PTBCTC
PTBCTC
INDIVIDUAL ASSIGNMENT
HA NOI - 4/2025
TABLE OF CONTENT
III. Financial Performance Analysis
1.1 CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEET
Cod
ITEMS Units 31/12/2022 31/12/2023
e
I Revenue Growth Indicators
1 Net Revenue Growth % 31,17% -8,99%
2 Operating Profit Growth % 72,33% -19,30%
3 Net Profit Growth % 63,05% -16,66%
4 Total Asset Growth % 19,05% -0,31%
5 Equity Growth % 17,95% 9,03%
II Liquidity Ratios
1 Current Ratio
times 1,08 1,11
2 Quick Ratio
times 0,57 0,65
3 Cash Ratio
times 0,18 0,10
285,030+102,000+822,906
152,063+302,163+746,548
0.75 0,75 0 0
1,609,992 1,599,371
Cash equivalent
+ Marketable
Securities
+ Net Receivables
Current liabilities
490,196−4,217
Equity−¿ Intagible Assets 534,474−2,217 0.37% 0.33% -0.04% -
11.3
%
20,436,426 18,190,866
40,902,080 40,061,092 49.96% 45.43% -4.53% -
Net Income 9.06
Before Noncontrolling %
Interest ,
Equity Income
¿ Nonrecurring
Items
Net Sales
123,840 103,214
( 415,599+490,196)/2 ( 490,196+534,474)/2 27,34% 20,15% -7.19 -
26.29
%
The company's net revenue in 2023 reached VND 4,139 billion, a decrease of VND
408.966 billion (-8.99%) compared to 2022.
The total production volume in 2023 was 15.76 million products (including FOB
products, export processing, and domestic processing), down by 1.18 million products (-
8.14%) compared to 2022. Among these, shirts, trousers, jackets, and suits for export
and domestic processing continued to dominate the company's revenue structure. While
unit prices for products slightly increased in 2023 compared to 2022, the change was
insignificant. However, the unit price for jackets experienced a slight decline, aligning
with the overall textile and garment industry trends in 2023.
Financial Revenue:
Financial revenue in 2023 was VND 4,139 billion, a decrease of VND 408.966 billion (-
8.99%) compared to 2022, primarily due to an exchange rate loss of VND 99.31 billion,
accounting for 82.2% of total financial revenue.
The company's revenue structure has remained stable over the past three years, with the
majority still coming from apparel (FOB product revenue + export processing revenue +
domestic garment sales/tailoring revenue + domestic processing revenue ~ 95% of total
revenue).
Domestic revenue in 2023 reached VND 416.72 billion, a decrease of VND 10.99
billion (-2.57%) compared to 2022, including:
Domestic product sales and tailoring revenue: VND 237.77 billion, down VND 11.1
billion (-4.46%).
Domestic processing revenue: VND 58.94 billion, down VND 20.14 billion (-25.47%).
Other domestic revenue (hotels, supermarkets, etc.) grew in 2023, reaching VND 120.0
billion, an increase of VND 20.24 billion (+20.3%) compared to 2022 (VND 99.75
billion).
Financial revenue in 2023 reached VND 114.051 billion, a decrease of VND 6.376
billion (-5.29%) compared to 2022, mainly due to exchange rate losses (VND 99.31
billion) and interest from deposits and loans (VND 20.67 billion).
Profitability:
Gross profit in 2023 was VND 436.627 billion, a decrease of VND 58.824 billion (-
11.87%) compared to 2022. The decline in cost of goods sold (-8.64%) and net revenue
(-8.99%) contributed to a lower gross profit margin.
Net operating profit in 2023 reached VND 120.017 billion, a decrease of VND 28.710
billion (-19.30%) compared to 2022. Although the cost of goods sold and financial
expenses decreased, an increase in selling expenses and a reduction in administrative
expenses affected the overall profit margin.
c) Fluctuations in Cost of Goods Sold and Other Expenses Relative to Net Revenue
Cost of Goods Sold (COGS): The company's COGS/net revenue ratio in 2023 was
3,702.491, down 350.283 to 88.07% of net revenue, a decrease of 1.38% compared to
2022 (89.45%). This reduction contributed to increased gross profit from sales and
service provision. The analysis of production cost components as a percentage of
revenue indicates that the decrease in COGS resulted from:
(i) A reduction in raw material costs in production (2023: 51.09% of revenue, 2024:
50.06% of revenue), demonstrating improved cost management.
