Strategy Management: Strategy Analysis of Garuda Indonesia
Strategy Management: Strategy Analysis of Garuda Indonesia
Strategy Management: Strategy Analysis of Garuda Indonesia
GROUP MEMBERS:
1. CUSTOMERS
First Class
Economy Class
2. VALUE PROPOSITION
3. CHANNELS
4. CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP
6. KEY RESOURCES
Finance:
Physical:
Intellectual:
Human Resources:
Support Activities
Human Resources
Support Activities
Information Technology
Support Activities
Procurement & Logistic System
Primary Activities
Marketing & Sales
One of marketing
activities conducted by
the Company is the
Garuda Indonesia
Travel Fair.
GATF is Garuda
Indonesias annual
exhibition held in
various regions with
its peak in Jakarta.
Primary Activities
Service
8. KEY PARTNERS
Airbus & Boeing
They are Garudas key partners and also suppliers, they provide
airplane and its spareparts
Garuda Indonesia has more than 1000 partners all around the world,
some of them are:
9. COST
(cont.)
SOURCE OF COMPETITIVE
ADVANTAGE
1. INTERNAL
Human resources
Corporate culture that will encourage the
creation of a conducive working environment
Service
Provides First Class Lounge service
Logistics and Operation
Joint Procurement that support the effectiveness
and maintain the quality standards
(cont.)
Information Technology
Completing the Integrated Contact Center to support passenger
services in comply with the SkyTeam standard
External
Competitors
Garuda has either local or international competitors that operate
the same route with them
Customers
Customers or target market of Garuda Indonesia are very wide spread.
Market Trends
World market trends now are moving extremely. Because of the economic crisis,
now people are preferred to travel in short haul more than long haul. Short haul
mean people are travel in regional around the country.
Potential Limitation
There are a lot of potential limitations to make
success this project.
Time Consuming
Budget
Technology Integration
Internal Assessment
Barriers to Entry
The aviation industry in Indonesia in 2013 is still considered prospective, in line with the economic
growth and the increase in purchasing power. The increasing demand for air travel has prompted
many airlines companies to join the competition in Indonesian aviation industry. More affordable
ticket prices, as well as more choice of airlines, have made more and more Indonesian people
choose flight as the main mode of transportation. So we can say that the barriers to entry this
industry is low.
Availability of Substitutes.
In the aviation industry in Indonesia theres no perfect substitutes. Because Indonesia is an
archipelago state, it will be hard to travel from island to island by trains, cars, or buses. Well, ship
can be an option but it will took a too much time even though the tickets are cheaper. Since airplane
tickets now are more affordable, and travelling by airplane is so much faster and the passenger will
not get tired on the way to their destinations, customers prefer to travels by airplanes than ships. It is
for domestic route. As for international routes, of course airplane is very preferable.
Power of Supplier
Supplier power in the airline industry is high as there are only a handful of suppliers. Additionally,
aircrafts must be ordered far in advance. The airlines company has only two primary choices for
supply of their jets which is either the Airbus or Boeing. Due to this reason, the supplier has
significant power. The long term nature of these purchases creates a long-term relationship whereby
the airline is often motivated to purchase the same kind of jets always.
Power of Buyer
Power of buyers is significantly high in the airline
industry. This is because consumers are given the
privilege of searching for the lowest flights available on
the internet and to complete the transaction without an
intermediary. Buyer power increases because of this
reason.
SWOT ANALYSIS
SWOT Analysis
Strength
SWOT Analysis
Weakness
Financial problem
US $1.2 milliard estimated to go down 18%
because of the decline of sales.
