Dhvani
Dhvani
How does Anandavardhana's theory of Dhvani help connect the apparent and hidden
meanings in poetry? Illustrate this concept with suitable examples.
Anandavardhana's theory of Dhvani (or suggestion) plays a crucial role in understanding the
layered meanings present in poetry. According to Anandavardhana, Dhvani is a form of
suggestion that transcends the direct, literal meaning of words. It helps connect the
apparent meaning, which is what the words explicitly say, with the hidden or implied
meaning, which is conveyed through suggestion. The theory suggests that words have the
power to evoke emotions, sentiments, and ideas that go beyond their surface-level meaning,
thus enriching the poetic experience.
Dhvani, in its simplest form, refers to the suggestion of a meaning that is not directly
expressed by the words themselves but is inferred by the reader. This hidden meaning is
often linked to the sentiment (Rasa) conveyed by the poem. The reader may not be
consciously aware of the deeper meaning, but it influences their emotional experience as
they read the poem. Anandavardhana emphasizes that the true essence of poetry is often
found in what is suggested rather than what is plainly stated. This hidden or implied
meaning is what makes poetry so powerful and layered, allowing it to resonate with readers
on different levels.
The first and most significant aspect of Dhvani is the idea of "Rasa" (sentiment), which is
central to Indian aesthetics. Rasa refers to the emotional response that a work of art evokes
in its audience. Dhvani connects the surface-level narrative with the deeper emotional
impact by suggesting underlying sentiments. For instance, a poem may describe a scene in
nature, such as a river flowing through a valley. On the surface, it might simply be an image
of a river, but through Dhvani, the description might evoke feelings of peace, nostalgia, or
even sadness, depending on the context and the way the scene is presented.
To understand how Dhvani works, let’s look at an example from classical Sanskrit poetry. In a
poem where a lover describes the changing seasons, the poet might mention the arrival of
spring, the blooming of flowers, and the sweet scent in the air. While the literal meaning is
simply a description of the seasons, the deeper meaning—the hidden suggestion—can
convey the lover’s longing for their beloved. The imagery of blooming flowers and the gentle
breeze suggests the emotions of love and yearning, even if these feelings are not explicitly
stated. This is where the power of Dhvani lies: it makes the reader feel the emotions
associated with the image, even though they are not directly mentioned.
Anandavardhana also highlights that Dhvani operates through both the words themselves
and the context in which they are placed. The combination of sound, rhythm, and structure
of a poem can enhance the suggestion of a particular sentiment. For example, a poet might
choose a particular word that, on its own, may not carry much emotional weight, but in the
context of the entire poem, it gains a new significance. This contextual suggestion allows the
poet to convey complex emotions without explicitly stating them, which is one of the
reasons why poetry can be so powerful and evocative.
One of the most important components of Dhvani is the concept of "Vyanjana," which refers
to the indirect communication of meaning. Vyanjana is the process by which the poet uses
words and expressions that suggest something beyond their literal meaning. For instance, in
a poem that describes a stormy night, the literal description might evoke an image of
darkness and chaos. However, through the suggestion of certain words, the storm could also
represent inner turmoil or a conflict between two characters. The poet does not directly say
that the storm represents emotional conflict, but the choice of words and their placement in
the poem creates that suggestion. The reader can then interpret the storm as a symbol of
the characters’ emotions, adding layers of meaning to the poem.
Another example of Dhvani can be seen in the famous Sanskrit poem "Shakuntala" by
Kalidasa. In this work, the poet uses nature to suggest the inner emotions of the characters.
For instance, when Shakuntala is in distress over her lover’s absence, the poet does not
explicitly describe her sadness. Instead, the natural world mirrors her emotional state. The
blooming of flowers or the fading of the moon can symbolize Shakuntala’s emotional
journey, thus connecting the external world to her internal feelings. Here, Dhvani bridges the
literal meaning (the physical world) with the hidden emotional states of the characters.
Dhvani also helps in connecting the various layers of meaning in a text. Anandavardhana
argues that good poetry often operates on multiple levels: the immediate, surface-level
meaning of the words, the deeper meanings that emerge through suggestion, and the
emotions that resonate with the reader. These layers do not contradict each other but work
together to create a more complete and enriching experience. The primary meaning might
be a simple narrative, but the suggested meaning elevates the poem into a profound
expression of human experience.
