Math Script
Math Script
Duration: 10 minutes
Target Audience: 11th-grade students
1. Introduction (1 min)
Opening Question: "Can the fastest runner in the world never catch up to a tortoise? Can an
arrow in flight actually be motionless? And can a hotel with infinite rooms that's completely full
still accept infinitely more guests?"
These questions aren't just hypothetical—they're famous paradoxes that forced mathematicians
to rethink fundamental concepts like motion, time, and infinity. Today, ill go over three of them:
The Paradox:
Why It's Confusing: It seems logical at each step, but contradicts reality.
Mathematical Resolution:
This infinite sum converges to approximately 102.0408 meters—the exact point where Achilles
catches up.
"Zeno’s flaw was assuming infinity implies impossibility. In reality, infinite processes can yield
finite results—this is an important part of calculus."
Why It's Confusing: If motion is impossible at every instant, how does the arrow move?
Resolution:
Flaw in the Logic: Zeno assumed motion requires progress within an instant
Modern View: Motion is defined over intervals of time (via derivatives in calculus)
Analogy: A movie is made of static frames, but motion emerges from their sequence
Thought Experiment: "If you freeze time, is a hummingbird's wing 'at rest'? Does that mean it
can't fly?"
You:
"Now, consider an arrow in flight. At any single instant, it occupies a fixed position—appearing
‘at rest.’ If time is composed of such instants, how does motion occur?"
"The paradox dissolves when we distinguish between instants and intervals. Motion isn’t a
property of moments but of change across time—formalized by derivatives. Think of a film:
Individual frames are static, but their sequence creates movement."
4. Hilbert's Grand Hotel (3 min)
Imagine there's a hotel with infinite rooms. They’re numbered 1, 2, 3, 4, and so on forever.
It may seem like you can accommodate anyone who ever shows up, but there is a limit, a
way to exceed even the infinity of rooms at the Hilbert hotel.
The next problem is how to add infinite guests, this is also simpkle
Solution: Move each guest from Room n → Room 2n (1→2, 2→4, 3→6, ...)
Result: All odd-numbered rooms (∞ of them!) are now vacant
Equation: ∞ + ∞ = ∞
Imagine there's a hotel with infinite rooms. They’re numbered 1, 2, 3, 4, and so on forever.
It may seem like you can accommodate anyone who ever shows up, but there is a limit, a
way to exceed even the infinity of rooms at the Hilbert hotel.
But now what if an infinite number of infinite busses show up? You can create an infinite
spreadsheet, one row for each bus, and a row at the top for all the people who are already
in the hotel.
the columns are for the position each person occupies, you’ve got hotel room 1 hotel room
2, etc. and you’ve got bus 1 seat 1 bus 1 seat 2 etc. We can draw a line that zigzags back and
forth across the spreadsheet running over every id once.
Then we can pull on the opposite ends of this line, straightening it out. We’ve gone from an
infinite-by-infinite grid, to a single straight line. Now align each person with a room and it
works.
But what if a big bus pulls up, an infinite bus with no seats. Instead everyone is identified
by their unique name and their names are made up of only 2 letters A and B, but they are
infinitely long. So someone is named ABBAA so on forever. Someone else is named
ABABABABABA etc. The problem is, we can no longer fit everyone. If you assign each
person with an infinite name a room, we can create the name of a person who doesn’t yet
have a room. The way you do it is you take the first letter of the first name and flip it from
A to B, the second letter of the second name and flip it from B to A. This new name is
guaranteed to appear nowhere on that list. Because it won't match the first letter of the
first name or the second letter of the second name or the third letter of the third name, it
will be different from every name on the list by at least one character. The number of rooms
in the Hilbert Hotel is infinite, sure, but it is countably infinite, meaning there are as many
rooms as there are positive integers 1 to infinity. You see, Some infinities are bigger than others.
So there's a limit to the people that you can fit in the Hilbert Hotel.
Final Thought: "Infinity isn't a number—it's a concept that bends the rules. And that's what
makes it so powerful."
Transcripts:
(00:00) They're Imagine there's a hotel with infinite rooms. numbered 1, 2, 3, 4, and so on
forever. This is the Hilbert Hotel and you are the manager. Now, it might seem like you could
accommodate anyone who ever shows up, but there is a limit, a way to exceed even the infinity
of rooms at the Hilbert Hotel.
(00:26) To start, let's say only one person is allowed in each room and all the rooms are full.
There are an infinite number of people in an infinite number of rooms. Then someone new
shows up and they want a room, but all the rooms are occupied, so what should you do? But all
the rooms are occupied, so what should you do? Well, a lesser manager might turn them away,
but you know about infinity, so you get on the PA and you tell all the guests to move down a
room.
