The document discusses the ethical challenges of environmental practices in workplaces, highlighting issues such as resource depletion, pollution, and lack of sustainable practices. It explores the root causes of these problems across different economic contexts and emphasizes the need for ethical accountability, particularly through the lens of Islamic teachings. The report concludes with recommendations for sustainable operations, environmental awareness, and community collaboration to address these challenges.
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0 ratings0% found this document useful (0 votes)
11 views13 pages
Islamiyat Project
The document discusses the ethical challenges of environmental practices in workplaces, highlighting issues such as resource depletion, pollution, and lack of sustainable practices. It explores the root causes of these problems across different economic contexts and emphasizes the need for ethical accountability, particularly through the lens of Islamic teachings. The report concludes with recommendations for sustainable operations, environmental awareness, and community collaboration to address these challenges.
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 13
SUBMITTED TO: Hafiz Amir
SUBMITTED BY: Group members
Aiman Naseer (SP22-BBA-002) Zohaib Ahmad (SP22-BBA-008) Ch Usman (SP22-BBA-011) Shanza Zainab (SP22-BBA-030) Haseeb Falak (SP22-BBA-032) SUBMISSION DATE: 26 November, 2024. ASSIGNMENT NO 03: Project Table of Contents Introduction..............................................................................................................................2 Findings and Discussion..........................................................................................................2 Ethical Challenge in Workplace Environmental Ethics...................................................2 1. Overuse and Depletion of Natural Resources............................................................2 2. Carbon Footprint and Pollution..................................................................................2 3. Lack of Sustainable Practices......................................................................................2 4. Responsibility Towards the Environment Ignored....................................................3 Root Cause of the Problem..................................................................................................3 1. Developed Countries.....................................................................................................3 2. Low-Income Countries.................................................................................................3 3. Global Supply Chains...................................................................................................3 4. Agriculture and Food Industries.................................................................................3 5. Emerging Technologies.................................................................................................4 Who Is Affected and How Many.........................................................................................4 1. Directly Affected Populations....................................................................................4 2. Indirectly Affected People............................................................................................4 3. Global Environmental Data:.....................................................................................4 Why the Problem Persists....................................................................................................4 Background of the Problem.................................................................................................5 Effects of Not Implementing Environmental Ethics.........................................................5 Effects on Mental Health..................................................................................................5 Economic and Reputational Losses.................................................................................5 Global Inequities...............................................................................................................6 Environmental Degradation and Irreversible Damage.................................................6 Legal and Regulatory Consequences..............................................................................6 Relevance to Islamic Teachings...........................................................................................7 CSR in Islam......................................................................................................................7 Conclusion and Recommendations.....................................................................................7 1. Take Up the Sustainable Operations...........................................................................7 2. Promoting Environmental Awareness.........................................................................7 3. Policy Implementation..................................................................................................8 4. Collaboration with the Community............................................................................8 Solutions to Environmental Ethics in Business with Reference to Islamic Teachings. . .8 1. Khilafah (Stewardship of the Earth)...........................................................................8 Implementations:..............................................................................................................8 2. Mizan (Balance and Moderation)................................................................................8 Implementation:................................................................................................................9 3. Tazkiyah (Purification of the Environment)...............................................................9 Implementation:................................................................................................................9 4. Charity and Community Engagement (Zakat and Sadaqah)...................................9 Other Solutions Proposed and Effectiveness......................................................................9 1. CSR Programs...............................................................................................................9 Effectiveness:...................................................................................................................10 2. Green Technologies and Eco-Innovations.................................................................10 Effectiveness:...................................................................................................................10 3. Environmental Regulations and Policy.....................................................................10 Effectiveness....................................................................................................................10 References...............................................................................................................................11 Introduction Environmental ethics looks at moral consideration about human relations with the environment and concerned with nature’s inherent worth, the relationships between ecological systems, and the obligations of humankind towards care for and maintenance of the environment. This philosophy is, and will become at an even greater rate, applicable to modern day workplaces as industries contribute heavily to the depletion of earth’s resources, environmental pollution, and excessive use of carbon dioxide and its derivatives. As far as the subject matter is concerned with “the present tip ethical dilemmas at workplaces and their solutions with the aid of Islamic teachings,” it can be argued that there is a true sense in applying environmental ethics in addressing relenting global challenges. Islamic teachings highlight the notions of stewardship (Khalifa) where an individual or a corporate body has a specific obligation to ensure sustainable management of earthly resources. Environmental ethics at working places are discussed in this report with regard to socio- ethical problems, their sources and results, and potential solutions based on Islamic and other best world practices regarding environmental management (Parboteeah & Kapp, 2008).
