Current State of Communication Systems Based On Electrical Power Transmission Lines
Current State of Communication Systems Based On Electrical Power Transmission Lines
Journal of Electrical Systems and Inf Technol (2021) 8:9 Journal of Electrical Systems
https://doi.org/10.1186/s43067-021-00028-9
and Information Technology
*Correspondence:
[email protected] Abstract
1
Department of Electrical Power line communication technology is a retrofit alternative technology for last mile
and Electronics Engineering,
Karadeniz Technical information technology. Despite several challenges, such as inadequate standards and
University, Trabzon, Turkey electromagnetic compatibility, it is maturing. In this review, we have analysed these
Full list of author information obstacles and its current application status.
is available at the end of the
article Keywords: Electrical power lines, Power line communication (PLC), Power line
networks, Noise, Channels, Modulation
Introduction
Indeed, advancements in communication engineering and technology have brought in
revolution in the telecommunication industry. One great impact has been in informa-
tion and service delivery during the last decades of the twentieth century to date. This is
due to the high demand for information created by the huge human population. Better
methods and channel models for signal transmission have been researched and devel-
oped. For instance, fibre optics has provided waveguide for numerous services at higher
speed while inheriting other advantages such immunity to electromagnetic interferences
amongst others [1, 2]. Despite all the positive attractions towards fibre communication,
it is expensive to install and it is limited to certain areas. That is, remote, rural and
mountainous areas. This has necessitated the search for alternative information trans-
mission methods. Power line communication (PLC) is one such alternative.
Power line communication technology is the basically a technology that uses pre-
existing and installed electrical power cables for transmission of information [3–6].
Traditionally, such electrical lines were designed exclusively for distribution and trans-
mission of electricity at lower frequency. This frequency varies from country to country,
mainly, 50 Hz or 60 Hz. Upon generation of electricity, it is distributed and transmitted
through different voltage network. Firstly, electricity is transmitted over high voltage
lines, then distribution is done over medium voltage lines, and lastly, it is converted/
scaled down using transformers for the end-user consumption in the low-voltage lines.
Figure 1 gives summary of PLC structure. This technology is therefore retrofit and eco-
nomically cheaper compared to other methods. There is no need for new cable installa-
tions. Secondly, electrical power network is the most developed, covers large areas and
© The Author(s) 2021. This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing,
adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and
the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material
in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material
is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the
permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativeco
mmons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
Ndolo and Çavdar Journal of Electrical Systems and Inf Technol (2021) 8:9 Page 2 of 10
reaches many homesteads. At distribution lines, they are majorly used for the control
signals, remote data acquisition and IP telephony services [7].
Power line communication is divided into three categories, namely ultra-narrowband,
narrowband and broadband as summarised in Table 1. The first two are commonly
grouped together and termed as narrowband PLC. We will characterise these categories
in the next section in details.
Table 2 Regulator standards for narrowband PLC and relevant modulation methods
Standards Modulation method Related works
Table 3 Regulator standards for broadband PLC and relevant modulation methods
Standards Modulation method Related works
IEC have also contributed widely in developing some of these standards for nar-
rowband PLC. Tables 2 and 3 provide summary lists of regulatory standards with
regard to electrical power line communication technology and respective modula-
tion techniques.
Attenuation which increases with frequency is another factor that hinders full exploi-
tation of PL for communication use. Attenuation in this case depends on the length of
branches, the material of the line and varying characteristic impedance too [44], and
[references herein].
Electromagnetic compatibility is another challenge. From Maxwell’s equation and elec-
tromagnetic theories [45, 46], and [references herein] electrical power lines, by exten-
sion PLC, act as antenna that excite electromagnetic waves. Therefore, use of frequency
spectrum ranging to 30 MHz which is reserved for radio communication may be inter-
fered with by power line communication networks. As discussed under standards, there
regulations have been set to minimise PLC electromagnetic interference on other ser-
vices. Additionally, electromagnetic compatibility restrictions limit transmission power
which in turn leads to low SNR at the receiver. Works on the latter are also ongoing.
The other major factor that degrades signal transmission in PL channels is non-Gauss-
ian noise. This noise will be discussed in a section below. Before that, we describe PLC
channel briefly.
