Robert J. Snyder, DPM, MSC, Cws Professor and Director of Clinical Research Barry University SPM
Robert J. Snyder, DPM, MSC, Cws Professor and Director of Clinical Research Barry University SPM
1. Ischemia = peripheral
arterial disease (PAD)
Malperfusion results in…
1. Ischemia… all ischemic wounds are
hypoxic
Chronic underlying
ischemia
Marston WA, et al. Natural history of limbs with
arterial insufficiency and chronic ulceration treated
without revascularization. J Vasc Surg 2006; 44:108-
114.
Microcirculatory dysfunction
exacerbates wound ischemia
No response to painful stimuli
Microvascular Arterial Occlusive Disease
Hypoxic Wound
Center
Zone of Tissue
Injury
Normally Perfused
And Oxygenated
Periwound Tissue
Partially Corrected Periwound
Hypoxia
Hypoxic Wound
Center
Zone of Tissue
Injury
Malperfused but
Hyperoxygenated
Periwound Tissue
We want to screen for, identify,
and intervene when possible…
1. Peripheral arterial
disease (PAD)…
Macrovascular Disease
2. Hypoxia…Microvascular Disease,
Edema, etc.
Key Concepts:
The assessment of vasculature requires a holistic
approach. Symptoms, signs, or investigations
taken in isolation can be misleading
The presence of a venous disease, for example,
does not imply that an ulcer is of purely venous
etiology. The patient may have a co-existing
arterial disease
In a similar analogy, the presence of a dorsalis
pulse does not rule out co-existing arterial disease
Investigation of Arterial Disease
Specific risk factors for atherosclerosis such as
diabetes mellitus, smoking, and
hypercolesterolemia should be assessed
Chest pain suggestive of ischemic heart disease,
weakness, falls, or dysrhythmias possibly related to
cerebrovascular accidents should also be assessed
for general vascular status
Vascular episodes outside the limbs are associated
with vascular disease within the limbs
Intermittent claudication
Caused by insufficient blood supply in
the presence of increased demand
created by the leg muscles as the
patient exercises
Indicative of mild to moderate PVD
Rest Pain
Represents end-stage PAD
Typically occurs in the toes or foot at night (however, can occur
anywhere in the lower limb)
Elevation of the legs to the same level as the heart (or above) while
sleeping causes a fall in the arterial pressure, which was previously
aided by the forces of gravity in the standing or sitting position (Leg
elevation exacerbates symptoms!)
Rest pain is thus characteristically relieved by swinging the legs
over the side of the bed or by standing (or treatment chair in your
office!)
Some patients will sleep in a chair to circumvent the symptoms
Physical Examination
Inspection
Tissue loss
Palpation
When foot ulcers are present
Auscultation in patients with diabetes
“Time is Tissue”
Vascular
Evaluate pedal pulses, popliteal, femoral( if necessary): DP absent in
8.1% of healthy individuals; PT in 2%.
CFT < 3 sec
Hair growth; trophic skin changes; fissures; thickened toenails
Skin temperature warm to warm, distal to proximal B/L lower
extremity (Cold to warm, or cold to cold could indicate PAD)
Always examine for temperature with the back of your hand
Temperature can also be measured with a thermal thermometer; In
patients with diabetes, a 4 degree difference in temperature from one
foot to the other may indicate increased risk of foot ulcer
Vascular
Hand held Doppler (triphasic, biphasic, monophasic, absent)
Ankle-Brachial Index/ABI (0.9-1.29)
If ABI >1.29 ( often seen in patients with diabetes as “pipe-stem”
arteries indicating medial calcinosis); perform Toe Brachial Index/TBI
(not affected by medial calcinosis)
Edema; lymphedema; lipodema
If hyperemia is present, lift the leg to see if there is pallor on elevation
(Burger’s sign) and intense rubor on dependency( seen in an ischemic
limb)
Diagnosing Peripheral Arterial Occlusive
Disease (PAOD): Complete Physical
Examination
Visual inspection:
Skin
Hair
Nails
Pulse examination
