TVM - MIT Problems 1
TVM - MIT Problems 1
1 Present Value 1
3 Common Stock 28
(a) an EAR?
(b) a quarterly APR?
(c) a monthly APR?
(a) annual
(b) monthly
(c) weekly
(d) continuously?
3. You can invest $50,000 in a certificate of deposit (CD) offered by your bank. The CD
is for 2 years and the bank quotes you a rate of 4%. How much will you have in 2 years
if the 4% is
(a) an EAR?
(b) a quarterly APR?
(c) a monthly APR?
4. You can invest $10,000 in a certificate of deposit (CD) offered by your bank. The CD
is for 5 years and the bank quotes you a rate of 4.5%. How much will you have in 5
years if the 4.5% is
(a) an EAR?
(b) a quarterly APR?
(c) a monthly APR?
(a) annual
(b) monthly
(c) daily
7. Suppose you invest $10,000 per year for 10 years at an average return of 5.5%. The
average future inflation rate is 2% per year.
(a) The first investment is made immediately. What is your ending investment bal-
ance?
(b) What is its purchasing power in todays dollars?
8. Overhaul of a production line generates the following incremental cash inflows over the
line’s 5-year remaining life.
C1 C2 C3 C4 C5
Cash inflow ($ million) +1.5 +1.3 +1.05 +0.9 +0.75
9. You have just inherited an office building. You expect the annual rental income (net
of maintenance and other cost) for the building to be $100,000 for the next year and
to increase at 5% per year indefinitely. A expanding internet company offers to rent
the building at a fixed annual rent for 5 years. After year 5, you could re-negotiate
or rent the building to another tenant. What is the minimum acceptable fixed rental
payments for this five-year agreement? Use a discount rate of 12%.
10. Two dealers compete to sell you a new Hummer with a list price of $45,000. Dealer
C offers to sell it for $40,000 cash. Dealer F offers “0-percent financing:” 48 monthly
payments of $937.50. (48x937.50=45,000)
(a) You can finance purchase by withdrawals from a money market fund yielding 2%
per year. Which deal is better?
(b) You always carry unpaid credit card balances charging interest at 15% per year.
Which deal is better?
11. Your sales are $10 million this and expected to grow at 5% in real terms for the next
three years. The appropriate nominal discount rate is 10%. The inflation is expected
to be 2% per year during the same period. What is the present value of your sales
revenue for the next three years?
13. You own three oil wells in Vidalia, Texas. They are expected to produce 7,000 barrels
next year in total, but production is declining by 6 percent every year after that.
Fortunately, you have a contract fixing the selling price at $15 per barrel for the next
12 years. What is the present value of the revenues from the well during the remaining
life of the contract? Assume a discount rate of 8 percent.
14. A geothermal power station produces cash flow at a current rate of $14 million per
year, after maintenance, all operating expenses and taxes. All the cash flow is paid
out to the power stations owners. The cash flow is expected to grow at the inflation
rate, which is forecasted at 2% per year. The opportunity cost of capital is 8%, about
3 percentage points above the long-term Treasury rate. (Assume this is an annually
compounded rate.)
The power station will operate for a very long time. Assume for simplicity that it will
last forever.
(a) What is the present value of the power station? Assume the first cash flow is
received one year hence.
(b) Now assume that the power stations cash flow is generated in a continuous stream,
starting immediately. What is the present value?
15. A foundation announces that it will be offering one MIT scholarship every year for an
indefinite number of years. The first scholarship is to be offered exactly one year from
now. When the scholarship is offered, the student will receive $20,000 annually for a
period of four years, beginning from the date the scholarship is offered. This student
is then expected to repay the principal amount received ($80,000) in 10 equal annual
installments, interest-free, starting one year after the expiration of her scholarship.
This implies that the foundation is really giving an interest-free loan under the guise of
a scholarship. The current interest is 6% for all maturities and is expected to remain
unchanged.