Findings and Discussion
Ethical Challenge in Workplace Environmental Ethics 1. Overuse and Depletion of Natural Resources Workplaces significantly contribute to over-extracting and depleting natural water, fossil fuels, and forests needed in maintaining the ecological balance of the planet. In many cases, industrial processes are apt to emphasize production over sustainability, which contributes significantly to deforestation, over-use of water, and exhausting non-renewable sources of energy. Studies reveal that industrial sectors consume about 30% of global natural resources, which threatens the future generations of resource scarcity and ecological instability. This unsustainable exploitation makes it important for industries to be resource efficient. 2. Carbon Footprint and Pollution Carbon emissions and the greenhouse gas affect climate change. Industries , through mass production activities , are major contributors to pollution as a result of illegal disposal of waste. Such actions even worsen the effects of climate change, disrupt ecosystems and pose a threat to human health. According to reports, approximately 20 percent of the working global population can end up suffering from exposure to environmental hazards such as polluted air and water resources caused by workplaces. Industrial activities not only affect natural reserves but also pose extreme health risks to the adjoining populations (Shrader-Frechette, 2001). 3. Lack of Sustainable Practices Some organizations tend to concentrate more on short term profits over the long term impact that is to the environment. Such practices, which are rather uncommon in the workplace, usually lead to ecological degradation and destruction of habitats, loss of biological diversity, and dislocation of the needy people. It does bring forth the fact regarding some businesses where sustainable approaches such as use of wind or solar energy, recycling, and conserving resources are not included in their business models. Sustainable practices are crucial not only to human existence and life but also to the societal efforts in trying to achieve the sustainable development goals. 4. Responsibility Towards the Environment Ignored Within any workplace, there is a common challenge that tends to be the disregard concerning ensuring environmental protection which prevails as a result of weak policies, ignorance, or lack of accountability. Corporations and individuals tend to abdicate their ethical relation to the environment and as a result, there are destructive practices that leaves the ecological systems in a bad state and lowers the public image. Not only does this carelessness reduce the level of employee motivation at the workplace, but it also affects the perceptions that businesses have in the society. The violation of the principles of environmental ethics is an indication of a lack of organizational principle and an impediment towards the achievement of sustainable development (Appelbaum et al., 2005).
Root Cause of the Problem
Environmental ethical issues are broad but vary in their implementation in different sectors and locations: 1. Developed Countries Industrial Sectors: In developed nations, industries such as manufacturing, energy, or transportation make a considerable contribution to global carbon emission, pollution and depletion of natural resources. For exampele, controversies about fossil fuel and renewable energy resources tend to emphasize the moral dilemmas in focussing on economic growth or concentrating in preserving the environment. Urban areas: Urban areas suffer the problems of air and water pollution by industrial effluents and disposal of solid waste. 2. Low-Income Countries a. Resource-Based Economies: Multinationals take advantage of these nations' resources. Extractive industries such as mining, deforestation, and oil sapping often result in leaving behind environmental blight, whereas benefits rarely accrue to local people. b. Labor-Intensive Industries: For the most part, firms in such countries fail to provide safe working conditions, thereby exposing the workers and people around them to hazardous situations (Dvorak et al., 2011). 3. Global Supply Chains o\tThird, ethical issues crop up when firms opt to produce in countries that have weak environmental regulations, giving room to avoid strict observance. 4. Agriculture and Food Industries o\sustainable agricultural practices, massive clearing of forests to plant more crops, misuse of water and other chemicals, on which the whole world suffer from devastating ecosystems, and the productivity of the locals. 5. Emerging Technologies The tech industry has three major concerns: electronic waste, energy consumption due to data centers, and rare earth elements mining, which usually happens in locations where little or no environmental oversight is provided.