Palpable
ABI (or TBI in some diabetics)
Provocative Tests (pathophysiology
deliberately induced i.e. reactive
hyperemia, treadmill )
Oxygenation and Perfusion Testing
Transcutaneous Oxygen
Skin Perfusion Pressures
Diagnosing Peripheral Arterial Disease (PAOD):
Complete Physical Examination
Pain
Pulselessness
Pallor
Parasthesias Poikilothermia,
Paralysis the inability to maintain a
constant core temperature independent of ambient temperature
loss of thermoregulation
Vascular
Vascular
Vascular
Vascular – Pedal Pulses
Vascular
Macrovascular Assessment
1. Hand-held Doppler/Ankle-Brachial Index (ABI)
2. Pulse Volume Recording (PVR)
3. Arterial duplex
4. Vascular consult for angiogram(CTA;MRA;CO2;
contrast angiogram)
Vascular
Microvascular Assessment
Toe-brachial index (TBI)
Photoplethysmography (PPG)
TcpO2
Skin Perfusion Pressure (SPP)
Peripheral Arterial Disease(PAD)
Affects 10 million Americans
Caused by arteriosclerosis
Can begin in the lower extremities but usually is more
generalized with lesions at multiple sites (vasculopath)
Increases risk of stroke and MI
An abnormal ABI could alert the physician to “at risk”
patients for stroke and MI
PAD: 5 year prognosis
20% will experience a non fatal stroke or MI
30% will succumb to a fatal event
Patients with Critical Limb Ischemia (CLI)
30% will require an amputation
20% willNot
be dead in 6 months
all patients with PAD are symptomatic
There are 160,000 amputations performed in the US at a cost of 10 billion
dollars (i.e. intermittent claudication, rest pain)
The Society of Interventional Radiologist reported that the Framingham
risk score (FRS) combined with the ABI could identify 45% of patients at
risk that were originally thought not to be
CONCLUSION:
Measurement of the ABI may improve the accuracy of cardiovascular risk prediction
beyond the FRS.
Ankle-Brachial Index Collaboration: Ankle-brachial index combined with Framingham risk score to predict cardiovascular events and
mortality: a meta-analysis. JAMA . 300(2): 197-208. 2008
When to “Escalate” the Vascular
Assessment
1. Abnormal pulse exam or abnormal ABI, TBI, SPP
2. Eschar or significant necrosis
3. Multiple ulcers on the foot or leg
4. Ulcer on the foot of a diabetic
Macrovascular Tests
Ankle-Brachial Index (ABI)
Diagnosing Peripheral Arterial Disease (PAOD):
Lower Extremity Arterial Circulation
Auscultate lower
extremity pulses with a
8-10 MHz Doppler
Doppler Waveform Analysis
Triphasic Flow
Rapid antegrade
flow during
systole
Transient reverse
flow in early
diastole
Slow antegrade
flow in late Stenosis Induced Changes
diastole •Decreased rate of rise of the antegrade flow
•A reduced amplitude of the forward velocity
•Loss of reverse flow ('biphasic' waveform)
•Severe stenosis result in a monophasic
waveform
Calculating the ABI
To calculate the Ankle Brachial index, divide the
highest ankle pressure by the highest arm
pressure.
Early
diastole
Late
Systole diastole
Baseline
Biphasic
Considered healthy but mildly abnormal
May be caused by compensatory vasodilatation from inflammation or
exercise
Could represent the initial effect on a waveform in the presence of
arterial obstruction
Sound: “one-two” rather than “one, two, three”
Waveform: The second component, representing flow reversal
(diastolic downstroke), is lost
Antegrade systole
blunted;
Retrograde diastole
lost
Monophasic
Abnormal
Sound: Only one component
Waveform: Rounded peak
Rounded peaks
Use of Ankle Brachial Index
(ABI) in Diagnosing PAD
When compared to angiography, ABI
95% sensitive
100% specific (almost)
May be falsely negative in patients with
calcified, poorly compressible vessels
May be falsely negative in symptomatic
patients with moderate aortoiliac stenosis
Eliminate some of the false negatives
Exercise Testing
Toe brachial index (TBI)
Wound Healing Prognostic Value of
Ankle and Toe Pressure
Apelqvist et al. (Diabetes Care. 1989)
314 diabetic pts with foot ulcers.
