Lecture 2 Comparison Between Various Transmission and Distribution Systems
Lecture 2 Comparison Between Various Transmission and Distribution Systems
DISTRIBUTION SYSTEMS
Dr. Muhammad Akmal
VARIOUS TRANSMISSION & DISTRIBUTION
SYSTEMS IN ELECTRICAL POWER SYSTEM
a) DC Systems:
I. DC two-wire system.
II. DC two-wire system with midpoint earthed.
III. DC three- wire system.
c) Two-Phase AC Systems:
DC Systems
DC Systems
DC Systems
This system is usually formed the basis for comparison with other
systems. Thus the volume of conductor material required in this
system shall be taken as the basic quantity.
COMPARISON OF COST OF CONDUCTORS
FOR OVERHEAD SYSTEMS
DC Systems
DC Systems
DC Systems
DC Systems
COMPARISON OF COST OF CONDUCTORS
FOR OVERHEAD SYSTEMS
DC Systems
DC Three-Wire System
This system consists of two outer wires and a neutral wire which is
grounded at the generator end. The load is connected either
between any outer and neutral wire or between the two outers. If
the load is balanced, no current flows through the neutral wire but
practically the neutral wire carries some amount of current so the
diameter of the neutral wire is selected one-half of the diameter of
the outer wires. Since we have two different voltage levels, power
loads as well as lightening loads can be connected to this system.
This system is shown in Figure 5.3.
COMPARISON OF COST OF CONDUCTORS
FOR OVERHEAD SYSTEMS
DC Systems
DC Three-Wire System
DC Three-Wire System
COMPARISON OF COST OF CONDUCTORS
FOR OVERHEAD SYSTEMS
DC Systems
DC Three-Wire System
COMPARISON OF COST OF CONDUCTORS
FOR OVERHEAD SYSTEMS
This is a two wire system. One wire is called live wire while
the second wire which is earthed is called neutral wire. In this
case supply is taken from the secondary side of the distribution
transformer. This system is shown in Figure 5.4.
COMPARISON OF COST OF CONDUCTORS
FOR OVERHEAD SYSTEMS
COMPARISON OF COST OF CONDUCTORS
FOR OVERHEAD SYSTEMS
Single Phase Three-Wire AC System
Single Phase AC Systems
3-Phase AC Systems
3-Phase AC Systems
COMPARISON OF COST OF CONDUCTORS
FOR OVERHEAD SYSTEMS
3-Phase AC Systems
COMPARISON OF COST OF CONDUCTORS
FOR OVERHEAD SYSTEMS
3-Phase 3-Wire AC System
3-Phase AC Systems
COMPARISON OF COST OF CONDUCTORS
FOR OVERHEAD SYSTEMS
3-Phase AC Systems
In this system, the neutral wire is taken from the star point of the
star-connection and is of half the cross-section of the line
conductors. If VP is the voltage of each winding, then the line
voltage √3VP. Single-phase residential lighting loads or single
phase motors are connected between the neutral and any one of the
live wires. These loads are connected symmetrically so that live
wires are loaded equally. Hence, the resultant current in the neutral
wire is zero or at least minimum. Three-phase induction motors
requiring higher voltages are put across the lines directly. This
system is shown in Figure 5.8.
COMPARISON OF COST OF CONDUCTORS
FOR OVERHEAD SYSTEMS
DC Two-Wire System
COMPARISON OF COST OF CONDUCTORS
FOR UNDERGROUND SYSTEMS
COMPARISON OF COST OF CONDUCTORS
FOR UNDERGROUND SYSTEMS
COMPARISON OF COST OF CONDUCTORS
FOR OVERHEAD SYSTEMS
DC Two-Wire System with Mid Point Earthed
COMPARISON OF COST OF CONDUCTORS
FOR UNDERGROUND SYSTEMS
DC Three-Wire System
Assuming balanced load, the current through the neutral or mid wire is
zero.