(00:52) So the person in room 1 moves to room 2, the one in room 2 moves to room 3, and so on
down the line. And now you can put the new guest in room 1. If a bus shows up with 100
people, you know exactly what to do. Just move everyone down 100 rooms and put the new
guests in their vacated rooms. But now say a bus shows up that is infinitely long and it's
carrying infinitely many people.
(01:16) You knew what to do with a finite number of people, but what do you do with infinite
people? You think about it for a minute and then come up with a plan. You tell each of your
existing guests to move to the room with double their room number. So the person in room one
moves to room two, room two moves to room four, room three to room six, and so on.
(01:38) And now all of the odd-numbered rooms are available. And you know there are an
infinite number of odd numbers, so you can give each person on the infinite bus a unique odd-
numbered room. This hotel is really starting to feel like it can fit everybody, and that's the
beauty of infinity. It goes on forever.
(01:58) And then, all of a sudden, more infinite buses show up. Not just one or two, but an
infinite number of infinite buses. So what can you do? Well, you pull out an infinite spreadsheet,
of course. You make a row for each bus, bus one, bus two, bus three, and so on, and a row at the
top for all the people who are already in the hotel.
(02:19) The columns are for the position each person occupies. So you've got hotel room 1,
hotel room 2, hotel room 3, etc. And then bus 1 seat 1, bus 1 seat 2, bus 1 seat 3, and so on. So
each person gets a unique identifier, which is a combination of their vehicle and their position in
it. So how do you assign the rooms? We'll start in the top left corner and draw a line that
zigzags back and forth across the spreadsheet, going over each unique ID exactly once.
(02:51) Then imagine you pull on the opposite ends of this line, straightening it out. So we've
gone from an infinite by infinite grid to a single infinite line. It's then pretty simple just to line
up each person on that line with a unique room in the hotel. So everyone fits, no problem. But
now a big bus pulls up, an infinite party bus with no seats.
(03:18) Instead, everyone on board is identified by their unique name, which is kind of strange.
So their names all consist of only two letters, A and B, but each name is infinitely long. So
someone is named A, B, B, A, A, A, A, A, A, A, A, A, and so on forever. Someone else is
named A, B, A, B, A, B, A, B, A, B, et cetera.
(03:40) On this bus, there's a person with every possible infinite sequence of these two letters.
Now, A-B-B-A-A-A-A-A, I'll call him Abba for short, he comes into the hotel to arrange the
rooms. But you tell him, sorry, there's no way we can fit all of you in the hotel. And he's like,
what do you mean? There's an infinite number of us, and you have an infinite number of rooms.
(04:04) Why won't this work? So you show them. You pull out your infinite spreadsheet again
and start assigning rooms to people on the bus. So you have room 1, assign it to ABBA, and
then room 2 to ABABABAB repeating, and you keep going, putting a different string of A's and
B's beside each room number. Now here's the problem, you tell Abba.
(04:25) Let's say we have a complete infinite list. I can still write down the name of a person
who doesn't yet have a room. The way you do it is you take the first letter of the first name and
flip it from an A to a B. Then take the second letter of the second name and flip it from a B to an
A. And you keep doing this all the way down the list and the name you write down is
guaranteed to appear nowhere on that list.
(04:54) Because it won't match the first letter of the first name or the second letter of the second
name or the third letter of the third name, it will be different from every name on the list by at
least one character. The letter on the diagonal. The number of rooms in the Hilbert Hotel is
infinite, sure, but it is countably infinite, meaning there are as many rooms as there are positive
integers 1 to infinity.
(05:16) By contrast, the number of people on the bus is uncountably infinite. If you try to match
up each one with an integer, you will still have people left over. Some infinities are bigger than
others. So there's a limit to the people that you can fit in the Hilbert Hotel.
(05:42) This is mind-blowing enough, but what's even crazier is that the discovery of different
sized infinities sparked a line of inquiry that led directly to the invention of the device you're
watching this on right now. But that's a story for another time.
Achilles, the fastest Greek warrior, races a tortoise—but gives it a 100-meter head start.
Common sense says he’ll win, right? Not according to Zeno. Here’s the catch: By the time
Achilles runs 100 meters, the tortoise crawls 2 meters ahead. When Achilles covers those 2
meters, the tortoise moves another 0.04 meters. This repeats infinitely, so it seems Achilles never
catches up."
