Pigeonhole Principle

Dr Aamir Hashmi
Email: [email protected]
Office Hours:
-My office:
Tuesday: 14:00 – 15:30
Cabin-3, F-102, B-Building
Wednesday: 1230 – 1400
Thursday: 14:00 – 15:30
Friday: 15:00 – 17:00
or by appointment (email)
Announcements
• Assignment-1 due on Wednesday (Nov 18)
• Help videos are there on YouTube
• Instructions for Assignment Submission:
Submit hand-written assignments only (you will get ZERO for types assignment)
All pages/Questions are in order (10 marks will be deducted if not in order)
No Late submission. STRICTLY
Submission in Class ONLY – NO SUBMISSION in OFFICE
(if you do not have class on Wednesday, submit on Thursday)
If your Assignment is found copied (even some parts of it), you will get ZERO marks
--------------
There will be Quiz -3 in next class (on Combination, Permutation, PIE)
Recap
Principle of Inclusion-Exclusion (PIE)
Pigeonhole Principle
PHP
Let us try to solve the simpler ones?
You have one minute to answer

Two or more people in UCP have the

same birthday
Let us try to solve the simpler ones?
You have one minute to answer

A Pair of Socks
Assume you have 10 orange socks and 10 blue socks
and you want to find a matching pair of socks from a
random pick. You will only need to pick three socks.
Let us try to solve the simpler ones?
You have one minute to answer

A Suit of Cards
Pick 5 cards from a standard deck of 52 cards, and at least two
cards will be of the same suit.
Let us try to solve the simpler ones?
You have one minute to answer
Hair: Two or more people in Lahore have
the same number of hair on their heads
At any given time in Lahore City there live at least two
people who have the same amount of hairs on their head
Let us try to solve the simpler ones?
You have one minute to answer

Hair: Two or more people in Lahore have

the same number of hair on their heads
At any given time in Lahore there live at least two people
who have the same amount of hairs on their head

A human has a maximum of about 500,000 hairs. In

comparison, there are millions of people in a metropolitan,
which outnumbers the number of hairs a human normally has.
By pigeonhole principle, at least two of them must have the
same number of hairs
Pigeonhole Principle---
(Section 2.4 of textbook)
LET US FORMULATE THE PROBLEM NOW
If there were no two people with the same number of strands of hair,
then,
• there would be at most one person having 0 strands,
Pigeonhole Principle---
(Section 2.4 of textbook)
LET US FORMULATE THE PROBLEM NOW
If there were no two people with the same number of strands of hair,
then,
• there would be at most one person having 0 strands,
• at most one person having exactly 1 strand,
Pigeonhole Principle---
(Section 2.4 of textbook)
LET US FORMULATE THE PROBLEM NOW
If there were no two people with the same number of strands of hair,
then,
• there would be at most one person having 0 strands,
• at most one person having exactly 1 strand,
• and so on.
Pigeonhole Principle---
(Section 2.4 of textbook)
LET US FORMULATE THE PROBLEM NOW
If there were no two people with the same number of strands of hair,
then,
• there would be at most one person having 0 strands,
• at most one person having exactly 1 strand,
• and so on.
• Finally, there would be at most one person having exactly 500,000
strands.
Pigeonhole Principle---
(Section 2.4 of textbook)
LET US FORMULATE THE PROBLEM NOW
If there were no two people with the same number of strands of hair,
then,
• there would be at most one person having 0 strands,
• at most one person having exactly 1 strand,
• and so on.
• Finally, there would be at most one person having exactly 500,000
strands.
But then this means that there are no more than 500,001 inhabitants of
Lahore.
Pigeonhole Principle---
(Section 2.4 of textbook)
Imagine 500,001 enormous boxes (or pigeon holes)
Pigeonhole Principle---
(Section 2.4 of textbook)
Imagine 500,001 enormous boxes (or pigeon holes)
• The first one is labeled “Lahoris having 0 strands of hair,”
Pigeonhole Principle---
(Section 2.4 of textbook)
Imagine 500,001 enormous boxes (or pigeon holes)
The first one is labeled “Lahoris having 0 strands of hair,”

the next is labeled “Lahoris having 1 strand of hair,”

• and so on.
Pigeonhole Principle---
(Section 2.4 of textbook)
Imagine 500,001 enormous boxes (or pigeon holes)
The first one is labeled “Lahoris having 0 strands of hair,”

the next is labeled “Lahoris having 1 strand of hair,”

• and so on.

