L7 Asymmetrical Fault
L7 Asymmetrical Fault
W6
2112110130
50
POWER SYSTEM ANALYSIS
Asymmetrical Faults
Prepared by: Prof. Ir. Dr Hazlie Mokhlis
3 Questions
Learning Outline
Symmetrical Components Theory
Sequence Impedance: Load, Line, Generator,
Transformer
Fault Analysis: Line-Ground, Line-Line, Line-
Line-Ground.
Examples and Class Exercises
2
by a sequencecomponent
Impedance seen
Sequence Impedance______________
• The impedance of an equipment or component to the
current of different sequences.
3
Zm MutualImpedance
Vc Z m I a Z m I b Z s I c Z n I n
Kirchhoff’ current law:
In Ia Ib Ic In (10.24)
AND substituteinto
In 1example
i
Substituting In into (10.23):
Va ( Z s Z n ) Z m Z n Zm Zn I a
V Z Z ( Z Z ) Z Z I (10.25) Applysamething to Vb Nctogetitsmatrix
b m n s n m n b eqn
Vc Z m Z n Z m Z n ( Z s Z n ) I c
4
Sequence Impedance of Y-Connected Load
Vak AV8
( Z s Z n ) Z m Z n Zm Zn I
abC
AI
Z abc Z m Z n ( Z s Z n ) Z m Z n (10.27)
Z m Z n Z m Z n ( Z s Z n )
Writing Vabcunbalancy
and Iabc in terms of their symmetrical components:
nuancedsymmetrialcomponent ofphaseA A Transformation Matrix
(𝐀𝐕 )=𝐙 (𝐀𝐈 ) (10.28)
Multiplying (10.28) by A-1 : 5
Va012 ( A Z abc A )I 012 2012 A zabeA
T.no 𝐙
a
(10.29)
Z I 012 012
a
where (10.30)
=𝐀 𝐙 𝐀
N 20 I
Substituting for Zabc, A and A-1 from (10.27), (10.10) and (10.12):
10.27
1 1 1 ( Z s Z n ) Z m Z n Z m Z n 1 1 1
1 (10.31)
Z 012 1 a a 2 Z m Z n ( Z s Z n ) Z m Z n 1 a 2 a
3
1 a 2 a Z m Z n Z m Z n ( Z s Z n ) 1 a a 2
5
𝐙 = 𝐀 standard 𝐙 𝐀 standard
Sequence Impedance of Y-Connected Load
Performing the multiplication in (10.31):
( Z s 3Z n 2 Z m ) 0 0 zeroseal
Z 012 0 (Z s Z m ) 0 tueSeg
(10.32)
0 0 ( Z s Z m ) seq
zerosea124
( Z s 3Z n ) 0 0
0
positusen
Z 012 0 (Z s )
negtiveseqimpedance (10.33)
0 0 ( Z s ) 22
6
Sequence Impedance of Transmission Lines
20 321
For sequence impedance transmission line, Z1 =Z2, Z0 is typically different
and larger by approximately 3 times than the positive and negative
sequence.
32 3 .ie
Y-Y connections with both neutrals grounded –I We know that the zero sequence
current equals the sum of phase currents.
Since both neutrals are grounded, there is a path for the zero sequence current to
flow in the primary and secondary, and the transformer exhibits the equivalent
leakage impedance per phase as shown in Fig. (a).
9
Sequence Impedances of Transformer
Connection diagram Zero-sequence circuit
Figure (b)
2
Y-Y connections with primary the neutral grounded – The primary neutral is
grounded, but since the secondary neutral is isolated, the secondary phase
current must sum up to zero.
This means that the zero-sequence current in the secondary is zero. Consequently,
the zero sequence current in the primary is also zero, reflecting infinite impedance
or an open circuit as shown in Fig. (b).
10
Sequence Impedances of Transformer
Connection diagram Zero-sequence circuit
Figure (c)
Y-Δ with grounded neutral – in this configuration, the primary currents can flow
because the zero-sequence circulating current in the Δ-connected secondary and
a ground return path for the Y-connected primary.
