EMSC 5103 : Sustainable Construction Design, method and materials

Sustainable construction Sustainable construction is defined as the creation and responsible management of a healthy built environment based on resource efficient and ecological principles (Yeang, 1995)

Resource base Where is it from? renewable materials? From fragile location? limited supply? Embodied pollution activities that produced wastes eg from: extraction, processing and production ; type of wastes; recycled materials? transportation i.e too far? Distribution too far? Too much packaging? Impact in use Detailing of the building for EE etc, toxicity of materials paints, varnishes, formaldehyde in plywood, chipboard, foam; vinyl products eg flooring tiles; timber treatment. Passive environmental control eg moisture and thermal by design, Final destination Reduce consumption rate in order to reduce waste production Durability quality of materials Maintenance maintenance-free building Life spans - 100 years? 50 years? element of service 10 years? What can we do 5 R refuse to use, reduce, reuse, recycle and repair

Five principles of Environment architecture Healthy interior environment Energy efficiency Ecological kind materials Environmental forms Good design

EMSC 5103 : Sustainable Construction -

All possible means are taken to ensure materials and buildings systems do not emit toxic substance and gases into the interior atmosphere All possible means are taken to ensure the building uses minimum energy Building materials are from source that minimize destruction of global environment All possible means are taken to relate the form and plan of the design to local site, region and climate. The form of buildings to be to a harmonious relationship between the inhabitants and nature Aim to have efficient, long lasting and elegant relationship of used areas, circulation, building form, mechanical systems an construction technology

EMSC 5103 : Sustainable Construction Efficiency in sustainable design

energy efficiency Energy use of a building is probably the single greatest environmental impact of a building. Decision made during the design and construction of a building will go on affecting the environmental performance of that building for decades to come. Renewable energy source is encouraged. Utilizing natural lighting and ventilation is another option Water is another important element in building either during the construction or during occupancy. Excess water usage will increase the production of wastewater which require more energy to treat. Recycling of grey water can reduce water demand for toilet flushing. No matter what the materials, using less is always preferable as long as the durability or structural integrity of a building is not compromise. Reduce waste production

Water efficiency

Materials efficiency Waste efficiency

4 R of sustainable design reduce

EMSC 5103 : Sustainable Construction Design for lower quantity of materials, resources and embodied energy. Select durable and expected to perform well over the service years.

Reuse

effective way to avoid further withdrawal of natural resources and creation of environmental pollution associated with then extraction, trans[ort, processing, manufacturing. Installation and disposal of the used materials. in terms of materials and also building. Reusing old buildings by changing its function.
Emphasize on the use of recycled materials and designing a home with recycling capability. It will avoid on using virgin materials Utilization of renewable energy from natural sources such As wind, solar heat etc. Will discuss on RE in later chapter

Recycle

Renewable

Stages Sustainable construction Planning Design

EMSC 5103 : Sustainable Construction The elements of sustainable construction To include sustainable aspiration Design to have sustainble approach in every sense 1. Setting the aspiration 2. Protecting aspiration 3. Production information and tender 4. Tender action 5. Mobilisation of the project 6. Construction to practical completion Main site issues 7. After practical completion Provide training and detail post management Operation and maintenance Monitoring Feedback POE,

Pre- project execution Construction process Handling over

Post occupant evaluation

EMSC 5103 : Sustainable Construction Design consideration

Site The site and its buildings are interrelated with their surroundings. They are not only consideration related to the aesthetic aspect but more specifically to the local climate, landscape features and neighboring buildings that might create variations to the microclimate. Wind Wind provide natural ventilation. The design should reflect the wind direction and how it is channeled over the site in a away that the building catches the wind and utilized the pressure to ventilate the internal space. Promote direct flow direction. Ventilation is necessary to provide oxygen and to remove contaminated air as human body required a constant supply of oxygen . Water Conserve the use of fresh and treated water Sun and Daylight usually admitted into building through windows or skylights but they natural might also transmit heat, sound and air through them also. sunlight A rectangular building in a tropical should be located with its longest axis in an east to west direction in order to avoid direct sun light

Existing Existing landscape is refereeing to natural features such as trees, slopes and peaks landscape as well as surrounding artificial features such as buildings. Need to consider how the building affects and being affected by the local climate. Plants adsorb CO2 and visual screens and sound diffusers to reduce sound and air pollution. Plants also serve as windbreakers and provide low-shields to the buildings

EMSC 5103 : Sustainable Construction Construction process

The key issues that require attention in relation to the process of sustainable construction are 1) The delivery of the aspirations for a building from inception to handover and beyond such that it can meet the increasingly common social expectation 2) The construction process itself. to ensure that the methods of building and impact of construction on community and environment is as kind as possible 3) The process of feedback so that experiences can be shared and continue for continual improvement There is lack of information regarding sustainable construction in Malaysia. The construction industries need to compile and compel those embark on sustainable construction in Malaysia to share their experiences, challenges and problem solving.