But here’s the flaw in Zeno’s logic. The distances Achilles runs form an infinite series: 100 + 2 +
0.04 + 0.0008 + … Yet this series converges to a finite sum—about 102.0408 meters—the exact
point where Achilles overtakes the tortoise. Zeno’s flaw was assuming infinity implies
impossibility. In reality, infinite processes can yield finite results—this is an important part of
calculus.
picture an arrow mid-flight. At any single moment, it occupies a fixed space—so is it ‘at rest’ in
that moment? If time is made of many moments, how does motion happen? Zeno argued the
arrow is frozen at every point, so motion is an illusion.
The paradox dissolves when we distinguish between instants and intervals. Motion isn’t many
single moments but the combination of change over time. Think of a movie: Each frame is static,
but the sequence creates movement. This is also a main part of Calculus with derivatives—rates
of change across intervals. Zeno’s mistake was assuming that motion requires progress within an
instant, not between them.
This statement contradicts itself where a person's existence is both necessary and impossible for
the time travel event to occur.
Hilbert’s Paradox of the Grand Hotel
Imagine there's a hotel with infinite rooms that are all occupied. They’re numbered 1, 2, 3, 4, and
so on forever. It may seem like you can accommodate anyone who ever shows up, but there is a
limit, a way to exceed even the infinity of rooms at the Hilbert hotel.
The next problem is how to add infinite guests, this is also simple
Solution: Move each guest from Room n → Room 2n (1→2, 2→4, 3→6, ...)
Result: All odd-numbered rooms (∞ of them!) are now vacant
Equation: ∞ + ∞ = ∞
Finally what if an infinite number of infinite busses show up? You can create an infinite
spreadsheet, one row for each bus, and a row at the top for all the people who are already in the
hotel.
the columns are for the position each person occupies, you’ve got hotel room 1 hotel room 2, etc.
and you’ve got bus 1 seat 1 bus 1 seat 2 etc. We can draw a line that zigzags back and forth
across the spreadsheet running over everything once.
Then we can pull on the opposite ends of this line, straightening it out. We’ve gone from an
infinite-by-infinite grid, to a single straight line. Now align each person with a room and it
works.
But what if a big bus pulls up, an infinite bus with no seats. Instead, everyone is identified by
their unique name and their names are made up of only 2 letters A and B, but they are infinitely
long. So someone is named ABBAA so on forever. Someone else is named ABABABABABA
etc. The problem is, we can no longer fit everyone. If you assign each person with an infinite
name, a room, we can create the name of a person who doesn’t yet have a room. The way you do
it is you take the first letter of the first name and flip it from A to B, the second letter of the
second name and flip it from B to A. This new name is guaranteed to appear nowhere on that list.
Because it won't match the first letter of the first name or the second letter of the second name or
the third letter of the third name, it will be different from every name on the list by at least one
character. The number of rooms in the Hilbert Hotel is infinite, sure, but it is countably infinite,
meaning there are as many rooms as there are positive integers 1 to infinity. See, some infinities
are bigger than others. So there's a limit to the people that you can fit in the Hilbert Hotel.
[Set the scene vividly.]
"Imagine a hotel with infinite rooms—all occupied. If a new guest arrives. What do you do?
Simple: Ask each guest to move to the next room (1→2, 2→3, etc.). Now Room 1 is free! Even
if an infinite bus arrives, you can move guests to double their room number (1→2, 2→4,
3→6…), freeing all odd rooms for the new infinite crowd."
"But what if infinitely many busses with infinite people show up? First we’ll Assign each guest a
unique pair (bus number, seat number) and map them diagonally across an infinite grid. This
proves ∞ + ∞ = ∞. Yet there’s a catch: Some infinities are bigger. A bus with guests named in
infinite A/B sequences (like ABABAB…) can’t fit—their infinity is ‘uncountable.’ The hotel’s
rooms are ‘countably’ infinite, matching natural numbers. This distinction—pioneered by Cantor
—revolutionized math."
---
Conclusion (0.5 minute)
"These paradoxes aren’t just clever puzzles. Zeno’s work laid the groundwork for calculus, and
Hilbert’s Hotel inspired set theory. Infinity bends the rules—it’s not a number but a concept that
reshaped mathematics. So next time you watch a movie or book a hotel room, remember:
sometimes the deepest truths come from questioning the impossible."
---
- Visuals: Mimic the number line (Achilles), movie frames (Arrow), and grid (Hotel) with hand
gestures or simple drawings.
- Engagement: For Hilbert’s Hotel, ask, "How would you fit two infinite groups?" before
revealing the solution.
- Final Thought: End on the "bigger infinities" idea to leave them curious.
This script balances clarity and depth while fitting your 10-minute limit. Let me know if you'd
like adjustments!