload
38 views17 pages

5th HW Part 1

Textbooks play an important role in language teaching by providing structure, activities, and support for both students and teachers. However, textbooks also have limitations and should not be relied on exclusively. When evaluating textbooks, it is important to consider their goals, content, methodology, and how they address the needs of both learners and instructors. Thorough evaluation involves analyzing textbooks at several levels - examining what they contain, what is required of users, and implicit assumptions. Checklists provide a systematic way to comprehensively assess textbooks against criteria. The evaluation process is cyclical as textbooks are adapted and improved over time based on teaching experiences.

Uploaded by

h
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PPTX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
38 views17 pages

5th HW Part 1

Textbooks play an important role in language teaching by providing structure, activities, and support for both students and teachers. However, textbooks also have limitations and should not be relied on exclusively. When evaluating textbooks, it is important to consider their goals, content, methodology, and how they address the needs of both learners and instructors. Thorough evaluation involves analyzing textbooks at several levels - examining what they contain, what is required of users, and implicit assumptions. Checklists provide a systematic way to comprehensively assess textbooks against criteria. The evaluation process is cyclical as textbooks are adapted and improved over time based on teaching experiences.

Uploaded by

h
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PPTX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 17

Textbook

Evaluation
Hadjer Gouasmia Group 2
The role of Textbooks

● Textbooks are designed to give cohesion to the language teaching and


learning process by providing direction, support and specific
language based activities aimed at offering classroom practice for
students. Furthermore, many textbooks claim to provide learners
with exposure to language in use. With these points in mind,
textbooks have often provided the syllabus for language programs
and multi-level series have taken learners from beginners to
advanced level. From the global perspective, textbooks have also
provided non- native speaker teachers with the support and security
necessary for many of them. Clearly, therefore, textbooks have had a
significant impact on many students and teachers and shaped the
Textbooks are an A rich source of all
extension to syllabi types of teaching A useful guide for
and a reflection of materials novice teachers
their objectives

Textbook
Learners can refer to Textbooks can be a A viable reference of a
textbooks when it source of inspiration ,for variety of interactive
comes to checking it is full of creative ideas activities and tasks
pronunciation, gaining that stimulate and boost
that promote learner
vocabulary, and learners’ imagination and
language use and
grasping grammatical creativity.
communicative skills
structures
The Relationship between Teachers and
Coursebooks
● A textbook is only as good as the teacher who uses it.

● It's important to remember that a textbook is just one tool, perhaps a


very important tool, in your teaching arsenal.

● Sometimes, teachers over-rely on textbooks and don't consider other


aids or other materials for the classroom.

● Teachers need to make many decisions, and one of those is how they want
to use the textbook.
Advantages of Textbooks
Textbooks :

➢ Provide a framework and a syllabus for a given program


➢ Offer a rich flexible and differentiated instructions
➢ Get learners exposed to well-organized, and of a high quality teaching
materials
➢ Bring about a variety of valuable and feasible teaching-learning resources
➢ Provide teachers with satisfactory opportunities to spend time in the
teaching practice rather than material development
➢ Offer teachers with a free training that would lift them up professionally
➢ Give cohesion to the language teaching and learning process by providing
direction, support and specific language based activities aimed at offering
classroom practice for students.
➢ Provide teachers under pressure with reassurance that they will be using
materials which they can have confidence.

➢ Textbooks are especially helpful for beginning teachers. The material to be


covered and the design of each lesson are carefully spelled out in detail

➢ Textbooks are a detailed sequence of teaching procedures that tell you what
to do and when to do it.

➢ Textbook is learners’ best reference when it comes to revision and exam


preparation.
Disadvantages of Textbooks
➢ Textbooks language is very often artificial and irrelevant to real life contexts

➢ Textbooks’ input and content provide a utopian and illusionary view to real life
issues

➢ Some textbooks are designed and created with no reference to learners’ ever-
changing needs and demands.

➢ Some teachers over-rely on textbooks considering them an ultimate source of


knowledge. This way, teachers get deskilled to think out of the box and bring
creativity to their teaching-learning environment
Methods of Analysis and
Evaluation
The Impressionistic Method

The Checklist Method

In-depth Method
The Impressionistic Method

● This method aims to help the evaluator obtain a general impression


on, or overview of, the added value of educational content. The
method may be more applicable in evaluating printed rather than
digital content. Of particular interest when reviewing content
through the impressionistic method are language elements, the
types of exercises used in learning, and the author’s view of the
learning process.
The Checklist Method
● The checklist is developed by listing items, steps, or tasks and is then
analyzed against criteria to determine if the procedure is completed
correctly.

● It has many positive advantages: It is systematic. The facts are


recorded in a handy format, making an allowance for smooth
assessment among connecting units of material. It is specific and gives
a not unusual place framework for decision-making.
In-depth Method

This method does not conform to what publishers and authors say, that is,
look at the type of language description the material is based on, the basic
assumptions or values ​about learning or the broader meaning, regardless of
whether the material may live up to the demands made for them
Evaluating Textbooks
According to Little john textbook evaluation is based on three levels:
The first level : is about :What is there?

This phase involves identifying these kinds of information:


● Aims and objectives of the book.
● Level of the book.
● Skills addressed.
● Topics covered.
● Situations it is intended for.
● Target learners.
● Time required.
● Components.
● Number and length of units.
● Organization of units
The second level is about: What is required of users?

It includes:
● What cognitive operations will be required
● What form of classroom organization will be involved
(individual, whole class work)?
● What medium will be involved
● Who will be the source of language information?
The third level is about "What is implied?":

It includes:

● Selection and sequencing of content ( Syllabus) and tasks


● Distribution of information across teacher and student
components
● Reconsideration of information collected at levels 1 and 2
The Cycle of Textbook Adaptaion

The cycle of textbook adaptation turns around different stages:

● Stage 1: Planning how to teach with the text

● Stage 2: teaching and readjusting

● Stage3: replanning how to teach based on evaluating the teaching and the
text

● Stage 4: reteaching
Guidelines for Evaluation
Cunningsworth (1995) provided the following guidelines for textbook evaluation:
● Coursebooks should correspond to learners’ needs, motivation, learning styles, purposes. They should
also serve the objectives of the course and ought to ease the learning process.
The checklist methos is an instrument that helps practioners evaluate course books in an effective and
practical way. Cunningsworth (1984) proposes a checklist that encompasses the following:
● Aims and approaches: is the coursebook flexible? Does it allow different teaching and learning
styles?
● Design and organization: is the content organized according to functions, topics, skills? Is the content
sequenced based on complexity, learnability, and usefulness?
● Language content: does the coursebook include materials for pronunciation, vocabulary that are
adequate in terms of quantity and range ?
● Skills: are all four skills adequately covered?
● Topic: will topics help expand students’ awareness and expand their experiences?
● Methodology: is the communicative approach to language learning present?
Is there a variety of techniques used for teaching?
● Teachers’ books: do they provide keys to exercises? Do they cover teaching techniques and language
items such as grammar?
Conclusion

Textbooks that appear sound on the surface often lack many of the
criteria of a truly useful book. Therefore, it is necessary for
individuals who are making choices to carefully examine all aspects of
the textbook and compare it against an assessment tool. An evaluation
checklist serves to ensure that significant factors will not be missed.

You might also like