(ii) Lower labor costs (2023: 23.23% of revenue, 2024: 21.69% of revenue), despite an
increase in average employee salaries, reflecting improved labor productivity.
Selling Expenses: In 2023, the company’s selling expenses amounted to VND 193.35
billion, an increase of VND 34.21 billion (+21.5%) compared to 2022, accounting for
4.16% of net revenue (higher than 3.84% in 2022). Advertising costs surged as the
company diversified its advertising channels, integrating traditional methods with online
platforms such as websites, Facebook, TikTok, and Zalo. Additionally, rising export
transportation and logistics costs aligned with the broader industry trend of increasing
freight and warehousing expenses in 2024. Although the company primarily sells
products under the FOB model (where buyers bear shipping costs), it has adopted
policies to share transportation cost burdens with import partners.
Despite the rise in administrative expenses due to provisions, the company has generally
maintained good cost control, ensuring that expense ratios remain aligned with revenue
scale.
d) Profit Fluctuations
The company's net profit after tax (NPAT) in 2023 was VND 103.21 billion, a decrease
of VND 5.42 billion (-5.25%) compared to 2022, primarily due to the provision for
doubtful short-term receivables related to Li & Fung (Express Inc).
These results indicate that the company’s business operations remain stable and
efficient, ensuring sufficient cash flow for debt repayment. Revenue and profits have
shown positive growth, while employee income has improved, reflecting an effective
business strategy. The company has successfully leveraged shifts in export orders in
2024 and demonstrated resilience despite ongoing challenges in the textile and garment
industry, including intense labor competition, small and low-value orders, and supply
chain risks.
Total Assets:
As of December 31, 2022, the total assets of the Company reached VND 2,296.76
billion, an increase of VND 367.44 billion compared to the end of 2021. The asset
structure slightly shifted from current assets to non-current assets, with the proportion of
current assets/total assets at 75.51%, slightly decreasing from 78.04% at the end of
2021, while the proportion of non-current assets/total assets increased from 21.96% to
24.49%.
As of December 31, 2022, current assets amounted to VND 1,734.18 billion, an increase
of VND 228.59 billion, equivalent to a 15.2% rise compared to December 31, 2021. The
increase in current assets was primarily due to growth in cash and cash equivalents,
short-term financial investments, and deductible VAT.
Non-current assets as of December 31, 2022, totaled VND 562.58 billion, an increase of
VND 138.85 billion, equivalent to a 32.8% rise compared to the same period in 2021.
The increase in non-current assets was mainly due to fixed assets (resulting from new
machinery and equipment purchases) and ongoing construction projects (related to the
investment and upgrade of three factories in Hung Ha, Ha Quang, and Bim Son).
Liabilities:
As of December 31, 2022, the Company's total liabilities amounted to VND 1,806.56
billion, an increase of VND 292.84 billion, equivalent to a 19.3% rise compared to
December 31, 2021.
Short-term liabilities as of December 31, 2022, totaled VND 1,609.99 billion, increasing
by VND 206.63 billion, equivalent to a 14.7% rise compared to December 31, 2021.
The strongest increases were in employee payables and short-term financial lease
borrowings.
Long-term liabilities as of December 31, 2022, reached VND 196.57 billion, an increase
of VND 86.21 billion, equivalent to a 78.1% rise compared to the end of 2021.
Equity:
As of December 31, 2022, the Company's equity stood at VND 490.2 billion, an
increase of VND 74.6 billion, equivalent to a 17.9% rise compared to December 31,
2021. Specifically:
Owner’s contributed capital remained at VND 302.4 billion, accounting for 13.17% of
total capital, unchanged over the past three years. A strong equity base helps maintain a
balanced and healthy financial structure.
Retained earnings for 2022 amounted to VND 131.06 billion, increasing by VND 51.62
billion compared to December 31, 2021. The Company consistently generates high
annual profits and retains a portion for reinvestment, facilitating future growth, while
the remaining portion is used for dividend payments to shareholders.
b) Financial Structure
The Company's financial structure remains stable, with a consistently positive and high
net working capital, ensuring financial balance. Specifically:
Net working capital (December 31, 2021) = VND 102.24 billion > 0.
Net working capital (December 31, 2022) = VND 124.19 billion > 0.
Net working capital (December 31, 2023) = VND 181.96 billion > 0.
As of December 31, 2023, the Company’s cash and cash equivalents amounted to VND
152.063 billion, accounting for 8.86% of total assets, decrease of VND 132.267 billion.
