APQP Overview
APQP Overview
Process Training
Advanced Product Quality Planning
March 15, 2017
1
APQP
Overview
Process Training
2
Supplier APQP: APQP Overview APQP Process Training
Goal: Utilize a standard approach for advanced product quality planning that will
support the development of a product or service to satisfy the customer and fulfill
the AIAG APQP Standard.
PHASE 1 SUPPLIER SOURCING (GSM Procedure 7.2.2)
Not included in the APQP process
PHASE 2 PLAN & DEFINE (8 ELEMENTS)
[APQP2-1] Supplier kick-off meeting
[APQP2-2] Submit initial Supplier Characteristics Summary (SCS]
[APQP2-3] Complete and submit PFMEA
[APQP2-4] Develop capability study plan to include rational sampling
[APQP2-5] Submit gage plan (including concepts, designs, methods, fixturing and clamping,
etc..)
[APQP2-6] Define packaging specifications
[APQP2-7] Verification of supplier equipment, tool and gage purchase orders
[APQP2-8] Submit supplier plan for APQP management of sub-tier suppliers
3
Supplier APQP: APQP Process Training
APQP Overview
4
Supplier APQP: APQP Process Training
APQP Overview
5
Supplier APQP: APQP Process Training
APQP Overview
6
APQP
Elements Table
Process Training
7
APQP Elements Table - 11 categories APQP Process Training
Goal: The list of elements is the required subject matter to be adjusted in accordance to the risk
assessment
8
APQP Elements selection APQP Process Training
Goal: The list of elements is the required subject matter to be adjusted in accordance to the risk assessment
ELEMENTS DESCRIPTION
▪ The Supplier APQP process addresses risk assessment in order to adjust resources and
activities accordingly.
▪ In total 8 different categories are defined :
PPAP Renewal – PPAP level based on program need
Bulk Materials – PPAP level 2
Catalog – Functional – PPAP level 2
Catalog - Non-Functional – PPAP level 4
Non Black Box Service Parts – PPAP level 2
OEM Directed Parts – PPAP level as agreed with OEM customer
Capacity Change w/ Additional Equipment/Tooling – PPAP level based on program need
Capacity Change w/o Additional Equipment/Tooling – PPAP level based on program need
▪ In addition, three categories are related to PPAP Level 3 with different level of risk from Low to
Medium to High
▪ In each category, a pre-selected list of elements are mandatory. In each category, a pre-
selected list of activities with AQE and SQE are mandatory to be performed. In any case, for
some special situation, the region may request more than requested at corporate level.
9
APQP
Risk Assessment
Process Training
10
APQP Risk Assessment APQP Process Training
Risk Assessment Guidelines
Goal: Use a common ranking of level of risk associated with each element being assessed
A risk is the combination of the probability of occurrence of a positive event (opportunity) or a negative
event (threat) and its impact on the objectives of the project. Based on our approach, the risk is seen as a
threat.
Risk Level 0 (Low): Negligible or non-existent
Risk Level 1 (Medium): Minor, project can continue but action plan recommended
Risk Level 2 (Medium): Major, project obstacles possible and action plan necessary
Risk Level 3 (High): Critical, project obstacles certain and Escalation necessary
11
APQP Risk Assessment APQP Process Training
Goal: Identify the level of potential risk in the APQP process to deliver a Perfect Launch.
Definitions
• Risk - A risk is an uncertain event or a set of events which, if they occur, will have an effect
on the achievement of objectives.
• Internal Risk – Risks associated with the Customer, Program, Specifications, Technology,
Complexity/Interface, Reliability/Safety
• External Risk – Risks associated with specific supplier selected
• APQP risk assessment = Consolidation of Internal Risk (2) AND External Risk (3) assessment
Process Steps:
1. Evaluate Internal Risk
Can be performed once the product drawings/specifications are available
Team: PLPL, Buyer, AQE Supervisor, PE (input from PQ & Sales is welcomed)
2. Evaluate External Risk
Performed after MAPP
Team: PLPL, Buyer, AQE (input from PE, PQ & Sales is welcomed)
3. Determine APQP Risk level
HIGH risk for internal OR HIGH risk external => part is at HIGH risk
LOW risk for internal AND LOW risk for external => part is at LOW risk
Others cases => part is at MEDIUM risk
12
APQP Risk Assessment APQP Process Training
Internal Risk Assessment
Goal: Identify the level of potential risk associated with Customer, Program, and Part specific
elements impact on the APQP process to deliver a Perfect Launch
Inputs
1. Drawings & Specifications
2. Customer requirements & feedback
3. Program timing
4. Part & application requirements / complexity
5. Internal APQP risk assessment form (FXXXX)
Process
1. Gain feedback from cross functional team
Team: PLPL, Buyer, AQE Supervisor, PE (input from PQ & Sales is
welcomed)
2. Evaluate each elements Risk
3. Calculate the internal risk assessment rating based on the
following:
Only one Risk at Level 3 => part is at HIGH risk
Any assessment with Risk at Level 0 OR at Level 1 => part is at
LOW risk
Others cases => part is at MEDIUM risk
Outcome: Internal Risk rating documented and results used for APQP
Risk Assessment
13
APQP Risk Assessment APQP Process Training
External Risk Assessment
Goal: Identify the level of potential risk associated with the selected supplier’s elements
impact on the APQP process to deliver a Perfect Launch
Inputs
MAPP
MCA
Past launch performance with selected supplier
External APQP risk assessment form (FXXXX)
Process
1. Gain feedback from cross functional team
Team: PLPL, Buyer, AQE (input from PE, PQ & Sales is welcomed)
2. Evaluate each elements Risk
3. Calculate the External risk assessment rating is based on the
following:
Only one Risk at Level 3 => part is at HIGH risk
Any assessment with Risk at Level 0 OR at Level 1 => part is at
LOW risk
Others cases => part is at MEDIUM risk
14
APQP Risk Assessment APQP Process Training
Final Risk Assessment
Goal: Calculate the APQP risk level based on the Internal & External Risk assessments
Inputs
• Completed Internal Risk Assessment
• Completed External Risk Assessment
Process
1. Worksheet auto calculates the APQP Risk level
15
SOURCING
Phase 1
Process Training
16
APQP Element AQE 1-1: APQP Process Training
Manufacturing Capability Assessment (MCA)
Goal: Confirm a supplier is able to manufacture product according Nexteer's quality requirements
Inputs:
• Nexteer Supplier Requirements (NSR)
17
APQP Element AQE 1-1: APQP Process Training
Manufacturing Capability Assessment (MCA)
Process Steps:
18
APQP Element AQE 1-2: APQP Process Training
Manufacturability Assessment & Process Plan (MAPP- F1039)
(MUST use latest version from Nexteer website)
19
APQP Element AQE 1-2: APQP Process Training
Manufacturability Assessment & Process Plan (MAPP)
Process Steps:
20
APQP APQP Process Training
Sourcing Phase
Goal: Award business to the optimal supplier based on Quality, Price, Capabilities, and
commodity strategy.
