VQA Benefits For AMR Networks: October 2007
VQA Benefits For AMR Networks: October 2007
Figure2::AMR-FRandEFRperformanceincleanspeech.AMR-FRisabletoprovideasimilarqualityasEFRat
about4-5dBlowerC/Ilevel.(Source:GSM06.75v7.2.0[1])
VQA Benefits for AMR Networks
Cop,||| 2007 0|ec| Newo||s 5/12
AscanbeseeninFigure2,AMR-FRenablesaC/Igainofabout4-5dBoverEFR,whichtranslatesintoapoten-
tialcapacitygainofupto150%[2].However,thisassumescleanspeechandanextensiveuseofthelowest
codecratesincludingAMR4.75andAMR5.90.
The AMR-HR Channel Mode
TheAMR-HRmodeusesahalfratechannel,whichmeansthatitonlytakesuphalfoftheradiobasestation
resourcesasacorrespondingAMR-FRcall.TheAMR-HRmodeenablescarrierstosupportmorecallswiththeir
existingradioinfrastructure,thusimprovingtheirequipmentutilization.Thisisparticularlyusefulindealing
withcapacitydemandpeakswhereacarriercanuseAMR-HRtoenablemoretraffcchannelsandavoidcon-
gestion.
TheAMR-HRcodecisbetterthantheoldGSMHalfRate(HR)codec,butitcannotmatchtheEFRcodec,ascan
beseeninFigure3:
Figure5::AMR-HRperformanceinnoisyspeechcomparedtoHR,FR,andEFR(Source:GSM06.75[1]).
ItturnsoutthatAMR-HRperformssignifcantlyworsethanthefull-ratecodecsFRandEFRinthecriticalarea7
dB<C/I<13dBduetothesensitivityofthelowestAMRcodecratestobackgroundnoise,ascanbeseeninthe
abovefgure.
Asaresult,AMR-HRwasunabletomeettheoriginal3GPPselectionrequirementsinnoisyconditions[1].
Conventional Ways of Addressing the AMR Limitations
Handset-Based Noise Suppression
DuringthestandardizationofAMR,3GPPidentifedtheimpactofbackgroundnoiseonvoicequalityandthe
limitationsofthelowestAMRcodecratesinnoisyconditions.Itissuedasetofminimumperformancerequire-
mentsonhandset-basednoisesuppressioninanattempttoaddresstheproblem[3].
Theserequirementsarehowevernotmandatoryandapparentlynotstringentenough,aslarge-scalemeasure-
mentsonliveAMRcallsshowthatconsiderableamountsofnoiseremaininthecallswithsignifcantimpacts
onvoicequalityanduserexperience.ThiscanbeseeninFigure6,whereabout20%ofAMRcallsfallbelow
acceptablequality:
VQA Benefits for AMR Networks
Cop,||| 2007 0|ec| Newo||s 8/12
Cumulative AMR Voice Quality Distribution - Uplink
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
< 1.7 < 2.2 < 2.7 < 3.3 < 3.8 < 4.3
< 33 < 43 < 53 < 63 < 74 < 100
P
e
r
c
e
n
t
a
g
e
o
f
C
a
l
l
s
No VQA
Acceptable
quality limit
MOS
R Factor
Figure6::About20%ofAMRcallsfallbelowacceptablequalityduetonoiseandacousticechoproblemsandhigh
useofAMR-HR(chartbasedonmixof50%AMR-FRand50%AMR-HRcallsat1%FERinaNorthAmericanGSM
network).
TheresultsintheabovechartwereobtainedfromobjectivevoicequalitymeasurementsaccordingtotheITU-T
G.107E-model[4]onmorethan10millionlivecallsinamajorGSMnetworkinNorthAmericawitha100%AMR
penetration.
TheITU-TG.107standardisanon-intrusivemeasurementmethodthatisabletotakeintoaccounttheimpactof
noiseandechoimpairmentsontheconversationalqualityoflivecalls.TheG.107standarddefnesametricfor
overallvoicequalitycalledthetransmissionratingfactorR.TheRfactorisanumberbetween0and100,where
thenumber100representsanidealcallwithnoimpairments.TheRfactorcanalsobetranslatedintoa
MOSfgure.