Note that no zero-sequence current can leave the Δ terminals, thus there is an
isolation between the primary and secondary sides as shown in figure (c)
11
Sequence Impedances of Transformer
Connection diagram Zero-sequence circuit
Figure (d)
d) Y-Δ connection with isolated neutral – in this configuration, because the neutral
is isolated, zero sequence current cannot flow and the equivalent circuit reflects
an infinite impedance or an open as shown in figure (d)
12
Sequence Impedances of Transformer
Connection diagram Zero-sequence circuit
Figure (e)
13
Sequence Impedances of Transformer
Connection diagram Zero-sequence circuit
current remember
diagram
Figure (a) flows
782
isolation between
Figure (c)
nocurrent
noIflow
Figure (d)
Current
To ZeroSeq
2n NeutralImpedance
hotshow
Figure (e)
Transformed
Notice that the neutral impedance plays an important role in the equivalent
circuit. When the neutral is grounded through an impedance Zn, because In=3Io, in 14
the equivalent circuit, the neutral impedance appears as 3Zn in the path of I0.
Sequence Impedances of a Loaded Generator
Ia
Zs Va Ea Z s I a Z n I n
Va
Ec
Ea Vb Eb Z s I b Z n I n
In N
Zs
Zs Eb Ib Vc Ec Z s I c Z n I n
Zn
Ic
Vb
Vc
Eb
15
Sequence Impedances of a Loaded Generator
The machine is supplying a three-phase balanced load. Applying kirchhoff’s voltage
law to each phase we obtain:
In Iat In Ic
Va Ea Z s I a Z n I n
Vb Eb Z s I b Z n I n
(10.45)
Vc Ec Z s I c Z n I n and I rearrange
Va E a ( Z s Z n ) Zn Z n I a
V E Z ( Z Z ) Z I
b b n s n n b (10.46)
Vc Ec Z n Zn ( Z s Z n ) I c
16
Vab AV92
Sequence Impedances of a Loaded Generator
Transforming the terminal voltages and currents phasors into their symmetrical
components:
AVa012 AE 012
a Z abc
AI 012
a (10.48)
Multiplying (10.48) by A-1:
abc
Va012 E 012
a (A Z A)I 012
a
(10.49)
E 012
a Z I
012 012
a
Where:
1 1 1 ( Z s Z n ) Zn Z n 1 1 1
1
Z 012 1 a a 2 Z n (Z s Z n ) Z n 1 a 2 a (10.50)
3
1 a 2 a Z n Zn ( Z s Z n ) 1 a a 2
C
𝐙 = 𝐀 𝐙 𝐀
Performing the above multiplication:
( Z s 3Z n ) 0 0 Z 0 0 0
OZ 012
0
0
Zs
0
0 0
Z s 0
Z1
0
0
Z 2
(10.51)
17
Sequence Impedances of a Loaded Generator
Since the generated emf is balanced, there is only positive-sequence voltage, i.e:
0
Ea
(10.52)
E 012
a
0
0
𝐕 =𝐄 −𝐙 𝐈 (10.49)
012
Substituting for E a and Z 012 in (10.49):
Va0 0 Z 0 I a0
Va0 0 Z 0 0 0 I a0
1 Va1 Ea Z 1 I a1 (10.54)
Va E a 0
1
Z 0 I a1 (10.53) or
Va2 0 0 0 Z 2 I a2 Va2 0 Z 2 I a2
18
Sequence Impedances of a Loaded Generator
The three equations in (10.54) can be represented by the three equivalent
sequence networks:
932451rem
ve 0 seq
Tue seq seq
𝑉 =𝐸 −𝑍 𝐼 𝑉 =0−𝑍 𝐼 𝑉 =0−𝑍 𝐼
• Important observations:
– The three sequences are independent.
– The positive-sequence network is the same as the one-line diagram used in
studying balance three-phase currents and voltages.
– Only the positive-sequence network has a source and no voltage source for
other sequences.