Inputs:
MAPP
MCA
RFQ
F1054 Sourcing form
Process Steps:
1. Sourcing Process
21
APQP
Phase 2
Process Training
22
APQP Element AQE 2-1 APQP Process Training
Supplier Kick-Off Mtg
Goal: Ensure all Quality/Cost/Delivery Nexteer requirements are communicated, understood,
& taken into account by supplier to guarantee a perfect launch
Inputs:
• MCA & MAPP
• Nomination Letter
• Nexteer Supplier Requirements (NSR)
• Nexteer Drawing
Process Steps:
1. Determine the PPAP Level (1-5), and explain what is expected for
each item
2. Review the Nomination Letter, validating the terms on which the
business was awarded on.
3. Review both Nexteer’s and Supplier’s Lessons Learned from similar
products and launches
4. Agree Upon Part Feature Terminology to improve communication
5. Develop initial Early Production Containment Agreement (EPC)
6. Document the items review using the Supplier Kick off Checklist
(Form XXXX)
7. Summarize the Kickoff Meeting for all attendees
Outcome: Nexteer and Supplier begin the APQP process fully aligned on
all of the expectations and requirements.
23
APQP Element AQE 2-1 APQP Process Training
Supplier Kick-Off Mtg – PPAP Checklist
Goal: All PPAP requirements are understood by the supplier, ensuring a successful submission.
Inputs:
• PPAP checklist & Instruction
• Signed MAPP
24
APQP Element AQE 2-1 APQP Process Training
Supplier kick-off Mtg – PPAP Checklist
Process Steps:
2. Others requirements must be defined such as CQI-9, Customer Requirement, Material, ... if
applicable
5. Supplier acknowledges receipt of PPAP checklist and submits copy of checklist with documented
progress during gate review.
8. MAPP open issues list in APQP open issue tracker and follow up during APQP
25
APQP Element AQE 2-1 APQP Process Training
Supplier Kick-Off Mtg – Nomination Letter Confirmation
Goal: Ensure all deliverables meet the program launch timing, quality and deliveries
Inputs:
Nomination Letter
Quoted Capacity from the Nomination Letter
Production Capacity Plan (Sec 1 of Run @ Rate form; appendix 15)
Run @ Rate Plan (Sec 2 of Run @ Rate form; appendix 15)
Key Date Information (Sec 6 of MAPP)
Supplier APQP Timeline (Sec 9 of MAPP)
Nexteer Program Timeline (CPI from PLL)
Supplier Investment Plan: List of (Equipment, Tooling & Gages) for critical items to meet capacity
requirements and the timeline to purchase them
Process Steps:
1. AQE confirms with supplier that Run@Rate is based on #shift, #hours and numbers of weeks per year.
Nexteer requirement is 240 days/year, 48 weeks/year, unless specified in the nomination letter.
2. AQE verifies Capacity by matching ALL of the information from the Inputs for Location, Timing, and
Capacity.
3. Any discrepancies will be noted, and addressed on the Supplier APQP Open Items List (Sec 8 of MAPP)
26
APQP Element AQE 2-1 APQP Process Training
Supplier Kick-Off Mtg – Lessons Learned Transfer
Process Steps:
1. AQE calls meeting to include PE/QE/Supplier to review previous issues, concerns or challenges from
similar product; use Input list.
2. All lessons learned must be identified/addressed in Design, PFMEA, and Control Plan.
3. Capture PTC's (Pass-Thru Characteristics), customer impacts, and spills
4. Any findings will be noted, and addressed on the Supplier APQP Open Items List (Sec 8 of MAPP)
27
APQP Element AQE 2-1 APQP Process Training
Supplier Kick-Off Mtg – Agree Upon Part Feature Terminology
Goal: Create and share common part feature terminology to prevent confusion
Inputs:
• Drawings & Specs from PE
Process Steps:
1. AGREE UPON PART FEATURE TERMINOLOGY between PE/AQE and Supplier to ensure common language
regarding part features across team members/functions
Component model view or drawing labeled with EXAMPLE
R&P Housing
Part #: 00000000
common terminology (names) for key features Torque
Sensor Bowl
Pinion Bore
Customer
Lift Hook
Boot Groove
Rack Bearing or
Adjuster Plug Bore
28
APQP Element AQE 2-1 APQP Process Training
Supplier Kick-Off Mtg – Early Production Containment Agreement
Goal: Identify critical characteristics that require controls that need to be
validated in EPC
Inputs:
• Lessons Learned from above steps
• Prototype parts
• Drawings & Specs from PE, Product exploded images
Process Steps: • MAPP
1. AQE to define EARLY PRODUCTION CONTAINMENT (EPC) Plan for supplier with PE/QE/Supplier.
Plan which details the component characteristics required for Early Production Containment, control method,
duration and exit requirements
EPC plan must meet product, process and program requirements including visual appearance items (ex. thread
patch coverage and lead thread protection where applicable)
Supplier develops and submits comprehensive EPC plan for AQE review and approval. Reference EPC Tracker
(F1075) .
