Business Law Final
Business Law Final
Business Law Final
• Discharge of contract
• Contract of indemnity & guarantee
• Contingent contract
• Wagering contract
• Alteration & rescission of contract
Discharge of
Contract.
Discharge of Contract.
•“Discharge of Contract means Termination of
Contractual relationship between parties.
•A contract is discharged when the rights and
obligations created by it come to an end.
• Examples:
Motor insurance
Marine insurance
Fire insurance
The promisee in a contract of indemnity, acting within the scope of his authority, is
entitled to recover from the promisor.
(1) all damages which he may be compelled to pay in any suit in respect of any
matter to which the promise to indemnify applies.
(2) all costs which he may be compelled to pay in any such suit, if in bringing of
defending it, he did not contravene the orders of the promisor, and acted as it would
have been prudent for him to act in the absence of any contract of indemnity, or if
the promisor authorized him to bring or defend the suit.
(3) all sums which he may have paid under the terms of any compromise of any such
suit, if the compromise was not contract to the orders of the promisor, and was one
which it would have been prudent for the promise to make in the absence of any
contract of indemnity, or if the promisor authorized him to compromise the suit.
RIGHTS OF INDEMNIFIER:
SURETY: The person who gives the guarantee is called the “surety”. Person giving guarantee is
also called as ‘guarantor’. ;
PRINCIPAL DEBTOR: the person in respect of whose default the guarantee is given is called
the “principal debtor”, and
CREDITOR: the person to whom the guarantee is given is called the “creditor”.
• Three parties are involved in contract of guarantee. Contract between any two of them is not
a ‘contract of guarantee’. It may be contract of indemnity.
• Primary liability is of the principal debtor. Liability of surety is secondary and arises when
Principal Debtor fails to fulfill his commitments. However, this is so when surety gives
guarantee at the request of principal debtor. If the surety gives guarantee on his own, then it
will be contract of indemnity. In such case, surety has all primary liabilities.
Consideration for Guarantee(Sec.127)
• Any thing done
• Any promise made
for the benefit of the Principal Debtor is the sufficient
consideration to the surety for giving the guarantee.
Example:
B requests A to sell and deliver to him goods on credit. A agrees to do so,
provided C will guarantee the payment of the price of the goods. C promises
to guarantee the payment in consideration of A's promise to deliver the
goods. This is a sufficient consideration for C's promise
Essentials of Contract of Guarantee
Tripartite Agreement:
A contract of guarantee entails three parties, principal debtor, creditor and
surety. In a successful contract of guarantee, there must be three
separate contracts between the three parties and each and every contract
must be consenting.
Liability:
Here the main liability lies with the principal debtor. Secondary liability lies
with the surety which can only be invoked once the principal debtor
defaults on its payment.
Essentials of Contract of Guarantee
Medium of Contract:
The Contract Act, 1872, does not strictly mention the need for any written form of
contract of guarantee. Both oral and written form will suffice.
• Distinguish between Contract of Indemnity and Contract of Guarantee.
1. No. of parties There are two parties to the contract viz. There are three parties to the viz.
indemnifier (promisor) and the creditor, principal debtor and the
Indemnified (promise). surety
2. Liability of parties Liability of the indemnifier to the Liability of the surety to the creditor is
indemnified is primary and independent. collateral or secondary, the primary
liability being that of the principal
debtor.
3. No. of contracts There is only one contract in case of a In a contract of guarantee there are
contract of indemnity, i.e., between the three contracts, between principal
indemnifier and the indemnified. Debtor and Creditor; between creditor
and the surety and between surety
and principal debtor.
4. Liability is due The liability of the indemnifier arises only There is usually an existing debt or
on the happening of a contingency. duty, the performance of which is
guaranteed by the surety.
Kinds of Guarantee
• Specific Guarantee
A guarantee to a single debt or transaction is called specific guarantee.
•Example:
Example:
Can buy food to the extent of 10k Mr Sannan On the Surety by Mr Shoaib
Mr Yasir
A.Risk to Security:
In this, the creditor will take Mortgage, in
terms of recovering if the debtor fails to pay.
Example:
Surety
Takes a loan with his car on
Mr. mortgage Mr by Mr
Fahad Adnan Farhan
Mr. Mr
Fahad Fails to pay the loan
Adnan
Mr Will pay instead of Mr
Farhan Fahad to Adnan
Mr
Farhan Will also take Fahad’s car Mr Adnan
Rights to Surety
2. Rights against Principle Debtor:
B. Right of Subrogation
The terms subrogation may be defined as the substitution of one person with
another with same right and liabilities.
When several co-sureties have given guarantee for the same debt with their
maximum limits, they are liable to pay equally but subject to the limits they have
fixed.
