Viscoelastic Surfactant (Ves) Fracturing Fluid - Clearfrac - HP
Viscoelastic Surfactant (Ves) Fracturing Fluid - Clearfrac - HP
Viscoelastic Surfactant (Ves) Fracturing Fluid - Clearfrac - HP
Kevin W. England
Engineering Manager
Schlumberger
* mark of Schlumberger
Fracturing Fluids - History
2 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
ClearFRAC* Fluids - Simple Chemistry
Viscoelastic
Surfactant
(MW:450)
3 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
Evolution of ClearFRAC*
• 1997 - Schlumberger introduced and pumped the first VES-
based fracturing fluid.
– Schlumberger has been pumping VES-based gravel pack fluids
worldwide for several years (PermPAC).
• Since then several revisions and new versions have been
released:
– Improvements in chemistry
– Systems tailored for specific market conditions
– Improved understanding from evaluation of many field applications
4 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
Example of Standard ClearFRAC*
• ClearFRAC-MT
Systems
– Excellent range of application - low viscosity
• ClearFRAC-HP
– High viscosity formulation and environmentally friendly
• ClearFRAC-HT
– Allows for applications up to 300 °F
• ClearFRAC-LTC
– Special version developed for Canadian shallow gas market
100 125 150 175 200 225 250 275 300 Temperature (°F)
ClearFRAC*-MT with KCl
ClearFRAC*-MT with Organic Salt J463
ClearFRAC*-HP with KCl
ClearFRAC*-HT
ClearFRAC*-LTC with NH4NO3
5 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
Mechanism of ClearFRAC*
Making of ClearFRAC*-HP
• Blend surfactant in brine
Brine
Worm-like Micelle
Viscoelastic
Surfactant
6 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
ClearFRAC*-HP - Viscosity
Development
Worm-like Micelle
Entanglement of Micelles
7 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
ClearFRAC*-HP - Closer Look
8 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
Viscosity - Shear Rate Dependence
3
10
• No permanent viscosity
o
75 F
degradation due to shear
2
10
• Viscosity is only temperature
100oF dependent - no thermal
Viscosity (Pa.s)
1
10
120oF degradation with time.
• The fluid exhibits elastic
0 140oF
10 properties because of the
160oF
entanglement of the rod- shaped
10
-1 micelles.
175oF
• The high low shear viscosity is
10
-2 responsible for proppant
10
-4
10
-3
10
-2
10
-1
10
0
10
1
10
2
10
3
transport and high fluid
Shear Rate (s -1) efficiency.
Note: Pa*sec = 1,000 cp
9 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
ClearFRAC*-HP - Break Mechanism
Worm-like Micelle
Breaking
• On contact with
hydrocarbons
Oil or Gas
• On dilution with
produced formation water
Spherical Micelles
10 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
Why ClearFRAC*-HP?
Polymer Recovery
50
45
Polymer Recovered (%)
40
35
30
25 45 lb/1,000 gal
20
15
Guar Fluid
10
5
0
0 25 50 75 100
Low
Time (hours) Concentration
Clean-up and Effective Fracture-
Guar Fluids
length
30-40%
30-45%
Cleanup
Clean-up
~55-70% Polymer ClearFRAC*-HP
11 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
Importance of Fracture Clean-up
"LOW"
Damage
0.6
"HIGH"
Damage 0.4
"HIGH"
0.2 Damage
0
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
Fractional Loss of Pack Porosity (%)
dsp 10/95 02
12 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
Effective Fracture Half-length (Xfeff) and
Fracture Conductivity (kfw)
Polymer Fluids ClearFRAC*-HP
100
80
% Retained
60
40
20
0
Guar Low Guar ClearFRAC*-HP
13 KWE Fracturing Fluid System
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
What is the “real” fracture length?
Propped Length
Effective Length
Hydraulic Length
14 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
Stimulation Requirements Depend on
Formation Characteristics
High Permeability Low Permeability
Formations Formations
14 100%
Folds of Increase (J/Jo)
90%
12 80%
70%
10 60%
50% Xf
8 40% re
30%
6 20%
10%
4
2
2 3 4 5 6
10 10 10 10 10
k f w 40
Relative Conductivity,
k A
15 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
ClearFRAC*-HP - Solution for Western
Venezuela
• ClearFRAC*-HP has viscosity needed to fracture stimulate
high permeability formations.
– Limitation of first-generation VES fluid systems.