Who Is Affected and How Many
Evidently ignoring the environment causes harm to billions of people across the globe: 1. Directly Affected Populations Workforce and Local Population: Millions of industrial workers in mining, construction, and manufacturing have to suffer from the grave environmental and health issues. People living in or around industrial towns suffer from polluted air, polluted water, and loss of forests due to it. Vulnerable Population in Developing Countries: These populations are the worst affected by unethical companies' behavior, including poisonous wastes disposal, overexploitation of natural resources, and lack of environmental protection. 2. Indirectly Affected People Global Population: Every single one is impacted by climate change, rising temperatures, extreme weather events, and resource scarcity due to unscrupulous business practices. Future Generations: The long-term effects of environmental degradation today jeopardize the survival and quality of life for billions in the future. 3. Global Environmental Data: Air Pollution: WHO indicates that over 90 percent of the global population respirates polluted air, with industrial activities being among the top contributors. Water Scarcity: 1.2 billion people suffer from water scarcity due to pollution and excessive use that stems partly from industrial processes. Biodiversity Loss: A vast percentage of species are headed for extinction due to habitat destruction as a result of corporate activities (Intja et al., 2023).
Why the Problem Persists
Short-term Gains vs. Long-term Accountability: Mainly, many businesses focus on quick earnings instead of long-term accountability for environmental actions. Regulatory Lag: Laxity in environmental legislations in some areas permits unethical practices. Consumer Demand: High consumer demand for inexpensive products fuels unsustainable practices in global supply chains. Limited Awareness: Some corporations and consumers lack awareness of the environmental and ethical implications of their actions. Technological Barriers: In some cases, sustainable alternatives are not yet cost-effective or widely available. Background of the Problem Environmental ethics at the workplace can trace their roots back to historical and current events. The beginning of industrialization was the period when things took a turning point around environmental degradation. Industrial processes mechanized under the Industrial Revolution with fossil fuel consumption tend to "milk" nature of most of her resources and will go as far as to permeate all spheres of society with pollutants. These trends solidified a consumer culture, gave rise to global trade networks, and continued the consumption of resources at an unsustainable rate while expanding that environmental footprint across nations (Lorenzo et al., 2010). In the modern workplace, these historic trends have been combined with some new realities. Globalization has escalated the pressure on ecosystems by virtue of its mechanisms for allowing goods, people, and technologies to flow rapidly into action at the expense of sustainable environments. At the same time, urbanization and technological development have increased waste generation at alarming levels, and electronic and plastic wastes have contributed to the challenge that arises because they are non-biodegradable while at times toxic. These facts and conditions point to an urgent need for organizations to embrace and promote environmental ethics as part of their operational and cultural frameworks
Effects of Not Implementing Environmental Ethics
Some of the effects of not taking up environmental ethics include; Effects on Mental Health Ignoring the ethics of the environment in the workplace leads to immense consequences for the mental health of employees. Workers who are subjected to hazardous environmental conditions often suffer from high levels of stress and anxiety, resulting in inefficiency and overall dissatisfaction in jobs. Beyond the job, the general consequences of environmental degeneration enhance existential fears associated with climate change. These looming uncertainties may soon intrude into the workplace, thereby undermining the morale of employees and a pervasive sense of powerlessness. As a result, organizations may struggle to achieve and sustain a productive, motivated workforce (Mitonga-Monga et al., 2016). Economic and Reputational Losses Failure to uphold environmental ethics can incur devastating economic and reputational losses for organizations: • Economic Impacts: Organizations convicted of unethical environmental practices are met with fines, lawsuits, and compliance costs. Clean up operations, compensations paid to the affected communities, and penalties become a source of loss of resources. • Brand Damage: Companies involved in environmental malpractices show continuous distrust among customers. Scandals related to pollution or resource exploitation break the value of a brand, hence deterring its customers and investors. • Operational Risks: The organizations engaged in unsustainable practices cause disturbances in supply chains, resources, and regulations, forcing the organizations to remain operationally inefficient. These consequences make it more challenging for companies to make profits sustainable, thereby threatening their long-term survival Global Inequities Environmental ethics neglect adversely affects weak and marginalized social groups, particularly in developing countries: • Environmental Load: The poor nations lack infrastructure, resources, and the ability to reduce and counteract the effect of industries towards the environment. Factory dumping, deforestation, and pollution raise some significant issues such as scarcity of water, unhealthy air, and poor public health. • Health Inequality: People in these regions are also at an increased risk of contracting respiratory diseases, waterborne diseases, and poisons. • Social Inequalities: Environmental irresponsibility