SWOT Analysis
Opportunities
SWOT Analysis
Threat
VERTICAL INTEGRATION
MARKET INTENSIVE
DIVERSIFICATION
Related
Unrelated
MATRIX(ES)
Weight
Garuda Indonesia
Lion Air
Rating
Weighted Rating
Score
Rating
Weighted Rating
Score
Technology
0.15
0.60
0.60
Advertising
0.05
0.20
0.20
Price
0.13
0.26
0.39
Facility
0.12
0.36
0.36
Services
0.25
0.75
0.50
Flight Route
0.03
0.09
0.09
On Time
0.10
0.20
0.10
Security
0.17
0.51
0.17
TOTAL
2.97
2.41
BCG MATRIX
Garuda Indonesia control in 50% market domestic
airplane. Due to expand in customer service and
business relations with other airline companies,
Garuda Indonesia become an important domain in
International Market. For give services in the largest
market, Garuda Indonesia has 40 branches company
in Indonesia , 38 branches company in which the
other country, and 13 representative office. Also
Garuda Indonesia has 30 route y aviation and 24
route international aviation.
SPACE MATRIX
Financial Position (FP)
Ratings
liquidity
Assets turnover
Total
13
Ratings
Profit Potential
Recourse Utilization
Leader In Innovation
Total
14
Ratings
-2
-3
Economical condition
-2
Total
-7
Ratings
-4
-2
-3
Total
-9
Constructing Matrix
FP Average is 13 : 4 =
3,25
IP Average is 14 : 4 =
3,25
SP Average is -7 : 3 =
-2.33
CP Average is -9 : 3 = -3
Directional Vector
Coordinate :
o
FP
CP
0,2
5
IP
0,9
2
SP
Conclusion
After we calculate the average of each position and also found the x and y
coordinate, we get that the line is in the top right side. It means the most
appropriate strategy for APLN is aggressive strategy.
Key Factors
Weight
AS
TAS
AS
TAS
Opportunities
Member of Skyteam Global Alliance
0.20
0.80
0.80
Threats
Recovery process of Europe
Weakening of The US economy
High domestic inflation
Weakening of Rupiah against foreign currencies
0.25
0.25
0.15
0.15
3
3
_
2
0.90
0.90
_
0.20
2
2
3
3
0.50
0.50
0.45
0.30
0.75
0.90
1.00
Strength
Migrated to the new PSS system called Altea
Usage of SkyTeam networks
0.25
0.30
3
3
0.75
0.90
3
3
Weakness
Expensive Price
Lack of human resource
Need more pilot
Customer relationship problem
Financial problem
Total
0.05
0.10
0.05
0.05
0.20
1.00
_
_
_
2
3
_
_
_
0.10
0.60
5.15
_
_
_
3
2
0.15
0.40
4.75
Strength
Weight
Rating
Weighted
Rating
Score
1.
0.15
0.2
2.
0.05
0.15
3.
0.15
0.45
4.
Aircraft Maintenance
Management Division
0.1
0.4
No.
Weakness
Weighted
Rating
Weighted
Rating Score
1.
0.05
0.10
2.
0.15
0.15
3.
0.05
0.05
4.
Customer relationship
problem
0.10
0.10
5.
Financial problem
0.2
0.4
TOTAL
2.00
Weight
Rating
Economic Development
0.20
0.80
International Market
0.10
0.30
High - Technology
0.15
0.45
0.15
0.60
Competitive environment
0.15
0.45
0.10
0.30
Political Condition
0.05
0.10
THREAT
Total
3.00
Garuda Indonesia prescription for divisions that fall into cells II, since
EFE is 3.00 and IFE 2.00.
Garuda Indonesia can use grow and build strategy.
SWOT Matrix
Opportunity
Strengt
h
Diversific
ation
Weakne
ss
Threat
INTERNAL/EXTERNAL
STRENGTH
WEAKNESS
1.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
2.
3.
OPPORTUNITIES
1.
2.
3.
STRATEGY S-O
The inscreasing
1.
economi growth
The new fleet ranks
supported leading edge
technology and fuelefficient
potential in the
international market will
be more powerful when 2.
combined with the
company global alliance
STRATEGY W-O
Recruitment cockpit,
cabin crew and pilots to
avoid further delays to
the Garuda Indonesia
flight schedule and can
increase the number of
its flights.
Threat
Strategy S-T
Strategy W-T
1.
1.
2.
Political situation
of a country or
place, can affect
the procurement
route to the venue
Land and sea
transport
equipment
cheaper than
airplanes
2.
