Syntax 2 by Dororo Hyakimaru Luffy
Syntax 2 by Dororo Hyakimaru Luffy
Transformational
Generative Grammar
(tgg)
Dedication
I would like to dedicate my work to my family. Also, this is dedicated to my close friends
who have always supported me throughout my years of studies.
Introduction :
Beginning in the late 1950s, structural linguistics sometimes became less popular
as proponents of generative linguistics, pioneered by Noam Chomsky, considered
the work of the American Structuralist to be conceptually too narrow. It is argued
that it is important to go beyond the arrangement of elements in order to create
a grammar that reflects the knowledge of native speakers.
The grammar of the syntactic structure is only preserved for parsing at the
template level. There are many drawbacks to tagging other types of sentences,
but there is no reason or reason to ignore them all.
Phrase structure grammar will be kept and it will launch a new type of reasoning
which is Transformational Generative Grammar which in turn going to add some
new features to this Grammar.
Phrase structure rules are called generative grammars, and word class grammars
are also called generative grammars. If we want to generate all kinds of offers, we
will face the problem of unlimited rules, the importance of which is related to the
acquisition process. How can I have an unlimited number of rules? Should I buy it?
And you know what? It would be impossible for every child to receive this in such
a short time. So this short time is a very important criterion in the language. Then
why do we only learn Korean when we become adults in 2-3 years? So, if you
follow the WCG reasoning, it will take a long time, not 2-3 years. You will probably
spend your entire life acquiring and assimilating the different patterns of each
sentence individually, and this is highly unlikely.
Haven’t we learned to master grammar? How can we know the subject, predicate
or verb?... We are not given any information about the language we are learning,
but we are learning the language unconsciously and through learning. The native
language is acquired unconsciously. Therefore, TGG is a new theory based on the
discovery of PSG and certain assumptions. PSG, however, has its drawbacks, but
remains the essence of the manifest from which other types of sentences are
derived. We must keep PSG as one of the most important components of this new
grammar.
At first it was claimed that PSG is a grammar for describing a language, but this
assumption was eventually refuted. For this reason, as a reaction to the inferiority
of the PSG, the TGG or New Grammar arose, and we claim to have deep thoughts.
For example, PSGs are considered responsible for only one type of sentence,
namely declarative sentences, and declarative sentences, in turn, are considered
surface structures. Declarative analysis refers to two levels of analysis: Surface
Structure and Deep Structure:
3- Meaning of Deep Structure and Surface Structure:
The surface structure is actually produced structure. It refers to the sentence as it
is pronounced or written.
Surface structure=sound
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
The deep structure is the abstract structure that allows the native speaker of a
language to know what the sentence means. It may then be said that the deep
structure expresses the semantic contents of a sentence, whereas the surface
structure of a sentence determines its phonetic form.
Deep structure=meaning
Deep structure (input) or structural description.
Surface structure (output)or structural change .
4 - General Review
Maximal projection of the auxiliary:
Tense (past or present)+m+ have-en+ be-ing For
example:
5 – Transformational rules
• Affix hopping rule
• Yes/no question rule
• Do support rule
• Passive transformation rule
• Agent deletion rule
• Wh movement rule
• Dative movement rule
• Complex np shift rule
• There insertion rule
• Reflexivization rule
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
Suffixes : Suffixes are morphemes (specific groups of letters with particular semantic meaning) that
are added onto the end of root words to change their meaning.
SC :. 1. 3 +. 2. 4
Adam be + present a smart boy
After the application of the morphophonemic rules ,the outcome is :
SS : Adam is a smart boy
So , the affix hopping is the affix that jumps or hops ,and is attached with the
verbal element
As we have seen in the example, when we apply the rule, the affix, which is the
‘present’ jump or hop and attached to the verbal element which is ‘be ’, and
finally we come to the surface structure which is ‘is’
This is why affix hopping is a very important rule, and you must apply it in all
sentences because without it the sentence is ungrammatical, and we also cannot
pronounce it, which means that we cannot say that Adam present be a smart
boy, there is no sentence in the language English like this.
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
1. 2. 3
SC : 1. 3. +. 2
Olivia go + past
After the application of the morphophonemic rules ,the outcome is : SS
: Olivia went
1. 2 3
SC : 2. 1. 3
Present be you. Ing dance ?
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
So ,in a yes /no question, we move or reverse the first two elements of aux ,
which are tense and be with np (you)
Bearing in mind that (be) should not be followed by (ing)
The third step is obligatory Affix
hopping:
First thing,we will take (SC : present be you ing dance as SD )
1. 2. X 1. 2
SC : 2 +1. X. 2+ 1
Be+ present you dance +ing?
After the application of the morphophonemic rules ,the outcome is :
SS : are you dancing ?
# can I help you?
First thing is to change the sentence to an active declarative sentence:
Ad : I can help you.
Apply the yes /no question rule .In this rule, we will move the first two elements
of aux , which are (present,can )and np (i)
SD : I present can help you
1 2 3
SC : 2 1. 3.
Present can I Help You ?
