Welcome: by Sayan Kumar EE (E), Unit 7&8 DVC Ctps Chandrapura
Welcome: by Sayan Kumar EE (E), Unit 7&8 DVC Ctps Chandrapura
to the presentation
on
by
Sayan Kumar
EE(E), Unit 7&8
DVC CTPS
Chandrapura
AREAS of POTENTIAL TROUBLE in ESP
INSULATORS
5.94 DISCHARGE
COLLECTING ELECTRODES
PLATES
15.16 31.25
21.93
RAPPING
MECHANISMS
25.72
DUST
REMOVAL
Numbers in percent of installations
PRECIPITATOR PROBLEMS…….. fundamental
INADEQUATE
HIGH
INADEQUATE
POOR BADLY
UNDER
UNSTABLE
INADEQUATE FAULTY
RE-
RESISTIVITY
HTSIZED
GASHV
RAPPING
FLOW
DESIGNED
TR ENTRAINMENT
SECTIONSSETS ERECTION
PARTICLES
EQUIPMENT
DISTRIBUTION
EQUIPMENT
ELECTRODES
Under
sized
Fundamental
Problems
Fundamental
Problems
High
resistivity
particle
• >1010
• Ohm - cm
• 107 - 1010
• Ohm - cm
• 104 – 107
• Ohm-cm
ELECTRICAL RESISTIVITY ……. influenced by
GAS
MOISTURE
GAS
COMPOSITION
GAS TEMPERATURE Vs RESISTIVITY of FLYASH
13
RESISTIVITY, OHM-CM (IN POWERS OF 10 )
12.5
12
11.5
11
10.5
10
9.5
9
50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450
GAS TEMPERATURE, DEG C
Increased
content of
SiO2 Increased
Al2O3 content of
CaO
Fe2O3
Na2O
K2O
P2O5
SO3
LiO2
High operating
Seriously current levels
reduced Reduced
performance operating
due to voltage levels
back-corona
High resistivity
( 1012 ohm – cm
and above )
High electrical
Very significant
force
voltage loss
component
across dust
retaining
layer
collected dust
Back Corona
-
Collecting
EMITTING
Plate
DUST LAYER ELECTRODE
on COLLECTING PLATE
Reduced
collection Significant
performance voltage drop
with high spark across dust layer
rates
Normal
resistivity
( 1011 ohm – cm )
Moderate
Reduced
electrical force
operating voltage
component
and current
retaining the
levels
collected dust
Normal
resistivity
( 107 - 1010
ohm – cm )
Sufficient
Normal
electrical force
operating voltage
component
and current
retaining the
levels
collected dust
Low
resistivity Reduced
Negligible voltage electrical force
( < 107 ohm – cm ) component
loss across dust
layer retaining
collected dust
Inadequate
HT sections
Too large an
area per
TR set
Poor
Electrical Restricted
Under powered Sectionalisation operating
electrical
Voltage and
energisation
Current
Inadequate
HV
Fundamental
equipment Problems
Poor Inadequate rating
sectionalisation of TR sets
Unstable
TR set
Operation
Uncontrolled Improper TR
Sparking set adjustment
Poor
gas flow
distribution
Fundamental
Problems
MAJOR PROBLEMS AND EFFECTS….
Reduced
operating voltage with
pre-mature sparking
Inadequate
rapping
equipment
Fundamental
Problems
MAJOR PROBLEMS AND EFFECTS….
Rapping mal-function or
inadequate design
Fundamental
Problems
Badly
designed
electrode
systems
Fundamental
problems
Faulty
erection
Fundamental
Problems
Component
Rating and
Tolerances
Poor
Quality
Control Mechanical
Field Erection
Design
“ Even the best basic design can be ruined by poor mechanical design
and / or by sloppy field construction “
MAJOR PROBLEMS AND EFFECTS….
Poor electrical
grounding system
VIBRATING / EXCESSIVE
POOR DISTORTED
SWINGING DUST
ELECTRODE COLLECTING
DISCHARGE DEPOSIT ON
ALIGNMENT PLATES
ELECTRODES ELECTRODES
DUST
FULL OR DEPOSITS GAS
AIR
OVERFLOWING IN SNEAKAGE
HOPPERS IN-LEAKAGE
GAS DUCTS
1
Poor
alignment
of
electrode
systems
Mechanical
Problems
MAJOR PROBLEMS AND EFFECTS….
Discharge electrode
misalignment
Discharge
electrode
Abnormal misalignment
Reduced
corona
performance
characteristic
Mechanical
Problems
2
Full /
over
flowing
hoppers
on the significance of dust removal system …
5. 94
“ 15.16
Careful attention to the
design, operation and
maintenance of the dust 31.25
removal system is extremely
important. It is significant to
note that the highest
incidence of discharge
21.93
electrode failure is related to
the highest degree of hopper
pluggage.”