PL transmission channel
In both [42] and [43], and [references herein] have compared power line communica-
tion channel as a multipath transmission medium. This is because of numerous reflec-
tion points, discrete and mismatched electrical loads in the PLC network. The channel
load is either varying periodically or aperiodically due to connection or disconnection of
electrical loads at varying times.
Understanding the channels behaviour is very vital in designing communication sys-
tems. Therefore, engineers and researchers apply channel models in order to characterise
PLC transmission channel. Generally, there are two models: bottom-up and up-bottom
approaches [43] and [references herein]. These approaches are iterative. Their approach
includes both measurements and CAD simulations. Both approaches are either applied
in time or frequency domain. The bottom-up model approach involves the use of mathe-
matical model to define electrical power line channel. Model’s parameters are calculated
followed by simulation. To validate simulation results, measurements must be carried.
The difference is that, the second approach starts with measurements. Thus, there is
need for comprehensive information of the network and its physical topology. It also
requires knowledge on impedances and features of cables. Up-bottom approach is prac-
tical and realistic. It is therefore the frequently used model by communication engineers.
Mathematical models for both approaches are available in [19] and [references herein]
for the reader to explore.
Berger et al. in [5] introduce the concept of MIMO PLC model. This is another tech-
nique that can be used to study the channel’s feature in order to improve PL communica-
tion system’s performance. Intensive studies of various models are focussed on possible
exploitation of adaptive filters and scheduling, development of efficient PLC code, wid-
ening the bandwidth amongst others. Other models of study are mentioned in [47].
Ndolo and Çavdar Journal of Electrical Systems and Inf Technol (2021) 8:9 Page 6 of 10
1966 Proposal of the first OFDM. This was for fading communication channels [52–54]
1967 Multicarrier systems [53–55]
1970 OFDM is patented [53, 54, 56]
1971 First application of DFT in OFDM [53, 54, 57]
1980 OFDM is applied in telephone networks [53, 54, 58]
1985 OFDM studies in mobile communication [53, 54, 59]
1987 Used in digital broadcasting [53, 54, 60]
1991 & 1994 Report and standard for ADSL and HDSL [53, 54, 61–63]
1995 First standard for OFDM-based digital broadcasting system [53, 54, 64]
1996 WLAN standard [53, 54, 65]
1997 DVB-T standard [53, 54]
1998 VDSL and BRAN standard [53, 54]
1999 & 2000 IEEE 802.11a & 802.11g WLAN standard [53, 54]
2003 Wavelet-OFDM for high-speed PLC [53, 54]
2004 IEEE 802.16 WMAN, 802.11n next generation WLAN and 802.15.3a MB-OFDM [53, 54]
2010 Performance comparison between wavelet-OFDM & filtered-OFDM [53, 54]
Conclusion
As human population continues to increase, the thirst and demand for data informa-
tion and education will always be on the rise. The emergence of COVID19 has also
put pressure on the existing communication systems as many organisations shift to
"work from home". This calls for alternative signal transmission technology. Electrical
power lines for communication have proven to be this option. With roughly 80% of
the world population connected to the electric grid, this technology ready infrastruc-
ture to connect millions to info-communication network for business, education and
other purposes. Thus, geographical communication coverage is increased. Despite
Ndolo and Çavdar Journal of Electrical Systems and Inf Technol (2021) 8:9 Page 8 of 10
the tremendous work done in both research industries and universities, there is
need for more to be done to improve this technology.
In order for PLC to reach optimal maturity and mass implementation, the chal-
lenging obstacles discussed above must be tackled scientifically, properly and effec-
tively. Additionally, there is need for adequate research funding and implementation
of national regulation standards to comply with the international ones for uniform-
ity across the globe. The latter issues affect developing countries such as Kenya and
Türkiye.
In this paper, we have provided a detailed overview on the current state of PL Com-
munication. We have summarised classes of PLC, regulation standards, transmission
channel models, noises and tabulated modulation techniques. Although this field of
research is maturing slowly and is fairly recent, it has become a promising one for
near-future applications especially in Access Mode “Last mile” implementation. We
hope this work will motivate researchers further to advance the penetration of PLC
technology in developing countries’ remote areas where electricity access is available
but with rugged terrains.