widens the gap between rich countries or companies and poor communities who suffer the most from such activities. This contributes to the vicious cycles of poverty and health disasters, thereby creating an ethical call for businesses and governments to adopt sustainable practices in every corner of the earth. Environmental Degradation and Irreversible Damage Environmental ethics overlooking leads to ecological degradation that results in loss of biodiversity, climatic alteration, and resource exhaustion: • Climate Change: Unchecked greenhouse gas emissions lead to global warming and, as a result, extreme weather patterns, rising sea levels, and habitat destruction. • Resource Scarcity: Overexploitation of natural resources in the absence of sustainability planning depletes critical supplies like freshwater, fertile soil, and clean air. • Loss of Biodiversity: Destruction of ecosystems harms countless species, disrupting ecological balance and reducing the planet's resilience to environmental shocks Legal and Regulatory Consequences Failure to observe environmental and legal standards exposed entities to significant legal dangers: • Fines and Penalties: Breach of environmental laws could result in considerable fines, litigations, and even closure of operations. • Scrutiny by Regulatory Bodies: The governments and international institutions are implementing more stringent legal provisions on the environment, and that creates difficulties for those organizations that do not comply. • Revocation of Licenses: Continued failure to observe the law may have licenses revoked, resulting in loss of business. Legal challenges not only drain financial resources but also tarnish an organization's reputation, making recovery challenging. Relevance to Islamic Teachings Islam emphasizes humanity's role as caretakers of the earth, a concept encapsulated in the principle of Khalifa (Stewardship). The Qur’an states, “He it is Who has made you successors upon the earth.” (Qur’an 6:165), highlighting the responsibility entrusted to humans to protect and nurture the environment. This stewardship mandates sustainable living, ensuring the well-being of all creation. In addition, Islam teaches Mizan, encouraging man to maintain ecological balance and refrain from exploiting natural resources. The Qur'an says to worshipers, "And the heaven He has raised high, and He has set the balance, that you may not transgress the balance" (Qur'an 55:7-9). Upkeeping this balance is further an important duty from God. Similarly, the principle of Israf (Avoiding Waste) holds true to Islamic disapproval of excessiveness since the Qur'an warns, ".eat and drink, but do not waste by excess, for Allah does not love the wasters" (Qur'an 7:31). Taken collectively, these principles form the basis of an Islamic approach to environmental ethics based on accountability, moderation, and respect for creation. CSR in Islam Beyond individual conducts, Islamic teachings regard collective responsibilities that also include those of organizations, as stated above. The principles of Islamic CSR stand upon mutual respect and justice and further facilitate harmony among individuals, society, and the environment. Companies are encouraged to practice Shariah-compliant CSR policies such that workplace practices align with environmental ethics. All these policies and regulations will be followed strictly to maintain organizational values which would be summed up as sustainability, equity, and respect towards the natural resources and attached to ethical and social obligations. This follows in line with Islamic principles and contributes to worldwide efforts in environmental conservation and ethical corporate governance.
Conclusion and Recommendations
1. Take Up the Sustainable Operations Adopting renewable sources of energy at the workplace, namely solar and wind power, can work to promote sustainability in workplace operations. Such energy alternatives will significantly reduce the carbon footprint of businesses while working towards long-term energy efficiency. Initiation of strong recycling programs within companies is another strategy to minimize waste and curb single-use plastics in companies, thereby fostering an environmentally friendly work culture. These measures contribute significantly to the preservation of environmental systems besides enhancing organizational reputation. 2. Promoting Environmental Awareness Creating a sense of environmental responsibility among employees is critical. Conducting training sessions and workshops focused on environmental ethics can help employees understand the importance of their role in protecting the planet. Integrating Islamic principles, such as khilafah (stewardship of the Earth), offers a unique cultural and ethical perspective to inspire actions aligned with environmental preservation. These initiatives instill a deeper connection between faith-based values and sustainable practices (Olvitt, 2010). 3. Policy Implementation Policy making and policy enforcement help in creating sustainable environmental conditions. Strict regulations of industrial emissions and waste disposal ensure that it does not pollute the environment. Also, governments can give tax incentives to motivate businesses to maintain green activities, such as the use of energy-efficient technologies or use of sustainable materials. Such policies create a framework of accountability and motivate organizations to first think about sustainability. 4. Collaboration with the Community Collaborating with local communities is essential to achieving broader environmental goals. Bringing citizens into activities like the plantation drives, clean-up campaigns, and water conservation helps build a joint system of responsibility for environmental care. Together with NGOs and environmental organizations, these efforts could amplify in creating sustainable ecosystems; thus, businesses and communities alike will be committed to such a greener future.
