DMSO Exotherm
DMSO Exotherm
org/OPRD Article
ABSTRACT: Dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) is widely used due to its excellent solvent properties; however, several serious incidents
have been reported related to the use of DMSO. DMSO can decompose autocatalytically, but we have no consensus with respect to
Downloaded via STONY BROOK UNIV SUNY on October 5, 2020 at 08:15:51 (UTC).
the chemical structure and function of the autocatalyst. Thermal decomposition of DMSO was carried out in an inert atmosphere,
and analysis of the nonvolatile fraction indicated the presence of several organic and inorganic acids. DMSO was believed to act as an
oxidizer as well as a reactant in the formation of these acids. The same acids were found in an isothermal heating test, and their
concentrations increased over heating time. Addition of acids to DMSO before starting isothermal heating significantly shortened the
induction period indicating that the acids generated in situ served as autocatalysts for the thermal decomposition of DMSO.
KEYWORDS: dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), thermal hazard, decomposition, autocatalyst, acid, induction period
■ INTRODUCTION
Dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) is an aprotic solvent with a high
Among the incompatible compounds above, the influence of
acids has been studied most extensively. Traynelis and
dissolving ability as well as other excellent properties, such as a Hergenrother15 reported that the addition of acid accelerated
high dielectric constant, a high boiling point, low vapor DMSO decomposition, with the generation of formaldehyde,
pressure, and free miscibility with water.1,2 In addition to these while the addition of base retarded decomposition.
Santosusso and Swern16 found that an acid was required for
solvent properties common to aprotic solvents, DMSO has low
the oxidation using DMSO and oxygen or hydroperoxide
biological toxicity, unlike the other compounds in this group.3
served to generate an acid catalyst in situ. They determined the
Accordingly, DMSO is the preferred solvent used for a wide
strong acids formed when oxidation was performed using
range of purposes and applications in both laboratory work and
DMSO as an oxidizer in the presence of air or peroxide.17
various industries. DMSO manufacturers have provided
Head and McCarty18 discovered the conditions that brought
product information covering various data, such as its physical
about the complete decomposition of DMSO, and the
and chemical properties, thermal stability, chemical stability,
proposed decomposition mechanism is as follows: (1) A
and safety requirements for handling.1,2
radical cation is formed by the reaction of DMSO and oxygen,
However, despite its wide use, severe incidents associated
(2) the radical cation reacts with another molecule of DMSO
with the runaway reaction of DMSO have been reported.4−6
to produce the dimethyl sulfonium cation, and (3) the
Safety concerns have been stated in industries where DMSO is
dimethyl sulfonium cation acts as a key intermediate in the
used as a solvent or reactant.7−11 Since DMSO is frequently
thermal decomposition of DMSO.
recycled for economic as well as environmental reasons in
The influence of foreign organic acids has been studied, and
industries, many incidents take place during steps in the
it was found that even weak acids accelerated the
recycling process, such as evaporation and distillation.6 The
decomposition of DMSO.19 As such, it is important to note
risks in DMSO distillation have been addressed, and a risk
that DMSO is not an inert solvent, as suggested by Bollyn.20
assessment was conducted.12 When a power failure takes place
The other important aspect observed in DMSO decom-
during distillation, heat removal ceases immediately, while
position is its autocatalytic nature. Although the definition of
heating continues; this scenario may cause a temperature
an autocatalyst or autocatalytic decomposition may vary by
increase to trigger DMSO decomposition resulting in potential
author, the overview described by Stoessel21 is widely
runaway reaction. It is important to understand the heat
acknowledged: “A reaction is called autocatalytic when a
generation process in DMSO decomposition.
reaction product acts as a catalyst on the reaction course”. The
DMSO itself is stable at temperatures below 150 °C, and it
begins to decompose slowly near its boiling temperature (189
°C).1,2 In contrast, DMSO reacts with various chemicals, such Received: March 21, 2020
as oxidizers, reducing agents, organic and inorganic acids, acid Published: August 20, 2020
halides, acid anhydrides, halogens, halogenated organics, and
sodium hydride. In the presence of these incompatible
chemicals, DMSO decomposition begins at a much lower
temperature.1,2,4,13,14
characteristic profile of autocatalytic decomposition is thermal decomposition of DMSO. The review provides a
illustrated in Figure 1. Decomposition proceeds slowly in the thorough explanation of DMSO decomposition, and details of
kinetic analysis were discussed. However, the discussion did
not cover the chemical nature of the autocatalyst function.