(-45.65%) compared to the end of 2023.
Short-term Receivables:
In 2023, the average collection period for receivables was approximately 41.9 days,
improving from 43.2 days in 2022. Cash inflows from receivables were primarily
processed through the Company's account at VCB Chuong Duong.
Overall, the Company's receivables quality is strong, with consistent turnover. With a
professional accounting team and rigorous monitoring, the Company ensures strict
control of receivables and properly provisions for doubtful debts per accounting
standards.
Advances to Suppliers:
As of December 31, 2023, other short-term receivables totaled VND 19.46 billion, a
decrease of VND 18.65 billion (-48.95%) compared to December 31, 2022, and
accounted for 0.49% of total assets. This included accrued interest receivables of VND
8.56 billion, employee advances of VND 0.36 billion, and compensation funds for land
clearance offset against future land lease payments for the Bim Son Factory expansion
project of VND 0.35 billion, with the remaining VND 3.48 billion consisting of other
receivables.
Inventory:
As of December 31, 2023, the Company's inventory amounted to VND 746.54 billion,
accounting for 30.65% of total assets, a decrease of VND 75.73 billion (-9.28%)
compared to December 31, 2023. The increase was mainly in raw materials (+VND
20.57 billion), work-in-progress (+VND 19.89 billion), finished goods (+VND 24.7
billion), and merchandise (+VND 2.19 billion).
Liquidity: As of December 31, 2023, the company's current ratio stood at 1.11 (>1),
indicating a healthy liquidity position. The company is capable of covering all short-
term liabilities with its short-term assets.
The accounts receivable turnover decreased from 9.34 to 8.44, increasing the collection
period from 39 days to 43.2 days, indicating lower receivables turnover.
The inventory turnover decrease from 4.79 to 4.73 times, longing the inventory holding
period from 76 days to 78 days, reflecting improved inventory turnover inefficiency.
The increase in both the collection period and inventory holding time led to impact cash
flow from business operations in 2023 compared to 2022.
Consequently, the working capital turnover decreased from 2.81 times in 2022 to 2.35
times in 2023, suggesting lower capital circulation in 2023. This aligns with the
anticipated recovery of the textile and garment industry in 2023 compared to 2022.
Debt Ratio:
The debt-to-equity ratio at the end of 2023 is 3.28 times, which is relatively high.
However, the majority of this debt is derived from trade payables.
If isolating bank loans, the bank debt-to-equity ratio stands at approximately 1.22 times,
indicating that the company effectively leverages its credibility to utilize supplier credit
(interest-free capital) while maintaining a moderate level of financial leverage from
banks.
Profitability Ratios:
In 2023, the gross profit margin decreased compared to 2022. Moreover, the operating
profit margin, return on assets (ROA), and return on equity (ROE) declined, primarily
due to provisions for doubtful receivables from the Li & Fung partnership.
Foreign Exchange Risk: Currency fluctuations significantly impact financial costs and
business profitability. The company must closely monitor exchange rate trends and
adopt risk management strategies such as forward contracts, financial derivatives, and
market diversification to reduce dependence on a single currency (USD).
Payment Risk: Late payments, customer insolvencies, or contract defaults could lead to
capital losses and cash flow disruptions. To mitigate this, the company should assess
partners' financial health, utilize letters of credit (L/C), and diversify its customer base
to avoid over-reliance on a few major clients.
Input Cost Risk: The cost of raw materials and transportation is expected to rise due to
geopolitical uncertainties, global conflicts, and fluctuating U.S. tax policies.
As a large, experienced enterprise, the company has outlined several strategic measures
to achieve its 2023 business goals:
Prioritizing ongoing investment projects, evaluating their efficiency, and only executing
projects that deliver tangible benefits to business operations.
VI. CONCLUSION
The financial analysis of May 10 Garment Group Corporation (Garco 10) reveals a
decline in both revenue and operating profit, reflecting challenges in the textile and
garment industry. The company's net revenue has decreased, indicating weaker demand,
pricing pressures, or shifts in market dynamics. Additionally, operating profit has
declined, largely due to rising production costs, increased labor expenses, and
fluctuations in material prices, which have squeezed profit margins.
Despite these challenges, the company's total assets remain stable, reflecting a strong
asset base. However, the decline in revenue has impacted working capital and liquidity,
requiring more efficient cash flow management. The balance sheet indicates a higher
reliance on short-term liabilities, which could pose financial risks if not carefully
managed.