1. 2. X
SC : 2. + 1 x
Can+ Present I help you?
After the application of the morphophonemic rules ,the outcome is :
SS: can I help you?
Conclusion :
We found that when creating yes/no questions, we simply moved the first two
elements to aux: the required tense and the optional modal, have or be . And put
them in front of the NP. That is, move tense (past/present) with M
(will/may/could/will/should), Have (has/had/had) or Be (is/was/are /were) before
NP. Our Structural Description (SD) consists of only these elements (M, Have, Be)
and NP, and the variable X representing each component after
Giving NP 1, as well as tense , M, Have, number 2 and finally the variable X
number 3. So, the outline of the structure is as follows:
Do usually appears in questions and negatives. Here we will focus on the form of
this DO. For example, Adam went to the store . did Adam go to the store ? In the
ad sentence, add the tense to go , not the aux verb. So DO helps move Tns even if
there is no auxiliary verb. DO is usually inserted after tns move and immediately
before affix hopping.
Example :
Did Adam go to the store?
Explanation:
Let’s Change the sentence to an active declarative sentence
Ad : Adam went to the store
Let’s apply yes/no question
1. 2 3
SC : 2. 1 3
Past Adam go To the store ?
The affix past is not followed by any AUX verb to be attached to, but rather an NP.
All that we need in order to produce a perfect question from above is to insert DO
to the left of past. The DO support or insertion is an obligatory rule which permits
us to attach the verb DO immediately to the left of any tense marker that is not
attached to a verb.
Let’s apply do support
SD : past Adam go to the store?
1. 2
SC : 1#do. 2
Past do Adam go to the store?
Let’s apply affix hopping
SD : past do Adam go to the store?
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
1. 2. X
SC:. 2+ 1. X
Do+past Adam go to the store?
After the application of the morphophonemic rules ,the outcome is :
SS :did Adam go to the store?
Note : In the active declarative sentence, the sentence should not be changed as
such :
Adam did go to the store Why
not ?
Let’s take it as an example
Ad: Adam did go to the store
Applying the “yes /no question” rule: SD
: Adam past do go to the store
1. 2 3
SC : 2 1 3
Past Adam do go to the store?
Apply the “do support” rule , because the tense ”past “can’t stand alone SD
: past Adam do go to the store?
1. 2
SC :. 1#do. 2
Past do Adam do go to the store?
The application of the “ affix hopping” rule:
SD : past do Adam do go to the store?
1. 2. X
SC : 2+1. X
Do +past Adam do go to the store?
After the application of the morphophonemic rules ,the outcome is :
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
Do support
SD : tense. x
1. 2
SC :. Tense#do 2
• All Passive sentences are derived from Active Sentences with transitive
verbs.
• Passive sentences are considered surface structures to Active sentences.
• The doer of the action called the Agent (subject)
• The receiver of the action called the Patient (one who/which receives the
action)
• The main verb should be [+ transitive]
How to apply passive transformation rule
The direct object of the active sentence becomes the grammatical subject of the
passive sentence. We add be-en to aux and keep the verb. We insert the
preposition with followed by the subject of the actual clause, which will be the
complement of the preposition by .
Example:
Ice cream is wanted by me now
First thing, change the sentence to an active declarative sentence
Ad : I want ice cream now
Active declarative
Yes/no question
Do support
Affix hopping
What about the passive transformation rule ?
For example
Ice cream is wanted by Lina now
Before changing it to an active declarative sentence, what rules do we have?
Of course, there is no yes/no question and no do support.
But there is affix hopping and passive transformation rule
1. 2. 3. 4. X
SC : 4 2+be-en. 3.#by 1. X
Ice cream present+be-en want by Lina now
Let’s apply affix hopping:
SD : ice cream present be-en want by Lina now
X. 1. 2. 1. 2. Y
SC:. X. 2+1. 2+1. Y
Ice cream be+ present want+ en by Lina now
After the application of the morphophonemic rules ,the outcome is :
SS: ice cream is wanted by Lina now
Example
The cake was eaten by Hajar
Change the sentence to an active declarative sentence
Ad : Hajar ate the cake
Apply the passive transformation rule:
SD : Hajar past eat the cake .
1. 2. 3. 4
SC: 4. 2+be-en. 3 #by 1
The cake past +be-en eat by Hajar .
The application of the “ affix hopping” rule
1. 2. 3. 4. 5
SC:. 1. 2. 3. 4. Q
Example:
The cake was eaten
First , there is no Yes /no question or do support
There is a passive transformation rule ,as well as agent deletion, because there is
no subject or agent .of course ,we have affix hopping.
Because there is agent deletion rule, we will add someone or somebody.
Change the sentence to an active declarative sentence
Ad : someone ate the cake
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
1. 2. 3. 4
SC:. 4. 2+be-en. 3 #by 1
The cake past +be-en eat by someone Apply
the “agent deletion” rule :
SD : The cake past be-en eat by someone
1. 2. 3. 4. 5
SC:. 1. 2. 3. 4
The cake past be-en eat.
The application of the “ affix hopping” rule:
SD : the cake past be-en eat.