Application of the
new IBE to remain
competitive with its
other
transportation
services
Do CRM
development
company to
maintain user
loyalty Garuda
Indonesia flight
services
3.
4.
5.
Competitive conditions 3.
tend to increase the
national aviation
industry and
international as well as 4.
the application of treble
Udder space (open sky)
ASEAN secure breath.
Strong capital needed
to plunge into the
aviation industry.
Aviation industry
creditors lend funds in
large quantities and the
average in the form of
long-term debt
MARKETING
Market Segmentation
Garudas new regional jets and turboprops will compete
primarily against their competitors. While the regional jets will fly
under the main Garuda brand and operate under a full-service
regional model with dual-class configuration, the turboprops will most
likely be delivered in single-class configuration
(cont)
High Cost
MARKETING
Garuda
Market Proposition
Bad
Facility
Good Facility
Citilink
Lion Air
Low cost
Air Asia
Assets
Capital
R&D
Objectives
1. To replace core airline system (PSS);
2. To provide technology required to join the SkyTeam alliance.
3. To develop a reliable platform of technology for all area of business.
4. To facilitate in making differences for certain business area.
5. To develop IT capability to significantly improve Garudas ability to
implement various IT initiatives
Cost Contributor
IOSA (IATA Operational Safety Audit) as proves that the airline has fulfilled global best
practice in safety and security procedures.
Individual touch-screen LCD TVs for executive and economy class passengers and equipped
with Audio Video on Demand (AVoD). AVoD is an entertainment system that offers latest
movie and audio tracks at your fingertips.
Garuda Indonesia is planning to provide wireless Internet service (Wi-Fi) for their eight new
aircraft at the end of this year.
With the 24-hour pass, a passenger is also entitled to enjoy TV channels: BBC, CNN, CNBC,
Euronews and NHK.
8 Principles Of Technology
All of which are intended to support the achievement of the Company, as well as to differentiate
whenever needed.
The eight principles are:
Capabilities to applied on functions that are required to have of competitive differentiation. For
other functions, the initiatives focused on using an integrated system on a platform that has been
proven reliable and need not customization.
Developing flexible and re-usable IT architecture, and facilitate easy access for passengers to
get services and information through various channels.
Garuda
Business
Ethics Issues
Indonesia
2011 Issue
Garuda Indonesia launched Business Ethics and Work Ethic on
February 10, 2011, marked by the signing of commitment by the Board
of Directors and the Board of Commissioners, the Vice President, and
the Senior General Manager of Branch Offices. The book of Business
Ethics and Work Ethics of the Company was ratified by the President
Director Decree No. JKTDZ/ SKEP/50023/11 dated 11 March 2011.
Corporate Identity, which contains the Companys Vision and Mission, and Corporate
Values, Key Behaviours to be upheld by employees.
Commendable Behaviour, describing relation with fellow employees, customers, business
partners, shareholders, and Competitors.
Compliance, describing transparency of communication and financial information,
handling conflicts of interest, gratification control, protection of the Companys assets and
confidentiality.
Employee responsibility, describing employees responsibility towards society,
Government and Environment.
Enforcement of Business Ethics and Ethics Code, describing Whistle Blowing System
(WBS), sanctions for violations, socialization of Business Ethics and Work Ethics, the
signing of Integrity Pact by all employees.
WBS Report
In 2013, there were 63 incoming reports to the WBS
website www.ga-whistleblower.com System.
the incoming reports in 2013 can be categorized as follows:
29 unsubstantiated reports (46%)
19 complaints related to services/operations (not related to fraud or
breach of corporate ethics) (30%)
15 substantiated reports of fraud and ethics violations(24%)
From 15 substantiated reports, 9 were followed with by investigation by the
designated investigator. From the investigation, 1 report was proved and 1 was
not. Based on these data, the percentage of proved reports reaching 7% of the
total number of incoming reports through WBS.
Complaint
s
Customer
input
Investigati
on
Followed
up
Customers are the Companys major stakeholder, and therefore the Company
strives to continuously improve the quality of service to its passengers as well as
provide optimum protection for passengers. Service quality improvements are
pursued on all stages of the passenger travel chain, comprising the pre-journey,
pre/in/post flight, and post-journey stages.
