Topic 2 - Part 1 - Work Environment Design - Visual Sense
Topic 2 - Part 1 - Work Environment Design - Visual Sense
Visual Sense
Engr. Suzette M. Mercado, PIE, Asean Eng
This module will describe how to measure and produce illumination, the effects of
different lighting conditions on visual performance and visual comfort, and psychological
effects of illumination, and the risks inherent in exposure to light. More so, it will provide
information about how lighting can affect workplace well-being, focusing on visual function
and its role in workplace productivity. Vision syndrome as well as the eye and vision
problems is defined and solutions to it will be discussed.
4
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Learning Objectives
5
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
1
Vision and the eye
⊳ The human eye is the organ which gives us the sense of sight and allowing us
to observe and learn more about the surrounding world than we do with any
of the other four senses.
⊳ We use our eyes in almost every activity we perform, whether reading,
working, watching television or writing etc.
⊳ The eye can detect bright light or dim light, but it cannot sense objects when
light is absent.
⊳ 70 percent of all sensory receptors are in the eyes
⊳ The vision is a photoreceptor sense
7
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
The Structure of the Eye
The eye is a fluid-filled membranous sphere that converts
electromagnetic radiation into nerve impulses that it transmits
to the brain along the optic nerve. Light enters through a
transparent outer covering called the cornea. The cornea
plays a major role in refracting the light. Further refraction
occurs as the light passes through the lens. The pupil works
like the aperture of a camera to vary the amount of light
entering the eye. In bright light, the iris contracts, the Figure 1. Basic structure of the eye.
pupillary diameter decreases and only the central part of the a = cornea; b = pupil; c = lens;
d = ciliary muscle; e = suspensory
lens forms an image on the retina. In poor light, the iris ligaments; f = retina; g = fovea;
h = blind spot; i = optic nerve.
expands, and a larger area of the lens is used.
8
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
“
In the electromagnetic spectrum.
Visible light falls in the range
380–760 nanometers (nm).
9
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
How We See
⊳ Our eyes sense energy from the outside in the form of light rays
and convert these into nerve impulses, which the brain
integrates into a visual picture of the outside world.
⊳ People differ greatly in their interpretation of visual data,
depending on their age, experience, attitude, and preconceived
ideas.
⊳ People also differ in their abilities to recognize colors and focus
clearly on visual targets, and usually significant changes in these
abilities occur as one ages.
10
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Visual Defects
11
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Visual Defects
⊳ Asthenopia is diminished visual acuity associated with eyestrain, pain in the eyes and
headache. It is common in people who carry out near visual work for long periods and
naturally reverses shortly after the cessation of close visual work.
⊳ Myopia is sometimes referred to as ‘nearsightedness’ because the near point is closer
to the eye in myopic people (for an equal amount of accommodation) than it is to a
healthy eye. Myopic individuals cannot bring distant objects into focus. Myopic
individuals can often carry out close tasks such as VDU work or sewing with ease but
experience difficulties with tasks such as driving when target objects are more than 5–
10 meters away.
12
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Visual Defects
⊳ Hypermetropia is sometimes referred to as ‘farsightedness’ because the near point is
farther away from the eye (for an equal amount of accommodation) than it is in a
healthy eye. Hypermetropic individuals can be said to lack refractive power and may
tire quickly when carrying out work in which the viewing distance is short (such as
using a VDU).
⊳ In astigmatism, there is an unequal curvature of the refractive of the eye such that the
refractive power is not the same in one plane as in another. When an object of
complex shape is viewed, the retinal image may be out of focus in one plane but not
in others. Astigmatic individuals often perform quite well when given simple eye tests
because the defect is corrected by the depth of focus of the eye. However, they may
experience severe difficulties at night or when there is excessive glare.
13
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Visual System
⊳ A complete eye examination is more than just reading letters on a chart 20 feet away.
⊳ This is simply one test to measure the function of one part of the visual system.
⊳ The eyeball is just the receiver of light.
⊳ Visual processing is accomplished in the brain, where visual perception occurs.
⊳ The visual cortex is the largest system in the human brain and is responsible for
processing the visual image. It lies at the occipital lobe of the brain above the
cerebellum.