X. 1. 2. 1. 2
SC:. X. 2+1. 2+1.
The cake be+past eat+en.
After the application of the morphophonemic rules ,the outcome is :
SS: the cake was eaten.
Wh movement rule:
An echo question is a type of direct question in which you repeat part or all of
what the other person has just said. Repeat the parrot’s question or Q. We do this
when we don’t fully understand or hear what someone is saying. Eco Q should be
considered as intonation.
Wh movement:
In linguistics, wh-movement is the formation of syntactic dependencies involving
interrogative words. An example in English is the dependency formed between
what and the object position of doing in "What are you doing?" Wh/operation as
follows:
We move the wh/word accompanied by its complement category, or with no
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
Explanation
First : what rules do we have in this sentence ?
There is a yes no question rule ( because there is a question mark ?)
Also we have “do support rule” (there is “do”)
And wh movement (because it begins with wh ),and affix hopping(obligatory rule)
Correct arrangement:
Wh movement
Yes no question
Do support
Affix hopping
Let’s apply the rules
First change the sentence to an active declarative sentence Ad
:you like which whiskey.
First, we will apply the rule of wh movement:
SD : you present like which whiskey
1 2 3
SC:. 3. 1. 2
Which whiskey you present like
As you may have noticed, We move the wh/word accompanied by its
complement category (which whiskey),not just (which) Apply the
“yes no question” rule :
In a yes no question, we move the first two elements of aux
In this example, we just have “present ”as an auxiliary
Therefore, we will only transfer the "present”
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
Wh movement rule:
SD :X tense +….. Wh
1. 2. 3
SC: 3 1. 2
Example
SD : you present have-en do what
1. 2. 3
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
SC : 3 1 2
What you present have-en do
Dative movement:
The term dative movement has been used to refer to the transformation that
relates a prepositional indirect-object construction (The girl gave milk to the cat)
to a double-object construction (The girl gave the cat milk), especially in English
(e.g. Erteschik-Shir 1979).
Dative movement or dative shift refers to a pattern in which the
subcategorization of a verb can take on two alternating forms, the oblique dative
form or the double object construction form.
Dative Movement has the effect of moving the indirect object to the position
immediately following the dative verb and deleting the preposition to or for".
Verbs that take two objects or can be called dative verbs: give, show, tell, send,
write, offer, pay… How to apply it ?
Example:
Hajar showed her sister the picture
As usual, there is dative movement and affix hopping:
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
SC: X 1. 4+2
Hajar past show her sister+the picture
The application of the “ affix hopping” rule
SD: Hajar past show her sister the picture
X. 1. 2. Y
SC: X. 2+ 1. Y
Hajar Show + past her sister the picture
After the application of the morphophonemic rules ,the outcome is :
SS: Hajar showed her sister the picture.
Complex np shift :
Complex NP Shift is a kind of movement in which we invert the NP with the PP.
Shift means there is no deletion of any elements of the sentence.
Imperative rule
An imperative sentence is a sentence that expresses a direct command, request,
invitations, warning, or instruction. Imperative sentences do not have a subject;
instead, a directive is given to an implied second person. For example, the
sentence “Wash the dinner plates” commands the implied subject to wash the
dishes
Examples:
Wash the dinner plates
Leave the house
Move the table
These examples need a subject, because every sentence needs a subject
In these examples, there is an omission of the np subject
And the deletion of modal
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
The omitted subject is “you “ and the Modal shall be either “will “or “shall”
Let’s add the subject and the Modal to the sentences You
will wash the dinner plates.
You will leave the house.
You will move the table.
Explanations :
As we have seen with all the rules,we apply the affix hopping rule at the end But
in the imperative rule,we have to apply the affix hopping first
Why?
Because in the imperative rule,we will delete “you” and “will”
And if we apply affix hopping after it , there’s no affix to hop “leave the house “
That’s why ,we should use affix hopping then apply the imperative rule:
1. 2. 3
SC:. 3
Wash the dinner plates.
1. 2. 3
SC: 3
Leave the house
SS: leave the house
Reflexivization rule :
In grammar, reflexivity is a property of syntactic constructs whereby two
arguments of an action or relation expressed by a single predicate have the same
reference. Reflexivity may be expressed by means of: reflexive pronouns or
reflexive verbs.
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
1. 2. 3. 4
SC: 1. 2. 3. 4+self
I present hurt me+self
For example:
There is a fly in my soup.
Change the sentence to an active declarative sentence
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
1. 2. 3. 4
SC: there 2 3+1 4
There present be +a fly in my soup
The application of the “ affix hopping” rule
He should arrive on time, shouldn’t he? He doesn’t love you, does he? They
love you, don’t they? He was walking in the park, wasn’t he? The man was not
being shot at, was he?
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
For example:
He should arrive on time, shouldn’t he?
Change the sentence to an active declarative:
Ad: he should arrive on time.
We will start with the affix hopping rule :
Conclusion
Exams
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
By :dororo hyakimaru Luffy
Good luck 🤞
Transformation
Generative
Grammar