ItcanbenotedthatbackgroundnoiselevelsinNorthAmericanmobilephonecallsaregenerallylowerthanthose
originatinginthedenselypopulatedurbanareasofe.g.Europe,Asia,theMiddleEast,andLatinAmerica,where
noiseimpairmentsincombinationwithlower-endhandsetshaveanevenbiggerimpactonuserexperience.
Theconclusionfromtheabovelarge-scalemeasurementsofliveAMRcallsisthatthebasicnoisesuppression
algorithmsthatarepresentonAMRphonesdonotseemtobesuffcientinaddressingtheproblemofexternal
impairments.
Restricting the Use of the Lowest AMR Codec Rates
OnecommonmethodintheindustrytoaddresstheproblemwiththeperformanceofthelowestAMRcodecrates
issimplytorestricttheuseofthesecodecrateseventhoughthisdoesnotreallyaddresstherootproblemwhichis
relatedtotheimpactofbackgroundnoise.
ExtensivemeasurementsinalargeandheavilyloadedNorthAmericanAMRnetworkshowedthatthebyfardomi-
natingcodecrateinAMR-FRmodewasAMR12.2,andthedominatingcodecrateinAMR-HRmodewasAMR
7.4.Theuseofthelowestcodecrates,AMR4.75,5.15,and5.90,wasverysmall.
ThesemeasurementsindicatethatnetworksarenottakingadvantageofthefullpotentialofAMR.Inorderto
achievethepromisedcapacityandqualitybeneftsofAMR,theremustbeamoresubstantialuseofthelower
codecrates,bothinAMR-FRandinAMR-HRmodes.
VQA Benefits for AMR Networks
Cop,||| 2007 0|ec| Newo||s 9/12
Ditechs VQA Solution
VQA Overview
DitechsVoiceQualityAssurance(VQA)solutionisacomprehensivesetofindustry-leadingvoiceprocessing
algorithmsincludingbi-directionalAdaptiveNoiseCancellation(ANC),AcousticEchoCancellation(AEC),andEn-
hancedVoiceIntelligibility(EVI)thattogethermitigatetheproblemsofusinglowbit-ratecodecsinnoisyenviron-
mentscommoninmobilecalling.Thus,VQAisanessentialcomplementtoAMR.
TheVQAsolutionisnetwork-based,whichmeansitprovidesconsistentvoicequalityenhancementtoallsubscrib-
ers,regardlessofhandsetmodelsthattheyuse.Thisenablescarrierstooptimizedeliveredqualityandcapacityin
awaythatisnototherwisepossible.Further,network-basedvoiceenhancementdoesnothavethelimitationsin
processingpowerandbatterylifethathandset-basedsolutionshave.
DitechssolutionistypicallydeployedonthestandardA-interfaceattheMobileSwitchingCenter(MSC)andis
abletoprocessandenhanceallcalltypesincludingmobile-to-mobileandmobile-to-PSTNcalls:
Figure7::DitechsSolutionatA-Interface
Thesolutionconsistsoftwosoftwarepackagesthataredeliveredononeofthreehardwareplatforms,wherethe
choiceofhardwareisbasedonnetworkinterfacerequirements:
VoiceQualityAssurance(VQA)improvesthespeechqualitybyemployingbackgroundnoisecancellation,
speechenhancementforlowbitrateGSMcodecs,backgroundnoisecompensation,acousticechocontrol,voice
leveladjustment,andoptionalhybridechocancellation
ExperienceIntelligenceTM(EXi)
o Quantifesandcategorizesexternalimpairmentssuchasnoiseandechothatarepresentonlivecalls
o GeneratesacallqualityscorebasedupontheITU-TG.107E-modelstandard[4].