See nexteer.com
Supplier portal
Processes section for
F1075
29
APQP Element AQE 2-1 APQP Process Training
Supplier Kick-Off Mtg – Early Production Containment Agreement
Process Steps Continued:
2. EPC represents Nexteer as the supplier's customer, so any NG (Not Good) parts found in EPC
is a serious matter. (NG parts treated with Customer impact urgency)
3. AQE emphasis to the supplier is important at this APQP phase such that EPC data must be
submitted to them on a weekly during startup and thru the AQE's formally approved EPC
exit.
4. Define and agree at this phase what the EPC period will be (based on time or quantities with
zero NG parts).
5. It is recommended that a final period of time (ex. last 30 days of a 90 day EPC period) be with
the production control plan sample sizes and frequencies in order to validate the PCP prior to
approving EPC exit.
6. Additional EPC characteristics can be added based on review of PFMEA, Control Plan,
Capability Studies, etc..
7. Use the EPC opportunity to further select boundary sample parts based on reject criteria.
8. Validate EPC characteristics prior to exit of EPC (Supplier shall not self exit).
30
APQP Element AQE 2-2: APQP Process Training
Submit initial Supplier Characteristics Summary (SCS)
Goal: Documents the features requiring a capability study for PPAP
Inputs:
• Drawings, Specifications, and DSS from PE side
Process Steps:
1. Supplier to complete and submit SCS (F1039) to AQE (SCS items may be added based on PFMEA and Control Plan)
Document which summarizes key features (QCL’s) or other feature(s) which require a high level of control or
process monitoring and states specification, initial process capability an; d supplier control method.
Complete initial SCS document. This step only requires the initial list of key components and dimensions to
be completed (Green section). Capability and control will be completed during later phases of APQP.
Primary function of the SCS is to summarize only drawing QCI and QCL details and can be used for customer
review summaries. Additional features (PTC's, lessons learned, etc..) added by AQE/PE to MAPP Section 3 or
Control Plan for special controls, sample size or frequency inspections or capability studies are to be
managed as part of PPAP submission and are not required in this SCS summary.
Outcome: Identify key features which need special controls or monitoring.
31
APQP Element AQE 2-3: APQP Process Training
Complete and submit PFMEA
Goal: Ensure the high severity items and high RPN’s are mitigated for the development of the
control plan
Inputs:
• DSS or DFMEA severity levels from PE
32
APQP Element AQE 2-3 APQP Process Training
Complete and submit PFMEA
Process Steps:
1. Supplier completed PFMEA with Severity, Occurrence and Detection rating for all dimensions
2. AQE/PE/QE review with supplier; minutes should include attendees, dates and key issues discussed
All drawing dimensions identified on PFMEA
With DSS Summary: DSS rankings dictate level of required control and inspection. Review PFMEA severity
rankings and Control Plans and inspection levels based upon prescribed DSS rankings
Without DSS: Nexteer PE provides DFMEA severity levels (including for Black/Grey Box Supplier Designs) to
ensure alignment with PFMEA and Control Plans. Review of PFMEA rankings and Control Plan control and
inspection levels based upon DFMEA severity levels (including for Black/Grey Box Supplier Designs)
Ensure that severity numbers match on the DFMEA and PFMEA
Occurrence ratings are based on past problem cases, accumulated experience, and lessons learned following the
AIAG standards.
Outcome: PFMEA is aligned with the DSS/DFMEA and inputs are available for
the Control Plan development.
33
APQP Element AQE 2-4: APQP Process Training
Develop Capability study plan to include rational sampling
Goal: Agreement of how to collect representative parts to validate the process capability of all
the value streams
Inputs:
• Supplier Characteristic Study - SCS from above steps
• Machine/Tooling/Cavity information from supplier
• MAPP
Process Steps:
1. Defined plan which details features that require capability study (reference MAPP) and details plan for
collecting parts, sample size, sub-grouping and process interactions (include sub-tier consideration)
Supplier to use information from MAPP and feedback from AQE to develop Capability Study Plan and submit to
AQE
Refer to or seek out I&CIM expertise, as necessary, for more complex manufacturing value streams (ex. Multiple
die cast machines feeding multiple machining centers with multiple tombstone fixtures. Statistically determined
process combinations and calculations for part flow do not always require a standard sample size and
subgrouping at each process step to validate capability for the overall process to Nexteer's requirements)
34
APQP Element AQE 2-5 APQP Process Training
Submit Gage Plan
Goal: To ensure the gages and methods developed for PPAP and production meet expectations
prior to PPAP submission
Inputs:
• Approved MAPP
• Proposed gage list (From AQE2-1) Supplier Investment Plan ( Equipment, Tooling & Gage) from supplier
35
APQP Element AQE 2-5 APQP Process Training
Submit Gage Plan
Process Steps:
4. Experts discussion is mandatory with software alignment to perform similar automatic
measurement (optical or tactile CMM)
5. Obtain agreement on gage plan (including concepts, designs, methods, fixturing and clamping, etc.)
6. Non-standard gage drawing approved by PE, AQE, Lab (requires PE, AQE, Metrology Lab signature)
7. Complete MSA (Measurement System Analysis) Plan
8. List dimensions and identify supplier gaging method, identify Nexteer gaging method, identify
dimensions requiring correlation and identify gages requiring correlation
9. Consider duplicate gage needs that may have been missed at MAPP time, and include receiving
plant inspection personnel early on to ensure measurement method and resultant correlation is not
a roadblock at PPAP submission or later in production.
Note: Supplier's ISO/TS certification needs to include gage manufacturing if they are proposing to build their own
gages.
36
APQP Element AQE 2-6 APQP Process Training
Define Packaging Specifications
Goal: Ensure the parts are protected during shipment and arrive in the desired format
(Qty, Orientation, etc…)
Inputs:
Packaging specification ("Nexteer Automotive Global Packaging and Shipping Manual Packaging and
Shipping Standards for Production Parts")
Nexteer pre-designed packaging as directed by PC&L, when applicable, and clarified in MAPP reviews
See nexteer.com
Supplier portal
Processes section for
Shipping & Labeling
guidance
37
APQP Element AQE 2-6 APQP Process Training
Define Packaging Specifications
Process Steps:
* Supplier is responsible for a dunnage design that insures 100% quality upon delivery to Nexteer's point of use.