⊳ Eyesight is the process of properly focusing the incoming light to the correct area of the
retina, whereas visual perception is the process of taking that information into the brain,
making sense of it, and reacting appropriately
14
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Visual System
⊳ When we walk into a dark movie theatre, it will take a few minutes before the
eyes adapt to the darkness. After that, we can see the surrounding people. This
process is called dark adaptation, and it is achieved by photo-chemical processes
in the eye.
⊳ When light hits the photopigments, they undergo a chemical reaction that
converts the light energy into electrical activity. This chemical reaction is referred
to as light adaptation. In this process, the photopigments are decomposed. Intense
light will decompose the photopigments rapidly and completely, thus reducing the
sensitivity of the eyes so that it becomes difficult to see in dim light.
15
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
2
Lighting and Illumination
⊳ Light may be defined as electromagnetic radiation that can affect the sense of
sight.
⊳ Without light, we cannot see.
⊳ The sun, a lamp, or an electronic display generates light. The moon, the walls of
a room, or a page of print reflect light.
⊳ The most important factor for human vision is luminance, the light energy
reflected from a surface (unless we stare into a light source).
17
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Sources of Light
18
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Sources of Light
⊳ Electric Lighting: The amount of light, the color of the light itself and the color that
objects appear vary with the type of electric lighting. The lighting must match the
workplace and the task. The following are common types of bulbs.
19
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Workplace Lighting
An important factor that affects workers’ ability to see well in the workplace is the
quality of light. Quality lighting, created by attention to brightness, contrast, quantity,
and color of light, results in visibility and visual comfort. Contrast between a task
object and its immediate background must be sufficient to enable the worker to clearly
view the task. Contrast ratios should be established to maximize productivity without
increasing eyestrain. In general, a 1:3:10 ratio is ideal; that is, the task area should be
less than 3 times as bright as its immediate surroundings (within 25° of the visual
target) and 10 times brighter than the peripheral area (past 25°).
20
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Workplace Lighting
As people age, their vision changes. This can be accommodated for with changes in the
lighting. Adjustments need to be made such as increasing light levels and reducing
glare.
Effects on Work Include:
⊳ decrease in productivity (less work is completed).
⊳ decrease in accuracy (more errors are made).
⊳ decrease in quality of work.
⊳ increase in accidents.
Poor lighting is also a workplace security hazard, especially for shift workers who may
not have coworkers nearby or must walk to a bus or parking lot after dark. 23
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Elements of Lighting
25
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Elements of Lighting
⊳ Luminance is the amount of light reflected or coming from a light source or surface. It is
important that there is not a great difference between the luminance levels for the task and that of
the surrounding area. Luminance levels for the immediate area surrounding the tasks should be one
third that of the task. The further from the task the less light is needed.
⊳ Reflectance is the percentage of light falling on a surface that is reflected. In an office the most
reflective surface should be the ceiling; the least reflective should be the floor and in between are
the reflectance of walls and furniture. In general, reflections from surfaces within the field of view
should be minimized. Color and finish are used to control the reflectance of a surface. A totally
black surface reflects no light. For a white surfaces the reverse is true. Also a matte finish reflects
less light than a shiny one of the same color.
26
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Elements of Lighting
⊳ Contrast is the relationship between the light coming from an object and the immediate
background, such as words on paper. High contrast is important for fine detail work. Using a black
pen in place of a pencil for handwritten copy will increase the contrast and improve the readability.
⊳ Glare occurs when there is too much direct or reflected light within the field of view. Glare causes
a decrease in contrast which results in decreased visibility and physical discomfort. Even low-level
indirect glare that may not be noticeable can cause eye strain and fatigue. The adverse effect of
glare on visibility increases with age. Glare can be controlled by using indirect light sources and
positioning direct and reflected light sources outside the field of view. Special anti-glare screens
are available for visual display terminals if necessary.
27
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Elements of Lighting
⊳ Color can affect both the mood and the perception of size in a workplace.
Blues and greens are considered relaxing or soothing.
Orange, yellow and brown colors are thought to be stimulating.
Red and violet are considered alarming or aggressive.
Pastel colors reduce the impact of color.
Cool colors such as blues and greens can make a space seem larger.
Reds and oranges can make a space seem smaller.
