Behavioural Finance Theories: Unit Ii
Behavioural Finance Theories: Unit Ii
FINANCE THEORIES
UNIT II
Boom and Bust Cycle
• The boom and bust cycle is the alternating phases of economic
growth and decline. It's another way to describe the business cycle or
economic cycle.
1. Boom Expansion
3. Bust Contraction
3. Bust
• The bust phase is the contraction stage of the business cycle. It is brutish, nasty, and
mercifully short. On average, it lasts 11 months.
• The economy contracts, the unemployment rate is 7% or higher, and the value of
investments falls.
• If it lasts more than three months, it's a recession.
• It can be triggered by a stock market crash, followed by a bear market.
• A stock market crash can cause a recession.
• As stock prices fall, everyone loses confidence in the state of the economy.
• When investors don’t feel confident about the future outlook, they pull out their
investments.
• They cut back business activities such as purchasing, hiring, and investing
Prospect Theory
• Prospect theory assumes that losses and gains are valued differently, and thus
individuals make decisions based on perceived gains instead of perceived
losses.
• Also known as the "loss-aversion" theory, the general concept is that if two
choices are put before an individual, both equal, with one presented in terms of
potential gains and the other in terms of possible losses, the former option will
be chosen.
• Not selling a stock that you hold when your current rational analysis of
the stock clearly indicates that it should be abandoned as an investment
• Selling a stock that has gone up slightly in price just to realize a gain of
any amount, when your analysis indicates that the stock should be held
longer for a much larger profit
• Telling oneself that an investment is not a loss until it’s realized (i.e.,
when the investment is sold)
BEHAVIOURAL BIASES THEORIES
Heuristics:-
• Heuristics are a subfield of cognitive psychology and behavioral science.
• They are shortcuts to simplify the assessment of probabilities in a decision
making process.
• Initially they dealt with cognitive biases in decision making, and then
encompassed emotional factors.
• The primary concern of the research was to understand and reduce the
deviations from rational choice models.
• However, the research found that those biases were often systematic, or not
random, and therefore they could be predicted.
• Tversky and Kahneman proposed three heuristics
1. Availability
2. Representativeness
3. Anchoring and adjustment.
Overconfidence Bias
• Overconfidence bias is a tendency to hold a false and
misleading assessment of our skills, intellect, or talent.
Illusion of Control:-
• The illusion of control bias occurs when people think they have control over a
situation when in fact they do not.
• People believe they have more control than they really do.
• This can be very dangerous in business or investing, as it leads us to think
situations are less risky than they actually are. Failure to accurately assess
risk leads to failure to adequately manage risk.
Timing Optimization:-
• Timing optimism is another aspect of overconfidence psychology.
• An example of this is where people overestimate how quickly they can do work
and underestimate how long it takes them to get things done.
• Especially for complicated tasks, business people constantly underestimate how
long a project will take to complete. Likewise, investors frequently underestimate
how long it may take for an investment to pay off.
Desirability Effect:-
• The desirability effect is when people overestimate the odds of something
happening simply because the outcome is desirable.
• This is sometimes referred to as “wishful thinking”, and is a type of overconfidence
bias. We make the mistake of believing that an outcome is more probable just
because that’s the outcome we want.
Representativeness Heuristic Bias
• The type of beliefs: Beliefs that are more personal lead to more
significant dissonance.
• The value of the beliefs: Beliefs that people hold in high regard tend
to cause greater dissonance.
• Smoking despite being aware of the adverse health effects of tobacco use.
• Choosing to promote a behavior, such as regular exercise, that a person does not
themselves practice. This type of cognitive dissonance is called hypocrisy.
• Telling a lie despite the person thinking of themselves as honest.
• Purchasing a new car that is not fuel efficient, despite being environmentally
conscious.
• Eating meat while also thinking of themselves as an animal lover who dislikes the
thought of killing animals. Some researchers call this the meat paradox.
Availability Bias
• The availability bias is the human tendency to think that examples of things that come
readily to mind are more representative than is actually the case.
• This bias helps to explain why we tend to take credit for our
successes while often denying any responsibility for failures.
• For example, a tennis player who wins his match might say, "I
won because I'm a good athlete," whereas the loser might say,
"I lost because the referee was unfair.“
• The self-serving bias has been thought of as a means of self-
esteem maintenance.
• Athletes win a game and attribute their win to hard work and practice. When they
lose the following week, they blame the loss on bad calls by the referees.