Convenient Access
The Company provides a number of access to submit Customer Voice in the form of Compliment,
Suggestion and Complaint.
The accesses are:
Website GA
Suggestion Form
One of the accesses for Customer Voice is attached in the inflight magazine Garuda Indonesia,
which is the suggestion form. It is the media used to survey Garuda Indonesias customers
satisfaction.
CSR
Vision
Mission
2.
Providing soft loans to finance the working capital or the purchase of fixed assets in
order to increase production and sales,
Providing free coaching for education, training, apprenticeship, promotion and other
matters related with partners productivity and managerial improvement.
Health
Accountability
The Company seeks to report its business performance in a transparent and fair
manner, through proper and measurable administration in accordance with the
interests of the Company, while taking into account the interests of shareholders and
other stakeholders.
Independency
To further expedite the implementation of good corporate governance principles, the Company shall
be managed independently so that each companys organ does not dominate nor intervene one
another. Each organ shall not be influenced by certain partys interests, free from conflict of interest
and from any influence or pressure, so that any decisions will be made objectively.
Seat load factor reached 74.1% and aircraft utilization rate can be maintained at 10
hours 44 minutes.
Amidst the busy traffic of the airports especially Soekarno-Hatta, our On Time
Performance can be maintained at above 80%, namely 83.8%.
Operating Income grew by 7% to USD 3.72 billion compared to 2012 which stood at
USD 3.47 billion, and revenue from passenger grew by 10% to USD 2.96
Step I:
Market
Attractiveness
Assessment
Step II:
Risk of Politic/
Security
Step IV:
Industry Attractiveness
(per specific industry)
Technological
& Industry
Characteristic
Assessment
(Supply Side)
Step V:
Country Rank
& Indentifi
cation of
KSF
Organizational &
Financial
Assessment
Step VI:
Specific
Internal
Competitive
ness
Assessment
STEP II
RISK OF POLITICAL AND SECURITY IN NEW
ZEALAND
The national security system should address all significant risks to New Zealanders and the nation, so
that people can live confidently and have opportunities to advance their way of life.
National security goals should be pursued in an accountable way, which meets the Governments
responsibility to protect New Zealand, its people, and its interests, while respecting civil liberties and
the rule of law.
The principle of subsidiarity should be applied to national security decisions, which means that the
responsibility and authority for decisions, and use of resources, ordinarily rests at the level of those
closest to the risk and best able to manage it.
New Zealand should strive to maintain independent control of its own security, while acknowledging
that it also benefits from norms of international law and state behaviour which are consistent with our
values, global and regional stability, and the support and goodwill of our partners and friends.
Strong institutions
Our legal system is based on English law. The judicial system is independent and
robust. Private property rights are strongly protected, contracts are secure and
intellectual property rights are enforced.
The sound legal framework is supported by a free and independent media, ensuring
high levels of transparency in Government and corporate decision-making.
Economic underpinnings
A long term drive for diversification means that New Zealands economy, although still
powered mainly by agriculture, now also benefits from a flourishing manufacturing
sector, a thriving tourism industry, and a strong renewable energy resource base.
Conclusion
Securitisation Theory can examine the extent to which energy security
is political in New Zealand. In other words, Securitisation Theory can
examine how and why energy security has been framed in politics or as
something to be addressed by government.
SOCIO-CULTURAL INTERACTION
INVESTMENT PROCEDURE
In New Zealand has put a lot of effort to simplify the rules and taxes
also offering investors many other benefits that enhance the whole
experience of doing business
POTENTIAL OF M&A
GOVERNMENTS SUPPORT
STEP IV
Industry Attractiveness
(per specific industry)
Competition
The competition within Airline Industry in New Zealand is not really tight.
There are only a handful number of airline company which specializes
in premium flights. For Example: Air New Zealand.