– Leakoff coefficient is viscosity controlled.
• ClearFRAC*-HP has viscosity needed to fracture stimulate
larger gross intervals (> 50 meters)
• ClearFRAC*-HP has improved compatibility (less emulsions)
with difficult crude oils.
• ClearFRAC*-HP has flowback enhancement additives
designed to accelerate the clean-up process.
16 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
ClearFRAC*-HP Fluid Rheology
350
1% ClearFRAC*-HP
300 2% ClearFRAC*-HP
3% ClearFRAC*-HP
250
Viscosity @ 100 sec-1 (cP)
4% ClearFRAC*-HP
200
17 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
Matrix Breaker System - QuikCLEAN-M
QuikCLEAN-M is added in the pad-stage to enhance formation
clean up. Fluid viscosity is reduced only at low shear rates (< 40
sec-1) and is intact at higher shear rates.
2% ClearFRAC*-HP, 130 F
FracTECH Core Tests 1,000 2% ClearFRAC*-HP
0.5% QuikCLEAN-M, 130 F
P 2% 2% 3% 2% ClearFRAC*-HP
ClearFRAC*-HP ClearFRAC*-HP 0.75% QuikCLEAN-M, 130 F
(psi/in)ClearFRAC*-HP 0.2%
Log[Viscosity(cP)]
(140 F) QuikCLEAN-M (170 F)
20 0 0 0
30 N/A 36 53
40 0 43 58
60 14 68 61
80 73 82 66
100
120 87 94 87
0.1 1 10 100 1000
Log[shear rate(sec-1)]
18 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
Proppant-pack Breaker - QuikCLEAN-F
Encapsulated breaker contains a powerful surfactant, upon release, will
decrease fluid viscosity significantly. It reduces resistance to flow and
accelerates clean-up in proppant-pack.
18 2% ClearFRAC*-HP
150F, 5 ppt QuikCLEAN-F 100,000
16 Control
2% ClearFRAC*-HP, 150 F
14 10,000 5 ppt QuikCLEAN-F
Viscosity (cP)
Resistance to flow
12
1,000
10
8 100
6
4 10
2
1
0
0.1 1 10 100 1,000
0 10 20 30 40
Time (min)
Shear Rate (sec )
-1
19 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
Non-emulsifying Agent for ClearFRAC*-
HP
A recently developed formulation has been identified as an effective
Non-emulsifying Agent (NEA-2) for ClearFRAC*-HP fluids. The
mixture should be delivered in the pre-pad stage, where crude oil meets
ClearFRAC fluid first.
• Test #1: 10ml 2% ClearFRAC*-HP, 10ml crude (Bakersfield, USA) #1 #3
• Test #2: 10ml 2% ClearFRAC*-HP, 10ml crude, 1 mL Standard NEA
• Test #3: 10ml 2% ClearFRAC*-HP, 10ml crude, 1.07 mL NEA-2
• Test #4: 10ml 2% ClearFRAC*-HP, 10ml crude, 1.20mL NEA-2
• Test #5: 10ml 2% ClearFRAC*-HP, 10ml crude, 1.33 mL NEA-2
Test# 1 2 3 4 5
Time needed for
complete emulsion > 1 day 30min. 10min. < 5min. 1 min.
breakage
20 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
ClearFRAC*-HP Benefit - Friction
Pressure Reduction
16,000
2.375"XX0.190"
1.75" 0.190"
88bpm;
bpm;44PPA
PPA
Surface Pressure (psi)
12,000
8,000
4,000
ClearFRAC* Fluid
20 ppt Guar
0
Depth/Length (ft)
21 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
ClearFRAC*-HP - Design
Considerations
• Candidate selection process is critical to successful application.
• General data collection.
– Well configuration: Tubing/ Casing/ Wellhead/Perforations/etc.
– Reservoir information.
• Select the fluid and proppant.
– ClearFRAC system selection based on rheology at surface and
BHT.
– ClearFRAC* compatibility with reservoir fluid.
• Perform economic calculations (treatment justification).
• Perform DataFRAC (calibration treatment).
• Finalize the design.
22 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
ClearFRAC*-HP - FracCADE
Considerations
• ClearFRAC* can be considered a power law fluid under
the shear rate conditions in the tubing and the fracture.
• Viscosity is constant @ temperature.
– Leakoff mechanism:
• Not a wall-building fluid (Ccv - leakoff viscosity).