DISCHARGE OF SURETY(Sec.131-141)
1.Revocation by notice.
2. Revocation by death
Any variation in the terms of the contract between the principal debtor and the
creditor without surety’s consent.
If the creditor releases the principal debtor, the surety also automatically
discharges.
5. Discharge of surety when creditor compounds with, gives time to, or agrees
not to sue, principal debtor.
When the creditor makes an arrangement for composition or promises to give time or not
sue the principal debtor without surety’s consent, the surety will be discharged.
DISCHARGE OF SURETY
Any act or omission to do an act by the creditor which results in harming the
rights of the surety, and also impairs the eventual remedy of the surety himself
against the principal debtor, discharges the surety.
B contracts to build a ship for C for a given sum, to be paid by installments as the work
reaches certain stages. A becomes surety to C for B's due performance of the contract. C,
without the knowledge of A, prepays to B the last two installments. A is discharged by this
prepayment.
Where the creditor loses or parts with any security which he receives from the
principal debtor without the consent of the surety, this discharges the surety to
the extent of the value of such security.
Contingent Contract
Meaning
• When the performance of a contract is not
immediately due but it becomes after the
happening or non-happening of some
contingency (i.e., some uncertain event) it is
known as Contingent Contract. The contract of
insurance, is an example of contingent
contract. In simple words, it is a conditional
contract
Definition
• According to Section 31:
“A "contingent contract" is a contract to do or
not to do something, if some event, collateral
to such contract, does or does not happen.’’
• Example:
A contracts to pay to B Rs. 10,000 if B's house
is burnt. This is a contingent contract.
Essentials
1. Depends on happening or non-happening of
a certain event:
The contract is contingent on the happening or
the non-happening of a certain event.
• Example: A promises to pay B Rs 5,000 if the
Train reaches to its station on time. This is a
contingent event.
2. The event is collateral to the contract:
It is important that the event is not a part of
the contract. It cannot be the performance
promised or a consideration for a promise.
• Example: A enters into a contract with B and
promises to deliver 5 television sets to him if
Brazil wins the FIFA World Cup provided B
pays him Rs 25,000 before the World Cup
kicks-off. This is a contingent contract since
A’`s obligation arises only when Brazil wins the
Cup which is a collateral event.
3. The event should not be a mere will of the
promisor:
• The event cannot be a wish of the promisor.
• Example: A promises to pay B Rs 5,000 if
Argentina wins the FIFA World Cup provided
he wants to. This is NOT a contingent contract.
Actually, this is not a contract at all.
4. The event should be uncertain:
• If the event is sure to happen, then the contract
is due to be performed. This is not a contingent
contract. The event should be uncertain.
• Example: A promises to pay B Rs 500 if it rains
in his city in the month of July. This is not a
contingent contract because in July rains are
almost a certainty in his city.
Rules Regarding Contingent contracts:
Introduction:
Contract alteration occurs after a contract has been signed but one party seeks to
modify the terms or key points of the contract with or without the consent of the
other party. The effect of contract alteration is that, legally, a new contract has been
created because it no longer reflects the intention of the parties at the time the
original contract was signed.
It is not illegal to alter a contract once it has been signed. However, it must be
materially changed, meaning that if an important part of the contract is altered by
the change, it must be made by mutual consent of both parties. If only one party
modifies the contract without the agreement of the other, then it is unlikely the
changes will be enforceable.
Relevant Provision:
• When an essential part of a writing has been cut, torn, burned, or erased, t
he alteration is also known as a mutilation.
• The alteration of a document by someone other than a party to it is called
a spoliation.
Definition:
• Any changes in the description of the goods or services that are involved
in the transaction are deemed material. For instance, if the property
described in a mortgage or deed is made larger or smaller, or if the days of
a week when services are to be performed changes, then it is a material
modification.
Essentials:
• If a contract includes language that describes the process for modifying
the terms or conditions, and those procedures are followed, contract law
decisions have determined that those changes are valid. Thus, the parties
will proceed to act under the modified terms of the altered contract. In
effect, it’s a new contract.
• However, if the modification has been performed with the consent of both
parties, it does not hold the non-consenting party liable for the changes. Even
if the non-consenting party changes the document back to reflect the original
intention by deleting the unauthorized modifications, the contract is still
considered invalid. A new contract must be created.
Rescission of Contract:
Introduction:
The undoing or termination of a contract that may have been entered into as a
result of misrepresentation, fraud, or undue influence.
Essentials:
Contract rescission requires that all parties give back any benefits they have
received while the contract was in force, and be returned to their original states,
as though the contract had never been formed in the first place. While some
jurisdictions use the words rescission and cancellation interchangeably, others use
the term rescission to refer to making something void, or for reversing a contract
or a judicial decision. For example, a higher court can rescind a judgment based
on errors made by the court during a criminal trial.
