Python
Python
net/publication/287087678
CITATIONS READS
0 2,750
1 author:
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Vivian Besem Ojong on 10 January 2018.
© 2012 Journal of Dharma: Dharmaram Journal of Religions and Philosophies (Dharmaram Vidya Kshetram, Bangalore), ISSN: 0253-7222
428 Vivian Besem Ojong
someone’s destiny that person will be poor while they are rich. They
are also wicked. They do not want to help people for nothing, if a
friend or family member asks for help they will keep promising and
never give. Sometimes they will prefer to make that person who is
asking them for help to join their society. Some groups do not make
innocent people their victims. Except that you take their money or
something of theirs they cannot kill you; but with others they will kill
you whether or not you take their money or not.
3. Types of Nyongo
There are different kinds of nyongo as far as the Cameroonian society is
concerned. In as much as wealth, success and power are the main reasons
why people engage in nyongo practices, there are some kinds of nyongo
associated specifically with some of these aspects while others are
associated with other concepts which will be examined below.
The Bamenda Grassfields people differentiate between various
categories of nyongo or witchcraft. There, witchcraft is as much a source
and resource of personal and collective power or powerlessness as it is a
call for “domesticated agency” against various forms of exploitation,
marginalization, inequality and individualism7 In Bum, a village in the
North West region of Cameroon there are two kinds of nyongo: the
Awung and the Msa. Awung is identifiable mainly through words and
actions. Members are seen as jealous and destructive, as they eat rather
than slave their victims mysteriously and their victims must be kin, as they
are expected to prove intimacy, and it is dangerous to victimize strangers.
Members can enhance their power through this and also protect themselves
against other nyongo practitioners with whom relations are of mutual fear
and distrust. Nyamnjoh continues that Msa on its part is an omnipresent
mysterious world of beauty, abundance, marvels and infinite possibilities,
inhabited by very wicked, hostile and vicious people. It is visible only to
the members who alone can visit it anytime, anywhere, and who can
conjure it up to appear for the innocent or non members to glimpse.
Everywhere in this community Msa is above all, an ambivalent place
where good and bad, pleasure and pain are all intertwined. Its inhabitants
are both the source of admiration and envy, especially for their material
abundance. Msa is like a market, complete with traders and buyers, a
bazaar where many come but where, unfortunately, few are rewarded with
clear-cut choices. To get what one wants, one must bargain and pay for it.
But the only currency in Msa is the human being, euphemistically known
as “goat” or “fowl.” Villains tether their victims at Msa like goats or fowl,
hoping for the best while risking the worst, as everything good or bad from
Msa is believed to proliferate like a virus once acquired.
In other parts of Cameroon as described by Harries,8 Ekong is the
most widespread form of nyongo today. It is performed by members, who
accept money from their clients and then provide them with slaves. Their
victims can be seen to weaken and finally die, while others get rich
without apparent reason. But even before they are dead, the Ekong victims
can be used. For the Douala, every person has an invisible double, which
can be bewitched and transported to work for his or her owner even as the
person is lying visibly on his bed. The connection between those that die
and those that accumulate wealth is one of cause and effect, proof being
provided by people being returned from the dead by nganga (healers) who
can see the occult slave trade.
To add to this, according to some participants of the research, there
are many kinds of nyongo with names unknown but which can be
identified through their activities. In some places, for example, village
local champions belong to nyongo houses as a thing of pride, while in
other societies in the stakes of each nyongo house or group, identifies it.
There are nyongo groups for poor or seemingly poor people, for the
average in the society and some for the elite class. For some membership
is restricted to the kind of influence you have in the society. One thing
stands out clear as far as nyongo is concerned, no matter the kind that its
members or practitioners seek to sever links with kin as far as their wealth
is concerned but mend things with them in relation to family ties. Indeed,
the fact that witchcraft accusations usually occur among kins is indicative
of how much people in the region are bound up in issues of solidarity,
intimacy, trust and the extent to which they are implicated in anxieties
surrounding social reproduction.