While the company continues to maintain its market presence and operational
efficiency, the decline in financial performance underscores the need for strategic
adjustments to navigate market uncertainties, cost pressures, and competitive challenges
in the garment industry.
V. APPENDIX
ASSETS
CURRENT ASSETS 100 1,734,181 1,505,593
(100 = 110 + 120 + 130 + 140 +
150)
2022 2021
Notes VND VND
Erro
r:
Refer
ence
sourc
e not
Revenue from sale of goods and foun
rendering of service 01 d 4,548,704 3,467,720
Erro
r:
Refer
ence
sourc
e not
foun
Deductions 02 d 479 371
2022 2021
Notes VND VND
Erro
r:
Refer
Net revenue form sale of goods
ence
and rendering of services (10 = 10 4,548,225 3,467,349
sourc
01 - 02)
e not
foun
d
Error:
Refer
Cost of goods sold and service ence
11 4,052,774 3,467,349
rendered sourc
e not
found
Gross profit from sales and
20 495,451 407,972
rendering of services (20 = 10 - 11)
Finance income Error:
Refer
ence
sourc
e not
21 found 120,427 44,215
Finance expense Error:
Refer
ence
sourc
e not
22 found 109,566 29,146
In which: Interest expense 23 19,100 13,164
Selling expenses Error:
Refer
ence
sourc
e not
25 found 158,093 152,526
2022 2021
Notes VND VND
Error:
Refer
ence
sourc
e not
Other income 31 found 3,554 5,891
Other expenses 32 2,036 628
Other profit
40 1,518 5,263
(40 = 31 - 32)
Accounting profit before tax
50 150,245 91,567
(50 = 30 + 40)
Error:
Refer
ence
Deferred tax (expense)/income 51 43.224.349.871 20.219.235.501
sourc
e not
found
Net profit after tax
60 123,840 75,954
(60 = 50 - 51)
Net profit after tax attributable to
Shareholders of the parents 61 97.791.437.986 103.214.087.276
Non-controlling interests 62 - -
ASSETS
CURRENT ASSETS 100 1,781,339 1,734,181
(100 = 110 + 120 + 130 + 140 +
150)
2023 2022
Notes VND VND
Erro
r:
Refer
ence
sourc
e not
Revenue from sale of goods and foun
redering of service 01 d 4,139.738 4,548,704
Erro
r:
Refer
ence
sourc
e not
foun
Deductions 02 d 630 479
42
Error: Reference source not found
Báo cáo kết quả hoạt động kinh doanh hợp nhất cho Error: Reference source not
found kết thúc Error: Reference source not found (tiếp theo)
Mẫu B 02 – DN[/HN]
(Ban hành theo Thông tư số [200/202]/TT-BTC
ngày 22/12/2014 của Bộ Tài chính)
2023 2022
Notes VND VND
Erro
r:
Refer
Net revenue form sale of goods
ence
and rendering of services (10 = 10 4,139,118 4,548,225
sourc
01 - 02)
e not
foun
d
Error:
Refer
Cost of goods sold and service ence
11 3,702,491 4,052,774
rendered sourc
e not
found
Gross profit from sales and
20 436,627 495,451
rendering of services (20 = 10 - 11)
Finance income Error:
Refer
ence
sourc
e not
21 found 114,051 120,427
Finance expense Error:
Refer
ence
sourc
e not
22 found 93,624 109,566
In which: Interest expense 23 32,388 19,100
Selling expenses Error:
Refer
ence
sourc
e not
25 found 159,144 158,093
Error: Reference source not found
Báo cáo kết quả hoạt động kinh doanh hợp nhất cho Error: Reference source not
found kết thúc Error: Reference source not found (tiếp theo)
Mẫu B 02 – DN[/HN]
(Ban hành theo Thông tư số [200/202]/TT-BTC
ngày 22/12/2014 của Bộ Tài chính)
2023 2022
Notes VND VND
2023 2022
Notes VND VND
Error:
Refer
ence
sourc
e not
Other income 31 found 4,153 3,554
Other expenses 32 737 2,036
Other profit
40 3,416 1,518
(40 = 31 - 32)
Accounting profit before tax
50 123,433 150,245
(50 = 30 + 40)
Error:
Refer
ence
Deferred tax (expense)/income 51 43.224.349.871 20.219.235.501
sourc
e not
found
Net profit after tax
60 103,214 123,840
(60 = 50 - 51)
Net profit after tax attributable to
Shareholders of the parents 61
Non-controlling interests 62