Typically, contract rescission can only be effected through equitable or legal
means. When effected through equitable means, a judicial decree voids the
contract and returns the parties immediately to the state in which they were
before they entered into the contract. The court does not award either party
damages.
In this case, rescission prevents either party from taking any future action
regarding the contract. As a legal remedy, the rescinding party provides the
other party with notice of rescission or cancellation, and returns any monies or
other benefits received from the contract.
• 3-Day Right of Rescission:
Rescission can only take place if the contract was fully formed to begin with,
which means that, if one party lacked understanding or intent, there was no
legal contract formed, so a rescission is not necessary or possible. Rescission is a
complete undoing of the contract, meaning all provisions are cancelled. There is
no thing as a “partial rescission.” Contracts are cancelled for a variety of reasons.
Common grounds for rescission include:
Mutual Consent:
If both parties agree to have the contract rescinded, they should indicate their
intent and consent through a separate written document. In the event only one
party wants the contract to be rescinded, he must give proper written notice
stating on what statutory grounds the rescission is requested, and it may be
necessary to have a court of law determine whether a cancellation may be
made.
Problems in the Contract Formulation:
Every contract must be made under legal conditions, and through legal means.
Consent to enter into a contractual agreement cannot be obtained through force or
intimidation, and all parties must clearly understand what they are getting into.
Problems in formation of a contract may include such issues as:
Mistake:
A contract may be rescinded if a party entered into the agreement due to reliance
upon, or belief in, a mistaken fact, or a mistake of law. Rescission based on mistake of
fact may be allowed if the effect of the mistake causes such a change in the contract’s
intent, or makes enforcement of the contract unconscionable.
Rescission on a mistake of law may be granted when a party is aware of the true facts
of the contract, but is mistaken as to the legal ramifications of those facts. A mistake of
law exists only when (1) all parties believe they know the law as it pertains to the
contract, but are mistaken, or (2) one party misunderstands the law at the time he
entered into the contract, and the other party fails to remedy the other party’s
misunderstanding.
Fraud:
Certain types of fraud support a recession and the fraud can be “actual” or
“constructive.” Actual fraudexists when one party misrepresents something with
the intent to deceive the other party. Constructive fraud occurs when one party
engages in misleading conduct without intending to defraud the other party. When
fraud of either type occurs, the innocent party may rescind the contract, as he
entered into the contract based on facts that were not true.
Rescission can take place if one of the parties to the contract lacks the capacity to
legally enter into a contract. For example, a party does not have the capacity to
enter into a contract if he is under 18, intoxicated, mentally incompetent,
or incapacitated due to illness.
Anticipatory Repudiation or Failure of Consideration:
When it becomes clear that one party will not be performing his part of the
bargain, whether intentionally or not, the contract may be rescinded for
“anticipatory repudiation.” In addition, if the contract consideration, which is
the thing of value given in return for goods or services, fails to become
available, is inadequate, or is illegal, the contract may be rescinded.
• Process for Rescinding a Contract:
It must first be determined whether the contract can be rescinded. This can be
done by reviewing the contract and the clauses within it to see if it contains
instructions for rescission. If the contract does not contain such a clause, the
person seeking the recession should contact an attorney or check the statutes in
their state.
If the contract cannot be rescinded according to state or federal law, the person
may attempt to negotiate a rescission with the other party. Any contract may be
rescinded by mutual agreement, even if the contract itself does not allow it.
The rescinding party must determine whether there are legal grounds for
rescission, such as mistake, fraud, or duress. Finally, written notice of rescission
must be given to the other party, after which the parties may negotiate a mutual
rescission, or either party may file a civil lawsuit.
• When Rescission is Not Available:
There are situations where rescission is not available as a remedy, and as an equitable
remedy, the decision is at the discretion of the court. A judge may deny rescission
based on certain facts, including:
1. One party has substantially fulfilled their part of the contract
2. A third party has already received some benefit from the contract
3. The requesting party has committed some wrong relating to the contract
(referred to as “unclean hands”)
4. The requesting party has unnecessarily delayed the request for rescission,
resulting in some prejudice to the other party
5. The requesting party has already asked for money damages. A contract
rescission cannot be obtained after requesting a monetary award.
• Related Legal Terms and Issues:
o Anticipatory Repudiation – A declaration by a party to a contract, whether
verbal or through actions, that he does not intend to uphold his obligations
under the contract. Also known as “anticipatory breach.”
o Civil Lawsuit – A lawsuit brought about in court when one person claims to
have suffered a loss due to the actions of another person.