-TC – 1 Committee
Air Pollution Control
Association ( APCA )
PROBLEMS with DUST REMOVAL FROM ESP
Major
Causes
Hopper Vacuum
Temperature
Pluggage Leakage
MAJOR PROBLEMS AND EFFECTS….
Inadequate or unreliable
ash evacuation system
Hopper
Pluggage
Ash fusion Misalignment
and of electrode
clinkering system
on the fluidizing devices …
5. 94
MAJOR
CAUSES
1
2 3
ELECTRICAL
EROSION CORROSION FATIGUE
DISCHARGE ELECTRODE FAILURES - MAGNITUDE
NO PROBLEM MAJOR
21.72 23.37
MINOR
54.91
47.04
INFREQUENT
Wire breakage
Excessive sparking
and loss of power
Advanced stage of corrosion
Corroded hot air flushing ducts of emitting system
MAJOR PROBLEMS AND EFFECTS….
Dust re-entrainment
and upsets in electrical
conditions
5
Distorted
collecting
plates
Mechanical
Problems
Close spacing Thermal
& expansion
abnormal corona problems
characteristics
Distorted
Collecting
Plates
Full
Mishandling hopper
during erection pressures
MAJOR PROBLEMS AND EFFECTS….
Excessive dust
fall-out in
flues
Changes in
particle size Poor gas
distribution distribution
7
Excessive
dust
deposit on
electrodes
Mechanical
Problems
on the influence of flyash accumulation
on the discharge electrode …
5. 94
15.16
“ Excessive build – ups
tend to suppress 31.25the
precipitator current by
elevating the voltage
required for initiation
21.93of the corona discharge.
Another problem is the
possible unequal corona
formation through a
particular field.”
Excessive
dust
accumulation
on spiral
emitters –
ineffective
rapping
Excessive
dust
accumulation
on spiral
emitters –
ineffective
rapping
8
Gas
Sneakage
Mechanical
Problems
Insulator
fouling &
shorting
Corrosion
Hopper dust
causing air
build-up
ingress
Condensation
Holes &
Crusty
sharp edges
deposits on
in collecting electrodes
electrodes
Blinding of
gas
distributor
screens
on electrical tracking on support insulators …
5. 94
Condensation leading to
insulator fouling and shorting,
crusty deposits on electrodes,
hopper dust hang-ups
Reduced
operating voltage with
pre-mature sparking
PRECIPITATOR PROBLEMS…….. operational
POOR
TUNING
OF
EXCESSIVE
ELECTRICAL
GASSETS
FLOW
PROCESS
POOR
UPSETS
ADJUSTMENT
OF
RAPPERS
1
Poor
adjust-
ment of
rappers
Operational
Problems
on the failure of coil assemblies …
( in vertical impact rappers )
5. 94
2
Process
upsets
Performance of ESP …. Process related parameters
Composition
of fine
particles
Concentration
Particle size
of water
distribution
vapor
Performance
of
Concentration Electrostatic
Precipitator Gas flow rate
of SO3
MAJOR PROBLEMS AND EFFECTS….
Corona quench
due to high
concentration of
fine particles
Unstable
conditions
( full load current at very
low primary voltages)
HV Bushing
Full
cracked or dirty
with surface or nearly full
conduction hoppers
MAJOR PROBLEMS AND EFFECTS….
Excess dust
re-entrainment and
loss of performance
4
Poor Operational
tuning of Problems
electrical
sets
MAJOR PROBLEMS AND EFFECTS….
Uncontrollable sparking,
sluggish response and
poor performance
MAJOR PROBLEMS AND EFFECTS….
Limited energisation
capability and performance
ELECTRICAL PERFORMANCE OF ESP ….
The electrical performance of an ESP can be
evaluated by comparing secondary currents,
secondary voltages and the spark rate to baseline
values for these parameters.
Unreliable
electrical operation,
failure of equipment and
loss of performance
Faulty
Local air
electrical bus
ingress
section
Excessive
sparking
Heavy Serious
dust release electrode
during rapping misalignment
OPERATION
&
MAINTENANCE
RECOMMENDED PROCEDURES FOR
RELIABLE OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE
RECOMMENDED PROCEDURES FOR
RELIABLE OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE
collection
RECOMMENDED PROCEDURES FOR
RELIABLE OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE
hopper emptying. See that all hoppers are promptly emptied at shut-
down
RECOMMENDED PROCEDURES FOR
RELIABLE OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE
RECOMMENDED PROCEDURES FOR
RELIABLE OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE
Check all access door seals and inspect the casing, flues, expansion
Check all main ground connections are safe and sound, free of
corrosion.