Abbreviations
PLC: Power line communication; ITU: International Telecommunication Union; CENELEC: European Committee for
Electro-technical Standardisation; IEC: International Electro-technical Commission; IEEE: Institute of Electrical and Elec-
tronics Engineer; ISO: International Organisation for Standardisation; FCC: Federal Communication Commission; RS: Reed
Solomon; CC: Convolutional codes; IPv6: Internet Protocol version 6; CAD: Computer-aided design; MIMO: Multiple-input
and multiple-output; SNR: Signal-to-noise ratio; OFDM: Orthogonal frequency division multiplexing; BSPK: Binary phase
shift keying; QAM: Quadrature amplitude modulation; FSK: Frequency shift keying; DFT: Discrete Fourier transform; KNX:
Konnex protocol; WLAN: Wireless local area network; PL: Power line; S-FSK: Spread FSK.
Acknowledgements
Not applicable.
Authors’ contributions
The details of contributions of the authors in the present works are as follows: (a) AN contributed to the literature collec-
tion and manuscript preparation. (b) İHÇ contributed and edited the manuscript. Finally, all authors read and approved
the final manuscript.
Funding
No funding organization is involved in this work.
Declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Author details
1
Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering, Karadeniz Technical University, Trabzon, Turkey. 2 Department
of Electrical and Electronics Engineering, Machakos University, Machakos, Kenya.
References
1. Pal BP (1992) Fundamentals of fibre optics in telecommunication and sensor systems. Bohem Press, Zürich
2. Agrawal GP (2012) Fiber-optic communication systems, vol 222. Wiley, Hoboken
3. Yousuf MS, El-Shafei M (2007) Power line communications: an overview—part I. In: 2007 innovations in information
technologies (IIT), pp 218–222
4. Carcelle X (2009) Power line communications in practice. Artech House, Norwood
Ndolo and Çavdar Journal of Electrical Systems and Inf Technol (2021) 8:9 Page 9 of 10
5. Berger LT, Schwager A, Pagani P, Schneider D (2014) MIMO power line communications: narrow and broadband
standards, EMC, and advanced processing. CRC Press, Boca Raton
6. Gridley JH (2014) Principles of electrical transmission lines in power and communication: the commonwealth and
international library: applied electricity and electronics division. Elsevier, Amsterdam
7. Mlynek P, Koutny M, Misurec J (2008) The communication unit for remote data acquisition via the Internet. In:
WSEAS international conference. proceedings. mathematics and computers in science and engineering
8. Schwartz M (2009) Carrier-wave telephony over power lines: early history [history of communications]. IEEE Com-
mun Mag 47(1):14–18
9. Galli S, Scaglione A, Wang Z (2011) For the grid and through the grid: the role of power line communications in the
smart grid. Proc IEEE 99(6):998–1027
10. Shaver DP (2011) Narrowband PLC solutions for AMI achieve long distance communications and flexibility with
immediate market impact. In: IEEE international conference on consumer electronics (ICCE), pp 601–602
11. Antoniali M, De Piante M, Tonello AM (2013) PLC noise and channel characterization in a compact electrical car. In:
2013 IEEE 17th international symposium on power line communications and its applications, pp 29–34
12. Aalamifar F, Hassanein HS, Takahara G (2012) Viability of powerline communication for the smart grid. In: 2012 26th
Biennial symposium on communications (QBSC), pp 19–23
13. Sittoni A, Brunelli D, Macii D, Tosato P, Petri D (2015) Street lighting in smart cities: a simulation tool for the design of
systems based on narrowband PLC. In: 2015 IEEE first international smart cities conference (ISC2), pp 1–6
14. Mlynek P, Misurec J, Kolka Z, Slacik J, Fujdiak R (2015) Narrowband power line communication for smart metering
and street lighting control. IFAC-Paper 48(4):215–219. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ifacol.2015.07.035
15. Yigit M, Gungor VC, Tuna G, Rangoussi M, Fadel E (2014) Power line communication technologies for smart grid
applications: a review of advances and challenges. Comput Netw 70:366–383
16. Shongwe T, Speidel U, Swart TG, Ferreira HC (2011) The effect of hamming distances on permutation codes for
multiuser communication in the power line communications channel. In: IEEE Africon’11, pp 1–5
17. Hrasnica H, Haidine A, Lehnert R (2004) Broadband powerline communications networks. Wiley Online Library,
Hoboken
18. Hallak G, Bumiller G, Lampe L, Tonello A, Swart T (2016) PLC for home and industry automation. In: Hallak G, Bumiller
G (eds) Power line communications: principles, standards and applications from multimedia to smart grid. Wiley,
Hoboken, pp 449–472
19. Ndjiongue A, Ferreira H (2019) Power line communications (PLC) technology: More than 20 years of intense
research. Trans Emerg Telecommun Technol. https://doi.org/10.1002/ett.3575
20. Razazian K, Yazdani J (2011) CENELEC and powerline communication specification in realization of smart grid
technology. In: 2011 2nd IEEE PES international conference and exhibition on innovative smart grid technologies,
