Lecture 6 Sampling
Lecture 6 Sampling
SAMPLING
Art of cutting a small portion of material from a large lot
and transferring it to the analyzer
Point
PointMaterialization
Materialization Error
Error Weighting Error
PME
PME SWE
Increment
Increment Delimi-
Delimi- Increment
IncrementExtraction
Extraction Increment
Incrementand
andSample
Sample
tation
tationError
Error Error
Error Preparation
PreparationError
Error
IDE
IDE IXE
IXE IPE
IPE
Point Selection Error
PSE
GOAL: x = m
å c iV i
Weighted mean concentration: = 4.82 mg/l
å Vi
Total emission estimate (unweighted):
M = 9×c ×V = 9×4 .89 × g / m ×5 .48 ×m = 241.13g
3 3
å c iV i
Weighted mean concentration: = 4.82 mg/l
å Vi
Total emission estimate (unweighted):
M = 9×c ×V = 9×4 .89 × g / m ×5 .48 ×m = 241.13g
3 3
𝜎 𝑛 = √ 𝜇𝑛
(1)
• The relative standard deviation is
1
𝜎 𝑟= (2)
√ 𝜇𝑛
The Fundamental Error (FE) variance σFE2 identified by Gy
(1982) is the ‘irreducible minimum’ of sampling errors, is the only error
that can be estimated before performing the sampling and arises from
the inherent variability of the material being sampled.
According to François-Bongarçon (1998), FE is ‘the smallest
achievable residual average error’, a loss of precision inherent in the
sample due to physical and chemical composition as well as particle
size distribution. It arises because of two characteristics of broken ore
materials, namely the compositional heterogeneity and the
distributional heterogeneity.
Example
Plant Manager: I am producing fine-ground limestone that is used
in paper mills for coating printing paper. According to their speci-
fication my product must not contain more than 5 particles/tonne
particles larger than 5 mm. How should I sample my product?
Sampling Expert: Well, let’s consider the problem. We could use the
Poisson distribution to estimate the required sample size. Let’s see:
The maximum relative standard deviation sr = 20 % = 0.2. From
equation 2 we can estimate how many coarse particles there should be
in the sample to have this standard deviation
1 1
𝑛= 2 = 2
=25
𝑠 𝑟 0. 2
If 1 tonne contains 5 coarse particles this result means that the primary
sample should be 25 tonnes. This is a good example of an impossible
sampling problem. Even though you could take a 25 tonne sample there
is no feasible technology to separate and count the coarse particles
from it. You shouldn’t try the traditional analytical approach in con-
trolling the quality of your product. Instead, if the specification is really
sensible, you forget the particle size analyzers and maintain the quality
of your product by process technological means, that is, you take care
that all equipment are regularly serviced and their high performance
maintained to guarantee the product quality.
P. Gy’s Fundamental sampling error model
According to Gy (1982), if the mass of the pile of broken
ore (100s of kg) is very large compared to the sample mass
(a few kg), the variance of the fundamental error may be
expressed as:
1 1
2 3
𝜎 =𝐾 𝑑 (
𝐹𝐸 − ) 𝑁
Where:
𝑀𝑆 𝑀 𝐿
Ms =Mass of sample measured in grams.
ML = Is the mass of material from which Ms is taken, measured in
grams
= Nominal size of fragments in the sample
K = Is a constant for any given ore
SAMPLING CONSTANT, K
K
L=d
L
𝐿
𝛽=
√ 𝑑
𝛽=1
𝛽 max
g=
Wide size distribution g = 0.25
C=
CONCLUSIONS
Sampling uncertainty can be, and should be
estimated
If the sampling uncertainty is not known it is questionable
whether the sample should be analyzed at all
Sampling nearly always takes a significant part of the
total uncertainty budget
Optimization of sampling and analytical procedures may
result significant savings, or better results, including
scales from laboratory procedures and process sampling
to large national surveys
Exercise:
Problem No. 1—What error is introduced when a
sample of given weight, MS, is taken from a pile of
broken ore? This problem is simply answered by
substituting the known factors into the original Gy’s
equation. Assume that dN= 1.25 cm. For
the sake of this exercise assume the following sampling conditions for a gold
bearing ore crushed to about 0.93 cm, with c= 16 000 000 for a gold-silver
amalgam, f= 0.5, g=0.25 and l= 0.000035.
QUESTIONS
How do you calculate the standard deviation and relative standard
deviation using Poisson distribution?
Write down the formula used to determine the constant on P.Gy’s
fundamental sampling error model and explain all the variables
present.