This study was performed to elucidate the chemical nature
of the autocatalyst.
■ EXPERIMENTAL SECTION
General. DMSO (99.98%) was purchased from Fujifilm
Wako Pure Chemical Corporation, Japan. Other chemicals
used for analysis were reagent grade, and water was deionized
and distilled in the laboratory.
The analytical gases used were highly purified gases
designated for GC−MS analysis.
Procedure for the Thermal Treatment of DMSO and
the Analysis of the Nonvolatile Fraction. DSC was
utilized to carry out the thermal treatment of DMSO. A small
portion (ca. 2 mg) of DMSO was poured into a high-pressure
Figure 1. Characteristic profile of autocatalytic decomposition. DSC pan made of stainless steel, which was sealed using a
dedicated press machine. All sample preparations were carried
out in a nitrogen glove box.
flat portion called the induction period, and this period lasts for Thermal treatment was performed using a DSC 7000X from
a relatively long time without an exotherm. Rapid exothermic Hitachi High-Technologies Japan under a constant heating
decomposition exceeds slow decomposition at a certain point, rate of 10 °C/min from room temperature to 430 °C.
leading the reaction mixture to undergo a runaway reaction. Completion of DMSO decomposition was verified by the
Prolonged storage of DMSO at elevated temperature may absence of an exothermic peak in a second run. After cooling,
cause the accumulation of decomposed substances, which the stainless pan was mechanically opened under cooling using
catalyze further decomposition. However, it is difficult to liquid nitrogen, and the inner wall was washed with distilled
predict sudden heat evolution given the unexpected timing of deionized water (DDW). The resulting extract was subjected
initiation. As a result, it may be too late to return to normal to ion chromatography (IC) in an instrument equipped with
conditions by the time one notices an abnormality in an electroconductivity detector and mass detector.
temperature and/or pressure. DMSO handling risks in Analytical instruments for qualitative analysis are as follows:
industrial settings may arise from this characteristic decom- The ion chromatograph was a Thermo Scientific DX-600
position profile. equipped with an electroconductivity detector. For TOFMS,
Brogli et al.5 reported that the autocatalytic decomposition an Agilent LC/MSD TOF was used. The columns used were
of DMSO occurred when aliphatic bromide was mixed with Thermo Scientific IonPac AG11-HC and AS11-HC. Experi-
DMSO and that small amounts of zinc oxide extended the ments were conducted in ESI-negative mode.
induction period and moderated the self-accelerating decom- Isothermal Heating Test and Analysis of the
position process once it occurred. Hall6 reported seven Resulting Material. The isothermal heating test was carried
incidents associated with DMSO decomposition in his paper, out using ARC, and the detailed experimental conditions are as
and some cases were related to autocatalytic decomposition or follows. For ARC, a TIAX accelerating rate calorimeter was
lacked an adequate thermal history for DMSO. used, conducted in a nitrogen atmosphere at temperatures of
In the early stage of popularization of accelerating rate 160, 170, and 185 °C. The sample bomb was an SUS316. The
calorimetry (ARC), Cardillo and Girelli22 carried out DMSO sample amount was 3.5 g. The minimum sensitivity was 0.02
decomposition experiments using ARC both in a nitrogen K/min. The cutoff temperature was 200 °C. The test period
atmosphere and in the air. In their results, the ARC self-heating was 10000 min maximum.
curve of DMSO in a nitrogen atmosphere showed a long Samples isothermally heated in the bomb at 185 °C for
induction period, whereas DMSO thermolysis in the air 2000, 4000, and 6000 min were quantitatively analyzed to
showed no such induction period. They realized that some determine the acid concentration. The isothermal heating test
acids were formed when decomposition was carried out in the was repeated from the beginning every time because
air; notably, they mentioned that DMSO decomposed in the intermediate sampling from the closed vessel was difficult.
air through a non-autocatalytic radical-like mechanism, After cooling, the resulting solution was diluted 10 times
although the detailed mechanism was not discussed. with DDW and subjected to IC analysis. For IC, a Thermo
Several others have studied DMSO decomposition to Scientific Integrion RFIC was used, with an electroconductivity
address industrial concerns,7−14,23 but we have no consensus detector and columns of IonPac AG18-4 μm + AS18-4 μm (4
with respect to the chemical structure and function of the mm φ × 150 mm). The eluent was the KOH gradient with the
autocatalyst. Dien et al.24 showed that the adiabatic behavior of use of an eluent generator.