Sustainability baton

The sustainability aspiration normally is high at briefing. But at each stage of procurement , the baton being drop or challenge throughout the process and particularly as responsibilities transfer from the client to design team to the contractor and back to the clients . What can we do to sustain that baton?? Need strong support and high inspiration.

Six attributes that are vital for sustainable construction

1 Stewardship/ownership of project is a vital aspect in delivering sustainable project. Failure to indentify appropriate targets, tools and benchmarking or to look to long-term manageability poses serious challenge. Getting support communities identify and meet the real needs requirements and aspirations of communities and stakeholders and involve them in key decisions Enhance biodiversity do not use materials that threatened species and environments and improve natural habitat where appropriate Create healthy environments enhance living, leisure and work environments; do not endanger the health of workers, users via exposure to pollutants Use resource effectively do not consume disproportionate amount of resources including money, water, energy, materials, lands during construction and handing over. Do not generate unnecessary wastage due to short life, poor design, inefficiency or less than ideal construction Minimize pollution create minimum dependence on polluting materials,

3 4 5

What can we do to obtain that sustainability aspiration? the stages in sustainable construction project planning
1 Setting the aspirations: Prepare a sustainable policy statement i.e protection of environment and reduce wastage Adopt life cycle approach and costing Set targets for energy and water consumption seek the best possible guidance on sustainability issue Avoid gimmick and over sizing, Think through building control; and management and strategies how to obtain feedback Consultation with stakeholders get them involved and get their feedbacks Community consultation can enhance a project by Providing the opportunity for a community to broaden its horizon and hand-on experience Brining people together Providing a community sense of ownership

What can we do to obtain that sustainability aspiration?

2 Protecting the aspiration: The design team requires to see all aspect of construction through the sustainable criteria filter money, materials, lighting, control, landscape, fabric, form, orientation, energy, fire protection, heating, waste. IT, ventilation, cooling, transport, water provision, coordination, changing legislation, policy, and building management. all the design team will be required to negotiate and agree to resolve cross cutting issues. It is important to benchmark the performance, labelling of materials and products, building and process need to be agreed. Production information and tender stage It is important to make sustainability aspects as contractual. Ensure contractors understand the issues and potential benefits on sustainability construction Provide adequate information in prelims to avoid substitution without approval Encourage the contractors to join Considerate Constructors scheme and to set a clear target and record achievements under CEEQUAL or BREEAM assessment,

3.

EMSC 5103 : Sustainable Construction Considerate contractors scheme It is voluntarily Code of Practice open to all contruction companies: it seeks to: 1. Minimize the disturbance or negative impact sometime caused by construction sites to the immediate neighbor 2. Eradicate offensive behaviour and language from construction sites 3. Recognize and reward a contractors commitment to raise standard of site management, safety and environmental awareness beyond statutory duties

Civil Engineering environmental quality assessment Scheme CEEQUAL

It aims to encourage the attainment of environmental excellence in civil engineering projects. It focuses on the processes that enable delivery of best practice and is robust enough to deal with projects of long timescale.

Contractor benefits Reducing waste, saves money of SC: Less time in repairing enviornmental damage Reduce risk of legal costs(fines) Better company profile Improve tender opportunities Reduced neighbor disputes Reduced demand for resources

What can we do to obtain that sustainability aspiration?

4 Tender Action stage There are various way in which the sustainability agenda can be at risk The bill and specification are not clear The subcontractors do not pick up novel specification and/or ignore the price implications of novel specification Failure to identify important/specific supplier Tender too high (fear of unknown)
Hence it is useful to have a period of information exchange prior to the tendering process. Allow bidding contractors to attend and queries on the key sustainable aspect of project,. 5 Mobilization stage It is important to make sustainability aspects to be contractual. Ensure that environmental statement of the finished building should be established. Methods statements, targets, and information on environmental issues should be established with subcontractors. Any specialist materials should be highlighted and supply chain issues identified

What can we do to obtain that sustainability aspiration?