SUPPLIER PACKAGING INFORMATION
double-click
Ne xte e r here
contact Advanced Name Dat e P hone Email
P C&L logon
discussions among PC&L, Nexteer Plant and AQE. This is then shared
ADDITIONAL COMMENTS
SHIPPING A DDRESS (STREET; CITY , STA TE ZIP) M A NUFA CTURING A DDRESS (STREET; CITY , STA TE ZIP)
with Suppliers for the APQP Element AQE4-3 (Validate Final Packaging)
SUPPLIER SCHEDULING CONTA CT NA M E EM A IL PHONE
(n/a)
DUNNA GE TY PE (V CI, p art it io ns, et c) DES C R IP TION / It e m # LW H (mm) TA RE W T (kg ) M A TERIA L
(n/a)
DUNNA GE TY PE (V CI, p art it io ns, et c) DES C R IP TION / It e m # LW H (mm) TA RE W T (kg ) M A TERIA L
(n/a)
Seco nd ary Co n t yp e(p allet ,p allet -b o x,et c) DES C R IP TION / It e m # LW H (mm) TA RE W T (kg ) M A TERIA L
STA NDA RD PA CK QUA NTITY (p er p rimary co nt ainer) NO. OF PRIM A RY CONTA INERS/ LA Y ER NO. OF LA Y ERS ON/ IN SECONDA RY CONTA INER
PA RT W EIGHT (kg ) PRIM A RY CONT GROSS W EIGHT (kg ) SECONDA RY CONT GROSS W EIGHT (kg ) M ETHOD TO SECURE LOA D M A TERIA L
(st ret ch wrap , b and ing , et c)
DES C R IP TION / It e m #
DES C R IP TION / It e m #
LW H (mm)
LW H (mm)
LW H (mm)
TA RE W T (kg )
TA RE W T (kg )
M A TERIA L
M A TERIA L
M A TERIA L
PRIM A RY B OX HA V E HA NDLES (Y o r N)
PA RT W EIGHT (kg ) PRIM A RY CONT GROSS W EIGHT (kg ) SECONDA RY CONT GROSS W EIGHT (kg ) M ETHOD TO SECURE LOA D M A TERIA L
(st ret ch wrap , b and ing , et c)
0 0
6. Approved SPI uploaded by AQE as part of PPAP package to Parts S UPPLIER FEEDBACK
NEXTEER APPROVALS
NEXTEER FEEDBACK
double-click
here
P lant P C&L Name Dat e
double-click
here
P lant I.E. Name Dat e
38
APQP Element AQE 2-7 APQP Process Training
Verification of supplier equipment, tool and gage purchase orders
Goal: Critical path of every long lead time equipment & tools & gages are verified and program
is funded for contracted capacity.
Inputs
▪ Nomination letter from Buyer (If incremental capacity is planned, it must be documented on the
nomination letter)
39
APQP Element AQE 2-7 APQP Process Training
Verification of supplier equipment, tool and gage purchase orders
Process Steps
1. Supplier provides Purchase Order(s) (P.O.) evidence for critical acquisitions for AQE/SQE
review and verification in accordance with the timing plan
Equipment
Tooling
Gages
2. Compare Supplier Capacity Plan to signed Nomination Letter along with any approved
Incremental Capacity Plans
3. Confirm P.O. received by the vendor and current lead-time meet program requirements
Outcome: All critical & long lead-time Equipment, Tooling, & Gages have
been verified ordered on time and timing meets the program timing.
40
APQP Element AQE 2-8 APQP Process Training
Submit supplier plan for APQP management of sub-tier suppliers
Goal: Confirm Nexteer supplier is deploying APQP with their respective supplier and
communicating Nexteer requirements
Inputs
• Sub-tier List with Risk Assessment
• Sub-tier Supplier Process Flow Diagram (as applicable)
• CQI’s-x (as applicable)
• Special Characteristics Summary highlighting dimensions controlled by sub-tier suppliers
• Nexteer Supplier’s sub-tier APQP plan & Timing
Process Steps
1. Verify Nexteer’s supplier sub-supplier APQP Process is robust and comprehends Nexteer requirements.
2. Verify Nexteer’s Supplier tracks and verifies the quality systems and performance of its suppliers.
Sub-tier List Sub-tier Process Flow Diagram
Sub-tier Audit plan Sub-tier APQP/PPAP plan
Material lead times in Supplier Timeline SCS to sub-tier supplier (as required)
CQI’s (as required)
41
APQP Element AQE 2-8 APQP Process Training
Submit supplier plan for APQP management of sub-tier suppliers
3. Where applicable, review Black/Grey Box Supplier Designs to ensure alignment with Nexteer's Tier 1
Supplier PFMEA and Control Plans, through to the final sub-supplier.
4. Verify that major milestones for their sub-tier suppliers are included on Nexteer’s supplier's program
timing plan
Raw Material Lead times
Long lead time items (equipment tooling, gages, etc....)
PPAP
Run at Rate
5. Determine which sub-tier suppliers require on-site visits from Nexteer
Frequency of visits (especially suppliers with critical characteristics)
Timing
Outcome: Sub-tier supplier’s launch is monitored and issues are addressed proactively to ensure a perfect
launch at Nexteer’s supplier.
42
APQP Gate Review 2 APQP Process Training
Plan & Define
Goal: Verify that the APQP project is on track by completing a management review of
objective evidence for all required phase elements.