16. You signed a rental lease for an office space in the Back Bay for five years with an
annual rent of $1 million, paid at the beginning of each year of the lease. Just before
you pay your first rent, the property owner wants to use the space for another purpose
and proposes to buy back the lease from you. The rent for similar space is now $1.25
million per year. What would be the minimum compensation that you would ask from
the property owner? Assume the interest rate to be 6%.
18. You are considering buying a car worth $30,000. The dealer, who is anxious to sell the
car, offers you an attractive financing package. You have to make a down-payment of
$3,500, and pay the rest over 5 years with annual payments. The dealer will charge
you interest at a constant annual interest rate of 2%, which may be different from the
market interest rate.
Note: the tradeoff between the two options is that in the first case, you can finance
your purchase at a relatively low rate of interest. In the second case, you receive a
lump-sum cash rebate.
19. Your brother-in-law asks you to lend him $100,000 as a second mortgage on his vacation
home. He promises to make level monthly payments for 10 years, 120 payments in all.
You decide that a fair interest rate is 8% compounded annually. What should the
monthly payment be on the $100,000 loan?
20. Your cousin is entering medical school next fall and asks you for financial help. He
needs $65,000 each year for the first two years. After that, he is in residency for two
years and will be able to pay you back $10,000 each year. Then he graduates and
becomes a fully qualified doctor, and will be able to pay you $40,000 each year. He
promises to pay you $40,000 for 5 years after he graduates. Are you taking a financial
loss or gain by helping him out? Assume that the interest rate is 5% and that there is
no risk.
21. You are awarded $500,000 in a lawsuit, payable immediately. The defendant makes a
counteroffer of $50,000 per year for the first three years, starting at the end of the first
year, followed by $60,000 per year for the next 10 years. Should you accept the offer if
the discount rate is 12%? How about if the discount rate is 8%?
22. You are considering buying a Back Bay two-bedroom apartment for $800,000. You
plan to make a $200,000 down payment and take a $600,000 30-year mortgage for the
rest. The interest rate on the mortgage is 6% monthly APR. Payments are due at the
end of every month.
23. True, false or “it depends” (give a brief explanation): U.S. Treasury securities have no
risk because they give sure payoffs at fixed future dates.
24. A 10-year German government bond (bund) has face value of 10,000 and an annual
coupon rate of 5%. Assume that interest rate (in euros) is equal to 6% per year.
25. You are considering buying a two bedroom apartment in Back Bay for $600,000. You
plan to make a $100,000 down payment and take out a $500,000 30-year mortgage for
the rest. The interest rate on the mortgage is 8.5% monthly APR.
26. John is 30 years old at the beginning of the new millennium and is thinking about
getting an MBA. John is currently making $40,000 per year and expects the same for
the remainder of his working years (until age 65). I f he goes to a business school, he
gives up his income for two years and, in addition, pays $20,000 per year for tuition.
In return, John expects an increase in his salary after his MBA is completed. Suppose
that the post-graduation salary increases at a 5% per year and that the discount rate
is 8%. What is miminum expected starting salary after graduation that makes going
to a business school a positive-NPV investment for John? For simplicity, assume that
all cash flows occur at the end of each year.
27. After doing well in your finance classes, you landed a job at the IMF. Your salary is
$100,000, and your contract is for 5 years. Your salary will stay the same during the 5
years and, since you are at the IMF, you are not subject to taxes. If you do well (which
we assume will happen with certainty), you will get a permanent contract. Under this
contract, your salary will grow at the rate of 3% per year, until retirement. Retirement
will occur in 30 years after your contract becomes permanent.
For simplicity, assume that your salary is paid at the end of each year. In other words,
(a) What is the value of your human capital? That is, what is the PV (as of today)
of all your future earnings?
(b) Assume that you spend 70% of your salary, and deposit the remainder in a savings
account, which pays the rate 4%. How much money will you have in the savings
account just after you received your fifth salary (end of year 5)? (You deposit
only 30% of that salary in the savings account.)