Hardwareplatformsdependentonnetworkconfguration
o E1basedA-interface:QuadVoiceProcessor(QVP)
o STM1basedA-interface:BroadbandVoiceProcessor(BVP)
VQA Benefits for AMR Networks
Cop,||| 2007 0|ec| Newo||s 10/12
Results from VQA Deployment in AMR Network
Figure8showstheresultsfromthemeasurementsinaNorthAmericanAMRnetworkthatwasdiscussedearlier,
includingtheeffectofVQA,whichherereducestheamountofunacceptablecallsfrom20%toonlyafew
percents:
Cumulative AMR Voice Quality Distribution - Uplink
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
< 1.7 < 2.2 < 2.7 < 3.3 < 3.8 < 4.3
< 33 < 43 < 53 < 63 < 74 < 100
P
e
r
c
e
n
t
a
g
e
o
f
C
a
l
l
s
No VQA
VQA
Acceptable
quality limit
MOS
R Factor
Figure8::VQAremovesexternalimpairmentsandreducestheamountofcallsbelowacceptablequalitylimit
from20%toonlyafewpercents(chartbasedonmixof50%AMR-FRand50%AMR-HRcallsat1%FERina
NorthAmericanGSMnetwork).
Theaboveresultsillustratestheabilityofanadvancednetwork-basedvoicequalityenhancementsolutionsuch
asVQAtoimprovethequalitydistributionofAMRcallsbyminimizingtheamountofcallsfallingbelowtheac-
ceptablequalitylimit.
VQA Benefts for AMR-HR and AMR-FR
VQAisanessentialcomplementtoAMRinthatitimprovestheperformanceofAMR-particularlyatthelower
codecratesbyremovingnoiseandechoimpairments.VQAalsohavelowbit-ratecodecenhancementfea-
turesincludedinEVIthatfurtherimprovethequalityofthelowestAMRcodecrates.
AmoreaggressiveuseofthelowestAMRcodecratesincombinationwithVQAwillreduceoverallFERlevelsin
thenetworkandremoveexternalimpairments,whilemaintainingorimprovingdeliveredquality.
ThisenablesGSMcarrierstocost-effectivelyimprovechannelcapacitybyincreasingtheiruseofAMR-HRin
areaswherecongestionisapotentialproblem.
Also,VQAcombinedwithamoreaggressiveuseofthelowestAMRcodecratesinAMR-FRmodewillenable
carrierstofurthertightentheirfrequencyreusetoincreaseBTSsitecapacityandspectrumeffciency,andto
lowertheneedforthecostlyconstructionofnewBTSsites.
VQA Benefits for AMR Networks
Cop,||| 2007 0|ec| Newo||s 11/12
Conclusions
Anadvancednetwork-basedvoicequalityenhancementsolutionsuchasDitechsVoiceQualityAssurance
(VQA)isanessentialcomplementtotheAMRcodecthatenablescarrierstofullyrealizethecoverage
andcapacitybeneftsoriginallypromisedbyAMR.
AMRprovidesexcellentradiolinkadaptationindiffcultRFenvironmentsbyrelyingonacombinationof
lowbit-ratespeechcodecsandpowerfulerror-correctioncodingtoachievethesebenefts.
However,thelowestcodecrates,e.g.AMR4.75kbpsandAMR5.90kbps,arehighlysensitivetoback-
groundnoise,andalthoughtheselowbit-ratecodecsperformquitewellincleanspeechconditions,their
qualitytendstodegradesignifcantlyinnoisyconditionscommoninwirelesscalling.
3GPPidentifedtheselimitationsalreadyduringthestandardizationofAMRandissuedasetofminimum
performancerequirementsonhandset-basednoisesuppressioninanattempttoaddresstheproblem.
Theserequirementsarehowevernotmandatoryandapparentlynotstringentenough,aslarge-scalemea-
surementsonliveAMRcallsshowthatconsiderableamountsofnoiseremainonthecallswithsignifcant
impactsonvoicequalityanduserexperienceasaresult.
Duetovoicequalityconcernssuchasthosedescribedabove,AMRcarriersoftentendtolimittheuseof
thelowestAMRcodecrates.ThisnotonlyforcescarrierstorestricttheamountofAMR-HRthattheycan
employinordertoimprovechannelcapacityandequipmentutilization,butitalsolimitsthespectrum
effciencyandcellcapacitygainstheycouldotherwiseachievewithamoreaggressiveuseofthelowest
codecratesinAMR-FRmode.