The last box is labeled “Lahoris having 500,000 strands of hair”

Pigeonhole Principle---
(Section 2.4 of textbook)
Imagine 500,001 enormous boxes (or pigeon holes)
The first one is labeled “Lahoris having 0 strands of hair,”

the next is labeled “Lahoris having 1 strand of hair,”

• and so on.

The last box is labeled “Lahoris having 500,000 strands of hair”

If everybody goes to the proper box, then about 10 million Lahoris are
properly assigned to some box (or hole).
Since we have only 500,001 boxes, there certainly will be a box containing more
than one Lahori.
Pigeonhole Principle---
(Section 2.4 of textbook)
•If  we have boxes and we place more than objects into them,
then there will be at least one box that contains more than
one object.

• Such proofs in mathematics are called pure existence proofs.

Pigeonhole Principle---
Pigeonhole Principle---
Pigeonhole Principle---
Pigeonhole Principle---

Figure out what are the pigeons and what are

the pigeon-holes !!!
Examples: PHP --- Do it by yourself
EXAMPLE 1
Among any group of 367 people, there must be at least two with the same
birthday, because there are only 366 possible birthdays.
Examples: PHP --- Do it by yourself
EXAMPLE 2
In any group of 27 English words, there must be at least two that begin with
the same letter, because there are 26 letters in the English alphabet.
Examples: PHP --- Do it by yourself
EXAMPLE 3
How many students must be in a class to guarantee that at least two students
receive the same score on the final exam, if the exam is graded on a scale
from 0 to 100 points?
Solution:
Examples: PHP --- Do it by yourself
EXAMPLE 3
How many students must be in a class to guarantee that at least two students
receive the same score on the final exam, if the exam is graded on a scale from 0
to 100 points?
Solution:
There are 101 possible scores on the final. The pigeon-hole principle shows that
among any 102 students there must be at least 2 students with the same score.

How many students to guarantee that at least 3 should receive the same score?

0 - 1 – 2 – 3 – 4 …. – 100 – 0 – 1 – 2 – 3 – 4 … – 100 – x
Examples: PHP --- Do it by yourself
• EXAMPLE 4
• How many students must be in a class to guarantee that at least 5 students
receive the same score on the final exam, if the exam is graded on a scale
from 0 to 100 points?

4*101 + 1 = 405
Examples: PHP --- Do it by yourself
• 
EXAMPLE 5
How many people should be there to guarantee that 9 people are born in
same month?

12*8 + 1 = 97

============================================================
Among 100 people there are at least who were born in the same month.
Examples: PHP --- Do it by yourself
• 
EXAMPLE 6
What is the minimum number of students required in a discrete mathematics
class to be sure that at least six will receive the same grade, if there are five
possible grades A, B, C, D, and F?

5 grades * 5 people/grade +1 = 26 people

Examples: PHP --- Do it by yourself
EXAMPLE 7
a) How many cards must be selected from a standard deck of 52 cards to
guarantee that at least three cards of the same suit are chosen?
b) How many must be selected to guarantee that at least three hearts are
selected?
Examples: PHP --- Do it by yourself
• 
EXAMPLE 7
a) How many cards must be selected from a standard deck of 52 cards to
guarantee that at least three cards of the same suit are chosen?

b) How many must be selected to guarantee that at least three hearts are
selected?
Examples: PHP --- Do it by yourself
• 
EXAMPLE 7
a) How many cards must be selected from a standard deck of 52 cards to
guarantee that at least three cards of the same suit are chosen?

b) How many must be selected to guarantee that at least three hearts are
selected?
We come across problems like these?
(We shall find the solution at the end of the lecture)
If you pick 5 integers from 1 to 8, you will definitely find two of
them must add up to 9.