Different types of lights will influence how colors are perceived. If the light source is not coordinated
with the color of a work area colors may be perceived as off or strange. Visibility may be more
different. 28
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Elements of Lighting
⊳ Visual Acuity. Visual acuity can be defined in several ways, usually done as the ability to detect
small details and discriminate small objects by eyesight. Visual acuity depends on the shape of the
object and on the wavelength, the illumination, the luminance, the contrast, and the duration of the
light stimulus. Visual acuity is usually measured at viewing distances of 6 m (20 ft) and 0.4 m (1.3
ft), because factors that determine the resolution of an object differ in far and near viewing. For
determining acuity, high-contrast patterns are presented to the observer. The most common patterns
are either Snellen letters. The smallest detail detected or identified is taken as the threshold. These
measures of acuity primarily depend on the ability to see edge differences between black and white
stimuli at rather high illuminance levels.
29
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Elements of Lighting
⊳ Visibility is the clarity with which a human can see an object. There are 3 critical
factors in visibility: visual angle, contrast and illuminance.
▸ Visual angle: size of target on retina; the angle the image takes up on retina.
▸ Contrast: relative difference in luminance (light reflected) for two surfaces
contrast = (Lmax – Lmin)/Lmax
31
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Measurement of Light
Illuminance
⊳ Lighting intensity is measured in candalas (cd), or lumens, where 1 cd =
12.57 lumens.
⊳ Illuminance is the amount of light shining on an object, measured in foot-
candles (fc):
Illuminance = intensity / d2
where d is in feet.
Intensity is foot-candles (fc)
luminous intensity is candela, luminous flux is lumens
⊳ Illuminance can be measured also in lux = cd/m2
32
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Measurement of Light
Luminance
⊳ Luminance is the amount of light reflected from an object,
▸ It impacts our ability to see objects,
▸ It is measured in foot-lamberts (fL):
33
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Measurement of Light
34
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Measurement of Illumination and Luminance
Reflectance
⊳ Reflectance is determined by the physical and color properties of an object; how much
light is absorbed or thrown back at the viewer? It is the property of a surface which is
determined by both color and surface finish and expressed as a percentage of light
reflected (luminance).
⊳ Table 6-1 lists reflectance for various colors and surfaces.
⊳ Reflectance is a ration between:
▸ The measured reflectance of the target surface,
▸ The measured reflectance of a standard Kodak neutral test card = 0.9
Reflectance
⊳ The proportion of light reflected by a lighted surface is referred to as reflectance. That
is,
reflectance
⊳ when luminance is measured in ft-lamberts, and illuminance in ft-candles. If the
luminance is measured in candelas/m2, and illuminance in lux, the reflectance
becomes:
reflectance
36
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Measurement of Light
Reflectance
White, painted surfaces have a reflectance of around 90%. Newsprint and bare
concrete are around 50%. Dark painted surfaces may be as low as 5%. The use of
appropriate paints and finishes is an important design strategy for spreading reflected light
evenly throughout the workplace in a way that can both reduce lighting bills and create a
more pleasant environment. Standards such as ANSI/IES RP-7-1979—Practices for
Industrial Lighting recommend reflectance values of 80% to 90% for ceilings, 40% to 60%
for walls, 25% to 45% for desks and bench tops, and 20% or higher for floors.
37
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Measurement of Light
38
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Recommended
Illumination
39
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Recommended
Illumination
Similar to Table 2, it
shows General and
Specific Illumination
Recommendations
(Adapted from IESNA, 1988.)
40
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Measurement of Light
To compute or measure recommended illumination:
⊳ Pick general category based on activity
⊳ Adjust for this three factors. The amount of light needed is a function of:
▸ The nature of the task (speed/accuracy of task),
▸ The worker (age and visual health),
▸ The reflectance of the task background.
This Table 3, shows the weight factors used in the light needed.
41
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Measurement of Light
⊳ For Example, table 2 will give you a range of lighting levels (low, medium, high)
suitable for a general task category:
⊳ After determining each weight and summing them, a similar set of rules are used to
assign a high, medium, or low value within the range of illumination values
suggested for the particular category. That is,
▸ choose between Low: -3, -2,
Medium: -1, 0, +1
High: +2, +3
42
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Example 1
43
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Solution to Example 1
Therefore,
Illuminance = 1500cd/(13.124ft)2 = 8.709 fc or
Illuminance = 1500cd/(4m)2 = 93.75 lux
44
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Example 2
46
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Solution to Example 2
1. How many fc’s are needed?
Find reflectance of surroundings: light cream gives you approximately 75% reflectance.