For example, let’s say you decide to purchase a lottery ticket. Which
option makes you feel better about your chances to win:
1.A ticket where you get to choose the numbers?
2.A ticket with randomly generated numbers?
So how can this bias impact investors?
1. Illusion of control bias can lead investors to trade more than is prudent. Researchers have found that
traders, especially online traders, believe themselves to possess more control over the outcomes of
their investments than they actually do. An excess of trading results, in the end, in decreased returns.
2. Illusions of control can lead investors to maintain underdiversified portfolios. Researchers have found
that investors hold concentrated positions because they gravitate toward companies over whose fate
they feel some amount of control. That control proves illusory, however, and the lack of
diversification hurts the investors’ portfolios.
3. Illusion of control bias can cause investors to use limit orders and other such techniques in order to
experience a false sense of control over their investments. In fact, the use of these mechanisms can
often lead to an overlooked opportunity or, worse, a detrimental, unnecessary purchase based on the
occurrence of an arbitrary price.
4. Illusion of control bias contributes, in general, to investor overconfidence. In particular, investors who
have been successful in business or other professional pursuits believe that they should also be
successful in the investment realm. What they find is that they may have had the ability to shape
outcomes in their vocation, but investments are a different matter altogether.
Endowment Bias
• The endowment effect describes how people tend to value items that
they own more highly than they would if they did not belong to them.
• This means that sellers often try to charge more for an item than it
would cost elsewhere.
Example: Let’s say a few months ago, you bought a concert ticket for
$100. You just found out that you won’t be able to make it to the concert
after all, so you decide to resell your ticket. You price the ticket at $150,
because just selling it at market value would feel like you were losing
out.
Individual Effects
• The endowment effect can impact us both as buyers and as sellers.
• This bias is easily exploited by marketers and salespeople: any tactic
that makes us feel a sense of psychological ownership over a product
can encourage us to spend more on it.
• As sellers, the endowment effect can lead us to price things
unreasonably, based on a misguided sense that if we don’t, we’ll lose
out.
Systematic Effect
• The endowment effect can cause us to overspend when we’re buying
things, leading to extra costs that add up over time.
• This bias can lead to opportunity costs i.e., gains that we miss out on
—if it causes us to overprice our old stuff to the point where we don’t
sell it.
Optimism Bias
• The optimism bias refers to our tendency to overestimate our
likelihood of experiencing positive events and underestimate our
likelihood of experiencing negative events.
Why it happens
• The optimism bias instills feelings of control.
• We generally want to feel as if we have control over our lives and our
fates. Negative events like illness, divorce, or financial loss often
threaten our plans or derail the predictions we have about ourselves.
• Optimism prevents us from lingering in these negative outcomes.
[Optimism Bias.docx]
How to avoid it
• Nobel Prize-winning economist Daniel Kahneman has widely researched the
optimism bias and proposes two different ways of mitigating its influence on our
decision making: taking an outside view and a post mortem approach
1. “Identify an appropriate reference class” – Look for a general category to put your
task in. This could be grocery shopping, home remodeling, or a professional project.
2. “Obtain statistics for this reference class” – Look for statistics on how long it takes
to complete the type of task on average. These are your “base rates”
3. “Use specific information about the case to adjust the baseline prediction” – If there
are certain concrete things that you think are worth changing your predictions for,
use your judgment to make prediction adjustments.
Confirmation Bias
• It is the tendency to process information by looking for, or
interpreting, information that is consistent with one’s existing
beliefs.
• This biased approach to decision making is largely unintentional
and often results in ignoring inconsistent information.
• Existing beliefs can include one’s expectations in a given
situation and predictions about a particular outcome.
• People are especially likely to process information to support
their own beliefs when the issue is highly important or self-
relevant.
Importance
• Confirmation bias is important because it may lead people to
hold strongly to false beliefs or to give more weight to
information that supports their beliefs than is warranted by the
evidence.
• People may be overconfident in their beliefs because they have
accumulated evidence to support them, when in reality much
evidence refuting their beliefs was overlooked or ignored,
evidence which, if considered, would lead to less confidence in
one’s beliefs.
• These factors may lead to risky decision making and lead people
to overlook warning signs and other important information.
Examples
• A person with low self-esteem is highly sensitive to being ignored by other
people, and they constantly monitor for signs that people might not like
them. Thus, if you are worried that someone is annoyed with you, you are
biased toward all the negative information about how that person acts
toward you. You interpret neutral behavior as indicative of something
negative.