6 Construction to almost completion stage Much is to be gained or lost during the period of delivery of the building itself. Establishing controls within the routine of the site operation will be beneficial. Unique or unusual elements, materials, products or services system should be explained even to the new workers All relevant subcontractors should have explanations of key environmental elements
Checking to make sure the products are of the required quality and that they work as specified and operate according to the manufacturer's recommendation At the handover stage, the client need the support to be able to use the building appropriately . Hence training is needed for all by the design team and specialist technology/materials installers. Once the building is under operation, it is beneficial for design team to maintain direct interest on the building in order to obtain feedback from the clients Best practice examples show that significant savings on energy and maintenance costs can be achieved through effective feedback

What can we do to obtain that sustainability aspiration?

7 After practical completion A lack of understanding on controls, design parameters can reduce the sustainable building efficiency . sustainability is a process and not a product (life long learning process) The test of a sustainable building is when the clients/user take over and operate the building.
Achievement of a sustainable aspiration is a complex interaction of design, designed manageability, client commitment and user understanding. Monitoring is essential there is significant benefits in monitoring key aspects of a buildings resource usage (i.e water, energy, waste materials etc).

What can we do to obtain that sustainability aspiration?

7 Post occupancy evaluation POE
Post occupancy evaluation POE or post occupation studies ought to cover all aspects of building performance space, cost, aesthetic, operations, use, occupation satisfaction, management, environmental performance etc. they should consider the way the building was procured, briefed, designed and occupied. PROBE = post occupancy evaluation of buildings and their engineering aspects. POE can help to iron out common problems in buildings, such as lights on unnecessarily and windows propped open against design intent . If it is detected n the early stages- it can save money and increasing comfort and satisfaction . Challenges in POE execution: Too many methods available for POE implementation. Costs difficult to obtain Aesthetic subjective Space efficiency, density or utilization which is easily carried out but rarely asked Design and procurement history which is often quite hard and expensive to study as the design team most probably had dispersed.

What can we do to obtain that sustainability aspiration?

7 PROBE = post occupancy evaluation of buildings and their engineering aspects. It measures : Energy - the energy assessment and reporting methodology EARM comprehensively covers building energy performance from both supply and demand perspective, which helps in a thorough understanding of technical performance and is helpful with diagnostic
Occupants using perceived ratings and attitudinal observations from questionnaires followed up with interview and discussion if necessary . Building use studies BUS occupants questionnaires covers occupants issue like comfort, health and productivity in a format which give a useful across wide range of discipline eg architecture, building services, facilities management. Air tightness an air pressure test examines the airtighness of the fabric presumably for containment of air for thermal comfort.

Pre-visit questionnaires to collect basic data about hours of use, plans and other background information A water consumption method A supplementary questionnaires on journey to work and transport mode.

The barriers of implementing PROBE

1. 2 Occupied buildings are complex system that are challenge to study to decide which element to study. POE study are often enthusiastically supported by lower level in a organization but vetoed by higher management secret data

3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10

POE by their nature are multi discipline. They have to deal with topics from supply industrys perspective and from user side.
The industry is not organized to collect POE and feedbacks information and deal with it. see as threat. Clients do not see why they should be doing something they hope to take for granted Academic do not regard building performance as an area of legitimate interest. Secrecy no communication between the manager of the building and supplier Professionals tend to be territorial and not willing to know/listen user perspective One needs lot of knowledge before proceed to do POE i.e not many trained to do so Most designers go straight to next job without learning from the one just completed might be due to time/cost.

What can we do to obtain that sustainability aspiration?

7 Example of PROBE, D:\OUM master class\4_1_Kolokotroni Post Occupancy Evaluation of Buildings.pdf D:\OUM master class\energy-assessment-methodology.pdf D:\OUM master class\poe survey2.pdfD:\OUM master class\Keynote Lecture 3 Low Carbon Cities & Sustainability.pdf D:\OUM master class\BR12 probe.pdf

EMSC 5103 : Sustainable Construction Materials selection - Some of the common materials use at construction are known to be toxic 1) Polyvinyl chloride PVC Risks: During manufacturing, ingredients such as vinyl chloride monomer emit dioxin and others. During use PVC products leach toxic additives, Disposal leaches toxic additives when disposed at landfill and release dioxin when incinerated Used in manufacturing process such as paints, plastic products, paper, textiles, carpets, pesticides, and fumigants, chipboards and plywood , thermal insulation, furniture, adhesives , glues and resins Risks: long term exposure may cause cancer. It is asthma trigger