Inputs:
• List of required phase elements as determined by APQP risk level
• Objective evidence for each element completed
• May be hard copy or online documents
• Nexteer program timing and supplier timeline
• Knowledge of changes to program, part design or supplier’s plan
• Copies of previous internal and external risk assessments
• Phase 2 gate review form
Process Steps:
1. Identify the required functional participants based on risk
2. AQE Supervisor schedules all the gate review meetings based on Supplier
APQP timing agreed to in Supplier Kick-off meeting
3. Document the attendance on the gate review form (Suppliers should
attend all Gate Reviews)
4. Complete the drawing status and change request sections of the form
43
APQP Gate Review 2 APQP Process Training
Plan & Define
Process Steps Continued:
5. Review the objective evidence provided by the AQE for each element and assign a status as follows:
Green – Element is complete, with evidence shown of detail that aligns with risk (e.g. meeting notes, onsite
review if required, detailed process documentation)
Yellow – Requires minor changes, or lacking sufficient detail for assigned risk
Red – Element not started or seriously late, jeopardizing program timing. Obvious lack of rigor or detail in the
evidence provided.
6. Document any significant changes at Nexteer or the supplier on the gate review form .
7. Document any critical pending requirements on the gate review form.
8. Identify any completed elements from a previous phase that must be reviewed again due to changes
identified during this gate review.
9. Review and update the internal and external risk assessments based on the findings of the gate review.
10. Gate review rating is automatically calculated based on elements ratings, drawing status, & ECR status
Schedule follow up review(s) if the gate review status is not green.
Escalate any significant changes, critical pending requirements or resource constraints to higher level Supplier
Quality or GSM management.
Note: Successful completion of the phase gate review is not required to begin work on elements that belong to later APQP
phases. However, all gate reviews must be complete with a green status before the AQE may transfer the part to an SQE.
Outcome: APQP elements all meet expectations and critical issues are
escalated and resolved timely
44
APQP
Phase 3
Process Training
45
APQP Element AQE 3-1: Verify capital equipment with evidence APQP Process Training
Goal: Confirm the supplier is meeting timeline requirements and has the required
equipment in place for Run @ Rate on site at their manufacturing facility
Inputs:
▪ Nomination letter and Buyer Parts Management Database
approved incremental capacity plan (PMD)
(if supplier will not have full capacity at PPAP)
46
APQP Element AQE 3-1: Verify capital equipment with evidence APQP Process Training
Inputs continued:
▪ MAPP section 10 http://www.nexteer.com/supplier-portal/processes/sourcing/
47
APQP Element AQE 3-1: Verify capital equipment with evidence APQP Process Training
Process Steps:
1. AQE confirms (actually see with their eyes) machines, tools and gages are at the manufacturing
location. Use photos, videos, Skype.
2. AQE confirms the number of machines and the planned cycle time meets the contracted capacity
3. Supplier completes Run @ Rate Plan and Capacity Plan
4. AQE reviews the Supplier’s staffing plan and confirms that it matches the timeline and will be
completed ahead of PPAP, Run @ Rate, and SOP
Outcome: AQE verified that the Supplier has complete capacity at their
facility to meet Customer required volume.
48
APQP Element AQE 3-2: Complete final production process flow diagram APQP Process Training
Goal: Document additional details that were not included on the original simplified
production process flow diagram as well as any modifications or improvements
Inputs:
▪ Design Severity and Sensitivity; DSS (from PE; Product Engineer and/or PLL)
49
APQP Element AQE 3-2: Complete final production process flow diagram APQP Process Training
Inputs continued:
▪ Process Flow Diagram Plan (MAPP section 4)
http://www.nexteer.com/supplier-portal/processes/sourcing/
50
APQP Element AQE 3-2: Complete final production Process Flow Diagram APQP Process Training
Inputs continued:
▪ Completed PFMEA
Process Steps:
1. AQE confirms that Process Flow Diagram created by the supplier
clearly and completely describes production process steps and
sequence of operations.
Both Incoming material and shipping considerations must be
included
Hidden factories have to be shown in the PFD: rework, check
out of the line, bypass process.
PFD is to be done Dock to Dock, take into account handling and
storage and shall include sub contracted operations
QCL’s are to be labeled at the correct steps in the
manufacturing process
Outcome: A completed and Approved (by AQE) Final Production Process Flow
Diagram ready for PPAP submission and representing the intended manufacturing
process that will meet Nexteer requirements.
51
APQP Element AQE 3-3: Complete and Submit Production Control Plan APQP Process Training
Goal: Document expected long term controls based on PFMEA inputs and EPC
(Early Production Containment) to ensure quality performance is achieved
Inputs:
• Production released drawing &
specifications
• DFMEA (Supplier) / Design Severity
and Sensitivity (DSS) used and
Provided by Product Engineer – PE
• MAPP (from Buyer/PMD)
• Process Flow Diagram (Reference
APQP Element: AQE3-2) & PFMEA
(Reference APQP Element: AQE2-3)
52
APQP Element AQE 3-3: Complete and Submit Production Control Plan APQP Process Training
Process Steps:
1. Compare DSS (or DFMEA), PFMEA, and Process Flow Diagram to determine inspection locations,
frequency and gage of dimensions, and ensure Severity is consistent through all documents.
2. Seek process expert review, agreement, and Sign-off for all CL!, CL2, & CL3 features per 3.2.5 Process
Expert Sign-Off Procedure
a) The list of commodities and respective process experts can be found at:
https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/0B2lA98OHdwoUSFFwb1lIWUVqZmM?usp=sharing
b) If the commodity does not have a process expert, the SQ supervisor must review the applicable line
items on the control plan
NOTE: Verify if there is an approved x1331 where applicable for any deviations from DSS requirements
that cannot meet G1331 guidelines.
53
APQP Element AQE 3-3: Complete and Submit Production Control Plan APQP Process Training
Process Steps:
1. Compare DSS (or DFMEA), PFMEA, and Process Flow Diagram to determine inspection locations,
frequency and gage of dimensions, and ensure Severity is consistent through all documents.
2. Seek process expert review, agreement, and Sign-off for all CL!, CL2, & CL3 features per 3.2.5 Process
Expert Sign-Off Procedure
a) The list of commodities and respective process experts can be found at:
Global Commodity Assignment by Buyer and Supplier Quality
b) If the commodity does not have a process expert, the SQ supervisor must review the applicable line
items on the control plan
NOTE: Verify if there is an approved x1331 where applicable for any deviations from DSS requirements
that cannot meet G1331 guidelines.
