Bme Lab: Belt Drive Vs Chain Drive Vs Gear Drive
Bme Lab: Belt Drive Vs Chain Drive Vs Gear Drive
By,
Yash Sorathiya
Belt drive
Advantages Disadvantages
It can easily install and easily remove. Power loss due to slip and creep.
The price of the belt drive is low. And speed is limited to some extent.
Simple in construction. Longer life is not possible.
The maintenance cost is low.
Chances of breaking are more.
No additional lubricant is required.
It can transfer power vertical, horizontal and
The operation temperature is limited
inclined too. between -35 to 85 degrees Celsius. If it
Power consumption is low. exceeds temperature then it causes wear.
Chain Drive
Roller chain
Silent chain
Leaf Chain
Flat-top Chain
Engineering Steel Chain
Advantages and Disadvantages for Chain
Drive
Advantages Disadvantages
Low maintenance. The major disadvantages are here it requires more and frequent
lubrication.
Greater efficiency up to 97 percent.
Slipping is negligible
It cannot be used where there is a requirement of slips.
It can withstand abrasive conditions. It cannot be used for précised motion requirements.
The chain drive is easy to install. It is noisy and therefore there is a problem of vibration.
It can be operated at a high temperature Like a belt The installation or initial cost is more.
which cants not operate at high temperatures. The velocity fluctuation is more.
Chain drive can be used up to 3 m in distances
between small and large
Gear Drive
SPUR GEAR
HELICAL GEAR
RACK AND PINION GEAR
BEVEL GEAR
WORM AND WORM WHEEL
SPIRAL GEAR
Advantages and Disadvantages for Gear Drive
Advantages Disadvantages
Positive drive and has more efficiency than belt If the tooth geometry of the gear is not properly
drive. maintained, the drive may get locked.
The operation of the drive is simple and effective. Not preferred when very high-speed transmission is
Life is more compared to other drives. required.
With one input speed, no. of output speeds can be If the lubrication arrangement is not provided,
obtained by. it may produce noise.
Safe and compact.
Constant velocity ration is obtained.
Using different types of gears, power can
be transmitted between shafts whose axes
are parallel, inclined, or intersecting to each other.
Difference between Belt Drive, Chain Drive and Gear Drive
Sr. No. Particulars Belt drive Chain drive Gear drive
1. Main element Pulleys, belt Sprockets, chain Gears
No slip No slip
2. Slip Slip may occurs
(Positive drive) (Positive drive)
3. Suitability For large centre distance For moderate center distance For short center distance
Failure of belt does not cause Failure of chain may not Failure of gear may cause serious
6. Failure
the further damage of machine. seriously damage the machine. break down in the machine
10. Use For low velocity ratio For moderate velocity ratio For high velocity ratio
Thank you