Prof. (DR.) Nirmal Kanti Chakrabarti
Prof. (DR.) Nirmal Kanti Chakrabarti
Prof. (DR.) Nirmal Kanti Chakrabarti
Politicality
Specificity
Uniformity
Penal sanction
Conceptualizing Criminal Justice
Aim of the administration of criminal justice is that
the guilty should be detected, convicted and duly
sentenced.
Criminal justice administration concerns the
procedures by which the substantive criminal laws are
actually implemented.
Types of Criminal Justice System
1.Inquisitorial System: In inquisitorial system an
extensive investigation and interrogations carried out
under control and supervision of Court to ensure that
innocent person is not subjected to trial. The
defendants has the burden of proving innocence.
2. Adversarial System : Under adversarial system an
accused is presumed not guilty and the prosecution is
to prove beyond all reasonable doubt the guilt of the
accused. This system presumes that the best way to get
the truth is to have a “contest” between the
prosecution and the defence.
Models of Criminal Justice Process
Herbert L. Packer: Two Models-
A. Crime Control Model- that criminal conduct
must be kept under tight control in order to preserve
public order.
B. Due Process Model- It protect an accused from
coercive easily abused power of the state
John Griffith-Family Model- an offender would be
treated as a person with respect and the role of the
society is to perceive an crime occurrence as criminal
deviance and reacting to it accordingly.
Constitutional Rights of Defendants
Art.20. Protection in respect of conviction and
punishment under an ex post facto criminal
legislation.
Doctrine of Double Jeopardy
Right against self- incrimination
Art.21. Protection of Life and Personal Liberty
Art.22. Protection against arrest and detention
Role of Judges
Pre-arrest judicial role
Pre-trial judicial role
Judicial role at trial stage
Judicial role in sentencing
decision:
(i) Why punish? How much to punish?
(ii) Justifying punishment
(iii) Sentencing discretion
(iv) Admonition and Probation
PLEABARGAINING
Sec.265A of Cr.P.C.- police Report u/s. 173 where
punishment is not death penalty, imprisonment for
life or exceeding
7years
Not applicable where offence
affects the socio-economic condition of the
country or committed against a woman or
A child below14years.
Guidelines u/s 265C to L
Pre-sentence hearing
The Judge shall hear
the accused on the
question of sentence
unless proceeds u/s
360.
Santa Singh v. State
Of Punjab
Plea-bargaining
Punishment
Death Sentence
Imprisonment
Fine
Confiscation of Property
Correction /Probation
Use of Discretion in Decision
Making Process
Gathering information
Validating information
Taking risks
Screening options
Making decision –
Deterrent,
Preventive or
Reformative
Correctional Administration &
Rehabilitation
Admonition
Probation
Juvenile Justice
Correction in
Prison
VICTIM JUSTICE
The word victim defined in Cr. P.C.(s.2.wa)
Victim’s right to participate in the process
Special protections to rape victim
Victim’s right to get compensation
Victims right to appeal
Challenges to CJA
Hydra-headed justice system
Huge pending cases
Delay in justice process
Delay in getting Forensic Report
Sentencing disparity
Misuse of discretionary powers
Thank you