Higher Ankle/Toe pressures in healers vs non-
healers (p <.001)
None healed with ankle pressure < 40 mmHg
Ankle pressure upper limit of healed group
could not be defined.
ABI and Wound Healing Predictions
ABI vs. Wound Healing is not correlated in diabetics and chronic renal
failure patients
Normal
Study
Right distal
SFA disease
Arterial Duplex
Arterial Duplex
Helps localize and grade the vascular disease
Not a screening test( can take 1-2 hours)
Often used in conjunction with traditional PVR and
segmental limb pressures
The peak systolic velocity determined by Doppler
ultrasound is an index of the percent diameter
reduction in the artery tested
Waveform Criteria
The type of waveform observed depends on the
severity of arterial diameter reduction
0%-19% reduction Triphasic waveform
20%-49% reduction Biphasic
50%-99% reduction Monophasic
Total occlusion No waveform
Color Doppler of the Lower
Extremities
Only qualitative
May “light up” potential trouble spots
Pulsed Doppler should be performed during any
arterial examination when quantitative information is
required
Color Doppler
The greater the amount of light absorbed by the blood cells, the
greater is the amount of blood in the area and, therefore, the
higher the amplitude of the PPG waveform displayed. It also
indicates that perfusion to the site is more normal.
How PPG is used?
PPG is used to assess the amount of blood in tissue at a
burn site, around a skin lesion, or to evaluate the
probable healing power of tissue at a proposed surgical
site
The blood flow is represented in a waveform format.
The Dicrotic Notch corresponds to the transient
increase in aortic pressure
upon closure of the aortic valves
Toe Pressures are controversial
Carter and Tate:
Toe pressures may reflect the overall obstruction in the arterial tree proximal to the
digits and are unaffected by arterial incompressibility
Toe pressures of 40mmHg or less correlated with severe deterioration such as tissue
loss, rest pain, and gangrene
The presence of diabetes increased the odds ratio for rest pain, skin lesions, or both
after controlling for systolic pressures and wave amplitude.
In summary:
Rest pain, skin lesions, or both were present in approximately 50% of limbs with toe
pressures less than or equal to 30 mmHg, in 16% of those with pressures of 31-40 mmHg,
and in 5% of limbs with arterial disease and toe pressure greater than 40 mmHg
Ramsey et al:
Toe pressure measurements had an average sensitivity of 85% with a specificity of
88% in asymptomatic limbs and 89% and 86% for ischemic limbs
They concluded that toe pressures of 30 mmHg indicated good healing potential;
ankle pressure < 80 mmHg were associated with poor healing
Ankle-Brachial Index Collaboration: Ankle-brachial index combined with Framingham risk score to predict cardiovascular
events and mortality: a meta-analysis. JAMA . 300(2): 197-208. 2008
Issues With PAD/CLI
Diagnosis and Standard Tests
Issue 1. Incompressible vessels render arterial occlusion
difficult, non-repeatable or even impossible
Issue 2. Distal occlusions
Issue 3. Unpredictability of toe as measurement site for
estimating distal perfusion
Issue 4. Separation of vascular from non-vascular causes of low
PtcO2
Toe as a Measurement Site
Toe pressures are painful in the
ischemic toe and plainly
impossible in certain cases.
0 mmHg
Predictive Accuracy of PtcO2
(Franceck, et al, 1989)
PtcO2
Diabetic wounds 31/34 (91%)
Non Diabetic wounds 22/22 (100%)
Arterial Doppler
Diabetic wounds 14/37 (37%)
Non Diabetics 7/22 (77%)
X
X
Accuracy of measurement
at these sites will
Plantar Foot
be dependent upon
the thickness of
the Stratum
Corneum…may
be obtainable in
40-50% of X
cases, worth a try
but limited by technology
X
in the same
way that
SPP may also be affected
by very think SC limiting
laser penetration.
Skin Perfusion Pressure (SPP)
SPP is measured in the
Microcirculation
Diagram of the
microcirculation where laser
Doppler detection occurs
during SPP measurement.
Note nutritional capillaries,
arteriovenous shunts, and the
sub-papillary venous plexus.
SPP Graph
SPP Interpretation Guideline
(in mmHg)
30 or less = Critical Limb Ischemia and the wound is
unlikely to heal