Ground Improvement Tehnique: Issues, Methods and Their Selection
Ground Improvement Tehnique: Issues, Methods and Their Selection
Ground Improvement Tehnique: Issues, Methods and Their Selection
Dr. J.N.Jha,
Professor and Head (Civil Engineering),
Guru Nanak Dev Engineering College,
Ludhiana, Punjab-141006
Present Day Scenario
•Densification
•Consolidation
•Weight reduction
•Reinforcement
•Chemical treatment
•Thermal stabilization
•Electrotreatment
•Biotechnical stabilization
Ground Improvement by Densification
Methods of Application :
Vibrocompaction
Dynamic Compaction
Blasting
Compaction Grouting
10-20 Good
20-30 Fair
30-50 Poor
>50 Unsuitable
Comparison of CPT Test
CPT Test Performed Before Densification of CPT Test Performed After Densification of
Sand Fills Sand Fills
Dynamic Compaction
Repeated lifting and Dropping
of Weight at a location
Tamping Weight
(Concrete/Cast iron/Steel)-
80 to 120 kN
Ht. of Drop- 10 to 15m
No. of drops (same location)-
8 to 12 times
Formation of Crater like
Depression-Filled with Extra Soil
Process Repeated- Grid Pattern at
a spacing of 2-4 m
Densification of Soil- 4-8m below
GL
In-Situ Dynamic Compaction
Blasting
Weight of Charge(Rough Guideline)- W= 164CR3
W = Weight of Explosive (N)
C = Coefficient (0.0025 for 60% detonator)
R = Radius of influence (m)
Arrangement of Explosive- Grid Pattern
Firing Pattern – From outside to inside
First Blast- At the corner of Periphery Line of First Grid from outside
Second Blast – At the Centre of Periphery Line of First Grid from outside
Third Blast - At the corner of Periphery Line of Second Grid from outside
Spacing – 3 to 8 m (Less than 3 generally avoided)
Depth of Stratum to be densified – 10m or less
•Depth of Explosive- 2/3 of depth
•Compaction - In one tier only
Depth of Stratum to be densified – More than 10m
•Depth of Charge – Greater than Radius of Sphere of Influence (R)
•Compaction- More than one Tier
Materials & Equipments
Dynamite sticks.
Electric detonator.
Drilling equipment.
Backfill material (Sand).
Waterproof packets.
Method
Series of boreholes are drilled and Pipe of 7.5 to 10 cm is driven to
the required depth
Dynamite sticks and detonator are wrapped in a water proof bundle
and is lowered through casings
Casing is withdrawn and a wad of paper or wood is placed against
the charge of Explosive (To protect it from misfire)
Boreholes are backfilled with sand to obtain full force of blast
Electric circuit is closed to fire the charge
The charge is fired in definite pattern
For deeper deposits blast is done in stages
Repeated shots are more affective than single larger one
Each successive blast in a given area will cause less densification
than the one preceding
Top 1m surface get disturbed and needs surface compaction
Compaction Grouting
Step -1 Predrilled Compaction Grouting hole to
desired depth
Step-2 Insert Compaction Grouting Casing in
Predrilled hole
Step-3 Begin Pumping Low Slump Compaction
Grout Mix in Stages and withdraw at
Controlled rate
Step-4 Withdraw casing as stages are complete
until the hole is complete
Key Issues Affecting Densification
Key Issues :
Percent of fines in the soil,
Ability of the soil to dissipate excess pore
water pressure,
Energy felt by the soil,
Presence of boulders, utilities and adjacent
structures, and
Mysterious phenomenon of ageing.
Presence of Fines
Methods of application:
Graphite Electrode
Metallic Electrodes
Shapes of Electrodes
Connecting Wires
DC Current Source
Flow of Water under Electro-osmosis
Advantages and Limitations
Advantages Limitations
• Practical application limited
Can be used for dewatering of
silty and clayey soils which are since very costly.
difficult to drain by gravity. • Before actual application on
Method is fast and instantaneous. site Laboratory tests and site
Environment-friendly method tests are imperative.
Equipments required are few in • Huge amount of electricity.
number and easy to carry to the
site. needed
Method useful for all types of • Highly skilled labour needed
soils. • Electrodes replacement needed
Efficiency of this method is very from time to time.
high.