For instance, in the famous poem "Meghaduta" (The Cloud Messenger) by Kalidasa, the
literal meaning is a cloud carrying a message from a lover to his distant wife. However, the
suggestion or Dhvani behind the poem connects the cloud to the lover’s feelings of
separation and longing. The cloud becomes a metaphor for the lover’s yearning, and the
imagery of the cloud journeying through the skies becomes a symbol for the emotional
journey of separation. The literal journey of the cloud is imbued with the emotional journey
of the lover, and the reader feels the depth of his longing, even though it is not directly
stated.
In conclusion, Anandavardhana's theory of Dhvani helps connect the apparent and hidden
meanings in poetry by emphasizing the power of suggestion. Through carefully chosen
words, structure, and context, poets can convey emotions and sentiments that go beyond
the literal meaning of the words. This connection between the apparent and hidden
meanings allows poetry to evoke a deeper emotional response in the reader, making it a
richer and more layered form of expression. By using Dhvani, poets can create works that
speak to the heart as well as the mind, offering readers an experience that resonates long
after the words have been read.
The statement "The soul of poetry is suggestion" encapsulates a central idea in literary
theory, particularly within the framework of Sanskrit aesthetics, and more specifically, the
theory of Dhvani proposed by Anandavardhana. According to this theory, poetry transcends
the mere expression of ideas or emotions through direct statements; rather, its essence lies
in suggestion, in what is implied rather than explicitly stated. I strongly agree with this
statement because the power of poetry lies not just in what it says, but in the deeper
meanings it evokes in the reader through indirect suggestion. Textual examples from
classical literature as well as modern poetry can be used to substantiate this view.
In classical Sanskrit poetry, the concept of suggestion is beautifully articulated in
Anandavardhana's theory of Dhvani. He suggests that the true essence of poetry is found
not in the literal meanings of words but in their ability to evoke emotions and sentiments
through suggestion. A poet’s words, while having a surface meaning, also suggest a deeper
emotional layer, an underlying sentiment that resonates with the reader. This sentiment is
what gives poetry its depth and soul.
An example of this can be found in Kalidasa’s "Meghaduta" (The Cloud Messenger), where
the literal story is about a cloud carrying a message from a lover to his distant wife. On the
surface, it is a simple narrative of longing and separation. However, the cloud, as a vehicle
for the lover’s emotions, takes on a deeper significance through suggestion. The journey of
the cloud mirrors the emotional journey of the lover, whose separation is not just described,
but suggested through the changing landscapes the cloud passes through. The sky, the
mountains, and the rivers that the cloud encounters are not just physical entities; they
become symbols of the lover’s emotions, emphasizing his longing, melancholy, and hope.
The literal meaning of the cloud’s journey is thus imbued with an emotional depth that is
never directly stated but is felt through suggestion.
Another example from classical Sanskrit literature is from the epic "Mahabharata,"
particularly in the description of Draupadi’s emotional turmoil during the infamous game of
dice. While the event itself is described in a straightforward manner, the emotions Draupadi
experiences—shame, humiliation, and helplessness—are conveyed not just by the words
themselves but by their arrangement and the context in which they are placed. The
suggestion of these emotions is more powerful than their explicit description. A good poet
doesn’t need to state the emotions directly; rather, they suggest them through the setting,
the actions, and the reactions of the characters.
In modern poetry, the soul of poetry as suggestion can be seen in the works of poets like
Emily Dickinson and T.S. Eliot. Dickinson’s poem "I Felt a Funeral in My Brain" is a powerful
example of suggestion. The poem describes a seemingly simple scene of a funeral, but the
imagery, rhythm, and mood evoke a deeper sense of inner turmoil and psychological death.
The speaker never directly says they are experiencing a mental breakdown, but through the
description of the funeral procession, the poem subtly suggests feelings of despair,
confusion, and existential dread. The literal imagery of a funeral is used to suggest a
personal, internal experience that goes far beyond the actual event described.
