Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 399 views

    Phenyl Formaldehyde Resins Manufacture - Disaster

    Uploaded by

    Indrajeet Pa
    1. A phenol-formaldehyde resin reaction runaway occurred at a Georgia-Pacific plant in Columbus, Ohio on September 10, 1997 resulting in an explosion that killed one operator and injured four others. 2. The explosion was caused by an excessive pressure buildup from the exothermic reaction when all raw materials and catalyst were added at once and heat was applied, exceeding the cooling capacity of the system. 3. Lessons learned included the need for thorough hazard assessment, understanding reaction chemistry and thermochemistry, administrative controls, temperature control, proper addition of raw materials, effective emergency relief, and learning from past accidents.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PPT, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Phenyl Formaldehyde Resins Manufacture - Disaster

    Uploaded by

    Indrajeet Pa
    399 views13 pages
    1. A phenol-formaldehyde resin reaction runaway occurred at a Georgia-Pacific plant in Columbus, Ohio on September 10, 1997 resulting in an explosion that killed one operator and injured four others. 2. The explosion was caused by an excessive pressure buildup from the exothermic reaction when all raw materials and catalyst were added at once and heat was applied, exceeding the cooling capacity of the system. 3. Lessons learned included the need for thorough hazard assessment, understanding reaction chemistry and thermochemistry, administrative controls, temperature control, proper addition of raw materials, effective emergency relief, and learning from past accidents.

    Original Description:

    Phenyl Formaldehyde Resins Manufacture -Disaster

    Original Title

    Phenyl Formaldehyde Resins Manufacture -Disaster

    Copyright

    © Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)

    Available Formats

    PPT, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    1. A phenol-formaldehyde resin reaction runaway occurred at a Georgia-Pacific plant in Columbus, Ohio on September 10, 1997 resulting in an explosion that killed one operator and injured four others. 2. The explosion was caused by an excessive pressure buildup from the exothermic reaction when all raw materials and catalyst were added at once and heat was applied, exceeding the cooling capacity of the system. 3. Lessons learned included the need for thorough hazard assessment, understanding reaction chemistry and thermochemistry, administrative controls, temperature control, proper addition of raw materials, effective emergency relief, and learning from past accidents.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PPT, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as ppt, pdf, or txt
    399 views13 pages

    Phenyl Formaldehyde Resins Manufacture - Disaster

    Uploaded by

    Indrajeet Pa
    1. A phenol-formaldehyde resin reaction runaway occurred at a Georgia-Pacific plant in Columbus, Ohio on September 10, 1997 resulting in an explosion that killed one operator and injured four others. 2. The explosion was caused by an excessive pressure buildup from the exothermic reaction when all raw materials and catalyst were added at once and heat was applied, exceeding the cooling capacity of the system. 3. Lessons learned included the need for thorough hazard assessment, understanding reaction chemistry and thermochemistry, administrative controls, temperature control, proper addition of raw materials, effective emergency relief, and learning from past accidents.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PPT, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as ppt, pdf, or txt
    of 13

    Phenyl formaldehyde resinsdisaster (case study)

    By Sonali Chavan Harshavardhan Chaudhari Saurabh Das Rohit Deora

    Phenyl formaldehyde resins


    The reaction of phenol or substituted phenol with an aldehyde, in the presence of an acidic or basic catalyst is used to prepare phenolic resins. Uses: Phenolic resins are used in adhesives, coatings, and molding compounds.
    OH NaOH OH (CH2OH)n1

    (n1+n2) HCHO (CH2OH)n2

    Heat of reaction: -180 cal/g Two step process: 1. Methylolation 2. Salification

    Process description
    Reaction in stirred vessel with condensor. Provision for heating and cooling. T=60oC, 37% wt. aq. formaldehyde + caustic soda, Phenol in molten state. Stoichiometric amount of Caustic soda (30% wt. solution) addition over 30 mins at 50oC. Emergency relief on the reactor is usually provided by rupture disks.

    Type of catalyst used, the ratio of reactants, and the reaction conditions determine the molecular structure and physical properties. Highly exothermic and sensitive to a variety of physical and chemical conditions. Heat generated by the reaction increases the reaction rate generating more heat. Reaction rate is typically an exponential function of temperature Pressure of the system will increase suddenly due to the vigorous evaporation of liquid. Internal Pressure > Ultimate tensile strength Thermal runaway !!!