54
APQP Element AQE 3-4: Submit Traceability Plan APQP Process Training
Goal: Ensure that a Traceability Plan mitigates the potential impact of non-conforming parts
Inputs:
• Drawing and Specification requirements
• Nexteer Supplier Requirements (NSR) http://www.nexteer.com/doing-business-with-nexteer/
55
APQP Element AQE 3-4: Submit Traceability Plan APQP Process Training
Inputs continued:
▪ Part size/shape/function for part marking (Reference Part Drawing)
▪ Manufacturing process / Expert lessons learned
(Examples: stamping, machining, die casting, etc.. (Reference Process Flow Diagram)
Process Steps:
1. Define acceptable level of traceability required Notes:
based on DSS and NSR ▪ Photos of traceability with
2. Identify traceability format Nexteer plant will decoder/explanation legend for PPAP, PPAP Check
receive, i.e. 2D bar code, laser etched numbers, ▪ ECR (Engineering Change Request) tracking
cavity number, shipping label, etc. number (if required) to update drawing to allow
3. Identify marking method, i.e. laser, dot matrix, cavity for individual part marking
number, label printer, etc. ▪ Confirmation that traceability plan meets
4. Identify points for variation, i.e. machines, fixtures, Nexteer Plant Operations’ expectations
cavities, shift, day, etc.
5. Include traceability on both PFMEA and Control Plan
6. Submit traceability plan that documents “HOW” the
traceability system will function to minimize the
exposure to defects (singular versus lot control).
7. Request drawing update for any changes related to
traceability
Outcome: Documented and Approved (by Product Engineer
and receiving Nexteer Plant) Traceability Plan
56
APQP Element AQE 3-5: Submit Pre-Production Control Plan including EPC APQP Process Training
Goal: Ensure that all supplier process controls are effective and the reporting of
non-conformances meet Nexteer’s expectations
Inputs:
▪ Production Control Plan (Reference APQP Element AQE3-3)
▪ DSS – Design Severity and Sensitivity (from Product Engineer)
▪ DFMEA (from Product Engineer, used to create DSS)
▪ PFMEA (Reference APQP Element AQE2-3) Notes: (Reference Supplier Kick-Off Meeting)
1. Documented Pre-Production Control Plan
Process Steps: 2. In case of a patented/proprietary processes, at a minimum an extract
of the production control plan is required to show every critical
1. Create a Pre-Production
dimension inspection gage and frequency.
Control Plan based on the 3. Where no critical characteristics or QCL’s exist on a drawing, the AQE
Production Control Plan, should identify characteristics or features for increased sample size
DSS, DFMEA and PFMEA and frequency. (Example: Pass-thru characteristics)
with a level of control in 4. EPC data must be submitted to AQE on a weekly/production run
basis.
accordance with Severity, 5. Define and agree at this stage what the EPC period will be (based on
Detection and Occurrence time or quantities with zero Non-Conforming parts).
from the PFMEA 6. It is recommended that a defined period of time (for example; last 30
days of a 90 day EPC period) be with the production control plan
2. Utilize pre-production sample sizes and frequencies in order to validate the PCP prior to
control plan for all parts approving EPC exit.
(MQ1, MQ2, etc..) 7. Formal notification from AQE to Supplier is required to close EPC
8. EPC needs to include label scanning verification at Supplier
Process Steps:
1. Identify the required functional participants based on risk
2. AQE Supervisor schedules all the gate review meetings based on Supplier
APQP timing agreed to in Supplier Kick-off meeting
3. Document the attendance on the gate review form (Suppliers should
attend all Gate Reviews)
4. Complete the drawing status and change request sections of the form
58
APQP Gate Review 3 APQP Process Training
Process Design & Development
Process Steps Continued:
5. Review the objective evidence provided by the AQE for each element and assign a status as follows:
Green – Element is complete, with evidence shown of detail that aligns with risk (e.g. meeting notes, onsite
review if required, detailed process documentation)
Yellow – Requires minor changes, or lacking sufficient detail for assigned risk
Red – Element not started or seriously late, jeopardizing program timing. Obvious lack of rigor or detail in the
evidence provided.
6. Document any significant changes at Nexteer or the supplier on the gate review form .
7. Document any critical pending requirements on the gate review form.
8. Identify any completed elements from a previous phase that must be reviewed again due to changes
identified during this gate review.
9. Review and update the internal and external risk assessments based on the findings of the gate review.
10. Gate review rating is automatically calculated based on elements ratings, drawing status, & ECR status
Schedule follow up review(s) if the gate review status is not green.
Escalate any significant changes, critical pending requirements or resource constraints to higher level Supplier
Quality or GSM management.
Note: Successful completion of the phase gate review is not required to begin work on elements that belong to later APQP
phases. However, all gate reviews must be complete with a green status before the AQE may transfer the part to an SQE.
Outcome: APQP elements all meet expectations and critical issues are
escalated and resolved timely
59
APQP
Phase 4
Process Training
60
APQP Element AQE 4-1: APQP Process Training
Initiate Measurement System Analysis
Goal: Qualify the measurement system prior to capability studies and PPAP
Prevent measurement discrepancies from impacting PPAP or serial production
Inputs:
Step#1: COMPLETE
• Drawing + DSS from PLM at production release MEASUREMENT
SYSTEM ANALYSIS
• Supplier Control Plan
• See requirements in NSR section 4.10 for samples
distribution used for MSA
• Engineering recommendation of measurement
• CMM program (if existing) Step#2: PRODUCT
DIMENSION
CORRELATION
• Supplier protocol / method of measurement Step#3: GAGE
CORRELATION /
• List of dimensions and a column identifying CALIBRATION
61
APQP Element AQE 4-1: APQP Process Training
Initiate Measurement System Analysis
Process Steps:
62
APQP Element AQE 4-2: APQP Process Training
Submit Appearance Approval
Goal: Gain agreement with Nexteer and customer on subjective visual requirements
Inputs:
Note: This element is only applicable to cosmetic visual items
▪ OEM Customer's requirements (especially for subjective items)
▪ Boundary samples
Process Steps:
Outcome: Transform cosmetic items into measurable value and gain OEM approval
63
APQP Element AQE 4-3: APQP Process Training
Validate final packaging
Goal: Ensure that final packaging is compliant to Supplier Packaging Instruction (SPI) and to
manufacturing site
Inputs:
• Supplier Packaging Instruction
• Supplier Packaging Trial Plan (from AQE2-6)
• This Element is linked to the Element AQE 2-6: Define Packaging Specifications
2. Validation with real package, with representative parts in real conditions of transportation.
This validation includes the complete transportation value stream (warehouse-sea
shipment-warehouse-railway-warehouse-truck-warehouse).