4. The State of Death
Generally speaking, death is considered to be accompanied by a change of
form or external appearance, but with some part of the original essence
surviving. Nyongo is a typical example of how the self can be transformed
through death. Ethnographic examples used in this article of living
relatives who have come across their dead relatives (those perceived to
have died through nyongo) suggest that the people are different from their
previous selves since they fail to interact with family members in the way
they did when they were alive and live lonely lives.
Melvis (a 32 years businesswoman in Durban) explained that her
aunt came home one day from her shop panting and stressed because,
according to her, her late second cousin’s daughter who had died as a
result of nyongo had come to her looking for a job. It seemed that she did
not know that her aunt knew that she was dead. When she introduced
herself, her aunt was so shocked that she gave her a seat and asked her
maid to watch her while she went to call her sister to come and check if
she was the same person who had died. When they returned to the shop,
they found the maid screaming because the ghost had seen them coming
and, knowing that her other aunt would recognize her, had disappeared.
Elizabeth, a 36 years old PhD student at the University of KwaZulu-
Natal in Durban, narrated the following story:
In Pinyin, my village, a young girl died. The death was so mysterious
that family members and friends were concerned actually to know
what took this young girl’s life. A witch doctor was being consulted
and he testified that the girl has been sold in to ‘Nyongo’ by her
mother’s sister. People could not believe what this man said, but
after this girl was buried, three years later, she was found in a
different town selling in the market. During these years, her aunt had
flourished and had two new cars and three houses. The person who
saw this little girl, called her by her name, and at that same spot, she
disappeared and has never been seen again.
In contemporary Cameroonian society, nyongo has become so real
that it cannot be omitted from any ontological conception of belief. Beliefs
and views about nyongo pose serious hermeneutical and epistemological
questions of whether or not those dead through nyongo practices are still
living and working and, if so, what the implications are for the living as
well as the dead. When I asked respondents whether it is possible for
someone to be dead yet alive, there were various responses. Valerie, a 30
year old man, said, “practically no, but in terms of Nyongo, yes.”
According to Melvis, spirits of people who do not die a natural death
linger until such time that they were supposed to die. Emmanuel, a 34 year
old man, said “I am not really sure but from the stories I have heard,
people who die from nyongo are seen elsewhere. So I can say that if
witchcraft does exist then it is possible.”
5. Appropriations of Nyongo
This form of witchcraft was first observed among the Bakweri of West
Cameroon and reported by Ardener in the 1950s. According to him, a
person possessing nyongo spirit is able to kill others, especially his/her
own relatives, and use their bodies to work for him/her in an invisible
town on Mount Kupe. Some people enter this occult group deliberately
because they are looking for a quick way of getting what they want out of
life. Others go there unknowingly and once in, there is no turning back.
They have the option of either joining or being killed by those in the
nyongo occult group. It is an easy option for those who love money and
also people who are impatient, who want to become rich at all costs
because their friends are rich.
When nyongo originally appeared in the 1950s, as Edwin Ardener
observed when he first encountered this form of witchcraft among the
Bakweri,9 it was believed that only family members could be sold. This is
still largely the case, but of late non-family members have also been sold
to nyongo. According to the informants in the study, anyone can be sold to
nyongo.Bongmba notes that all the practitioner needs is some link with the
intended victim – a gift of money, for example, or even something as
simple as dropping money for the innocent victim to pick up.
6. Death through Nyongo and Transformation of Self
Death through nyongo is a type of rebirth because it ushers the individual
into a new life with new experiences and a new existence. This is because
the person dies when sold and is ‘reborn’ into a new category. The
question is whether people who die through nyongo should be given a new
name since they are still living and working in an invisible economy. This
is debatable since technically, they are the same people but at the same
time different because they cannot fit into their previous roles in life.
Stephen Eliis and Gerrie Ter Haar believe that “anything that ceases to
exist in one category, and which may more appropriately be assigned to
another category as a result of changes it has undergone, may thus be
considered to have “died” in the first category, even while some elements
of its previous nature is transferred to its new existence.”10 These elements
enable some continuity of life to be experienced, rather than life consisting
9
Ardener E., “The Plantations and the People of Victoria Division” in S.
Ardener Kingdom on Mount Cameroon, 151-226.