Theaboveissuescanbeaddressedbydeployingpowerfulnetwork-basedvoiceprocessingsolutionswith
adaptivenoiseandechocancellationfunctionsandlowbit-ratecodecenhancementssuchasVQA.These
solutionsenablecarrierstoachievethefullbeneftsofAMRbyemployingadvanceddigitalsignalprocess-
ingmethodstoremoveexternalimpairmentsandenhancetheperformanceofespeciallythelowestAMR
codecrates.
References
[1]GSM06.75version7.2.0:PerformanceCharacterizationoftheGSMAdaptiveMulti-Rate(AMR)
SpeechCodec
[2]GSM,GPRSandEDGEPerformance,2ndEdition,Halonen,Romero,Melero,WileyLtd.
[3]3GPPTS26.077:MinimumPerformanceRequirementsforNoiseSuppresser;ApplicationtotheAdap-
tiveMulti-Rate(AMR)SpeechEncoder.
[4]ITU-TG.107Recommendation:TheE-Model,acomputationalmodelforuseintransmissionplanning.
VQA Benefits for AMR Networks
12/12
Corporate Headquarters
US Sales West
DitechNetworks
825EastMiddlefieldRd.
MountainView,CA94043
USA
1-800-234-0884(TollFree)
1-650-623-1300(Direct)
1-650-564-9599(Fax)
[email protected]
US Sales Office East and Central
DitechNetworks
8360GreensboroDr.
McLean,VA22102
USA
1-800-234-0884(TollFree)
1-650-623-1300(Direct)
1-650-564-9599(Fax)
[email protected]
Canada Sales Office
DitechNetworks
2275LakeshoreBlvdWest,Suite500
Toronto,ONM8V3Y3
Canada
1-416-255-7776(Phone)
[email protected]
Mexico Sales Office
DitechNetworks
TorcuatoTasso245-6o.Piso
Col.Polanco
Mxico,D.F.C.P.11570
Mxico
+52(55)5254-5422(Main)
+52(55)5350-8679(Sales)
[email protected]
Brazil Sales Office
DitechNetworks
AlamedaAraguaia,933
Alphaville
Barueri,SP06455-000
Brazil
+55(11)4208-6266(Main)
+55(21)3521-5543(Sales)
[email protected]
[email protected]
China Sales Office
DitechNetworks
Unit3010,No.500
XiangyangSouthRoad
XuhuiDistrict
Shanghai200031
PRC
+86(21)54560305(Phone)
[email protected]
South-East Asia Sales Office
DitechNetworks
LippoPlaza3rdFloor
Jl.Jend.SudirmanKav.25
Jakarta12920
Indonesia
+62(21)52913780(Phone)
+62(21)5221977(Fax)
[email protected]
South Asia Sales Office
DitechNetworks
No.8/11,SarvapriyaVihar
NewDelhi110016
India
+919810372555(Phone)
[email protected]
Middle East/Africa Sales Office
DitechNetworks
21El-FawakehSt.,3rdFloor
Dokki,Giza12311
Egypt
+202336-5100(Phone)
+202761-8964(Fax)
[email protected]
Spain Sales Office
DitechNetworks
TorresQuevedo,1(P.T.M.)
28760TresCantosMadrid
Spain
+34(91)8037444(Main)
+34(91)8292690(Sales)
[email protected]
[email protected]
Cop,||| 2007 0|ec| Newo||s. /|| |||s |ese|.ed. lac|e vo|ce l|ocesso| aud vC/ a|e |adera||s o 0|ec| Newo||s. /|| o|e| b|auds a|e |e p|ope|, o |e||
|espec|.e owue|s. 'pec|ca|ous ra, c|aue w||ou uo|ce. !||s docureu was |as |e.|sed 02/07.
About Ditech Networks
DitechNetworkssuppliesvoiceprocessingequipmentfortelecommunicationnetworksaroundtheworld.DitechNetworkstechnology
solutionsincludevoice,mediaprocessing,SIP,andsecuritydeliveredoncarrier-gradescalableplatformstoenhancethedeliveryof
communicationsservicesovermobile,VoiceoverIP,andwirelinenetworks.DitechNetworkscustomersarepremiernetworkoperators
includingVerizon,AT&T,OrascomTelecom,andothersthatcollectivelyservemorethan150millionsubscribers.