Solutions to Environmental Ethics in Business with Reference to Islamic
Teachings Islamic teachings are particularly significant in providing important guidance principles to business in the adoption of ethical responsible practices towards business. The scriptures view mankind as custodians for the earth to act in a balanced course between the fulfillment of human needs and ecological preservation. Below are proposed solutions to the challenge of integrating environmental ethics in business based on Islamic teachings (Mansour et al., 2017). 1. Khilafah (Stewardship of the Earth) Islam teaches human beings as khalifah or stewards of the Earth, entrusted with responsibility over and for the preservation of its resources. Humans are entrusted by the Quran with the management of the earth's wealth, as neither their actions nor any business dealings should lead to harming the land or its resources to the point of corruption or depletion. Khalifah essentially means that all business processes must show respect to nature and utilize resources in a sustainable way and avoid waste. Implementations: The business should infuse the concept of khalifah as the corporate value, where it should reflect that environmental care is at the heart of its operation. In addition to this, it should also save from carbon footprint, conserve natural resources, and others such as recycling, waste reduction, and use of renewable energy sources. Leadership should relay this responsibility to the employees through training and through policies that embody these values (Mohammad et al., 2018). 2. Mizan (Balance and Moderation) The Quran repeatedly points out the principle of mizan, which translates to balance. Humans have been cautioned not to waste while being greedy. For business purposes, this principle can be implemented by carrying out operations in such a way that they maintain ecological balance. Overconsumption of available resources, environmental degradation, and overall unsustainable practices make its presence against natural balance as practiced by Islam. Implementation: For the implementation of mizan, companies should be known for practicing resource efficiency. This can be achieved through using energy-efficient technology, responsible raw material use, and minimizing waste generation. Excessive production and unnecessary consumption are avoided, which actually promotes hazard to the environment. Waste- reduction policies, like having a zero-waste policy, should be implemented following the doctrine of moderation as preached in Islam. 3. Tazkiyah (Purification of the Environment) Teachings of Islam focus on cleansing not just the soul but also the surroundings. Tazkiyah goes beyond individual morals to include wellness and sanitation of the surrounding environment. Pollution of the surroundings is considered a moral evil because the act violates the natural state of purity that Allah has ordained. Implementation: In practice, businesses can engage in initiatives to keep the environment clean and free of harmful pollutants. This may include minimizing emissions, using green technologies, and also taking part in local environmental clean-up projects. Companies can also contribute by encouraging people to use eco-friendly products and packaging that are sustainable (Kashif et al., 2015). 4. Charity and Community Engagement (Zakat and Sadaqah) Zakat is an obligatory charity upon Muslims, while sadaqah is given as voluntary charity. Zakat and sadaqah contribute to companies moving toward the cause of supporting society; this includes taking care of the environment. Some examples of charity in the perspective of the Islamic world include planting trees, conserving water, and financing agricultural practices that can be considered sustainable and still secure food. To fulfill the obligation of zakat or sadaqah, enterprises can allocate some of the profits they make towards environmental causes. For instance, firms may donate to programs for reforestation or clean energy, or even help conserve water in parched areas. In addition, companies may take up initiatives that portray them as being socially responsible by doing good both for the environment and for the communities.