    Phenol-Formaldehyde Reaction Incidents at Various Companies


    Date
    Sep 10, 1997

    State
    OH

    Description
    A 8,000 gallon reactor exploded during production of a phenol-formaldehyde resin.

    Effect
    1 worker fatality, 4 employees injured, 3 firefighters treated for chemical burns. Evacuation of residents for several hours.
    Residents evacuated for 5 hours.

    Aug 18, 1994

    OH

    Pressure buildup during manufacture of phenolic resin, pressure increased, rupture disks popped. Product was released through emergency vent. The cause of accident was reported as failure to open condensate return line. A 13,000 gallon reactor exploded during production of a phenol-formaldehyde resin. Explosion occurred during initial stages of catalyst addition. Temperature increased in chemical reactor, releasing phenol formaldehyde resin. Manufacture of phenolic resins and thermoset plastics; release of phenol and formaldehyde from process vessel. Manufacture of phenolic resins; release of phenol and phenolic resin from process vessel; operator error cited as cause. Specialty paper manufacturing; release of phenolic resin and methanol from process vessel.

    Feb 29, 1992

    GA

    4 employees injured, 1 seriously. 1 firefighter treated for chemical burns. Evacuation of 200 residents for 3 hours. None reported. None reported. 1 injured.

    Nov 11, 1991 Oct 16, 1989 Aug 28, 1989

    OH WI NY

    Jul 25, 1989

    VA

    None reported.

    Case study
    On September 10, 1997 the Georgia- Pacific Resins plant in Columbus experienced a large explosion in a resin kettle (reactor). 8,000-gallon batch reactor The explosion resulted from a runaway reaction in Kettle No. 2. The reactors safety systems failed to contain the rapidly expanding gases

    What happened?
    An operator charged raw materials and catalyst to the reactor and turned on steam to heat

    the contents.
    A high temperature alarm sounded and the operator turned off the steam. There was a large, highly energetic explosion. Separation of the top of the reactor from the shell.

    A nearby holding tank was destroyed and another reactor was partially damaged.
    Operator killed, 4 injured, 3 firemen burned severely. Occupational Safety and Health Administration slapped the company with $400000 fine. Residents within a mile radius of the facility were evacuated. People complaining of burning of skin, rashes, sore throat, headaches, breathing problems due to bronchitis, burning of throat, and nausea.

    Cause
    All the raw materials and catalyst were charged to the reactor at once followed by the addition of heat. Heat generated exceeded the cooling capacity of the system Excessive pressure generated by a runaway reaction. Pressure generated could not be vented through the emergency relief system.

    Runaway due to
    Accumulation of Formaldehyde Deviation from process Poor agitation Improper heating or cooling

    Lessons learned
    Thorough hazard assesment Complete identification of reaction chemistry and thermochemistry Administrative controls Temperature control Addition of raw materials Emergency relief Learning from accident history and near misses

    Steps To Reduce Hazards


    Modify processes to improve inherent safety. Minimize the potential for human error. Understand events that may lead to an overpressure and eventually to vessel rupture. Use lessons learned. Evaluate Standard Operating Practices. Evaluate employee training and oversight. Evaluate the effectiveness of the emergency relief system.

    Social Impact
    Concerns regarding future accidents: Fear that the GPRI plant will experience another serious accident The railroad and other plants in the area could also have a chemical accident Concern that residents wouldnt even know if an accident takes place (no alarm) Residents have no information on what to do in the event of an accident (evacuation?) Concern that a warning will come too late Concerns about children at school or children being caught in a vapor cloud Concern for elderly and sick people who may not hear or respond to a warning When we see fire trucks or hear a loud noise, we dont know what is going on

    Social Impact
    Concerns regarding air emissions and odors Reports of chemical smells and/or burning eyes Experiences with odors, burning eyes, and visual plumes from the plant Concern about formaldehyde emissions from Georgia Pacific Plant Awareness that formaldehyde is highly toxic General concern that air in the area is not healthy Awareness of other emission sources in area (including large numbers of trucks) Concern that high rates of asthma and other illness that may be attributable to air emissions Concern that Ohio EPA doesnt do enough to reduce air pollution in the area

    You might also like