– The neutral of the system is the reference for positive- and negative-sequence
networks, but ground is the reference for zero-sequence networks. Thus, zero
sequence current can only flow if the circuit from the system neutrals to
ground is complete. A Noground Nozero sequence
– The grounding impedance is reflected in the zero sequence network as 3Zn
– The three-sequence systems can be solved separately on a per phase basis.
The phase currents and voltages can then be determined by superposing their
symmetrical components of current and voltage respectively. 19
Single Line-To-Ground Fault
Three-phase generator with neutral grounded through an impedance Zn and
SLGF is assumed to occur at phase A through impedance Zf .
fault
GND
Ia Faulthappens to
hereneA
Zs
Ea Va Zf
Ec N
In Zs
Zs Eb Ib=0
Zn
Ic=0
Vb
Vc
Oath
Assuming the generator is initially on no-load, the SLGF conditions at the are:
throughLineA toAND Faultresultsin thislinehavinglowestimpedance
current
All
Va Z f I a (10.55) Ib Ic 0 (10.56)
20
Single Line-To-Ground Fault
Substituting for Ib = Ic = 0, the symmetrical components of currents from (10.14)
are:
I A Iabs If Ia I'a I
I a0 1 1 1 I a I a0 1 1 1 I a
1 1 1 1
I a 3 1 a a 2 O
0 I a 3 1 a a 2 I b (10.14)
(10.57)
I a2 2
a 0 I a2 1 a 2 a I c
1 a
O
21
Single Line-To-Ground Fault Va 2fIa
for zero seq 2 2s 32N
Va ZtIa 0
3Z f I a E a ( Z 0 Z 1 Z 2 ) I a0 (10.61) Va Z f I a (10.55)
or
Ea (10.62) 1
I 0
0
a I a0 I a1 I a2 I a (10.58)
Z Z 1 Z 2 3Z f 3
oneline diagram
25 fault impedance
1 Ea
I a0 I a1 I a2 I a (10.58) I a0 (10.62)
3 Z 0 Z 1 Z 2 3Z f
Ia FaultCurrent
Knowt
No derivation 23
Line-To-Line Fault
Three-phase generator with a fault through an impedance Zf between phase B and C.
ec
I =0 a
ftp
Ib may
Zs equal
through
goes direction
Ea Va current
Eb opposite
Zs
N
Zs all I
Ec Ib Ib
yp.ve
Zf Vb
Ic
Vc
Vb Vc Z f I b (10.64) Ia 0 (10.66)
Ib Ic 0 (10.65)
24
Line-To-Line Fault
Substituting for Ia = 0, and Ic = -Ib, the symmetrical components of the currents
from (10.14) are:
I a0 1 1 1 0
1 1 I a0 1 1 1 I a
I a 3 1 a a 2 I b 1 1 1 a
a 2 I b
(10.67)
I
3 (10.14)
I a2
1 a 2
a I b
a
I a2
1 a 2
a I c
I a0 0 (10.68)
1
I a1 (a a 2 ) I b (10.69) I
3
1
I a2 (a 2 a ) I b (10.70)
3
25
Line-To-Line Fault 1
I a1 (a a 2 ) I b (10.69)
3
1 (10.70)
Also, from (10.69) and (10.70), we note that: I a2 (a 2 a ) I b
3
I a1 I a2 (10.71)
Va Va0 Va1 Va2
From (10.16), we have:
Vb Va0 a 2Va1 aVa2 (10.16)
Vb Vc (Va0 a 2Va1 aVa2 ) (Va0 aVa1 a 2Va2 ) Vc Va0 aVa1 a 2Va2
(a 2 a )(Va1 Va2 )
(10.72) Vb Vc Z f I b (10.64)
Ub Vc Z f I b
Substituti ng for Va1 and Va2 from (10.54) and noting I a2 I a1 , we get :
Ib 314 (10.73)
(a 2 a )[ E a ( Z 1 Z 2 ) I a1 ] Z f I b
a ay Va0 0 Z 0 I a0
Substituti ng for I b from (10.69), we get :
Va1 Ea Z 1 I a1 (10.54)
3I a1 (10.74) Va2 0 Z 2 I a2
Ea (Z Z ) I Z f
1 2 1
a
( a a 2 )( a 2 a)
26
Line-To-Line Fault J.n.ae
Since (a a 2 )(a 2 a) 3, solving for I a1 results in :
Ea
I a1
(Z 1 Z 2 Z f ) (10.75)
I a 1 1 1 0
I 1 a 2 a I a1
(10.76)
b
I c 1 a a 2 I a1
0
I b I c (a 2 a ) I a1 (10.77) or I b j 3I a1 (10.78)
Fault Current is I
27
Line-To-Line Fault
Eq. (10.71) and (10.75) can be represented by connecting the positive and negative –
sequence networks as shown in the following figure.