Other Solutions Proposed and Effectiveness
Various solutions have been proposed globally to address environmental ethics in business. These solutions are based on regulatory frameworks, technological advancements, and corporate responsibility programs. Some of the prominent solutions along with their effectiveness are as follows: 1. CSR Programs Many organizations have embraced CSR initiatives as a response to environmental issues through a shift towards sustainable practices. Such initiatives include programs to reduce carbon emissions, enhance renewable energy investments, and conserve environments. Though the initiatives are maturing, the problem remains that most of them are just new forms of greenwashing with little long-term environmental benefits. Effectiveness: CSR programs have increased awareness, and also made businesses accountable for their environmental impact. However, these are often voluntary with no strict regulations to enforce. Some companies implement CSR initiatives as part of marketing strategy without a commitment to environmental sustainability. For better effectiveness, CSR efforts must be in line with specific, measurable environmental goals and companies should be held accountable for their impact. 2. Green Technologies and Eco-Innovations Using green technologies such as renewable energy, energy-efficient systems, and recycling of wastes technology have been one of the giant challenges in the fight against the environment; hence, many companies have ventured into such innovations to minimize carbon footprint and render economies much more sustainable. Effectiveness: It is proved that green technologies efficiently reduce environmental harm, while their implementation remains expensive for many enterprises, especially small to medium-sized ones. Additionally, the scale of implementation remains small. Incentives provided by the government-such as tax breaks or subsidies to enterprises implementing environmentally friendly technologies-can encourage the wider popularization and make the solutions much more affordable. 3. Environmental Regulations and Policy Regulations that limit pollution and waste also exist worldwide. These include emissions, waste management, and the regulations on sourcing merchandise sustainably. Though the regulations can drive business to more environmentally friendly practices, they are often not universally applied and depend on the country of operation. Effectiveness Where environmental rules are more seriously enforced, the countries have seen an effective decrease in pollution and an improvement in waste management. In contrast, these policies lack real impact when the enforcement is weak or where businesses easily circumvent it. If implemented globally toward more consistent and stricter rules and if there were international cooperation, they would be most likely amplified (Kancharla & Dadhich, 2021). References Appelbaum, S. H., Deguire, K. J., & Lay, M. (2005). The relationship of ethical climate to deviant workplace behaviour. Corporate Governance: The International Journal of Business in Society, 5(4), 43–55. Dvorak, B. I., Stewart, B. A., Hosni, A. A., Hawkey, S. A., & Nelsen, V. (2011). Intensive Environmental Sustainability Education: Long-Term Impacts on Workplace Behavior. Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice, 137(2), 113– 120. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)EI.1943-5541.0000054 Intja, N., Moyo, I., & Mangundu, A. F. (2023). Applying Environmental Ethics in the Workplace: The Case of the Rundu Campus of the University of Namibia. 1st International Conference on Ethics and Justice for a Sustainable World Co- Organised by the University of Zululand, South Africa and the University of Namibia Online, 8–9. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4478187 Kancharla, R., & Dadhich, A. (2021). Perceived ethics training and workplace behavior: The mediating role of perceived ethical culture. European Journal of Training and Development, 45(1), 53–73. Kashif, M., De Run, E. C., Abdul Rehman, M., & Ting, H. (2015). Bringing Islamic tradition back to management development: A new Islamic Dawah based framework to foster workplace ethics. Journal of Islamic Marketing, 6(3), 429–446. Lorenzo, O., Esqueda, P., & Larson, J. (2010). Safety and Ethics in the Global Workplace: Asymmetries in Culture and Infrastructure. Journal of Business Ethics, 92(1), 87–106. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-009-0142-9 Mansour, M. S., Hassan, K. H., & Bagheri, P. (2017). Shari’ah Perspective on Green Jobs and Environmental Ethics. Ethics, Policy & Environment, 20(1), 59–77. https://doi.org/10.1080/21550085.2017.1291829 Mitonga-Monga, J., Flotman, A.-P., & Cilliers, F. (2016). Workplace ethics culture and work engagement: The mediating effect of ethical leadership in a developing world context. Journal of Psychology in Africa, 26(4), 326–333. https://doi.org/10.1080/14330237.2016.1208928 Mohammad, J., Quoquab, F., Idris, F., Al-Jabari, M., Hussin, N., & Wishah, R. (2018). The relationship between Islamic work ethic and workplace outcome: A partial least squares approach. Personnel Review, 47(7), 1286–1308. Olvitt, L. (2010). Ethics-oriented learning in environmental education workplaces: An activity theory approach. Southern African Journal of Environmental Education, 27. https://www.ajol.info/index.php/sajee/article/view/122874 Parboteeah, K. P., & Kapp, E. A. (2008). Ethical Climates and Workplace Safety Behaviors: An Empirical Investigation. Journal of Business Ethics, 80(3), 515–529. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-007-9452-y Shrader-Frechette, K. (2001). Workplace Pollution: Nuclear Safety, Ethics, and the Exploitation–Avoidance Argument. Risk, 12, 311.