pp 1–7
21. Galli S, Logvinov O (2008) Recent developments in the standardization of power line communications within the
IEEE. IEEE Commun Mag 46(7):64–71
22. Leclare J, Niktash A, Levi V (2017) An overview, history, and formation of IEEE P1901.2 for narrowband OFDM PLC.
Maxim Integr Appl Note 5676:1–7
23. Logvinov O (2013) Netricity PLC and the IEEE P1901.2 Standard. HomePlug Power Line Alliance
24. Sanz A (2013) 3: ITU-T G. 9904 (PRIME 1.4)
25. Galli S, Lys T (2015) Next generation narrowband (under 500 kHz) power line communications (PLC) standards.
China Commun 12(3):1–8
26. Van Laere A, Wawrzyniak C, Bette S, Moeyaert V (2016) Development, validation and utilization of an ITU-T G. 9903
PHY simulator for communication performance evaluation. In: 2016 international symposium on power line com-
munications and its applications (ISPLC), pp 167–172
27. Lu X, Monnier O, Dallas P (2012) Developing robust power line communications (PLC) with G3. Texas Instruments
28. I.-I. E. Commission and others (1996) IEC 61334-4-41
29. British Standards Institution (1998) Distribution Automation Using Distribution Line Carrier Systems: General consid-
erations, guide for specification. BSI, London
30. Bali MC, Rebai C (2014) S-FSK modem design and experimental validation for robust narrowband powerline com-
munication. In: 2014 IEEE international instrumentation and measurement technology conference (I2MTC) proceed-
ings, pp 1251–1255
31. Hoch M (2011) Comparison of PLC G3 and PRIME. In: 2011 IEEE international symposium on power line communica-
tions and its applications, pp 165–169
32. Razazian K, Umari M, Kamalizad A, Loginov V, Navid M (2010) G3-PLC specification for powerline communication:
overview, system simulation and field trial results. In: ISPLC2010, pp 313–318
33. San-Salvador Á, Herrero Á (2012) Contacting the devices: a review of communication protocols. In: Ambient
intelligence-software and applications. Springer, pp 3–10
34. D’Innocenzo F, Bucci G, Fiorucci E, Ciancetta F (2017) Domestic electrical standard system for power line communi-
cation tests. In: 2017 IEEE international instrumentation and measurement technology conference (I2MTC), pp 1–6