10
Ellis Stephen and Haar G. T., Worlds of Power: Religious Thought and
Political Practice, Johannesburg: Wits University Press, 2001.
of phases completely unrelated to one another. This would mean that there
are some boundaries of identity that are crossed. The question then arises:
do these people actually cross boundaries? There may not be any
straightforward answer to this question but it would appear that, such a
person is a boundary crosser, who is both human and spirit (in the sense
that they have a human appearance but also have the ability to appear and
disappear, which is not human. These people temporarily cross the
boundaries of life and death. Van Gennep11 and Victor Turner12 both
described this type of dwelling on the margins as “liminality.” This is a
subjective state of being on the threshold of ‘betwixt’ and between two
different existential positions.
To be in this space is to be caught up in intense “boundary work.”13
Waiting in the grave or mortuary for the nyongo people can be considered
a rite of passage, where the bodies of those who will be used in slave
labour are in a liminal space, waiting for something to happen.14 In this
case, they are waiting to be deployed to their work destination. Such a
space is embedded with secrecy (since this activity is carried out at night
and only nyongo people are privileged with such information. In the case
of nyongo, waiting is an undesirable state where the victims wait to begin
a new life of oppression and loss of self. Such a space places them in
liminality. A distinction is made here between transitional and perpetual
liminality. Being in transitional liminality is the state of waiting to be
abducted from the grave into forced slave labour, but perpetual liminality
is a state of being in continuous loyalty to the owner until he/she dies,
when the person is freed to die. This type of liminality appears to be
mandatory and is at the centre of nyongo economies.
7. The State of the Working Dead
Nyongo seems to freeze the distance between life and death, causing a
grey area between the living and the dead. Through nyongo discourse, it is
becoming increasingly difficult to discuss life and death in absolutist
terms. It would appear that those sold to slave labour are not dead but are
‘living people’ waiting for real death. The debate about when a person is
11
Van Gennep A., Les Rites de Passage: Etudes Systematiques des Rites, Paris:
E. Noury, 1981.
12
Turner V., The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-structure, New York: De
Gruyter, 1969.
13
Hernes T. and Paulsen N., ed., Managing Boundaries in Organisations:
Multiple Perspectives, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2003, 1-5.
14
Crapanzano V., Waiting: The Whites of South Africa, London: Granada, 1985.
really considered dead began in 1975 and the conclusion was that a person
should be declared dead once they have lost the ability to meaningfully
interact with others. Such thinkers15 argued that the legal boundary of
death should be the state of permanent unconsciousness, which marks the
death of a person.
Based on the interviews and the general perception that those who
have been enslaved by nyongo labour are not really dead, they should be
reconceptualised as living people because they are actively involved in
wealth creation economies. They are seen in the market places, shops,
plantations and so on. They should be considered living on the basis of
their contribution to the economy. The main question is whether these
people can be reintegrated into society by any means. The interviews
revealed that, if the person had been sold and had not died the ‘first death’
(that is, before being buried and working in the nyongo economy), the
person can lead a normal life. The story below by Audin, a 28 year old
female, exemplifies the above point.
It is common practice in Cameroon for people to join njangi, fund
rising groups. When these youth go to the markets they join these
small njangi groups and they do not know that most of these groups
are nyongo societies. They contribute all their money all the time
knowing that they will benefit from it and plough back the money
into their business to make it grow. When it is their turn to benefit,
only then they are told how much money they will be getting and
what they need to bring which is usually some family member.
A cousin of mine has been a victim of such groups. He was
trading in ‘nchang shoes.’ He would live from Bamenda and go to all
the bush markets surrounding the North West to sell his goods and he
was doing well until his friend told him of the njangi they were doing
in Pinyin market and how beneficial it is. The friend lured and
cajoled him to join the group and he did. Pinyin market is once a
week so each time they went to that market, the friend would come
to his shed to collect his money for the njangi. That went on every
week until one day his friend came and told him that he is the one
benefitting from the njangi the following week and as such he needs
to be present at the meeting this week so that they’ll tell him about
what he needs to do. He agreed and went to the meeting that week
and they told him that he will be getting five million francs CFC. He
15
Gervais K. G., Redefining Death, New York: Yale University Press, 1986.
was surprised and asked them how it was possible since he thought
he would be getting only 500 000 CFA. It is only then that they
explained things to him. And they told him he had to sacrifice his
mother to get that money. He loved his mother so much and his
father had died a long time ago and their mother single raised him
and his two younger sisters up. He begged and pleaded with them
that he didn’t know that is what it entailed but they wouldn’t listen.