3. Label on pallet and on carton/plastic/metallic boxes with the associated bar code system is
also part of this validation
4. Have supplier send label prior to shipment to verify Nexteer can read the barcode.
Labeling Requirements
65
APQP Element AQE 4-4: APQP Process Training
F1058 process audit initiation
Goal: Evaluation of production readiness (equipment, documentation, operators) for launch, SQE
awareness of the process, and identification of any open issues requiring closure prior to the
responsibility shift to SQE
Inputs:
▪ Drawing + DSS + Specifications ▪ MCA results
▪ CQI-x audits (if applicable) ▪ All equipment, tools, gages & spare parts
66
APQP Element AQE 4-4: APQP Process Training
F1058 process audit initiation
Process Steps:
1. F1058 process audit initiation means to detect in advance non conformity and situation at risk in the
supplier process. This element is requested to ensure that the element “AQE5-1 F1058 process audit
closure” to be closed correctly the first time.
2. The “F-1058 – Supplier Process Production Readiness Audit Form” is the form to use and the action
plan is populated accordingly.
Outcome: Identify risks and address process issues prior to PPAP, MQ1 and MQ2
samples; closing gaps by Nexteer SOP.
67
APQP Element AQE 4-5: APQP Process Training
Supplier PPAP submission & Approval
Goal: Validate product & process compliance to Nexteer's requirements
Inputs: Process Steps:
▪ Drawings/Specs production released in PLM 1. COMPLETE PPAP BUILD
▪ PPAP Checksheet Supplier performs a controlled PPAP Production Run
▪ PPAP Checksheet Instructions Quantity as defined in the Nexteer Supplier Requirements
Supplier's intended manufacturing location on production
intent equipment/tooling, at production rates with
▪ ALL PPAP documents in the expected production operators - incorporating the full production flow
electronic format (NSR 4.3) diagram and control plan
68
APQP Element AQE 4-5: APQP Process Training
Supplier PPAP submission & Approval
Process Steps Continued:
Inputs: 3. SHIP PPAP PARTS TO NEXTEER PLANT
• PPAP P.O. Guarantee deliveries from supplier to Nexteer in mass
production conditions: process, packaging,
Nexteer Manufacturing Address
transportation, warehouse(s), up to the Nexteer
• AQE approved PPAP checksheet/documentation production line (Use X3483, PPAP Label)
Outcome: Part Submission Warrant (PSW) approved and signed by Nexteer Lead
Using Plant (Send signed copy to supplier)
69
APQP Element AQE 4-6: APQP Process Training
MQ1 samples due
Goal: To ensure production intent parts are available for Nexteer’s machine run off on vendor floor
Inputs:
▪ Approved Supplier PPAP or IRW (see element AQE 4-5 Supplier PPAP submission & Approval)
▪ P.O. including MRD (Material Required Date), drawing and revision number, specific packaging and
location for MQ1 parts, if required
Process Steps:
1. Supplier sends sample parts produced for the purpose of Machine Qualification on a production
or fabrication machine at a Nexteer machine builder location
3. Supplier ships parts identified using PPAP label (X-3483) to Nexteer machine builder location
Outcome: MQ1 parts available for machine run-off at machine builder floor.
70
APQP Element AQE 4-7: APQP Process Training
MQ2 samples due
Goal: To ensure production parts are available for machine run off at Nexteer
Inputs:
▪ Approved Supplier PPAP or IRW (see element AQE 4-5 Supplier PPAP submission (GSM4-2) & Approval)
▪ P.O. including MRD (Material Required Date), drawing and revision number, specific packaging and
location for MQ2 parts, if required
X3483
Global Sample and PPAP Label
Process Steps:
1. Supplier sends sample parts for the
purpose of Machine Qualification on a
production or fabrication machine at a
Nexteer Manufacturing location. (If not
already PPAP approved, follow Global
Sample and PPAP Label Instruction -
X3483)
2. AQE ensures the supplier is
shipping quantities meet MRD
requirements
Outcome: MQ2 parts are PPAP approved with a signed PSW, shipped to the
appropriate Nexteer plant, and are available for Production Trial Runs and Nexteer
Customer PPAP submission
71
APQP Gate Review 4 APQP Process Training
Product & Process Validation
Goal: Verify that the APQP project is on track by completing a management review of
objective evidence for all required phase elements.
Inputs:
• List of required phase elements as determined by APQP risk level
• Objective evidence for each element completed
May be hard copy or online documents
• Nexteer program timing and supplier timeline
• Knowledge of changes to program, part design or supplier’s plan
• Copies of previous internal and external risk assessments
• Phase 2 gate review form
Process Steps:
1. Identify the required functional participants based on risk
2. AQE Supervisor schedules all the gate review meetings based on Supplier
APQP timing agreed to in Supplier Kick-off meeting
3. Document the attendance on the gate review form (Suppliers should
attend all Gate Reviews)
4. Complete the drawing status and change request sections of the form
72
APQP Gate Review 4 APQP Process Training
Product & Process Validation
Outcome: APQP elements all meet expectations and critical issues are
escalated and resolved timely
73
APQP
Phase 5
Process Training
74
APQP Element AQE 5-1: APQP Process Training
F1058 Process Audit Closure
Goal: Evaluation of supplier production readiness (equipment, documentation, operators) for launch.