Find the general task category: Category F
Find weighting factors based on:
Task characteristic value weight
▸ Age of workers, 55 + +1
▸ Reflectance of surroundings, greater than 70% -1
▸ Criticality: speed and accuracy, critical +1
Total Weight = 1 + (-1) + 1 = + 1
To find amount of light needed, use weighting factor to pick illuminance value:
since total weight factor is equal to +1, it requires medium illumination, need at least 150
fc!
47
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Solution to Example 2
2. Is a 800 lumen bulb sufficient?
Is a 800 lumen bulb sufficient to provide 150 fc on the work surface, if the light source is
5 ft. from the work surface?
1 cd = 12.57 lumens
800 lumens to candela: 800 lumens * 1 cd/12.57 lumens = 63.64 cd
To compute Illuminance (fc):
Illuminance (fc) = intensity/d2
63.64 cd/(5ft)2 = 2.5 fc
Therefore, this bulb at 5 ft is inadequate! (Ok for general lighting in a public area).
48
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
“
Historically, ergonomics can be seen to have arisen as a
response to the need for rapid design of complex systems. The
modern ergonomist has an important role to play as a member
of the design team, providing scientific information about
humans and ensuring that all aspects of the system are evaluated
from the users’ or operators’ point of view. The participatory
approach seems to be the best way to ensure that the
implementation of ergonomics will be effective.
49
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
3
Lighting Design
1. more efficient lamps, ballasts, and fixtures. 6. photoelectric sensors that sense the amount of
2. better placement and arrangement of light daylight in the room and
fixtures, shields, and shades. either switch lamps on or off or adjust the lamp
3. use of daylight. brightness accordingly.
4. timers and occupancy sensors that turn lights 7. localized lighting in areas where more light is
off when they are not needed. needed.
5. on-off and dimmer switches in convenient 8. reduced lighting levels in nonproduction areas.
locations so that people can turn off or reduce 9. regular cleaning of lamps, fixtures, windows,
unneeded lighting. skylights, walls, and ceilings.
10. placing lights in better locations.
53
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Strategies for Ambient Illumination
1. providing shades and window curtains to keep direct sunlight off the surfaces of CRTs or
other displays.
2. placing shades on lamps and light fixtures.
3. locating light sources well above the work surface so they are not directly casting their
light on the screen.
4. providing dimmer switches so people can adjust the light levels downwards.
5. changing the orientation of workstations to reduce reflections off of the display surface.
54
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Improving Visibility
⊳ One can improve visability in several ways:
▸ Increase source intensity (increase wattage, change to more efficient type:
florescent, halogen)
▸ Bring target closer to viewer
▸ Bring target closer to light source
▸ Increase contrast
▸ Increase target size (big print books)
⊳ Solutions to Glare
▸ Change to indirect lighting,
▸ Change lighting angle, or work surface angle,
▸ Use non-glare surfaces,
▸ Use polarizing filters on light sources or eyewear
55
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Guidelines for the visual design of VDU tasks
56
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Visual Ergonomics
57
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
ISO for Lighting Design and Requirements
Lehto, M. R., Landry, S.J., Introduction to Human factors and Ergonomics for Engineers, 2nd Edition, CRC Press, 2013
https://www.pdfdrive.com/fitting-the-human-introduction-to-ergonomics-human-factors-engineering-e158280956.html
https://kuliahdianmardi.files.wordpress.com/2016/03/handbook-of-human-factors-and-ergonomics-fourth-edition-2012.pdf
http://ssu.ac.ir/cms/fileadmin/user_upload/Daneshkadaha/dbehdasht/khatamat_behdashti/kotobe_latin/Introduction_to_Ergonomics.pdf
https://www.pdfdrive.com/a-guide-to-human-factors-and-ergonomics-e34320317.html
https://www.ccohs.ca/
https://www.iso.org/
59
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
Questions For
Discussion
60
BATANGAS STATE UNIVERSITY – Industrial Engineering Department
1. Why is lighting important?