PLANT
PLANT OWNER
NAME
Field No Bus Section 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
kV kV kV kV kV kV kV kV kV kV
Left
1
Right
Left
2
Right
Left
3
Right
Left
4
Right
Left
5
Right
Left
6
Right
Left
7
Right
Left
8
Right
Left
9
Right
Left
10
Right
Note: 1) During V- I characteristics, the respective EC panels will be operated with a charge ratio of 1:1
2) While taking readings, always proceed from the rear field to the inlet field
PLANT PLANT
OWNER NAME
UNIT RATING A /B /C /D /E
ESP CASING
No (MW) /F
Bus
Field No 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
Section
kV kV kV kV kV kV kV kV kV kV
Left
1
Right
Left
2
Right
BOILER UCB / COAL / ASH DATA
PLANT
PLANT OWNER
NAME
Unit Load
UNIT No RATING (MW)
(MW)
Analysis of Coal Date Date Date Date Date Date Date Date
Fixed Carbon %
Volatiles %
Moisture %
Ash %
Sulphur %
Analysis of Flyash Date Date Date Date Date Date Date Date
Silica %
Alumina %
Iron Oxide %
Calcium Oxide %
Magnesia %
Sodium Oxide %
Potassium Oxide %
Phosphorous Pentoxide %
Titania %
Sulphur Trioxide %
PLANT
PLANT
OWNE
NAME
R
Fixed
%
Carbon
Volatiles %
Moisture %
Ash %
Sulphur %
Analysis of Date Date Date Date Date Date Date Date
Flyash
Silica %
Alumina %
Iron Oxide %
Calcium
%
Oxide
Magnesia %
Sodium
%
Oxide
Potassium
%
Oxide
Phosphoro
us %
Pentoxide
Titania %
Sulphur
%
Trioxide
Resistivity ohm-
of flyash cm
ELECTRONIC CONTROLLER PANEL READINGS
PLANT
PLANT OWNER
NAME
Left
1
Right
Left
2
Right
Left
3
Right
Left
4
Right
Left
5
Right
Left
6
Right
Left
7
Right
Left
8
Right
Left
9
Right
Left
10
Right
PLANT
PLANT
OWNE
NAME
R
UNIT RATING A /B /C /D
ESP CASING
No (MW) /E /F
Gas
Unit
Temperature at
Date Time Load
ESP inlet (Deg
(MW)
C)
Secon
Secon
Bus Prim. Prim. . Charg Spark
Field .
Sectio Volt. Curre Curre e rate / Remarks
No Volt
n (V) nt (A) n Ratio mt
(kV)
(mA)
Left
1
Right
Left
2
Right
AUXILIARY CONTROL PANEL READINGS
Left
1
Right
Left
2
Right
Left
3
Right
Left
4
Right
Left
5
Right
Left
6
Right
Left
7
Right
Left
8
Right
Left
9
Right
Left
10
Right
PLANT PLANT
OWNER NAME
UNIT A /B /C /D /E
RATING (MW) ESP CASING
No /F
Gas
Unit
Temperature
Date Time Load
at ESP inlet
(MW)
(Deg C)
Left
2
Right
on the requirement of a minimum level of personnel
to be assigned for maintenance of ESPs …
5. 94
The number depends to a great extent on the size and complexity of
the installation. It is prudent to have at least one highly trained
person to oversee a critical unit on a full time basis, especially if the
installation size is over a 450 m3 / s capacity or is designed for
15.16
particulate emission of 150 mg / Nm3 or less .
31.25
Whether additional personnel are required should be based on
process characteristics and the history of problems.
The repetitive problems should be corrected by equipment
modifications, but trained manpower is often needed to provide the
21.93input.
critical
60
FIEFIELD - 1
FIELD
LDFIELD -1- - 1
1FIEFIELLD - 1FIELD
Secondary Voltage, kV
50
40 FIELD - 7
PROJECT: SHREE CEMENTS LTD - 2 X 150 MW - CFBC
30
VOLTAGE - CURRENT ( V-I ) CHARACTERISTICS OF ELECTRICAL BUS
SECTIONS OF ELECTROSTATIC PRECIPITATOR - Unit # 1
20 PASS : A
0
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400
Secondary Current, mA
PASS - A
TYPICAL V – I CHARACTERISTICS OF AN ESP
AFTER A CFBC BOILER ( Gas Load )
60
FIELD - -11 -
FIELDFIELD
1FIEFIELLD - 1FIELD
50
Secondary Voltage, kV
40
FIEFIELDFIELD - 1
FIELD --17-
FIDFIELD
1FIEFIELLD -
1FIELD
30 PROJECT: SHREE CEMENTS LTD - 2 X 150 MW - CFBC
0
PASS -0B 200 400 600
Secondary Current, mA
800 1000 1200 1400
•There is no
substitute for the
building of
1 maximum reliability
into the precipitator
designs
• The economic advantages
to be gained by
improvements in
reliability design vary,
2 dependent on the specific
process characteristics
and even the attitudes of
personnel at plants
• Elimination of stack puffs and
upset conditions is the goal
of all. However, this goal will
not be achieved within
reasonable precipitator sizes
3 unless concerted efforts are
made by regulatory,
manufacturer and user
groups to work toward
understanding the basic
problems
In its simplest expression, a green