There are n people in a party and n is more than 1 so they can

shake hands with one another at will.
You will always find two people who shake hands with the same
number of people.

Choose 51 numbers from integers between 1 and 100 inclusively.

Then there must be two consecutive numbers of among the
chosen integers.
We come across problems like these?
(We shall find the solution at the end of the lecture)
• There are 13 squares of side 1 unit positioned inside a circle of radius 2.
Show that at least 2 of the squares have a common point.
We come across problems like these?
(We shall find the solution at the end of the lecture)
• There are 13 squares of side 1 positioned inside a circle of radius 2. Show
that at least 2 of the squares have a common point.
We come across problems like these?
(We shall find the solution at the end of the lecture)
• There are 13 squares of side 1 positioned inside a circle of radius 2. Show
that at least 2 of the squares have a common point.
Examples: PHP --- Do it by yourself
Example From the textbook (Section 2.4 – Pages
35-36)
Examples: PHP --- Do it by yourself
Example From the textbook (Section 2.4 – Pages
35-36)
Examples: PHP --- Do it by yourself

From the textbook (Section 2.4 – Pages

Example 35-36)

Pythagorous
  theorem:
YouTube Videos: (to help you in lecture slides and book–reading)
• Click here: YouTube Playlist
• Stay Safe and Healthy

Xie Xie!!!

Note:
Assignment-1 Deadline: Wednesday – in class
Quiz: 1st class of next week (Combinations, Permutations, PIE)
MORE PRACTICE
PROBLEMS
Do it by yourself
Try to solve this one?
• 
EXAMPLE 8
What is the least number of area codes needed to guarantee that the 25
million phones in a state can be assigned distinct 10-digit telephone
numbers?
(Assume that telephone numbers are of the form NXX-NXX-XXXX, where the
first three digits form the area code, N represents a digit from 2 to 9 inclusive,
and X represents any digit.)

NXX-XXXX
Examples: PHP --- Do it by yourself
Examples: PHP --- Do it by yourself
Examples: PHP --- Do it by yourself
 Try it at your own:
Pigeonhole Principle
 Try it at your own:
Pigeonhole Principle
 Try it at your own:
Pigeonhole Principle
 Try it at your own:
Pigeonhole Principle
 Try it at your own:
Pigeonhole Principle
If you pick 5 integers from 1 to 8, you will definitely find two
of them must add up to 9.

1,8
2,7
3,6
4,5
 Try it at your own:
Pigeonhole Principle
If you pick 5 integers from 1 to 8, you will definitely find two
of them must add up to 9.

No matter which integer you choose, you can always pair it with another integer from 1 to 8 to sum to 9.
Thus, there are four such pairs overall:

We are going to stuff five pigeons (chosen integers) into four pigeonholes (pairs).

By the pigeonhole principle, the average value =

,
so the maximum value is at least 2.
Two of the integers must be from the same pair, which sums to 9.
 Try it at your own:
Pigeonhole Principle

We are given a 9x3 rectangle divided into 27 squares as shown

below.
If we paint all of the smaller squares either blue or red, we will always
find a rectangle whose four corners are of the same color no matter
how we paint these squares.
We are given a 9x3 rectangle divided into 27 squares as shown
below.
If we paint all of the smaller squares either blue or red, we will
always find a rectangle whose four corners are of the same color
no matter how we paint these squares.
 Try it at your own:
Pigeonhole Principle

Shaking Hands
There are n people in a party and n is more than 1 so they
can shake hands with one another at will.
You will always find two people who shake hands with the
same number of people.
 Try it at your own:
Pigeonhole Principle

Do I Know You?
• In a room with n people in it, there must be at least two
people who know the same number of people.