Similarly, T.S. Eliot’s "The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock" uses suggestion to convey the
complexity of the speaker’s emotions. The poem is filled with indirect references to
Prufrock’s feelings of inadequacy, self-doubt, and fear of rejection. The famous line "Do I
dare disturb the universe?" is an example of suggestion. Eliot doesn’t say directly that
Prufrock is paralyzed by his own insecurities and fear of the unknown, but the question itself
implies a profound sense of hesitation and anxiety. The universe here is not just a vast,
external entity, but a metaphor for the speaker's own life, choices, and relationships. The
suggestion works at a deeper level, giving readers insight into Prufrock’s inner conflict
without explicitly stating it.
The strength of poetry lies in its ability to convey complex emotions and ideas without
needing to state them outright. The suggestion provides readers with space for
interpretation, allowing them to engage with the poem on a more personal level. This is why
poetry is often considered more profound than prose—it taps into the subconscious,
evoking emotions and thoughts that are not always directly accessible through rational or
logical language.
Moreover, suggestion in poetry also adds layers of meaning. It is not just about conveying a
single emotion or idea, but about creating a multi-dimensional experience for the reader.
The suggestion allows the poet to address multiple themes and emotions simultaneously. A
single phrase or image can have different meanings depending on the reader's
interpretation, and this ambiguity is what gives poetry its richness.
In conclusion, I firmly believe that "the soul of poetry is suggestion." It is through suggestion
that poetry becomes more than just an arrangement of words or a narrative; it becomes a
living, breathing experience that resonates with the reader on multiple levels. Whether in
classical Sanskrit poetry, modern Western poetry, or any other form of literary expression,
suggestion adds depth, complexity, and emotional power to poetry. The reader's
engagement with the hidden meanings in the poem is what makes poetry a unique and
enduring form of artistic expression.
Anandavardhana, a classical Indian literary theorist, is most famous for his concept of
Dhvani, or suggestion, which he discussed in his work Dhvanyaloka. One of the important
aspects of his theory is the idea of undiscerned sequentiality, which refers to how meaning
and emotional content are subtly conveyed in a piece of literature through the sequence of
words, sentences, and overall composition, even when the connection between them is not
immediately obvious or directly stated.
The idea behind undiscerned sequentiality is that a piece of literature doesn’t always need to
be explicit in its meanings. Rather, meanings can unfold gradually as a work progresses, and
the overall sentiment or theme becomes clear through the flow and arrangement of words
and ideas. This sequence of thought or emotion isn’t always immediately discernible
because it may not be conveyed in a straightforward, direct manner. Instead, it emerges over
time as the reader processes the various elements of the work.
In Anandavardhana’s view, literature often has layers of meaning that develop from one part
of a text to the next. For example, the mood or emotional tone of a poem may not be
apparent in the first line or stanza but can become more evident as the poem progresses. A
simple metaphor or symbol introduced at the beginning of a work can gradually take on
deeper significance as the narrative or poetic structure develops, revealing a more complex
emotional or thematic landscape.
This subtle unfolding of meaning is what Anandavardhana refers to as undiscerned
sequentiality. He suggests that words and phrases in poetry or literature can convey a sense
of mood or sentiment without explicitly stating it. The sequence of words, phrases, and
sentences works together to create a cumulative effect, allowing the reader to sense the
evolving emotional or thematic undercurrent without being directly told what it is.
For instance, in a poem about a lover’s longing, the initial verses might describe the beauty
of nature, the time of day, or the environment. These observations might seem unrelated at
first, but as the poem unfolds, the reader begins to understand that these elements are all
expressions of the lover's yearning and emotional state. The sequence of images builds upon
each other, and the emotional depth becomes clearer as the poem progresses. The
connection between the initial, seemingly unrelated observations, and the final emotional
revelation, is an example of undiscerned sequentiality.
This approach allows the poet to create a richer and more subtle experience for the reader,
where meanings are not imposed directly but are suggested and revealed over time. It
encourages the reader to engage with the text actively, interpreting the gradual build-up of
meaning as they move through it.
Anandavardhana’s concept of undiscerned sequentiality helps explain how literature can
convey complex emotions and ideas in a way that feels organic, layered, and deeply
resonant. It shows how literature can create a sense of emotional depth and complexity
through structure, arrangement, and the subtle connection between words and ideas, rather
than through straightforward statements.