Onelinediagram of
f 2 l fault
0
Ea
I a1 I a2 (10.71) I a1 (10.75)
(Z 1 Z 2 Z f )
28
Double Line-To-Ground Fault
Figure below shows a three-phase generator with a fault on phases B and C
through an impedance Zf to ground.
Line b c to 2s to AND
Ia = 0
Zs Va
Ea
Ec N
In Zs
Zs Eb Ib
Zn
Ic Zf Vb
Vc
Assuming the generator is initially on no-load, the boundary conditions at the fault
point are:
𝑉 = 𝑉 = 𝑍 (𝐼 + 𝐼 ) (10.79)
𝐼 =𝐼 +𝐼 +𝐼 =0 (10.80)
29
Double Line-To-Ground Fault
From Eq. (10.16), the phase voltages Vb and Vc are
Va Va0 Va1 Va2
𝑉 = 𝑉 + 𝑎 𝑉 + 𝑎𝑉 (10.81) Vb Va0 a 2Va1 aVa2 (10.16)
Vc Va0 aVa1 a 2Va2
𝑉 = 𝑉 + 𝑎𝑉 + 𝑎 𝑉 (10.82)
𝑉 = 𝑉 = 𝑍 (𝐼 + 𝐼 ) (10.79)
Since V = 𝑉 , from above we note that
BoundaryCondition
Needtoknowthese 4eqns
I f I b I c 3I 0
a
(10.89)
E a Z 1 I a1 (10.86)
I 0
0
a
( Z 3Z f )
E a Z 1 I a1 (10.87)
I
2
a
Z2
7 Ea
I a1
Z 2 ( Z 0 3Z f ) (10.88)
Z
1
Z 2 Z 0 3Z f
I a 1 1 1 I a0
I 1 a 2
b a I a1 (10.8)
I c 1 a a 2 I a2
Figure 10.15 Sequence network connection for double line-to-ground fault
32
2n 0 083
EXAMPLE 5
The one-line diagram of a simple power system is show in Figure 10.16. The neutral of each
generator is grounded through a current-limiting reactor of 0.25/3 per unit on a 100-MVA
base. The system data expressed in per unit on a common 100-mva base tabulated below. The
generators are running on no-load at their rated voltage and rated frequency with their emfs in
phase.