autocatalytic decomposition could be expressed using kinetic Effect of Acid Addition on DMSO Decomposition. A
parameters deduced from the isothermal differential scanning small portion of acid was added to DMSO before starting the
calorimetry (DSC) curve. ARC is used to assess the thermal isothermal heating test using ARC. The concentrations of the
hazard potential of energetic chemicals, including DMSO, as representative acids were taken from the data point at 6000
ARC can provide near-perfect adiabatic conditions.8−10 min and 185 °C. In the acid investigation, the headspace was
Brandes and Smith25 reviewed the literature discussing the filled with helium, and the temperature was set to 185 °C. To
1615 https://dx.doi.org/10.1021/acs.oprd.0c00113
Org. Process Res. Dev. 2020, 24, 1614−1620
Organic Process Research & Development pubs.acs.org/OPRD Article
Figure 2. Ion chromatograms obtained for the nonvolatile fraction. Upper: data recorded by the electroconductivity detector, lower: total ion
chromatogram (TIC) recorded by the mass detector.
determine the effect of the environmental gas, air and carbon volatile fraction after DMSO decomposition.15 Similarly, acetic
dioxide were separately introduced into DMSO using a small acid and formic acid were thought to be the oxidized products
tube as a bubbler, and the headspace of the ARC bomb was of the corresponding aldehydes.
carefully sealed with the same gas. An isothermal heating test Santosusso and Swern16 observed the in situ generation of
was also conducted on these samples at 185 °C. Detailed ARC the strong acids, methanesulfonic acid and sulfuric acid, when
experimental conditions are as follows. For ARC, a THT Euro DMSO was heated with peroxide. The same authors claimed
ARC was used, under a helium atmosphere for acid that they carried out qualitative analysis of the acids by the ion-
investigation and at a temperature of 185 °C. The sample exchange isolation technique, but unfortunately, no detailed
bomb was an SUS316. The sample amount was 3.0 g. The information regarding the analysis was provided.17 The
minimum sensitivity was 0.02 K/min. The cutoff setting was generation of these strong acids was confirmed in our
400 °C or 12.0 MPa. The test period was 250 h maximum. experiment. It has been reported that peroxide or air is
Figure 3. TOFMS data obtained for the carboxylic acids. Upper: Peak #1, lower: Peak #2.
generated and gradually accumulated in the inert atmosphere strength of these acids in water, sulfuric acid (pKa −3.19 ±
during the induction period. Formic acid showed the highest 0.15) 30 is many orders of magnitude stronger than
concentration followed by methanesulfonic acid and sulfuric methanesulfonic acid (pKa 1.75 ± 0.50),30 but methanesul-
acid. These acids were generated and accumulated during the fonic acid unexpectedly showed a larger acceleration effect on
induction period, and they acted as catalysts in the DMSO decomposition. Similarly, although formic acid is a
decomposition of DMSO. weak acid with a pKa of 3.74 ± 0.10,30 the sample containing
Effect of Acid Addition on DMSO Decomposition. The 2000 ppm formic acid showed the largest acceleration effect on
effect of formic acid was compared to that of blank DMSO, as the induction period among the acids investigated.
shown in Figure 5. The sample containing 2000 ppm formic The effects of the environmental gas were notable, as shown
in Figure 7. Bubbling coupled with filling of air in the
■ CONCLUSIONS
In this work, the analytical study was combined with
isothermal heating tests to elucidate the autocatalysts involved
in DMSO decomposition. The relevant findings were as
follows:
(1) Several kinds of acids were found in the nonvolatile
Figure 6. Isothermal heating test (3): effects of methanesulfonic acid fraction after complete DMSO decomposition in an
and sulfuric acid. inert atmosphere.
1618 https://dx.doi.org/10.1021/acs.oprd.0c00113
Org. Process Res. Dev. 2020, 24, 1614−1620
Organic Process Research & Development
■
pubs.acs.org/OPRD Article
■
Sulfoxide (DMSO) as a Solvent. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2012, 16,
1994−2000.
ASSOCIATED CONTENT (9) Wang, Z.; Richter, S. M.; Bellettini, J. R.; Pu, Y.-M.; Hill, D. R.