Less man-power required to • Method becomes ineffective If
implement this method. the moisture content of the soil
is extremely low
Vacuum consolidation
Vacuum consolidation,
Both liquid and gas (water and air) are extracted from the
ground by suction
This Suction is induced by the creation of vacuum on the
ground surface and assisted by a system of vertical and
horizontal drains
Vacuum is applied to the pore phase in a sealed membrane
system
The vacuum causes water to drain out from the soil and
creates negative pore water pressure in the soil
This leads to an increase in effective stress to the magnitude
of the induced negative pore water pressure, without the
increase of total stress
•For rapid pre-consolidation,
vertical drains (Prefabricated
Vertical Drains) along with
the vacuum preloading are
used
•Vertical drains helps to
distribute the vacuum
pressures to the deeper
layers and drain out water
from the sub soil
•Vacuum preloading with
PVD substantially reduces
the lateral displacement and
potential shear failure
•Maximum achievable
vacuum pressure in the field
is only about 80kPa
Schematic view vacuum consolidation technique
Advantages of Vacuum preloading technique
over the Surcharge preloading technique
•Ground improvement with vacuum preloading does not
require any fill material and there is no need of heavy
machinery
•Construction period is generally shorter
•The increase in effective stress under vacuum preloading is
isotropic. Therefore, the corresponding lateral displacement
is in the inward direction and there is no risk of shear failure
•Application of Vacuum Preloading improves Bearing
capacity of soil by 100% in the case of soft clays and
eliminates 70% of the total estimated settlement of design
load
•The overall cost of vacuum preloading is only about 2/3rd of
that with surcharge preloading
Ground Improvement by Consolidation
Methods of Application:
Placing lightweight materials over the native
soil in one of three ways:
• Spread in a loose form, then compacted
• Cut in block forms, then stacked according to a
certain arrangement, or
• Pumped in a flowable liquid form
Lightweight material used for ground
improvement
Fill Material Source/Process Dry Unit Weight
(kg/m3)
Wood fibers Sawed lumber waste 550 – 960
Shredded tire Mechanically cut tire chips 600 – 900
Dredged underwater
Clam shells 1100 – 1200
deposits
Expanded shale Vitrified shale or clay 600 – 1040
Fly ash Residue of burned coal 1120 – 1400
Air-cooled slag Blast furnace material 1100 – 1500
Foaming agent in a concrete
Flowable fill 335 – 770
matrix
Block molded expanded
Geofoam 12 – 32
polystyrene
key Issues (Weight Reduction Method)
Key Issues:
Soil-grout compatibility and reactivity,
Operational parameters,
Column verticality, and
Weathering effects
Soil-grout compatibility and reactivity
The type of grout used and the make-up of the grout mix are
dependent on the properties of the ground
In permeation grouting, the principal parameter affecting
permeation is the size of the intergranular voids, usually
represented by the soil’s coefficient of permeability
Success of jet grouting is influenced by ground characteristics
such as the size and frequency of boulders, and the presence of
peat or organic materials
In lime columns, the feasibility of stabilization and the amount
of lime needed for pozzolanic reaction are influenced by the
type of soil being treated
Operational parameters
• All deep chemical treatment methods are operator-sensitive and
their success depends on operational parameters controlled by
the construction crew
• Both the strength and the permeability of the treated mass are
influenced by
Net amount of cement in the ground (controlled volumes of
cement, water and additives mixed at the grout plant or at the
top of the deep mix auger)
By the level of the soil-grout mixing achieved in situ
•In deep soil mixing, the grout flow is usually adjusted constantly to
accommodate varying drill speeds in different soil strata
•Diameter of the column is a function of operating parameters,
such as injection pressure, grout flow, and rod withdrawal and
rotation rates
• In case of fracture grouting the grout mix is adjusted by the operator
to provide the required performance(performance-type specifications)
Column verticality
• The verticality of the constructed column is an important issue in
jet grouting, particularly when used to construct fluid barriers
• Multiple rows of overlapped columns are usually designed when
used for construction of a cut-off wall, on the basis of the
assumed permeability of the jet grouted column
• When two adjacent columns deviate from their vertical
alignments in opposite directions, the required column
overlapping may not materialize, and voids may develop in the
jet grout wall rendering it ineffective as a cut-off wall
• The verticality and overlapping of columns are less of an issue in
deep soil mixing since the columns are constructed to fixed
diameters and the overlapping is ensured by the construction
process
Weathering effects
Methods of Application:
Electrokinetic remediation
Electroheating
Electrokineting fencing
Bioelectrokinetic injection
(a)Ground,
(b)Groundwater
(c)Construction considerations including schedule,
materials, accessibility, right-of- way, equipment and
labor
(d) environmental concerns,
(e) durability, maintenance and operational requirements
(f) contracting, politics and tradition,
(g) cost
Thank you...............
Waste Containment with Geosynthetics
Large quantities of waste are being produced
since 1990 due to Rapid industrialisation and
Excessive urbanisation
Waste needs to be disposed off and only disposal
bin is ground and it occupies large chunk of land.
One million ton of municipal solid waste
occupies approximately one million square meter
(One square kilometer of land area when waste is
spread uniformly with a thickness of one meter)
Other problem associated with waste disposal
Source of pollution
Contaminates the soil beneath the waste
Contaminates the ground water as
contaminants travel from the solid waste to
the subsurface environment
Other sources of subsurface contamination