Determine the fault current for the following faults:
a. A balanced three-phase fault at bus 3 through a fault impedanceZ f = j 0.1 per unit
b. A single line-to-ground fault at bus 3 through a fault impedance Z f = j 0.1 per unit
c. A line-to-line fault at bus 3 through a fault impedance Z f = j 0.1 per unit
d. A double line-to-ground fault at bus 3 through a fault impedance Z f = j 0.1 per unit
tueseg veseq Osey
Item Base Rated X1 X2 X0
MVA Voltage
G1 100 20-kV 0.15 0.15 0.05
G2 100 20 kV 0.15 0.15 0.05
T1 100 20/220 kV 0.10 0.10 0.10
T2 100 20/220 kV 0.10 0.10 0.10
L12 100 220 kV 0.125 0.125 0.30
L13 100 220 kV 0.15 0.15 0.35
L23 100 220 kV 0.25 0.25 0.7125
AND
GNP
Ygnd Ygnd
Δ Ygnd
Figure 10.16
Fault Bus3
Fault
0 sequence
Item Base Rated X1 X2 X0
MVA Voltage
G1 100 20-kV 0.15 0.15 0.05
8
G2 100 20 kV 0.15 0.15 0.05
T1 100 20/220 kV 0.10 0.10 0.10
T2 100 20/220 kV 0.10 0.10 0.10
L12 100 220 kV 0.125 0.125 0.30
L13 100 220 kV 0.15 0.15 0.35
L23 100 220 kV 0.25 0.25 0.7125
34
To find Thevenin impedance viewed from the faulted bus (bus 3), we convert the delta
formed by buses 123 to an equivalent Y as shown below
8
000
O O
DeltaconverttoY Ycircuitry
Fig. 10.17 Positive-sequence impedance
35
( j 0.2857143)( j 0.3095238)
Z
1
33 j 0.0714286
j 0.5952381
j 0.22
series to eachother
36
Oseq needto consider ifgenerator isgrounded connertionoftransformer primary secondary side
To find thevenin impedance viewed from the faulted bus (bus 3), we convert the
delta formed by buses 123 to an equivalent Y as shown in figure 10.19(b)
Ygnd Hand III T1
Bihalesco In
T2
2 0.25 D gnd
If
0 O
o B open
aix a
721
Tayoly
connected
Tayo
42 0 Δ Y
Convert
( j 0.30)( j 0.35)
43
0 Z 1S j 0.0770642 j0.077064
j1.3625
( j 0.30)( j 0.7125)
Impedance value is from
Z 2S j 0.1568807
j1.3625
10 sequence exceptforZn
( j 0.35)( j 0.7125)
Z 3S j 0.1830257
j1.3625
Notonside
( j 0.4770642)( j 0.2568807)
Z 330 j 0.1830275
j 0.7339449
j 0.35
D
j0.077064
0 serves
Fig. 10.20
Zero-sequence network found already
value 21,2 s
38
Fast pu
21 O 1 Given inthequestion
(a) Balanced three-phase fault at bus 3
Assuming the no-load generated emfs are equal to 1.0 per unit, the fault via I
current is assumed
V3a( 0 ) 1 .0
I 3 (F) -j3.125 pu 820.1 - 90 A
Z133 Z f j0.22 j 0.1
000
Z133 Z 33
2
Z 33
0
3Z f j0.22 j0.22 j 0.35 3(j0.1)
39
(c) Line-to Line fault at bus 3
The zero-sequence component of current is zero, i.e.,
I 30 0
The positive-and negative-sequence components of the fault current are
a
V3(0) 1.0 10 75
I13 I32 -j1.8519 pu
Z133 Z33
2
Zf j0.22 j0.22 j0.1
40
The negative-sequence component of current is :
V3a( 0 ) Z133 I133 1.0 ( j 0.22)( j 2.6017)
I 32 2
j1.9438 pu
Z 33 j0.22
I 3 ( F ) I 3b I 3c 1.973290
41
2012
UNBALANCED FAULT ANALYSIS USING BUS IMPEDANCE MATRIX
42
Double Line-to-Ground Fault Using Zbus
V k ( 0)
I k1 (10.94)
Z kk2 ( Z kk0 3Z f )
Z kk1
Z kk2 Z kk0 3Z f
V ( 0 ) Z 1 1
kk I k
I k2 k (10.95)
Z kk2
Vk (0) Z kk
1 1
Ik
I
0
k (10.96)
Z kk0 3Z f
Where Z1kk , and Z 2kk , and Zokk are the diagonal elements in the k axis of the corresponding
bus impedance matrix. The phase currents are obtained from (10.91), and the result current is
I k ( F ) I kb I kC (10.97)
43
Exercise 3_______________________
Steps: (1) Convert Line voltage into symmetrical component line voltage
(2) Convert symmetrical component line voltage to symmetrical
component phase voltage
(3) Calculate voltage phase (in phasor) by adding the symmetrical component
(4) Calculate line current by dividing voltage phase with resistor value
Using the obtained symmetrical voltage and current, calculate the total power
absorbed at the load.