*
sı Supporting Information Safe Scale-Up of Pharmaceutical Manufacturing Processes with
The Supporting Information is available free of charge at Dimethyl Sulfoxide as the Solvent and a Reactant or a Byproduct.
https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.oprd.0c00113. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2014, 18, 1836−1842.
(10) Yang, Q.; Sheg, M.; Henkelis, J. J.; Tu, S.; Wiensch, E.; Zhang,
GC−MS analysis of DMSO (PDF) H.; Zhang, Y.; Tucker, C.; Ejeh, D. E. Explosion Hazards of Sodium
■ AUTHOR INFORMATION
Corresponding Author
Hydride in Dimethyl Sulfoxide, N,N-Dimethylformamide, and N,N-
Dimethylacetamide. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2019, 2210.
(11) Yang, Q.; Sane, N.; Klosowski, D.; Lee, M.; Rosenthal, T.; Wng,
N. X.; Wiensch, E. Mizoroki−Heck Cross-Coupling of Bromoben-
Yoshikuni Deguchi − Kaneka Corporation, Takasago, Hyogo zenes with Styrenes: Another Exampleof Pd-Catalyzed Cross-
676-8688, Japan; Yokohama National University, Yokohama Coupling with Potential Safety Hazards. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2019,
240-8501, Japan; orcid.org/0000-0002-3240-1728; 23, 2148−2156.
Phone: +81-90-7090-1467; Email: Yoshikuni.Deguchi@ (12) Fierz, H. Assessment of Thermal Safety during Distillation of
kaneka.co.jp DMSO. I Chem E Symposium Series 1994, 134, 563−574.
(13) Yang, X.-W.; Zhang, X.-Y.; Guo, Z.-C.; Bai, W.-S.; Hao, L.; Wei,
Authors H.-Y. Effects of Incompatible Substances on the Thermal Stability of
Masafumi Kono − Nippon Refine Co., Ltd., Ichihara, Chiba Dimethyl Sulfoxide. Thermochim. Acta 2013, 559, 76−81.
290-0067, Japan; Yokohama National University, Yokohama (14) Yang, Q.; Sheng, M.; Li, X.; Tucker, C.; Vásques Céspedes, S.;
240-8501, Japan Webb, N. J.; Whiteker, G. T.; Yu, J. Potential Explosion Hazards
Yuto Koizumi − Yokohama National University, Yokohama Associated with the Autocatalytic Thermal Decomposition of
240-8501, Japan Dimethyl Sulfoxide and Its Mixtures. Org. Process Res. Dev. 2020,
Yu-ichiro Izato − Yokohama National University, Yokohama 24, 916−939.
(15) Traynelis, V. J.; Hergenrother, W. L. Decomposition of
240-8501, Japan
Dimethyl Sulfoxide Aided by Ethylene Glycol, Acetamide, and
Atsumi Miyake − Yokohama National University, Yokohama Related Compounds. J. Org. Chem. 1964, 29, 221−222.
240-8501, Japan (16) Santosusso, T. M.; Swern, D. On the Mechanism of Oxidation
Complete contact information is available at: of Epoxides by DMSO. Tetrahedron Lett. 1968, 9, 4261−4264.
https://pubs.acs.org/10.1021/acs.oprd.0c00113 (17) Santosusso, T. M.; Swern, D. Acid Catalysis as a Basis for a
Mechanistic Rationale of Some Dimethyl Sulfoxide Reactions.
Notes Tetrahedron Lett. 1974, 15, 4255−4258.
(18) Head, D. L.; McCarty, C. G. The Thermal Decomposition of
The authors declare no competing financial interest.
■
DMSO. Tetrahedron Lett. 1973, 14, 1405−1408.
(19) Babasaki, Y.; Iizuka, Y.; Miyake, A. Influence of Organic Acid
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS on the Thermal Behavior of Dimethyl Sulfoxide. J. Therm. Anal.
The authors thank Dr. Yoshiaki Iizuka for fruitful discussions. Calorim. 2015, 121, 295−301.
1619 https://dx.doi.org/10.1021/acs.oprd.0c00113
Org. Process Res. Dev. 2020, 24, 1614−1620
Organic Process Research & Development pubs.acs.org/OPRD Article
1620 https://dx.doi.org/10.1021/acs.oprd.0c00113
Org. Process Res. Dev. 2020, 24, 1614−1620