He said he is not interested in the money anymore and that they
should keep it and let it go but they wouldn’t listen. He ran out of the
place and went to his shed. Packed his things and left the market that
day. He didn’t go to that particular market again just to keep away
from them. But still they wouldn’t live him alone. They would
appear to him and taunt him, threaten him. Things became worse and
his friend came to him and told him to pay ten million in exchange
for his life and that of his mother. He decided to stop his njangi
business. Borrowed money from money lenders and bought two taxis
thinking this would make money faster. The taxis worked only for a
day and he parked the one he was driving in front of the house and it
mysteriously caught fire and was burnt to ashes. Two days later the
other one also caught fire. Both the occult people and the money
lenders were after him for the money. The occult people told him the
only way out for him is to sacrifice his mother and he will get back
everything and they’ll also make him rich.
To cut the long story short, he finally ran away from Bamenda
and went to Yaoundé. There the people were still after him to the
extent that they asked him to remove his cloths and go naked. He
was going around only in underwear. He entered the taxi and a lady
sitting next to him asked him why he is going around naked. He
explained to the lady. She felt sorry for him and told him that the
same thing had happened to his sister. The lady took him far away to
the land of the pigmies and showed him where they delivered his
sister from the occult powers. He didn’t have money to pay. So the
pigmies decided after the women pleaded to heal him and he would
come back and pay and finally they delivered him using their own
powers. They told him that he should come back and pay and that if
he doesn’t they will cast a spell on him and that theirs will be worse
than that of the njangi.
It is possible for someone to be dead but alive. This is not only
with nyongi but even some groups in Cameroon believe that people
die and come back. For example, the Bayangis believe that a person
would die and come back to life so they will pack the person’s things
and keep them somewhere believing that the person will come to
collect the things so that they can use it in their next life.
The above scenario, according to the interviews, is the only possible
way people can easily reintegrate. However to consider reintegration after
burial would depend on two factors: 1. the ability of the person to return to
their previous self and 2. the ability of society to accept the person as a
living person. This would probably depent on how we reconceptualise
nyongo death. If we redefine nyongo dead as a ‘type of migrant worker’
who has travelled, their reintegration might be possible and easier. It is
important to note that nyongo death creates a situation where people may
or may not return. Families who have lost people through nyongo death
will continue to live in limbo, especially in instances where people have
claimed that, that person has been seen working somewhere. One major
challenge here is the lack of appropriate research to support the assertion
that forced slave nyongo labourers are not dead. Pronouncing these people
dead shows society’s inability to deal with the possibilities of treating
them as living and accepting them in the normal routines of life.
Contemplating reintegration poses serious methodological and
epistemological challenges to the current discourse. Firstly, will that
person be conscious enough to remember their role and status in the family
and society at large? Secondly, if that person has lost all consciousness of
their previous self, but the living are able to recognise them; how will the
person be reintegrated? Will he/she be given a new identity and birth
certificate, be assigned to a neighbourhood, etc.? These are practical
questions but difficult to answer since more research is needed. It is an
area that is not currently under investigation.
8. Conclusion
In conclusion, there are two views on the issue of life after death through
nyongo; on the one hand there are those who ontologically believe that
there is a site of life and economic activity beyond the world that we
know. This group, on the basis of their perceived choice to believe in its
existence, (as the interviews show) live and interact with others bearing in
mind the existence and dangers of nyongo. For this group, it is becoming
increasingly difficult to accept a gift from friends or family members
without envisaging a nyongo transaction. Nyongo is so enshrined in their
minds that acts of goodwill and reciprocity are misjudged or
16
Giddens A., The Construction of Society, Cambridge: Polity Press, 1984.