• Loss aversion, an aspect of prospect theory, asserts that losses loom larger than gains
Example: Investors are prone to keep losing stocks, hoping they will rebound, and are more likely
to sell gaining stocks, afraid of a potential downturn
• Cognitive errors, which cause a person’s decisions to deviate from rationality, fall into two
subcategories
• Belief preservation errors refer to the tendency to cling to one’s initial belief even after
receiving new information that contradicts it
Emotional errors arise as a result of attitudes or feelings that cause one to deviate from
rationality
External Factors defining investors behaviour
• Risk Tolerance: Risk refers to the volatility of portfolio’s value. The amount of risk the investor
is willing to take on is an extremely important factor.
• Return Needs: This refers to whether the investor needs to emphasize growth or income.
• Investment Horizon: The time horizon starts when the investment portfolio is implemented
and ends when the investor will need to take the money out.
• Tax Exposure: Investors in higher tax brackets prefer such investments where the return is tax
exempt, others will have no such preference.
• Market Trends: You need to understand how various asset classes have performed in the past
before planning your finances.
• Investment Needs: How much money do you need at the time of maturity?
• Risk Coverage: A type of insurance coverage that can exclude only risks that have been
specifically outlined in the contract.
• Dependents: People who relies on another person, especially a family member, for financial
support.
How Greed affects asset prices and returns ?
Jeff Bezos, the CEO of Amazon once asked Warren Buffet, “Your investment thesis is so simple. Why
doesn’t everyone just copy you?” Buffet responded to Bezos by saying, “Because no one wants to get
rich slow”.
What Warren Buffet said to Jeff Bezos is the essence of Greed in investment behaviour.
• Investors want to make profits quickly and bull markets provide a great opportunity to make profits
in a short period of time.
• When price keeps rising, more and more people invest more and more money in stocks.
• Stock prices follow the law of demand and supply.
• With higher demand (more money), prices keep rising further and profits grow.
• Growing profits fuel more greed and more money get invested raising prices to excessive levels.
• At very high prices, asset bubbles are created i.e. prices are much more than intrinsic or
fundamental value of assets.
• Like all bubbles, asset bubbles eventually burst and prices crash. Investors who had bought stocks at
very high prices face big losses when market corrects.
How Fear affects asset prices and returns ?
• When asset prices get overheated it eventually corrects. Bear markets (falling markets)
can be triggered by a number of factors but the most common factor is slowing or sluggish
economy.
• It has generally been seen that a stock price fall faster than it rises.
• 2 – 3 years of gains in stock price can be wiped out in just 2 – 3 months during bear
markets.
• A number of reasons can be ascribed to severe crashes seen in bear markets e.g. high
leverage through derivatives near bull market peaks, margin calls getting triggered etc,
but the fundamental reason is Fear.
• When prices fall sharply, investors fear that it will fall more and sell in panic.
• Stock prices follow the law of demand and supply.
• In a bear market, supply of stocks is high since most investors want to sell in panic.
• Panic selling causes stock prices to fall sharply.
• Ultimately, prices fall to such low levels that stock valuations become attractive (cheap)
and the markets eventually bottoms out.
Emotional Finance
• Emotional finance is a new paradigm in the understanding of investment activity and prediction of
asset prices and market behaviour.
• It differs both from traditional finance theory which is based on the idea investors are “rational”,
and behavioural finance which although recognising that investors are prone to bias nevertheless
implicitly assumes they can still learn to be rational.
• Emotional finance recognises that people are inherently irrational and largely driven by their
emotions, both those of which they are consciously aware and, more importantly, those which are
unconscious.
• These latter are even more powerful because they are not directly accessible to the conscious mind.
• Emotional finance draws explicitly on the insights of the psychoanalytic understanding of the
human mind to describe how unconscious processes drive investment decisions and market
dynamics, and are an integral part of all financial decision making
Types of Investors
Active Investors:-
• This kind of investor doesn't try to go for the biggest possible gains at all
times.
• Instead, the passive investor accepts reasonable gains in exchange for a
lower stress level and more free time.
• This person may invest in mutual funds so the funds' money managers
can make buy and sell decisions.
• She may buy individual stock in established companies and hold that
investment for a year or more.
• Passive investors tend to remove stress from investment decisions by
setting parameters for adding more stock to their portfolios.
• For example, when their stocks rise 20 pecent, they may sell some to
take profits.
Speculators:-
“The flip side of a bubble is when an asset is undersold, often in overreaction to bad news,
and investors run the risk of missing an opportunity when the asset price bounces back.”
THANK YOU !!