Alternative materials Possible PVC alterative Stainless steel conduit/pipes Use polyethylene (PE), polypropylene (PP), or rubber sheathing for wiring Copper or PE water pipes Cast iron rainwater containers Linoleum or rubber instead of vinyl floor coverings Cellulose insulation Water based paint Natural timber in lieu of chipboard etc

2) Formalde hyde

EMSC 5103 : Sustainable Construction Materials selection - Some of the common materials use at construction are known to be toxic 3) solvents Risks: Range from irritation and headsche to dermatitis (skin problem) colour blindness, brain damage, cancer

Alternative materials Natural water based emulsion paints Linseed oil based gloss paint Avoidance materials that required or containing glue Where use of glue is unavoidable, use solvent/formaldehyde free glues Avaoidance of timber treatemtn through detailing

EMSC 5103 : Sustainable Construction

Some of key site issues

1. Wild life Action must be taken to minimize damage to the site ecology (ideally). All site actions are potential threats because of : Changes to water quality Destruction of habitats Damage to vegetation Interruption to wildlife movements Dust, noise and lighting pollution Damage, removal or burial of rock formations Main example of contamination risks are Contamination encountered during works Handling/excavating contaminated ground and polluting aquifer Windblown dusts Stockpiling contaminated materials that leaches Spillage of contaminants' eg oils Discharge of contaminated de-watering

2. Contamination

EMSC 5103 : Sustainable Construction Some key site issues 3. Waste The issues are: monitoring procedures, raw materials wastage, storage and handling, reduction of landfill tax, potential for reuse and recycling, transport and disposal. Need to consider issues: Legislation and penalties The nature of any potential damage to the environment Potential impact on project/budget Site dust, emissiojns and odour cause annoyance and health risks. Use containment method fpr demolition Keep plant clean Keep earthwork damp amd revegetate Clean concrete pour-and-batching regime Minimise site cutting, grouting and grinding No burning on site

4. Emissions

EMSC 5103 : Sustainable Construction Some of key site issues 5. Water Relevant issues within water strategy are Water abstraction Water disposal Spillage Vehicle washing effluent Surface water runoff Silty water Pumping to grassland Settlement tanks Lagoons, sewage discharge Evaluate potential noise/vibration problems and monitor levels before starting Inform neighbours Minimise and monitor effects during work Monitor conditions after works are complete Archeological sites are irreplaceable and early investigation is essential if significant delay and costs are to be abvoided/

6. Noise

7. Archeology

EMSC 5103 : Sustainable Construction

Green materials
Definition of green materials Green building materials are those that use earth resources in an environmentally responsible way and respect the nature cycles and interrelationship with ecosystem Non toxic Made from recycled materials and themselves are recyclable They are energy efficient and water efficient They are green the way they are extracted, manufactured, the way they are used, and reclaimed after used. Has high mark for resource management, impact on indoor environmental quality and performance.

Resources The impact of products on the earth resources, management Its impact on biodiversity and ecosystem Its favours: reduce, reuse, recycle and renew Non sustainable resource management causes: Pollution to water, air Depletion of raw materials Destruction of ecosystem during acquisition of raw materials

EMSC 5103 : Sustainable Construction

Green materials
Why use green materials? Can help to divert indoor air quality liability claims, sick building syndrome according to US NIOSH, the relative causes of poor indoor air quality : inadequate ventilation; indoor contaminants; outdoor contaminants . Respond to consumer demand healthy building and energy efficiency structures Economic benefits reduce claim from sick building, cheaper to manage than to clean up wastes, Provide compliance with certain regulatory requirement locally or globally -Montreal protocol , 1987 control ozone emission -Earth summit, Rio De Janeiro - Agenda 21, 1992 Usage of earth resources sustainable way Non toxic materials Have recycled items in them

What are green building materials?

EMSC 5103 : Sustainable Construction

Green materials
Expensive? Initial cost is expensive But when consider the societal costs (which is difficult to quantify) , it is still cheaper Green products are often competitive to purchase and installation (especially those with recycled materials) Energy efficient products such as light fixtures and appliances must be evaluated in terms of life cycle analysis as they generally more expensive to purchase and install but less expensive to operate. Standardization and green label , international environmental ISO iso 14000 etc Identify material categories Identify green building materials option Gather technical information Review submitted information Evaluate green materials Select and document choice

Challenge of assessing greenness

Selection process 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.