28. Retirement planning: Mr. Jones is contemplating retirement. He is 55 and his net
worth now is $2 million. He hopes that after retirement he can maintain a lifestyle
that costs him $100,000 per year in today’s dollars (i.e., real dollars, inflation adjusted).
If he retires, he will invest all his net worth in government bonds that yield a safe
annual return of 5%. Inflation is expected to be 2% per year. Ignore taxes.
(a) Is Mr. Jones rich enough to retire today if he lives until (i) 80 (ii) 100 (iii) 115?
(b) Mr. Jones thinks he will live until about 100. What advice will you give him
about retiring?
29. Suppose you invest $50,000 for ten years at a nominal rate of 7.5% per year. If the
annual inflation rate is 3% for the next ten years, what is the real value of your
investment at the end of ten years?
31. A 10-year U.S. Treasury bond with a face value of $10,000 pays a coupon of 5.5%
(2.75% of face value every 6 months). The semi-annually compounded interest rate is
5.2 % (a 6-month discount rate of 5.2/2 = 2.6%).
My spouse and I are each 62 and hope to retire in 3 years. After retirement we will
receive $5,000 per month after taxes from our employers pension plans and $1000 per
month after taxes from Social Security. Unfortunately our monthly living expenses are
$15,000. Our social obligations preclude further economies.
We have $1,200,000 invested in a high-grade corporate-bond mutual fund. Unfortu-
nately the after-tax return on the fund has dropped to 3.5% per year. We plan to
make annual withdrawals from the fund to cover the difference between our pension
and social security income and our living expenses. How long will the money last?
Sincerely,
Luxury Challenged
Marblehead, MA
34. The annually compounded discount rate is 5.5%. You are asked to calculate the present
value of a 12-year annuity with payments of $50,000 per year. Calculate PV for each
of the following cases.
(a) The annuity payments arrive at one-year intervals. The first payment arrives one
year from now.
(b) The first payment arrives in 6 months. Following payments arrive at one-year
intervals, at 18 months, 30 months, etc.
(a) How much money will you have in year 30 if neither the contribution nor the in-
terest income is tax-deferred? (In this case, you can withdraw the money without
paying any additional tax at year 30.)
(b) How much money will you have in 30 years if the contribution is not tax-deferred
but the interest income is? (In this case, only the cumulative interest is taxed at
year 30.)
(c) How much money will you have in 30 years if both the contribution and the
interest income are tax-deferred?
(d) Would you expect the benefit of tax deferral to increase or decrease as the tax
rate increases? Why?
6. False. The choice of the horizon date should not affect the present value.
12. The value of company ABC is the PV of the growing annuity of cash flow:
10
PV = 1.09−1.05 = $250 million.
13. Assume all the oil is sold at the end of each year; for example the PV of the production
for the first year is $7000×$15
1.08
= $97, 222. The PV of the second year production is
$6580×$15
1.082
= $84, 619. The PV of the total production in the first 12 years is $608,254
and by then the annual production has declined to 3,544 barrels.
14. (a) Assuming first cash flow one year from now in real terms is $14m:
rreal = (1.08/1.02) − 1 = 5.88%
P V = 14/0.0588 = $238m (no growth)
Using nominal values: 14 ∗ 1.02/(0.08 − 0.02) = $238m
Alternatively, if assuming first cash flow one year from now in real terms is
14/1.02 = $13.73m, P V = (14/1.02)/0.0588 = $233.33m
Using nominal values: 14/(0.08 − 0.02) = $233.33m
Note: in order to get full credit, the assumptions made should have been clearly
stated.
The value of your current lease is $1 million for 5 years, and the total PV is $4.4651 mil-
lion. Therefore the difference is $1.1163 million, and this should be the compensation
you asked from the owner.
