Public Goods, Externalities, and Information Asymmetries
Public Goods, Externalities, and Information Asymmetries
Public Goods, Externalities, and Information Asymmetries
Externalities, and
Information
Asymmetries
Public Goods
• Private goods
– Rivalry and excludability
• Public goods
– Nonrivalry
– Nonexcludability
– Free-rider problem
– No market demand
Optimal Quantity of a
Public Good
• Supplied by the government
• Government estimates demand
• Compare marginal benefit to
marginal cost
• Demand for a public good
– Sum individual willingness to pay
– Sum vertically
Demand for Public Goods
Example: two individuals
(1) (2) (3) (4)
Quantity Adams’ Benson’s Collective
Of Public Willingness Willingness Willingness
Good To Pay (Price) To Pay (Price) To Pay (Price)
1 P4 + P5 = P9
2 3 + 4 = 7
3 2 + 3 = 5
4 1 + 2 = 3
5 0 + 1 = 1
Graphically…
Demand for Public Goods
Collective Demand S Optimal
Quantity
P7 for 2 Items P9
P
7 Collective
P3 for 4 Items Willingness
5
DC To Pay
Connect the Dots 3
1
Q
P4 for 2 Items P
P6
5
4 D2
P2 for 4 Items 3
2
1
Benson
0
Adams’ Demand 1 2 4 Q
5
P3 for 2 Items P
P6 5
P1 for 4 Items D1
4
3
2
1
Adams
0 Q
Cost-Benefit Analysis
• Provide a public good?
• How much should be provided?
• Resources are limited
• Marginal-cost-marginal-benefit rule
• Allocate government resources to
maximize net benefit
Externalities
• Market failure
– Requires government action
• Negative externality
– External cost
– Overproduction
• Positive externality
– External benefit
– Underproduction
Externalities
P P
Negative
Externalities
St St
Positive
S Externalities
Dt
D D
Overallocation Underallocation
0 Qo Qe Q 0 Qe Qo Q
Negative Positive
Externalities Externalities
Coase Theorem
• Externalities corrected by
individual bargaining
– Property ownership defined
– Small number people
– Bargaining costs negligible
• Limitations
• Liability rules and lawsuits
Government Intervention
• Correct negative externality
– Direct controls
– Specific taxes
• Correct positive externality
– Subsidize buyers or producers
– Government provision
Market Based Approach
• Tragedy of the commons
– Resource lacks defined ownership
– Air, lakes, etc.
– No incentive to maintain
• Market for externality rights
– Right to pollute
– Can be bought and sold
Market for Pollution Rights
• Advantages
• Real-world examples
P
D2018 S=Supply of
Price Per Pollution Right
Pollution
D2008 Rights
P200
P100
Socially
Optimal Amount
Of Pollution
Abatement
MB
0 Q1
Climate Change
• Earth has warmed over the last
century
• Human activity contributing factor
• Carbon dioxide and greenhouse
effect
• Kyoto Protocol 1997
• Climate change policies
Information Failures
• Asymmetric information
• Inadequate buyer information
– Gasoline market
– Licensing of surgeons
• Inadequate seller information
– Moral hazard problem
– Adverse selection problem
– Workplace safety
• Qualification
Lojack: A Case of Positive
Externalities
• Crime reduction expenditures
– Some redistribute vs. reduce crime
• Lojack car recoveries 95% vs. 60%
• External benefits
– Catch thieves
– Locate and stop chop shops
• MSB 15 times the MC
– Underallocation