Scribd
Upload
23 views

Zimbardo Lesson 3

- Research into conformity has studied how individuals conform to group norms and pressures. Studies like those by Asch and Zimbardo examined how participants conformed in experimental settings and adopted negative social roles. - Conformity research has limitations in terms of lacking ecological validity since experiments are conducted in artificial lab settings rather than real world situations. Cultural and historical biases may also influence findings. - Improving ecological validity through field experiments can help address these limitations by observing natural behavior. Critically evaluating findings in relation to cultural and historical contexts can also help account for potential biases.

Uploaded by

ali
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
Available Formats
Download as PPTX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
23 views

Zimbardo Lesson 3

- Research into conformity has studied how individuals conform to group norms and pressures. Studies like those by Asch and Zimbardo examined how participants conformed in experimental settings and adopted negative social roles. - Conformity research has limitations in terms of lacking ecological validity since experiments are conducted in artificial lab settings rather than real world situations. Cultural and historical biases may also influence findings. - Improving ecological validity through field experiments can help address these limitations by observing natural behavior. Critically evaluating findings in relation to cultural and historical contexts can also help account for potential biases.

Uploaded by

ali
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
Available Formats
Download as PPTX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 33

Q

UIZ
• W hat is the d efi n it io n of conform ity?

• What ar e the 3 t y pes of confor mity?

• What ar e 2 explanations of conf ormity?

• What p er cent age of p pt's conform ed in the majority of the clinical trials in

Asch's stu dy?

• Name 3 evaluat i on p oint s for Asch's stu dy

• W hat is on e st udy ( ot her than Asch) into conformity?


100
90
80

I 70 ''
''
t
.I
60
50
''
'
'' '
- HI MSE
- • - Low MSE
''
J 40
30
' '' \

' \
20
\
10
0
The following phrases refer to different types of conformity.

Select the two phrases that describe internalisation. l i c k t w o boxes


only.

D
A The deepest level of conformity.

B The individual conforms publicly with the rest of


the group but may privately disagree with them.

D
C The beliefs of the group become part of the individual's
own belief system.

D The individual goes along with the group but does


not agree with them.

D
E The individual changes his / her beliefs, but ii is a
temporary change.
Outline one method that psychologists have used to study conformity.

(2)

Explain one limitation of this method.

(2)

Suggest an appropriate way of overcoming this limitation.

(2)
(Total 6 mar1<o)
The most likely method offered is an experiment (such as those carried out by Asch);
however, other methods are also credit-worthy (observations, role-plays). 1 mark for
identification of the method and a further mark for elaboration; laboratory experiment (1
mark) where confederates deliberately gave the wrong answer to see if the na'ive
participant conformed (further mark for elaboration). Candidates could either refer to a
research method in general, or they could describe the procedures of a particular study
for 2 marks.
It is worth noting that sometimes a very brief or succinct answer can still be sufficient
for
2 marks.

[If a response for (a) gains no marks, marks can be awarded for (b) and / or (c) if the
limitation and way of overcoming it could apply to conformity research).

(b) A03 = 2

The limitation will depend on the method given in (a). Lab experiments lack ecological
validity (1 mark) this means that the findings cannot be generalised to the real world
(further mark for elaboration).
It is worth noting that sometimes a very brief or succinct answer can still be sufficient for
2 marks.

(c) A03 = 2

To overcome lack of ecological validity conduct the experiment in the real world (1 mark)
by setting up a field experiment so people behave as they would do normally (1 further
mark).
IMPLICATIONS OF RESEARCH INTO CONFORMITY TO
SOCIAL ROLES...

Zimbardo believed that theguard's drift into sadi stic behaviour was an
aut om at ic consequence of them embracing their roles, this st op p ed
them from seeing that their behaviour was wrong

Reicher & Haslam believe that behaviour is dependent on the norms and
values associ at ed w it h their specific social ident it y.
Outline and evaluate research into conformity.
(Total 12 marils)
Marks for this question: A01 = 6 , A03 =
6
Level Marks Description

Knowledge is acx:urate and generally well detailed.


Discussion / evaluation / application is effective. The
4 10 - 12 answer is clear, coherenl Speciailst terminology Is used
effectively. Minor detail and I or expansion of argument
sometimes lacking.

Knowledge is evident. There are occasional


inacx:uracies . There Is some effective discussion /
3 7 -9 evaluation / application. The answer is mosUy clear and
organised.
Specialist terminology is mostly used appropriately.

Knowledge is present. Focus Is mainly on description.


Any discussion/ evaluation / application is of limited
2 4-6 effectiveness. The answer lacks clarity, acx:uracy and
organisation in places. Specialist terminology is used
inappropriatelyon occasions.

Knowledge is limited. Discussion / evaluation /


application ls limited, poorly focused or absent. The
1 1- 3 answer as a whole lacks clarity, has many inaccuracies
and is poorly organised . Specialist terminology is either
absent or inappropriately used.

0 No relevant content.
A01

Candidates may offer any research that is relevant to conformity. The most likely studies
are those by Asch, Crutchfield, Sherif, Perrin and Spencer; but any other relevant study
is creditworthy. Zimbardo'sprison study investigated conforming to social roles and is
also creditworthy.

A03

The evaluation may be in terms of methodological issues such as the artificiality of


laboratoryresearch; cultural and historical bias; ethical issues. For example, Asch's
studies were carried out in America in the 1950s and have been criticized as only being
relevant to that particular culture and in that historical time. When Perrin and Spencer
replicated Asch's study they did not find such high levels of conformity.

You might also like