• Function of pore fluid saturation.
– Non-damaging (fluid retained factor = 1)
– Proppant transport with low viscosity fluid.
• ClearFRAC* transports proppant very efficiently.
23 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
ClearFRAC*-HP - Additional
Considerations
• Near-wellbore effect:
– Minimize the Near-wellbore effect by perforation design (phasing,
entrance diameter, oriented perforations, etc. ), Using higher viscosity
in the Pad and sand slug (erosion).
• Fracturing multiple zones (laminated formations):
– To stimulate the entire zone. Rate and viscosity consideration.
• BHP (Foamed, energized or straight fluid)
• Gross height of stimulated interval:
– Higher fluid viscosity and pump rate are needed.
• Permeability
– FLA is possibly needed for higher permeability ( k > 50 mD)
24 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
ClearFRAC*-HP - Flowback
Considerations
• Flowback should be conducted in the same way other
fracturing fluids are returned.
CONSIDERATIONS
• The advantage of flowing back immediately reduces the
amount of fluid invasion in the matrix.
– standard practice of flowback is to begin immediately after treatment at
low rates, obtain closure and increase rate slowly.
– Use of breakers lower the low shear viscosity of fluid and thus lower
the amount of proppant flowback.
– A small choke at surface can cause foam generation on the surface.
25 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
Cost Comparison with ClearFRAC*-
MT
ClearFRAC*-HP is isolated from natural products without complex
synthetic processes. The average cost saving over first generation fluids,
like ClearFRAC*-MT, is approximately 45%.
60
50
Cost Saving (%)
40
30
20
10
0
80 110 130 150 170 180
Well Temperature (F)
26 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
ClearFRAC* - Case Histories
• > 5,000 ClearFRAC* treatments performed worldwide
• BHST: 75°–255°F
• Oil and Gas Wells
• Formation permeability of 0.001 to 1,000 mD
• Job Size up to 300,000 lbs proppant/zone
• Maximum downhole proppant concentration - 16 ppa
• Pump Rates: 6–60 bbl/min
• Pipe sizes from 1 3/4” Coiled Tubing to 7” casing
• Majority of treatments have been foamed with N2
• Friction pressure 10 to 65% less than polymer-based
fluids.
27 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
Case History - Gulf of Mexico, USA
• BHT - 140 oF
• BHP - 2,150 psi
• Permeability - 50 mD
• Net Height- 36 ft
• Well Type - Gas
• Young’s Modulus - 8x105 psi
• ClearFRAC*-MT in Sea Water
• FloSAVER Fluid Loss additive
• Fluid volume - 16,000 gal
• Proppant volume - 80,000 lbs
29 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
Case History - Oklahoma, USA
• ClearFRAC*-HP Evaluation
– 61 treatments have been pumped.
– Pump rates from 15-60 bpm.
– ClearFRAC*-HP concentrations from 1-2%.
– Well depth from 2,000-6,000 ft.
– BHST from 90-160 °F.
– Total proppant pumped from 12,000-357,000 lb/stage.
– N2 foam quality from 65-70%
– Initial post-treatment evaluation shows average of 400% increase in
fracture conductivity and 50% increased fracture half-length for
ClearFRAC*-HP wells.
30 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
ClearFRAC* Summary
• First polymer-free water-based fracturing fluid
• 100% retained permeability of proppant pack
• Environmental friendly
• Simple and reliable system
100
80
31 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
ClearFRAC*-HP Summary
• Performance
– Extensive field tests conducted. Better productions than polymer
wells have been observed.
• Fluid viscosity
– Higher fluid viscosity favors wider hydraulic fracture width.
• Breaker
– Enhanced flowback additives are available.
• Emulsion
– NEA-2 is available for crudes that form emulsions with
ClearFRAC*-HP
• Cost
– ~45% cost reduction compared to standard VES fluid systems.
32 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger
Conclusion
Conventional Crosslinked Polymer-based Fluids Systems:
– High polymer concentration restricts flow, meaning less
effective fracture half-length.
Low Polymer Fluid Systems:
– Less polymer means lower damage, and better effective
fracture half-length and fracture conductivity.
ClearFRAC* Fluid Systems (NO Polymer Systems):
– NO polymer means NO residue to damage the fracture,
maximum effective fracture half-length and conductivity, and
hence, maximum production.
33 KWE
10/26/20
* mark of Schlumberger