Just like Garuda Indonesia, Air New Zealand offers high quality flights
with reasonable price rather than flights with cheaper price but offers
normal quality. Even though, Air New Zealand is very popular in New
Zealand itself, so it is recommended to consider it as a tough competitor
and take careful actions when trying to enter the market
Access To Technology
Technology in New Zealand is quite advanced, even better than
Indonesia. Internet and other communication technologies have already
became a normal thing in New Zealand. People book flights through the
Internet, frequent use of online tickets and also online customer
services. So in this case, technology is not a problem
Access To End-User
As stated before, there are only a handful number of airline company
which specializes in premium flights. People in New Zealand may want
to try something new. So if Garuda is able to gain attention of customer
and might as well be able to spread brand awareness among the citizen
of New Zealand, Garuda Indonesia will stand a chance.
Step VI
Specific Internal Competitiveness Assessment
Due Diligence
Control System
Procedures designed and established to
check,record,regulate,supervise,authenticate, and (if
necessary) restrict, the access to an asset,resource or
system.
Recruitment System
Step #1 Determine your ideal recruiting target the goal of this step is to determine
precisely who recruiting efforts should target, including performance level, experience level, and
whether or not they are actively looking for a job.
Step #2 Understanding your targets decision criteria a significant part of any recruiting
process is attracting desired talent, which you cannot do effectively without understanding what
your targets consider important.
Step #3 Knowing where your target hangs out having defined your target and their
decision criteria, the next step aims at identifying where you are most likely to find the target
talent, including what communication channels would be effective for recruitment messages.
Step #4 Employment branding driving a pipeline of talent is the role of employment
branding, a science-driven discipline that produces a consistent flow of qualified talent interested
in some day working for your organization.
Step #5 Learning your targets job search process at this step you implement a process
designed to identify the typical process that your target audience uses once they begin a job
search. The goal is to better understand precisely how they look for jobs, so that you can
engineer your approach to advertising opportunities to make your jobs visible to them.
Step #6 Posting jobs for active candidates because active candidates are proactively
seeking out job openings, it doesnt take a lot to make your job postings visible.
Step #7 Directly sourcing non-active prospects because non-active prospects are
not in job search mode, they are unlikely to read any job postings or to visit your corporate
career site.
Step #8 Providing prospects with additional information at this step potential
candidates have decided to consider your firm but want additional information before they decide
to actually apply.
Step #9 The job application process by this step, potential candidates have been
convinced to apply for a position, so the goal is for a large percentage of the qualified individuals
who visit the site to complete the application process.
Step #10 Sorting applications by job once applications are received, the goal is to ensure
that the highest quality applications are sorted relevant to the most appropriate jobs (manually or
via software).
Step #11 The initial screening of applications and resumes at this step applications are
screened to see if they meet minimum qualifications for the job.
Step #12 The initial phone screen having screened resumes, the next step
involves screening the individual behind the application.
Step #13 Interviewing and selling qualified applicants in this step the
most qualified candidates advance to formal interviews and other assessment
activities.
Step #14 The final interview the goal of this step is to confirm your initial
desirability ranking and set expectations among those most likely to receive an
offer.
Step #15 The reference checking process with your short list vetted and
expectations for an offer set, the next step validates the perception of your
assessment team using references.
Step #16 The offer process the goal of this step is to put together an offer that is within
the companys boundaries and that meets as many of the candidates job acceptance criteria as
possible.
Step #17 The post-offer acceptance process once an offer is accepted, it doesnt
ensure the candidate will actually show up for work! The goal of this step is to ensure those that
accept our offers dont back out (as a result of a counteroffer or second thoughts).
Step #18 contrary to popular belief, the primary goal of onboarding is not to get employees
enrolled in benefits, but rather to provide resources and information that enable new hires to
become productive as fast as possible.
Step #19 Feedback and new hire monitoring if the ultimate goal is continuous
improvement of the recruiting process, then this step is the most important of all.
SOURCES
(cont.)
https://
www.garuda-indonesia.com/id/en/corporate-partners/index.page
https://
www.garuda-indonesia.com/id/en/destination/route-map/index-interna
tional.page
http://data.worldbank.org/country/new-zealand#cp_surv