SQE gains awareness of the process, and identification of any open issues requiring closure prior to the
responsibility shift from AQE to SQE
Inputs:
• F1058 open item list (APQP Element
AQE4-4, F1058 process audit initiation)
This should include the Supplier’s
original action plan, timing, as well as
current closure status
See nexteer.com
Supplier portal
Quality section for
F1058 Process Audit
file
75
APQP Element AQE 5-1: APQP Process Training
F1058 Process Audit Closure
Process Steps:
1. AQE sends F1058 form to supplier or directs
them to the file on the Nexteer supplier
portal (as shown below)
76
APQP Element AQE 5-2: APQP Process Training
Run at Rate
Goal: Ensure the supplier’s manufacturing process meets the contracted capacity and identify any
potential issues & risks
Inputs:
• Supplier’s Appendix 15 Run at Rate Plan from APQP
Element AQE 3-1
COMMENTS:
77
APQP Element AQE 5-2: APQP Process Training
Run at Rate
Process Steps:
1. Supplier submits their Capacity Plan and Run at
Rate Plan to AQE from APQP Element AQE 3-1
78
APQP Element AQE 5-2: APQP Process Training
Run at Rate
Process 1 Process Steps:
Process 2 1. Conduct and document Run at Rate (AQE to invite
SQE and Plant Quality):
79
APQP Element AQE 5-2: APQP Process Training
Run at Rate
Outcome: The supplier’s manufacturing process along with their sub-tiers is verified
to meet the contracted capacity (on Appendix 15 form). Any potential issues & risks are
identified while the production process is stressed (quality, handling, material flow,
gaging, bottle neck, safety)
80
APQP Element AQE 5-3: APQP Process Training
Final Production Sign-off (AQE to SQE hand-off)
Goal: Ensure perfect launch readiness and transfer lead role to SQE for seamless production
Inputs:
• Pre-Production Control Plan (PPCP)
• PFMEA
81
APQP Element AQE 5-3: APQP Process Training
Final Production Sign-off (AQE to SQE hand-off)
Process Steps:
1. AQE/SQE should compare PPCP to supplied EPC data to confirm all items are being inspected
and there are no defects in EPC for the past 30 days.
2. AQE/SQE should compare EPC data to in process production data, and require any control
plan improvements to prevent bad parts from being produced and/or shipped to Nexteer.
3. AQE/SQE confirms any Problem Case issued did not reflect EPC items and all Problem Cases
are closed in Intelex
4. AQE/SQE confirms 3 Legged 5 Why addresses root causes and systemic issues with irreversible
corrective actions in place and documented in PFMEA and Production Control Plan
The supplier should update their PPAP for changed PFMEA and Production Control Plan
5. Supplier shall only exit from EPC with AQE/SQE approval
Supplier submits written request (ex. Email) to AQE/SQE to exit EPC
Formal notification (ex. Email) from AQE/SQE to Supplier closing EPC
Exit can be either by specific EPC item or as an overall EPC exit approval.
6. Gate 5 review requires both AQE and SQE to be involved to close out APQP and to transition
from AQE to SQE
Outcome: The supplier is verified as ready to Go Live, the AQE and SQE close out the
APQP, and transition of lead responsibility moves from the AQE Launch phase to SQE
Seamless Production phase.
82
APQP Gate Review 5 APQP Process Training
Production & AQE to SQE Transition
Goal: Verify that the APQP project is on track by completing a management review of
objective evidence for all required phase elements.
Inputs:
• List of required phase elements as determined by APQP risk level
• Objective evidence for each element completed
• May be hard copy or online documents
• Nexteer program timing and supplier timeline
• Knowledge of changes to program, part design or supplier’s plan
• Copies of previous internal and external risk assessments
• Phase 2 gate review form
Process Steps:
1. Identify the required functional participants based on risk
2. AQE Supervisor schedules all the gate review meetings based on Supplier
APQP timing agreed to in Supplier Kick-off meeting
3. Document the attendance on the gate review form (Suppliers should
attend all Gate Reviews)
4. Complete the drawing status and change request sections of the form
83
APQP Gate Review 5 APQP Process Training
Production & AQE to SQE Transition
Process Steps Continued:
5. Review the objective evidence provided by the AQE for each element and assign a status as follows:
Green – Element is complete, with evidence shown of detail that aligns with risk (e.g. meeting notes, onsite
review if required, detailed process documentation)
Yellow – Requires minor changes, or lacking sufficient detail for assigned risk
Red – Element not started or seriously late, jeopardizing program timing. Obvious lack of rigor or detail in the
evidence provided.
6. Document any significant changes at Nexteer or the supplier on the gate review form .
7. Document any critical pending requirements on the gate review form.
8. Identify any completed elements from a previous phase that must be reviewed again due to changes
identified during this gate review.
9. Review and update the internal and external risk assessments based on the findings of the gate review.
10. Gate review rating is automatically calculated based on elements ratings, drawing status, & ECR status
Schedule follow up review(s) if the gate review status is not green.
Escalate any significant changes, critical pending requirements or resource constraints to higher level Supplier
Quality or GSM management.
Note: Successful completion of the phase gate review is not required to begin work on elements that belong to later APQP
phases. However, all gate reviews must be complete with a green status before the AQE may transfer the part to an SQE.
Outcome: APQP elements all meet expectations and critical issues are
escalated and resolved timely
84
APQP APQP Process Training
Summary
Goal: Utilize a standard approach to produce a product quality plan, which will
support the development of a product or service that will satisfy the customer
Inputs:
AIAG APQP Standard
Trained AQE’s
Process that remains flexible enough for all applicable circumstances while ensuring that the intent is
achieved
Process Steps:
Thoroughly complete all elements in Phases 2-5 (Note: documentation required in English)
Supplier owns APQP activities
AQE owns Nexteer’s interest for a thorough and timely APQP – Extreme ownership!
Gate Reviews are scheduled and held based on the program timing … not completion of the elements
Each element is reviewed in detail during the appropriate gate review for accuracy and completeness
85
Thank You
86