17. Use growing annuity formula assuming that the payments are made at the begining of
each year and you pay in full for the year that you die (unfortunately).
The value if you have an expected life of T years is:
! " ! "T
1.05 1.05
PV = $750 + $750 ∗ + · · · + $750 ∗
1.12 1.12
# ! "T $
1 1 1.05
= $750 + $750 − × (1)
0.12 − 0.05 0.12 − 0.05 1.12
18. (a) Let the annual payment = C. The PV of all my payments, discounted at the
dealer’s rate, must equal to the price, i.e.,
C 1
3500 + 0.02 (1 − 1.025 ) = 30000.
The cost of the second option is 30, 000 − 2, 500 = $27, 500. I should pay cash.
21. The PV of the offer at discount rate of 12% is $359,921. With the discount rate of 8%
the PV increases to $446,821. In both cases accepting the award of $500,000 is prefer-
able. This calculation ignores other consideration such as difference tax treatment.
.06 12
22. (a) EAR = (1 + 12
) − 1 = 0.06168.
(b) Let C be the monthly payment. The effective interest rate per month is 0.0612
=
0.005.' The( PV )of the *mortgage annuity must equal the amount borrowed:
C 1 (12×30)
0.005
1 − 1.005 = 600, 000.
C = $3, 597.30.
' ( 1 )(12×25) *
(c) 3597.30
0.005
1 − 1.005
= $558, 326.10.
.085 12
25. (a) EAR = (1 + 12
) − 1 = 0.088391.
(b) The effective interest rate per month is .085 12
= 0.0070833.
Let C be the monthly payment. The PV of the mortgage annuity must equal the
amount 'borrowed: *
C 1 (12×30)
0.0070833
1 − 1.0070833
= 500, 000.
C = $3, 844.57.
' *
3844.57 1 (12×30−60)
(c) 0.0070833 1 − 1.0070833 = $477, 451.33.
26. The PV of the current salary at the discount rate of 8% is $468,687. It is assumed that
salaries are paid at the end of each year (only an approximation to the more accurate
monthly payment) and he works up to the end of his 65th year.
To calculate the break-even starting salary after MBA, one needs to include the nega-
tive NPV of the cost of MBA as well as the lost income for the 2-years spent in school
and compare that against the positive NPV of the increased earning power. The neg-
ative NPV of the cost of MBA is $35,665 and the loss in salary is $71,330 for a total
of $-106,995.
Even if the starting salary after the MBA is as low as $32,687 it still pays off to get
the MBA. Of course, getting an MBA makes the skill set more flexible (such as the
28. (a) Assume that every year, Mr. Jones withdraws the year’s living expense at the
beginning of the year. If he retires today and lives for another T years, he would
need the following amount:
' *
1.05 1.02 T
S = 100, 000 1.05−1.02 1 − 1.05 .
(i) T = 25 : S(25) = $1, 804, 335.76 (enough).
(ii) T = 45 : S(45) = $2, 550, 363.68 (not enough).
(iii) T = 60 : S(60) = $2, 885, 219.04 (not enough).
(b) Mr. Jones can (i) work longer and retire later, (ii) downgrade his lifestyle and
reduce living expense, or (iii) find better investment opportunities that give higher
returns (though he must also consider the risk involved).
29. The nomilar value is $50, 000 × (1.07510 ) Inflation reduced this by a factor of (1.03)10 .
So the real value is only $76,680.
of which the principal is 30 × 2000 × (1 − 0.28) = $43, 200, implying that the
interest is 113, 843 − 43200 = $70, 643.79. Tax on this is 70643.79 × 0.28 implying
that the take-home amount is $94,063.
After taxes, this is only 158116.37 × (1 − 0.28) = 113, 843.789. Note: The answers
to (b) and (c) are identical. Given the after–tax interest rate, it doesn’t matter
whether your money is taxed on the way in or the way out.
(d) Increase, because more deferred tax can be used to accrue interest.