44
LineVoltage
For Yconnection
45
Convert Symmetrical line voltage to symmetrical phase voltage
𝑉
120°
𝑉
120°
120°
𝑉 Phasevoltage
A for tut veena
thosevoltage
or Éuff
writing
Intamin LineCurrent Question
HHc
ucaq
Iranian
mfm
46
Irine Van
Vphase
To tabulate power R
∗
𝑆( ) = 3(𝐕 𝐈 )
∗ ∗ ∗
= 3𝑉 𝐼 + 3𝑉 𝐼 + 3𝑉 𝐼
Directmultiply
Don't inlude angle in calcular
47
B
Exercise 4_______________________
48
LineCurrent Symmetrial Component ofhimComment
Symmetrical component of line currents:
co 1
I a0 ( I a I b I c )
3
1
I a1 ( I a aI b a 2 I c )
3
1
I a2 ( I a a 2 I b aI c )
3
As per Δ circuit
characteristics
49
Phase Current
Symmetrial Line Current Symmetrical
O
o
AND UND
Ygrid Δ
Ygnd Ygnd
tuel
ToNote
Find EquivalentImpedancesFirst 2133 lositiveSequenceImpedance 233 NegativeSequenceImpedance 283 0 SequenceImpedance
Alwaysconvert Ato Yconneltron
Calculate Positive NegativeSequence Impedances first
Given
that X tueseq X2 veseq are equal then 733 I
Tofind 2 3 233 labelthe impedanies in airluitcorrectly then simplifythem Thevenin EqCircuit toget impedance value
Getequivalent tue sequence re sequence network diagram
inseras
3
EquivalentTheremin parallel semes
713101 3722
series
27 50.22
0714286
1 150
ftp 0595238
5030714286
tueser vesee
Drawing Network Diagram
233
70.22
off 22
off
Ea
o o
ve sequence ve sequence
T2 D Yan
KtogND
Yann and D and Impedance values arefrom
2y j 1.3625
I
215 5030 5035 j0 0770642
30021 3732 values 1.3625
bio.EE
go.us Yfi ipifijj.iii'matronsassot
51.3625
1135010 shy.io
310.25 jo213
350.05 series
Fd6421
350.05
It 9j
jo 1830257
15688071
jo.istjo.ostjo.io jo.irtjo
150.1550.055010 10.770642
parallel jollt.jo15688071
7135010 jo.ir
2 27 50 35 Draw 0
seqDiag
12,3
123 series 233 50.350 271.35 to
32
C Balance 3 phase Fault Bus 3 25 0.1 pu
I F
2 If
j
j
3.125p u
jot
FaultCurrent is Ia 319 Eg
15910.63 Ia Ia Ih Ia
2 2 2
a Busthat faultoccurs at
Faultcurrent Linecurrent 0 sequence
j 0.2250.22101
I 3 5 34
I I I'a EG10.75
l
I's I I
2 2 2
L compute values oflinecurrent Is
go.sn t 22tjo I
g compute Values
of phase current I's
If I a a I's
1 1 1
1
f in
f DoubleLine
to AND Fault Bus3
8
10.881
If Ea 2 I 18 Ea 2 I'a 10861
2 22120 32 20 32
22 20 325
Compute Id first then useresulttocomputetherest
I I Fa 213 I 3 IS Ea I
2 2 2 34 233 233 325
2 2 325 1 0.22 52.6017 526017
1.0 50.226
jo22 310.1
jo356579
50.221 I 51.9438 IS jo
Is j 2.6017pu Compute values of linecurrent I
faines
Phase current 108 compute of phase current I
If
If 3T IS
II
I
I
FaultCurrent If IbtIc 318
If 165.9
É 4.058 14.07
1.973 90