35. Lu X, Kim IH, Vedantham R (2013) Implementing prime for robust and reliable power line communication (PLC).
Texas Instruments White Paper
36. Podhoranský P, Lipovský M, Zemanovič J, Sabo M (2007) Transfer and error rate measurement in the PLC LonWorks
systems
37. Yuan Z, Feng X, Li Y, Zhen Y (2010) Design of OFDM power line carrier communication node based on MAX2990. J
Chengde Pet Coll (3), 14
38. Guo J, Su S, Fu C (2011) Research on power quality monitoring system based on low-voltage PLC technology. In:
2011 international conference on advanced power system automation and protection, vol 2, pp 1574–1577
39. Lee M, Newman RE, Latchman HA, Katar S, Yonge L (2003) HomePlug 1.0 powerline communication LANs—proto-
col description and performance results. Int J Commun Syst 16(5):447–473
Ndolo and Çavdar Journal of Electrical Systems and Inf Technol (2021) 8:9 Page 10 of 10
40. Afkhamie KH, Katar S, Yonge L, Newman R (2005) An overview of the upcoming HomePlug AV standard. In: Interna-
tional symposium on power line communications and its applications, 2005, pp 400–404
41. Zimmermann M, Dostert K (2000) Low voltage power distribution network as last mile access network- signal
propagation and noise scenario in the HF-range. AEU-ARCH Elektr Ubertragungstechn 54(1):13–22
42. Güzelgöz S, Arslan H, Islam A, Domijan A (2011) A review of wireless and PLC propagation channel characteristics for
smart grid environments. J Electr Comput Eng 2011:1–12. https://doi.org/10.1155/2011/154040
43. Zimmermann M, Dostert K (2002) A multipath model for the powerline channel. IEEE Trans Commun 50(4):553–559
44. Durbak DW, Stewart JR (1990) PLC signal attenuation in branched networks. IEEE Trans Power Deliv 5(2):878–883
45. Harrington RF (1961) Time-harmonic electromagnetic fields. McGraw-Hill, New York
46. Balanis CA (2016) Antenna theory: analysis and design. Wiley, Hoboken
47. Ndolo AO (2016) Optimal narrowband and broadband data communication transmission in low-voltage power line.
Int J Res Eng Technol 05(05):305–308. https://doi.org/10.15623/ijret.2016.0505056
48. Albert AL (1940) Electrical communication. Wiley, Hoboken
49. Albert AL (1952) The electrical fundamentals of communication. McGraw-Hill, New York
50. Al-Mawali KS, Hussain ZM (2009) Performance of bit-interleaved coded OFDM in power line communications with
impulsive noise. In: 2009 international conference on advanced technologies for communications, pp 49–53
51. Abd-Alaziz W, Mei Z, Johnston M, Le Goff S (2017) Non-binary turbo-coded OFDM-PLC system in the presence of
impulsive noise. In: 2017 25th European signal processing conference (EUSIPCO), pp 2576–2580
52. Chang RW (1966) Synthesis of band-limited orthogonal signals for multichannel data transmission. Bell Syst Tech J
45(10):1775–1796
53. Hanzo L, Keller T (2007) OFDM and MC-CDMA: a primer. Wiley, Hoboken
54. Hanzo L, Webb W, Keller T (2000) Single-and multi-carrier quadrature amplitude modulation: principles and applica-
tions for personal communications, WATM and broadcasting: 2nd. IEEE Press-John Wiley, Hoboken
55. Saltzberg B (1967) Performance of an efficient parallel data transmission system. IEEE Trans Commun Technol
15(6):805–811
56. Chang RW (1970) Orthogonal frequency multiplex data transmission system. US Patent 3,488,445
57. Weinstein S, Ebert P (1971) Data transmission by frequency-division multiplexing using the discrete Fourier trans-
form. IEEE Trans Commun Technol 19(5):628–634
58. Keasler WE, Bitzer DL, Tucker PT (1980) High speed modem suitable for operating with a switched network. Google
Patents
59. Cimini L (1985) Analysis and simulation of a digital mobile channel using orthogonal frequency division multiplex-
ing. IEEE Trans Commun 33(7):665–675
60. Lassalle R, Alard M (1987) Principles of modulation and channel coding for digital broadcasting for mobile receivers.
EBU Tech Rev 224(1):68–190
61. Cioffi JM (1991) A multicarrier primer. In: ANSI T1E1, vol 4, pp 91–157
62. Veeneman D, Olshansky R (1995) ADSL for video and data services. In: Proceedings IEEE international conference on
communications ICC’95, vol 2, pp 837–841
63. Taha HJ, Salleh M (2009) Multi-carrier transmission techniques for wireless communication systems: a survey. Wseas
Trans Commun 8(5):457–472
64. EN ETSI (1995) ETS 300 401, Radio broadcasting systems: digital audio broadcasting (DAB) to mobile, portable and
fixed receivers. European Telecommunications Standards Institute, Valbonne
65. Etsi E (1996) Radio equipment and systems (RES): high performance radio local area network (HIPERLAN) type 1;
functional specification. ETSI ETS 300:652