Transfer of Property
Transfer of Property
15
Transfer of Property
(Property)
Transfer for benefit of unborn person (s. 13)
General principle
Transfer directly to unborn person
Transfer for the benefit of unborn person
o Creation of prior life-interest
o Only absolute interest (no life interest) can be given
Girjesh Dutt v Data Din AIR 1934 Oudh 35.
Validity of transfer to be assessed by the language of the deed, and not
by actual events
Subsequent conduct of limited owner irrelevant
JV Satyanarayana v Pyboyina Manikyan AIR 1983 AP 139.
Read with s 20 of the TPA
Hindu Law and Muslim Law
Indian Law and English Law
The Indian Succession Act 1925 — s. 113
Slide-1 30/01/2018
Lecture-
15
Transfer of Property
(Principles
Rule againstof Transfer of Property)
Perpetuity (s. 14)
Transfer in perpetuity — meaning
Minority
Object of rule against perpetuity
Maximum permissible remoteness of vesting
Essentials of rule against perpetuity u/s 14
• There is a transfer of property.
• The transfer is for the ultimate benefit of an unborn person who is given
absolute interest.
• The vesting of interest in favour of ultimate beneficiary is preceded by life or
limited interests of living person(s).
• The ultimate beneficiary must come into existence before the death of the
last preceding living person.
• Vesting of interest in favour of the ultimate beneficiary may be postponed
only upto the life or lives of living person(s) plus minority of ultimate
beneficiary, but not beyond that.
Slide-2 30/01/2018
Lecture-
15
Transfer of Property
Validity of transfer to be assessed
(Principles by theof
of Transfer language of the deed, and not
Property)
by actual events
Subsequent conduct of limited owner irrelevant
Contingent interest
Read with s 20 of the TPA
Ram Newaz v Nankoo AIR 1926 All 283.
Exceptions to the rule against perpetuity
o Transfer for the benefit of public (religious, charitable endowments, wakfs,
etc)
o Personal agreements
o Right of pre-emption (Ram Baran Prasad v Ram Mohit Hazra AIR 1967 SC
744)
o Charge
o Lease
S. 114 of the Indian Succession Act 1925
Hindu law and Muslim law, and English law
Slide-2 30/01/2018