0% found this document useful (0 votes)
43 views20 pages

Topic 3-1

Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1/ 20

TOPIC 3

MARKET FAILURE
MARKET FAILURE

• A situation in which the price system fails to


operate efficiently, creating a problem for
society.
• Four examples of market failure:
– lack of competition
– externalities
– public goods
– income inequality.
MARKET FAILURE:
LACK OF COMPETITION
• Firms without competitors tend to restrict supply
through collusion, which raises prices to maximise
their profits.
• leads to non-optimal allocation
• Examples:
– Visy and Amcor price fixing
– Price fixing by Queensland’s fire protection
industry.
MARKET FAILURE:
LACK OF COMPETITION
EXTERNALITIES

• An externality is a cost or benefit imposed on


third parties (people other than the buyers
and sellers of the good).
• Externalities can be:
– negative (harmful spillovers)
– positive (beneficial spillovers).
NEGATIVE EXTERNALITIES
• Those that are detrimental to third parties:
– a neighbour’s consumption of loud music may
reduce your ability to study
– noise pollution caused by aircraft
– smoke from a factory.

• Approaches to solving these ‘failures’ include:


– taxes (e.g. pollution taxes)
– regulations (to limit pollution).
NEGATIVE EXTERNALITIES
NEGATIVE EXTERNALITIES
TAXING TRAFFIC
• What external costs may be caused by traffic
congestion?
• How would a congestion charge address congestion?
• How would drivers who pay the fees benefit from this
program?
• What criticisms could be made of congestion
charges?
• Can you think of any other remedies for congestion
besides a congestion charge?
A SUGAR TAX?
A SUGAR TAX?
A SUGAR TAX?
• Food taxes intended to shift consumption towards
a healthier diet are controversial. Some people
think that individuals should make their own
choices, and if they prefer unhealthy products, the
government should not interfere.
• In view of the fact that those who become ill will
be cared for at some public expense, others argue
that the government has a role in keeping people
healthy.
• Use this opportunity to apply an economists
thinking to the issue.
POSITIVE EXTERNALITIES
• Externalities that are beneficial to third parties:
– government expenditure in schooling benefits the
whole of society, not just students
– vaccinations provide a direct benefit to the patient
and a spillover benefit to other people (less chance
of contracting the disease.
POSITIVE EXTERNALITIES

• Approaches to preventing market failure in


immunisation:
– provide subsidies for attending school and being
vaccinated against disease
– by passing laws requiring all parents to immunise
their children.
POSITIVE EXTERNALITIES
PUBLIC GOODS

• A good or service that the government, rather


than the market, must provide if it is to be
made available in sufficient quantity.
• It has two special properties once produced:
1. users collectively consume benefits
2. there is no way to prevent people who do not pay
(free riders) from consuming the good or service.
PUBLIC GOODS

• Public goods are paid for using tax revenues.


Why?
• If public goods are made available only in the
marketplace, people wait for someone else to
pay and the result is an under-production or
zero production of public goods: free-rider
problem.
PUBLIC GOODS

• Examples of public goods:


– the judicial system
– street lighting
– maritime navigation markers
– quarantine service.
PUBLIC GOODS
• Networks TV signals are non-rival in
consumption, that is, providing the signal
to one household with a television does
not prevent other households with
televisions from watching the associated
programs.
• How have network TV stations managed
to overcome this problem?
INCOME INEQUALITY
• Even if the market operates efficiently, an
unequal distribution of income can still
result.
• Some disagreement on whether it is a
market failure.
• But there is widespread support for a
policy of reducing income inequality.

You might also like