Maximum voltage between outers = Vm volts
COMPARISON OF COST OF CONDUCTORS
FOR UNDERGROUND SYSTEMS
DC Three-Wire System
DC Three-Wire System
COMPARISON OF COST OF CONDUCTORS
FOR UNDERGROUND SYSTEMS
DC Three-Wire System
COMPARISON OF COST OF CONDUCTORS
FOR UNDERGROUND SYSTEMS
Single-Phase AC Systems
Figure 5.13 AC Single-Phase Two- Wire System With Mid Point Earthed.
COMPARISON OF COST OF CONDUCTORS
FOR UNDERGROUND SYSTEMS
2. Skin Effect
In AC systems, more current tends to flow through the outer
periphery of the conductor due to unequal distribution of flux
which increases the effective resistance of the line. This
phenomenon is called Skin Effect. Skin Effect is only found in
AC systems and is absent in DC systems.
COMPARISON BETWEEN AC AND DC
SUPPLY SYSTEMS
3. Charging Current
No charging or discharging currents are found in DC systems.
But in AC systems, even if we don’t load the line, it draws some
charging current due to inherent capacitance of line.
4. Voltage Regulation
DC has better voltage regulation than AC because of absence of
XL and XC. Inductance and capacitance of line increases the
voltage regulation in case of AC.
COMPARISON BETWEEN AC AND DC
SUPPLY SYSTEMS
8. Insulation Requirements
In case of DC system, insulation requirements are less as
compared with AC systems.
CHOICE OF WORKING VOLTAGE FOR
TRANSMISSION
Before discussing the method of determination of the most
economical working voltage for transmission we will discuss
here the, advantages and limitations of high voltage transmission.
The advantages of adopting high voltage for transmission are
given below:
CHOICE OF WORKING VOLTAGE FOR
TRANSMISSION
The curve plotted is of the form shown in Figure 5.17. From the
curve it is observed that the optimum voltage from economy
point of view will be voltage corresponding to point A on the
curve. In fact higher voltage would be chosen as large working
voltage, power loss and voltage drop are reduced, load can be
increased if required and control becomes easier.
In practice it is not possible to determine the economic voltage
by the method explained above. To avoid the complications and
labour, an empirical formula for determining the optimum
voltage for lines more than 30 km long is given as,
CHOICE OF WORKING VOLTAGE FOR
TRANSMISSION
Solution:
Let the lighting load to be supplied be P watts at voltage V volts
(between line and neutral in case of 3-phase, 4-wire system) and
line losses be W watts in both of the cases:
Example 5.2: An existing single phase AC system comprising
of two overhead conductors is to be converted into a 3-phase,
3-wire system by providing an additional conductor or same
size. Calculate the percentage or additional load that can be
transmitted by the three-phase system if the operating line
voltage and percentage line losses remain the same in both
the systems.
Solution: Let the operating line voltage and power factor in both
the systems be V volts and respectively. If I1 is single phase
current, I2 is the three-phase current and R is the resistance of
each conductor, then in single phase ac system
Example 5.3: An existing DC three-wire system is to be
converted to a 3-phase 4-wire ac system by the addition of
another conductor equal in x-section to each outer of the dc
system. Assuming the percentage copper loss and voltage at
the consumer’s terminals are to remain same in both
systems, find the additional percentage load that can be
supplied in two cases. Assume balanced load in both cases
and unity power factor in case of AC system.
Solution: Let the supply and load voltages to neutral be VS and
VL volts respectively and resistance of each conductor be R
ohms.
Example 5.4: A 3-wire dc system is converted to a 4-wire 3-
phase AC system by the addition of another wire equal in
section to one of the outers. For the same effective voltages
between outers and neutral at the consumer’s terminals and
the same percentage loss, find the percentage of additional
load that can be supplied. Assume balanced load and the ac
system a power factor of 0.9.
Solution: Let the voltage between outer and neutral be V volts in
both of the cases and currents in 3- wire DC system and 3-phase,
4-wire system I1 and I2 respectively.